Biggest Mistake in X Factor History

[Joe.]

How the hell did Sophie Habibas (WHO!??) get through when Jade didn't!?

Unbelievable.

[Patrick]

Who cares, it's sh*te.

[Tom]

Katie Waissell over Gamu :idc:

[Joe.]

Yes but Jade was superb.

[Tom]

Yes but Jade was superb.

She was a fat ugly beast who could only just hold a tune and relied on a sob story of her nana practically mirroring that of R Wayne on Britain's Got the Pop Factor. She shouldn't have got anywhere near as far as she did

[Iceman]

Katie Waissell over Gamu :idc:

Gamu's trending worldwide on twitter :laugh:

[Joe.]

No. Katie Waissel is God.

http://images.mirror.co.uk/upl/m4/sep2010/8/2/image-12-for-search-for-a-star-x-marks-the-hot-gallery-148247537.jpg

[Maia]

I like seeing unknowns get through rather than always just the ones shoved down our throats from the very beginning all the time.

[Sam:)]

She was a fat ugly beast who could only just hold a tune and relied on a sob story of her nana practically mirroring that of R Wayne on Britain's Got the Pop Factor. She shouldn't have got anywhere near as far as she did

http://static.guim.co.uk/sys-images/Arts/Arts_/Pictures/2008/10/13/kay460.jpg

[Vicky.]

Katie Waissell over Gamu :idc:

This

[LaLaLand]

Sophie has a wonderful voice.

['Conor]

i hated Jade

['Conor]

Katie Waissell over Gamu :idc:

this.

[Sam:)]

TBF Janet should have went,she is basically Diana Vickers but not as attractive and her voice isnt as strong

[Jords]

I like both Misha and Sophie but Jade topped them imo, it was a difficult choice though :(

[Tom]

This

Whats wrong with us today, agreeing on everything? Like I've entered the twilight zone :joker:

[Vicky.]

Whats wrong with us today, agreeing on everything? Like I've entered the twilight zone :joker:

I know. It is quite strange :joker:

[Barbie]

Weasel getting through and no Gamu was the worst decision ever!

[Doogle]

Noooooo, how did Mishit get in and not Jade?

[MeMyselfAndI]

Erm.. Sophie Haabis is amazing, they've like edited her out. Misha is the worst girl, Jade/Melanie should have got through over her.

[Lee.]

Sophie is the dark horse... she's been my fav since her first audition.

Jade should have gone through though.. I still have hope though. I think its going to be a wildcard twist next week.

[bbfan1991]

Misha isn't the worst girl IMO, she's just a different artist in terms of the genre of music that she sings and I want variety from the contestants. I don't want them all singing bubblegum pop!

[Jords]

tbf not many of them sing bubblegum pop...

[bbfan1991]

I liked Gamu's audition last year but after that I didn't like her and I was glad Cheryl didn't put her through. The controversy still lingers LOL!:D

[Wildcat!]

I dont think it was that cut an dry, tHEy were both really goog in their final auditions. But I did prefer Jade.

[Doogle]

Looking back Gamu was immensely overrated and I hated Katie with a passion but without her last years would have been boring with no one to hate. Same with Frankie this year, I hate him but I'm secretly glad he made it for that reason. I always need someone to despise.

But yeah, Gamu was autotuned in her audition if I recall correctly, and she wasn't the best, but she was better than Katie vocally.

[bbfan1991]

.. When Louis kept in The Conway Sisters over Maria Lawson:bawling:.

[Niamh.]

ahhhhhhhhhh It's not really

[Doogle]

.. When Louis kept in The Conway Sisters over Maria Lawson:bawling:.
Omfg this! I was so pissed off. She looked like she was gonna cry :sad:

That was the first ever episode I watched. Weird how I remember this and not important things.

[Vicky.]

Worst decision in XF was simon saving Jedward over Lucie

Or Louis still being a judge..one of the two :p

[MeMyselfAndI]

You mean over Lucie :tongue:

[Vicky.]

Oh **** yeah, thats what I meant :laugh:

[Vicky.]

Edited it, what a horrid mistake. I didnt like laura and loved lucie

[Doogle]

Laura from XF5?

[Vicky.]

Yeah

[Doogle]

And I agree at the time I was absolutely raging at Simon for choosing Jedward when he claimed to hate them. But I have been following Lucie (not literally, I mean on FB and Twitter) since the show and she seems to be doing alright. Even if she hasn't had like 7 number ones :joker:

[bbfan1991]

I enjoyed Lucie going over Jedward. She was my favourite girl that year but it was obvious for business reasons Simon and the producers wanted to keep the twins in for a while longer.

There was only 0.4% between them that week (Jedward 9.2, Lucie 8.8)

[DrunkerThanMoses]

Um Sophie is a goddess queen , so fudge off

Plus Laura deserved to go because she had to be sacrificed to save our other queen Ruth :)

[Vicky.]

Ruth :lovedup:

[Doogle]

Ruth was bloody awful

[bbfan1991]

I didn't see the big deal about Laura, she was alright but too overrated IMO and glad Ruth decimated her in that sing off.

[DrunkerThanMoses]

Ruth was bloody awful

:shocked: Okay Im going to let you off this time, but if you talk **** again I will have to destroy you

[Joelle.]

Treyc and Aiden both going over Katie was an absolute joke, but Lucie going over Jedward was even worse. Just Simon trying to be controversial without actually giving a toss about talent. :bored:

Oh and Scott Bruton going over Daniel Evans... :nono:

[Joelle.]

Ruth was bloody awful

Surely not our fierce Latino Queen Ruth Lorenzo? :shocked:

[Mystic Mock]

Frankie going through over John.

[Mystic Mock]

.. When Louis kept in The Conway Sisters over Maria Lawson:bawling:.

Oh if we are counting The Live Shows then Katie Waissel being kept in over Aiden Grimshaw was the worst decision ever on so many levels that it would take me a year to write down.

[bbfan1991]

Oh if we are counting The Live Shows then Katie Waissel being kept in over Aiden Grimshaw was the worst decision ever on so many levels that it would take me a year to write down.

I preferred Katie over Aiden:joker:.

[MusicXian]

Sophie is great. Feel bad for Mel :(

[bbfan1991]

Sophie is great. Feel bad for Mel :(

I wanted Melanie to get through, however Sophie is good. Melanie might benefit from improving and coming back next year instead:).

[Mystic Mock]

I preferred Katie over Aiden:joker:.

But even you should be able to admit that Simon only kept her in for controversy surely?

[Joelle.]

Oh and Jamie Archer going over Lloyd Daniels was an absolute disgrace as well. :bored:

[bbfan1991]

But even you should be able to admit that Simon only kept her in for controversy surely?

Yes like Jedward were:).

[Mystic Mock]

Yes like Jedward were:).

I agree.

[Mystic Mock]

Oh and Jamie Archer going over Lloyd Daniels was an absolute disgrace as well. :bored:

And I agree with this but blame Simon for sticking him on 1st with Radio GAGA.

[Joelle.]

And I agree with this but blame Simon for sticking him on 1st with Radio GAGA.

Simon just turned him into a past it hasbeen rocker by giving him old rock ballads every week. :bored:

[bbfan1991]

Lloyd was dire, not as bad as Eoghan:eek:. I liked Jamie but Simon messed him around with the song choices and he didn't get Jamie as an artist.

[Mystic Mock]

Lloyd was dire, not as bad as Eoghan:eek:. I liked Jamie but Simon messed him around with the song choices and he didn't get Jamie as an artist.

Maybe Simon did get him as an artist but because he wanted Olly and Danyl to last longer than Jamie, Jamie got the leftover songs like Radio GAGA and that week 4 performance that I cant remember the song title of.

[Joelle.]

Tbh Jamie wasn't suited to the show. Simon had no idea how to mentor him properly so just gave him cliched rock ballads. :bored:

[bbfan1991]

Eoghan staying in over Diana, silly girls:mad::bored:.

[Mystic Mock]

Eoghan staying in over Diana, silly girls:mad::bored:.

Diana wasnt my type of singer but out of the final 4 I think she deserved to win,so her coming 4th I thought was a disgrace.

[Joelle.]

Eoghan staying in over Diana, silly girls:mad::bored:.

I was actually disgusted when this happened. Diana was by far my favourite contestant ever at the time. Eoghan was dreadful. :bored:

[bbfan1991]

I was actually disgusted when this happened. Diana was by far my favourite contestant ever at the time. Eoghan was dreadful. :bored:

Relieved he hasn't been heard of since that year:joker::D.

[Adamw92]

Eoghan staying in over Diana, silly girls:mad::bored:.

I will NEVER get over this! :bawling: :mad:

also agree with Maria going over The Conway Sisters, that was an absolute joke and I've hated Louis ever since!

and then Lucie going over Jedward, I remember actually shouting at the TV when it happened :joker:

[Black Dagger]

Oh and Jamie Archer going over Lloyd Daniels was an absolute disgrace as well. :bored:

That was a TRAVESTY... how did Lloyd get through over Duane and Ethan anyway?

Anyway... Jade was dull, I hope she comes back next year though.

Ray getting into the final over Ben was another one I can not forget.

[fruit_cake]

for me it was either Jedward staying over Lucie, or Gamu not going in because of Katie Waissel

[fruit_cake]

or Rhyddian not winning

[ArcticLion]

or Rhyddian not winning

This! i cant even remeber who he got beat by :suspect:

[Mystic Mock]

This! i cant even remeber who he got beat by :suspect:

Leon Jackson is who he lost to,it was a ****ing disgraceful win Imo.:mad:

[MeMyselfAndI]

I think I'm in the minority on this forum, who preffured Laura White to Ruth, and i was very annoyed Ruth was saved depsite not being popular with the public, unlike Laura.

[MeMyselfAndI]

Leon Jackson is who he lost to,it was a ****ing disgraceful win Imo.:mad:

I've Watched XF2-XF7, and Leon is the worst winner yet. I didn't see 1 though, so I'm not sure how bad Steve was.

[Lee.]

or Rhyddian not winning

This.

[Mystic Mock]

I've Watched XF2-XF7, and Leon is the worst winner yet. I didn't see 1 though, so I'm not sure how bad Steve was.

I only watched the final of XF1 and Steve was much better than Leon.

[Lewis.]

Lucie going over Jedward was the biggest mistake in the history of X Factor.

[Doogle]

In my opinion:

Leona > Alexandra > Shayne > Matt > Leon > Steve > Joe

But Rhydian (who I hated), Olly, Rebecca, Andy & G4 were all better than the winner of their year.

[Billy]

Alisha Bennett over Steph Woods.

WONT.EVER.UNDERSTAND.

[Tom]

Tbh Jamie wasn't suited to the show. Simon had no idea how to mentor him properly so just gave him cliched rock ballads. :bored:

Jamie peaked in his audition and that was largely down to the song. I think Simon should have put Treyc Cohen through instead of Jamie. Treyc was better in 2009 and Simon is good with that kind of singer. Cheryl completely ruined her by trying to make her more contemporary but stripping her style away at the same time.

[Marc]

I thought Sophie was much better than Jade. She and Jade have similar tones to their voices but I definitely believe Sophie can do more with her vocals than Jade could.

I don't know what the twist is but I assume it's something about Jade

[Benjamin]

Who cares, it's sh*te.

This. I wish people would get over this sorry excuse for a 'talent' show now.

[Marc]

Ya'll don't need to be watching it or following the stories if you don't like it. :xyxwave:

[camertone]

I really liked Jade, but I also really like the 4 girls Kelly picked for live show. It was a hard decision. Jade can be quite a star when she learns to be confident with her talent! Hope she comes back next year!

[Jordan.]

The wildcards last year where a disgrace.

That disgusting hobo Wagner, fat Paije and ****ing Diva Fever. Then Treyc who no one gave a **** about because they wanted Gamu.

[Vicky.]

Ya'll don't need to be watching it or following the stories if you don't like it. :xyxwave:

:joker:

[Marc]

Yeah Jade can come back next year and be all like :sad: I didn'nee make itt last yearr so I be back!

[Black Dagger]

The wildcards last year where a disgrace.

That disgusting hobo Wagner, fat Paije and ****ing Diva Fever. Then Treyc who no one gave a **** about because they wanted Gamu.

Wagner was a saint, how dare you!

[Mystic Mock]

Wagner was a saint, how dare you!

What he said about poor Paije aswell.:bawling:

[bbfan1991]

Matt Cardle's ironing vests:yuk::eek:.

[Mystic Mock]

Heres another reason why im pissed off aswell.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_X_Factor_(UK_series_7)

Check the timeslots for week 6 and then the percentages? so they didnt just have the nerve of trapping him in the bottom two,but Simon also dared to vote Aiden out.

But for those that dont want to search for the percentages of that week heres the result.

Wagner 6.30%
Katie 5.29%
Aiden 5.01%

I liked Wagner but come on Aiden was cheated out of the show with how late Wagner was on that week.

Thats why I dont get why people say results like Jedward staying over Lucie was worse than this.

[Ryan244]

Has to be Austin getting eliminated in week 4 of series 5, by far the best male vocalist ever on the show

[Doogle]

Heres another reason why im pissed off aswell.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_X_Factor_(UK_series_7)

Check the timeslots for week 6 and then the percentages? so they didnt just have the nerve of trapping him in the bottom two,but Simon also dared to vote Aiden out.

But for those that dont want to search for the percentages of that week heres the result.

Wagner 6.30%
Katie 5.29%
Aiden 5.01%

I liked Wagner but come on Aiden was cheated out of the show with how late Wagner was on that week.

Thats why I dont get why people say results like Jedward staying over Lucie was worse than this.
Because Aiden was boring and **** and Wagner was entertaining and legendary

[Mystic Mock]

Because Aiden was boring and **** and Wagner was entertaining and legendary

I thought Aiden was an interesting performer that was really good when danii gave him the correct song choices,while Wagner was entertaining and pulled out Creep in week 8 but they shouldnt be showing blatent bias in the timeslots as Wagner was on later than Aiden in week 2,3,4,5 & week 6.

Really that week it should have been wagner on first with Katie on second which then equals the true bottom two of week 6.

[AndyEssex1]

Simon keeping in Jedward over Lucie Jones, considering he had said the whole series that the first chance he had to get rid of them, he would, and he didn't. Lucie was growing in the sho at exactly the same time as Alexandra did in 2008. I think that decision lost Simon a lot of respect and made a lot of people angry (not that he cares)

[bbfan1991]

Simon keeping in Jedward over Lucie Jones, considering he had said the whole series that the first chance he had to get rid of them, he would, and he didn't. Lucie was growing in the sho at exactly the same time as Alexandra did in 2008. I think that decision lost Simon a lot of respect and made a lot of people angry (not that he cares)

Like Simon said both had no chance of winning, although Lucie was more talented they've both done well after the show and she was dignifed about her exit despite the disappointment and she said Jedward worked hard.

For business reasons Simon realised he had to keep Jedward in for a bit longer because of their crazy antics and controversial element.