X-Factor Ratings Week 1

[Tom4784]

You know the drill, rate the acts and tell us your thoughts. Also tell us who you think should leave.

Amelia Lily - 7/10 It wasn't bad, it was forgettable by the end though.
Johnny Robinson - 4/10 It was....fun. It'll be in between him or Jonjo to leave though.
Frankie Cocozza - 5/10 He needs to work on his breathing, he sounded like he just ran a marathon.
Rhythmics - 6/10 They shouldn't all rap it was cringey. If they had to do Nicky Minaj then they should have done Moment 4 Life, Fly or Your Love as they have more singy bits in there. It was decent though.
Sophie Habibis - 8/10 A really strong performance, shame she'll be going tomorrow though, it should be Amelia that leaves.
Jonjo Kerr - 2/10 I can barely remember it apart from the fact it was terrible.
James Micheal - 7/10 It wasn't perfect but I liked it, he's the best boy in my opinion.
2 Shoes - 6/10 They're fun but I think they'll be going home.
Misha Bryan - 8/10 If Janet doesn't win she will.
Sami Brookes - 7/10 Good vocal, I like how she didn't go down the ballad route but we've seen it all before.
Nu Vibe - 2/10 They sounded like a bunch of drunks singing a football chant.
Marcus Collins - 6/10 Terrible song choice.
The Risk - 7/10 Probably the best group.
Kitty Brucknell - KITTY/10 Quite frankly the most stunning thing I've ever witnessed on X Factor. Give her the recording contract now. Lady Gaga wishes she was Kitty Brucknell.
Craig Colton - 5/10 Yawn.
Janet Devlin - 8/10 She's gonna win the whole thing.

FIRST ELIMINATIONS
Jonjo - He looks like he's been plucked off the street and been made to sing.
Craig Colton - He bores me to tears, he has talent but he's got no chance of winning.
Nu Vibe - They're awful, Tulisa would be wise to cut them and keep the boyband vote intact for The Risk as they'll both suffer if they both stay.
Amelia Lily - She was the weakest girl, I like all of Kelly's acts though.

[Jordan.]

Janet - 9/10
Misha - 8/10
Amelia - 7/10
Sophie - 7/10
The Risk - 6/10
Frankie - 6/10
Kitty - 6/10
Craig - 6/10
Rhythmix - 5/10
James - 5/10
Sami - 5/10
Marcus - 5/10
Nu Vibe - 3/10
Jonjo - 3/10
Johnny - 1/10
2 Shoes - 0/10

[Marc]

Janet Misha and Craig were all great.

The groups were all pretty rubbish but I do find 2Shoes funny and therefore want them to stay and Nu Vibe can ******* off

[MusicXian]

I've said who I think will go, but I want

Frankie
Misha
Old Vibe
Johnny

To go. Unfortunately none of them will.

[IheartBB]

Amelia - Losing the distinctive white blonde hair was a mistake. But as far as the performance goes, it was a very solid opener and set the standard for the rest of the night -- 7/10
Johnny - No comment - 1/10
Rhythmix - I expected a car crash and I pretty much got it. Miss Frank are still the best girl band in X-Factor history, despite what Gary Barlow says -- 2/10
Frankie - Didn’t get it at all. Awkward stage presence and a song that he didn’t look comfortable singing. I thought he would be edgier -- 2/10
Sophie - Nice performance. She’s someone who can offer so much over the course of the show I feel. It’s just a shame this silly “twist” will probably see her go home in the first week -- 6/10
Jonjo - Cringe worthy. Below average vocals, hardly any emotion and zero energy. His apparent poor working relationship with Louis does not bode well for him tomorrow -- 2/10
2 Shoes - This is probably as good as it’s going to get from them. It was fun but they are merely making up the numbers -- 3/10
James - I was intrigued to see him perform with his guitar but it was all very under-whelming. It only seemed to put emphasis on his average vocals -- 3/10
Misha - What a talent. Best of the night -- 8/10
Nu Vibe - Good start, messy middle, solid ending. Could be interesting to watch over the weeks. I can only hope the scouse guy doesn’t get a microphone next week though -- 5/10
Marcus - Unnecessarily cheesy. With a voice like his, he doesn’t need gimmicks -- 4/10
Sami - She did very well considering the terrible song choice. I expect her to only get better over the weeks -- 6/10
The Risk - A risk that seems to have paid off. Much better than expected. Undoubtedly the best group -- 7/10
Craig - Hit about 75% of the notes. Likable guy but I don’t see a market for him after the show -- 6/10
Kitty - Average in pretty much every sense. She didn’t really do herself justice tonight -- 4/10
Janet - Not a huge fan of the Ellie Golding style voice but she did well tonight and will go very far in this competition -- 6/10

[Jords]

Sophie 9/10
Kitty 9/10
--------------------
The Risk 8/10
Craig 8/10
Janet 8/10
Rhythmix 8/10
--------------------
James 7/10
Sami 7/10
--------------------
Misha 6/10
Nu Vibe 6/10
Johnny 6/10
--------------------
Amelia 5/10
2 Shoes 5/10
--------------------
Frankie 4/10
Marcus 4/10
--------------------
Jonjo 3/10

[nanaimo]

Janet 10/10
Misha 9/10
Amelia 8/10
Rhythmix 7/10
Craig 7/10
Sophie 6/10
The Risk 6/10
James 4/10
Johnny 4/10
2 Shoes 3/10
Marcus 3/10
Sami 2/10
Kitty 2/10
Frankie 1/10
Jojo 0/10
Nu Vibe 0/10

[Kerry]

Amelia Lily - 7/10
Johnny 0/10 (Louis is just ripping the piss out of him)
Frankie 3/10 (looked like he needed the loo)
Rhythmics 8/10 (better than I thought)
Sophie 9/10
JonJo 2/10 (disappointed :( )
2 Shoes 0/10 (another farce)
James 7/10
Misha 8/10
Nu Vibe 3/10 (barely remember them)
Marcus totally forgotten it
The Risk 10/10
Kitty 7/10
Craig 8/10
Janet 10/10

[MeMyselfAndI]

Sophie - 10/10
Janet - 10/10
Misha B - 9/10
The Risk - 9/10
Craig - 8/10
Kitty - 7/10
Rythmics - 6/10
Amelia -6/10 (Disspointed, still prefure her to Misha B though)
Marcus - 6/10
James - 5/10
2 Shoes - 4/10
Jonjo - 4/10
Frankie - 4/10
Nu Vibe - 3/10
Johnny - 2/10

[fruit_cake]

Amelia Lily 4
Johnny 0
Frankie 4
Rhythmics 4
Sophie 6
JonJo 4
2 Shoes 1
James 5
Misha 5
Nu Vibe 6
Marcus 6
The Risk 4
Craig 8
Kitty 6
Janet 8

[Rawrbear]

Amelia Lily - 8/10 I though Amelia did very well, she put a good twist on the song and she did not disappoint
Johnny Robinson - 1/10 What was that...
Frankie Cocozza - 5/10 The verse were great, but the chorus that was another thing
Rhythmics - 6/10 When they started i was all like "what are they doing" but halfway through the song they really got into and well done to them i enjoyed it
Sophie Habibis - 6/10 Yawn..Am going to blame the song choice though
Jonjo Kerr - 2/10 What a car crash
James Micheal - 7/10 I really enjoyed his performance and i think it will be Sad that he goes home (most likely)
2 Shoes - 6/10 I usally hate the gimmicky joke acts...But i liked them, Diva fever who can sing?
Misha Bryan - 9/10 As Kelly would say She "killed it" it was an amassing preformance
Sami Brookes - 6/10 I dont know what to think about Sami....
Nu Vibe - 0/10 They should go home it was horrid
Marcus Collins - 5/10 "Terrible song choice." <---Agreed
The Risk - 7/10 Surprised me i found them pretty good
Kitty Brucknell - 7/10 Most say she tried and did well
Craig Colton - 7/10 Enjoyed Craig's Performance but he will go home in a few weeks
Janet Devlin - 7/10 I kinda forgot Janet performance i just recall she did really well

FIRST ELIMINATIONS
Jonjo - Well first performance was dreadful looked like he hated it
Frankie - Frankie seems like he can only sing one time of song
Nu Vibe - When watching i just wanted their performance if this was a public vote they'd be goners
Sophie - Who?

[Sam:)]

Amelia 5/10
Johnny 2/10
Rhythmix 6/10
Frankie 0/10
Sophie 8/10
Jonjo 3/10
2 Shoes 4/10
James 7/10
Misha 8/10
Nu Vibe 3/10
Marcus 6/10
Sami 6/10
The Risk 7/10
Craig 9/10
Kitty 8/10
Janet 7/10

[Joelle.]

Misha - 10/10
Janet - 9/10
Craig - 9/10
Sophie - 9/10
The Risk - 9/10
Sami - 8/10
Marcus - 8/10
Amelia - 7/10
Rhythmix - 7/10
Kitty - 7/10
Frankie - 5/10
James - 4/10
Johnny - 3/10
2 Shoes - 2/10
Jonjo - 1/10
Nu Vibe - 0/10

[Z]

Watched them all on YouTube earlier...

Amelia Lily - 3/10 - forgettable, a bit out of tune at points as well.
Johnny Robinson - 2/10 - made me cringe but he can actually sing, even if it's mortifying
Frankie Cocozza - 2/10 - terrible, it was a naff, identical (yet worse) copycat version of the original and his stage presence was just awkward. The breathing into the microphone was weird.
Rhythmix - 4/10 - better than the usual girl band output but they grate on me a bit; I think it's perhaps their image, would be nice if they weren't dressed in such a generic X Factor way... I dunno. The performance was probably one of the most exciting ones.
Sophie Habibis - 6/10 - The only performance that actually stood out for me, she's a very good singer but it wasn't amazing.
Jonjo Kerr - 2/10 - pub singer, doesn't stand out at all.
James Michael - 3/10 - out of tune at times I thought and really boring performance.
2 Shoes - 2/10 - nothing wrong with their singing but it got boring and I tuned out, the song didn't do them any favours.
Misha Bryan - 4/10 - it was good but she's way too confident, maybe even over confident, and puts it across in her performance in a very irritating manner - she's full of herself. Don't like her.
Sami Brookes - 3/10 - the singing was fine but, as with 2 Shoes, I zoned out and didn't find it particularly entertaining.
Nu Vibe - 3/10 - it started out like it was going to be brilliant but they lost their way a bit during the performance and it started to be a bit shouty, they're pretty forgettable.
Marcus Collins - 2/10 - sounded off key to me and it was a crap song choice, but he should be better with a different song.
The Risk - 4/10 - pretty solid effort but it screamed rip off to me, they're better than Nu Vibe.
Kitty Brucknell - 2/10 - utter crap. She was off key at times and shouted her way through it. Waissel comparisons with the whole singing Queen on Week 1 and going for a wacky image/wacky imagery.
Craig Colton - 3/10 - good vocals I guess but it made me cringe how seriously he was taking himself with the facial expressions.
Janet Devlin - 4/10 - it was captivating at times but she wasn't fantastic; I reckon she's the favourite though going by what I've seen of the auditions etc.