Old Judges v New Judges....

[Stevep]

...who do you prefer? I wasn't totally convinced when they appointed Kelly Rowland, but i must admit she's pretty good.
(Btw, when i say old, i mean last years)


Also if you was given the option to pick 4 judges from all the previous judges, plus the ones on there now, who would you pick?

[Lewis.]

I'd have Simon, Gary, Kelly and Sharon.

[Tom4784]

Gary, Dannii, Kelly & Simon.

[Vicky.]

Gary, Dannii, Kelly & Simon.

^^

[Tom]

They'll never ever ever ever ever top the original Simon, Sharon & Louis. That one went to pot when Dannii joined but Simon, Cheryl, Dannii and Louis will always be remembered as the defining panel. The new lot are doing fine, another year of the same panel would've been boring. I like them all, Gary annoys me a bit but meh

[MusicXian]

I like Tulisa. Not necessarily saying she made the best choices always but she brings her personality to the show.

[Joelle.]

I like the new judges, but Louis still being there spoils it a bit.

Kelly, Dannii, Simon and Gary would be the best panel.

[Princess]

New anyday and not just because of Gary but I just love the new panel, don't miss any of the old judges.

[joeysteele]

My choices would be Gary,Louis, Kelly and Dannii. Simon had gone rather stale,my views of Ms Cole are well known and Sharon wasn't a good mentor really.

Tulisa has already messed the groups section up this year, daft re-forming groups at Judges house stage,niot even hearing the re-formed group even sing together again.She'll be down to 2 acts in about 4 weeks.