Melanie or Jade

[bbfan1991]

Who would you prefer to make the live shows?

[Doogle]

Jade. I cant remember Melanie

[Locke.]

Melanie.

[bbfan1991]

Jade. I cant remember Melanie

_n8rSONahLY

[Tom]

Jade is rubbish, Melanie is OK, not sure any of them should make the live shows though. Amelia Lily ****s allover Melanie :lovedup:

I like the ginger girl. forgot her name, she sung You've Got The Love

[Callum]

Jade, I didn't like her rendition of Someone Like You but I thought she was good doing You've Got the Love last night.

[MusicXian]

Melanie.

[DrunkerThanMoses]

Neither Nicole Simpson (the girl who was in Jades group last night), should get through, shes beautiful and a better singer than them all

[Tom]

Neither Nicole Simpson (the girl who was in Jades group last night), should get through, shes beautiful and a better singer than them all

Thats the ginger one I meant, shes brilliant. Thanks for the name reminder. Along with Amelia Lily, Janet and Misha Byran (the black girl who we didnt see last night) they should be the top 4

[jjj2]

Melanie

[rk3388]

whos jsde?

[DrunkerThanMoses]

whos jsde?

Scottish Vicky Pollard

[Marc]

Jade

[Tom4784]

I voted for Jsde.

[joeysteele]

Not that keen on either but of the 2, Melanie for me.

[Jords]

Janet >>>>>

[Joelle.]

Jade is ridiculously overrated, she is just a mediocre version of Adele. Melanie should get to the Live shows over her definitely, her unseen first song at her audition sounded stunning. Nicole Simpson was far better in the group performance of You've Got The Love, she should have made Judges Houses instead of Jade IMO. Neither of them have been given enough airtime to stand a chance though, they've just forced Jade upon us like cold turkey sandwiches on Boxing Day. :bored: