X Factor Live; Elimination #4 - 8pm [Discussion Thread]

[Smithy]

It's a Halloween themed week on XF, and with Kelly stuck in the US due to a viral infection, series 5 winner Alexandra Burke will fill in as a guest judge :amazed:

http://www.firstnews.co.uk/site_data/images/alexandra_burke_4b86928147c73.jpg

QOTD: Will Alexandra be a good judge, or just say "I know how hard this is, and you did well" ?

[Doogle]

Alex :lovedup:

QOTD: the latter :(

[Tom]

It should've been

http://static.unrealitytv.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2010/08/nicole.jpg

:(

[Tom]

It should've been

http://static.unrealitytv.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2010/08/nicole.jpg

:(

[Locke.]

Nicole is an unbelivably terrible judge.

Hopefully Alex is good.

[Tom]

Nicole is an unbelivably terrible judge.

Hopefully Alex is good.

Shes awful on the American one but she was good on the British one last year

Alex will be fine and is a good choice, I just hope she doesn't sit there and say how amazing everyone is

[Doogle]

I love Nicole and thought she was great last year but I didn't really want her there tonight.

She was amazing on XF USA last night though :love:

[Maia]

I'm not sure how I feel about Alex being a judge...We'll see though, hopefully she does alright

[Callum]

Alex will be a good judge I think, she has the experience anyway.

[arista]

Also on ITV1HD


http://i.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2011/10/29/article-2054908-0E955EEF00000578-22_224x634.jpg
Dermot getting Ready for Tonights Live Show

[GypsyGoth]

:amazed:

[Smithy]

flop theme

[GypsyGoth]

qotd: I think Alex will be an awful judge, well she'll been too afraid to insult anyone.

[Maia]

Rhythmix has a new name, The Risk has a new member, and the panel has a new judge. Here we go, this is The X Factor.

[Smithy]

wtf, cringe at gary

[GypsyGoth]

Tulisa :lovedup:

[Maia]

It looks so random having Alexandra there :laugh:

[Braden]

It's actually nice to see Alexandra again.

[Braden]

okay, what the **** is Tulisa wearing?

[Maia]

Tulisa's cat ears LOL

[Locke.]

Tulisa :worship:

[Tom]

Its quite funny how Louis has sat next to two people who have come off a talent show he's judged. First Cheryl and now Alex

[Callum]

Too much drama

[Doogle]

Sob story in the live shows. :rolleyes:

[Gillian-73]

QOTD Alexandra will probably just be nice to them all! i wasn't expecting her i thought they'd get nicole in

[Harry!]

Sob story in the live shows. :rolleyes:

This :bored:

[GypsyGoth]

That is a pretty good choice.

[Maia]

X Factor groups usually tend to lose members and stuff after the show. This year's bunch really aren't wasting any time.

[Ninastar]

D:

[Doogle]

So he got rejected as a solo artist, became a boyband member, got voted out then came back in another boyband?

[Callum]

Horrendous

[Tom]

So they've replaced someone who was useless with someone whos equally useless? They should've just stuck with the 3 of them

[Maia]

So he got rejected as a solo artist, became a boyband member, got voted out then came back in another boyband?

Pretty much LOL. Just about sums up this series :tongue:

[Harry!]

I really hate how this year all classic songs have been "modernised"

[GypsyGoth]

This sounds a bit flat.

[Harry!]

Flat, dull

[Maia]

The Nu Vibe member is rubbing off the dull Nu Vibe effect onto The Risk.

[Novo]

That was amazing

[Maia]

PMSL when Alexandra came on my mum was all "WHO'S SHE?"

[Ithinkiloveyoutoo]

love alex. fook kelly

[Smithy]

oh it was gary who did the been there done that first :idc:

[Tom]

Impressed with Alexandra already

[Braden]

The judges are trying to trick us into liking them by giving them positive feedback, like they're better vocalists blah blah blah.

I've got their number,

[Callum]

Alexandra Burke is a good judge

[Maia]

Heeeere's Johnny

[Locke.]

The Risk and Johnny, the best 2 on first, what is going on

[Harry!]

Johnny is so funny!

[Smithy]

:laugh3:

[Tom]

Should have been Wuthering Heights :idc:

[Doogle]

Absolutely amazing :worship:

[Harry!]

Least he isn't doing Madonna's Frozen, I love him!

[Novo]

This is really good, this is what he can do when they don't make him a joke act

[Maia]

Johnny owning the stage

[Tom]

wtf Gary

[Maia]

The Risk - 3/10
Johnny - 7/10

[Gillian-73]

The Risk 3/10
Johnny 7/10

[Novo]

The Risk - 7/10
Johnny - 8/10

[GypsyGoth]

I used to dislike him, but he's actually ok.

The Risk 4/10
Johnny 6/10

[Locke.]

The Risk - 6/10
Johnny - 6/10

Johnny is bottom 2 tomorrow night.

[Maia]

Sophie and Marcus :amazed:

[Callum]

Johnny is overrated

[Adamw92]

The Risk - 5.5/10
Johnny - 6.5/10

[Doogle]

If Johnny is B2 with that performance I'll be very annoyed.

[GypsyGoth]

Everyone in the square wants her to win.

[GypsyGoth]

This is from Kill Bill :amazed:

[Tom]

I like this song, but the Audiobullies version.

[Maia]

Now it feels more like Halloween :love:

[Gillian-73]

I love sophie

[Ninastar]

i like this song

[Smithy]

omg :lovedup:

[Harry!]

Oh a bit of Cher <3 Bang Bang <3

[Tom]

Not her best performance, and I hate people who sing in a London accent. Bottom 2 methinks

[Maia]

If she did the Audio Bullys version that would've been amazing

[Doogle]

Her worst one yet.

[GypsyGoth]

I think it was a brave performance.

[Maia]

The Risk - 3/10
Johnny - 7/10
Sophie - 8/10

[Gillian-73]

I liked that, love the song

[Maia]

The Audio Bullys version is what was missing Louis

[Adamw92]

The Risk - 5.5/10
Johnny - 6.5/10
Sophie - 6/10

[GypsyGoth]

The Risk 4/10
Johnny 6/10
Sophie 7/10

[Doogle]

I agree with Gary (:()

[Vicky.]

Alexandra should be a permanent judge

[Harry!]

I liked that <3

[Gillian-73]

Not her best performance but still my fave of the night thus far!

[Adamw92]

I actually agree with Louis :shocked:

[Niamh.]

Christ, Sophie was brutal :/

[Smithy]

2 weeks in a row garys put marcus on first :bored:

[Doogle]

Marcus :amazed:

[Maia]

She should've done this non ballad version of the song...:whistle:

kxr5Rg-Sotg

[Gillian-73]

The Risk 3/10
Johnny 7/10
Sophie 7.5/10

[Tom]

Why does everyone keep calling her Alexander?

Marcus annoys me, I think theres something really sly about him

[Maia]

Ahh yes, time for the real talent :worship:

[Niamh.]

The Risk - 6/10
Johnny - 8.5/10
Sophie - 3/10

[Maia]

Superstition and Need You Tonight mashup? :suspect:

[Niamh.]

Love Marcus

[Tom]

He'd be better in a boy band

[Niamh.]

The Risk - 6/10
Johnny - 8.5/10
Sophie - 3/10
Marcus - 8/10

[Vicky.]

First week when I have liked Marcus

[Adamw92]

The Risk - 5.5/10
Johnny - 6.5/10
Sophie - 6/10
Marcus - 8.5/10

[Maia]

The Risk - 3/10
Johnny - 7/10
Sophie - 8/10
Marcus - 8/10

[GypsyGoth]

He's a good performer.

[Locke.]

Marcus - 6.5/10
The Risk - 6/10
Johnny - 6/10
Sophie - 3/10

[GypsyGoth]

The Risk 4/10
Johnny 6/10
Sophie 7/10
Marcus 7/10

[Doogle]

His best performance yet. :D

[Locke.]

He'd be better in a boy band

He was in Eton Road after they were on this a few years ago

[Gillian-73]

The Risk 3/10
Johnny 7/10
Sophie 7.5/10
Marcus 6.5/10

[Callum]

Really enjoying Alexandra as a judge

[Maia]

Misha Beee

[Locke.]

Misha :bored:

[Maia]

I am pretty sure she wore that outfit before

[Doogle]

Ugh not this song.

[Tom]

Damage limitation when they realise the only one that can win and have a good career after it had judges against her

[Smithy]

WTF is on her head

[Maia]

All I think of when I hear this is the Corsydol advert

[Gillian-73]

I like alexandra as a judge!

[Harry!]

Love Misha B <3 Although she is too much like Nicki Minaj.

[Maia]

That was actually good

[Ninastar]

WTF is on her head

a monobrow and a horn

[Tom]

Great Halloween performance!

[GypsyGoth]

The Risk 4/10
Johnny 6/10
Sophie 7/10
Marcus 7/10
Misha B 8/10

[Maia]

Louis trying to imitate Kelly :joker::joker:

[Tom]

Louis: "You put it down baby girl" :laugh3:

[Gillian-73]

Didn't enjoy misha as much tonight!

[Callum]

I don't like Misha. Her raps are unnecessary.

[Adamw92]

The Risk - 5.5/10
Johnny - 6.5/10
Sophie - 6/10
Marcus - 8.5/10
Misha - 6.5/10

[Maia]

The Risk - 3/10
Johnny - 7/10
Sophie - 7/10
Marcus - 8/10
Misha - 7.5/10

[Locke.]

Can't wait for her to go home

[Tom]

Can't wait for her to go home

You have a long wait :idc:

[Gillian-73]

The Risk 3/10
Johnny 7/10
Sophie 7.5/10
Marcus 6.5/10
Misha B 6.5/10

[Locke.]

She won't make the top 5, so less than 6 weeks, that is short enough

[Maia]

Looking forward to Janet and...dare I say it...Frankie as well.

[Callum]

Looking forward to the star of the show Kitty

[Smithy]

upbeat? :joker:

[Maia]

Janet :worship:

[Ninastar]

Looking forward to Janet and...dare I say it...Frankie as well.

we can no longer be friends

[Locke.]

Janet actually looks quite fit tonight

[Smithy]

:love:

[Braden]

It's like she's being out of tune on purpose.

[Adamw92]

:lovedup:

[Tom]

Janet is awful but good performance for the theme. she looks psycho

[GypsyGoth]

Wow!!!!!

[GypsyGoth]

The Risk 4/10
Johnny 6/10
Sophie 7/10
Marcus 7/10
Misha B 8/10
Janet 9/10

[Maia]

we can no longer be friends

But he's so hateable it's fun to watch :sad:

[Adamw92]

The Risk - 5.5/10
Johnny - 6.5/10
Sophie - 6/10
Marcus - 8.5/10
Misha - 6.5/10
Janet - 9/10

[Maia]

The Risk - 3/10
Johnny - 7/10
Sophie - 7/10
Marcus - 8/10
Misha - 7.5/10
Janet - 9/10

[LaLaLand]

Right so it'snot okay for Sophie to sing ballads every weeks but Janet can do whatever she likes?

They're obviously given 'targets' of who to give negative advice to thus influencing the votes.

[Locke.]

Janet - 7/10
Marcus - 6.5/10
The Risk - 6/10
Johnny - 6/10
Misha - 5/10
Sophie - 3/10

Pretty crap so far..... again

[Ithinkiloveyoutoo]

she's alright but she needs variety

[Maia]

I hope she plays guitar one of these weeks :love:

[Maia]

Oh my god. Here he is.

[Smithy]

he's never ****ing proud of what he's done :rolleyes:

[Maia]

:laugh2: He is such a prick

[Callum]

:yuk:

[Maia]

Blooody hell

[Gillian-73]

The Risk 3/10
Johnny 7/10
Sophie 7.5/10
Marcus 6.5/10
Misha B 6.5/10
Janet 8/10

[Braden]

I'm so over these intro's.

[Ninastar]

But he's so hateable it's fun to watch :sad:

okay, we can be civil

[Maia]

I didn't think he could get any worse

[GypsyGoth]

The song suits his limited singing voice.

[Adamw92]

You should go, Frankie

[Ithinkiloveyoutoo]

frankie sooks

[Gillian-73]

This is probably frankie's best performance! not that i like him!

[GypsyGoth]

The Risk 4/10
Johnny 6/10
Sophie 7/10
Marcus 7/10
Misha B 8/10
Janet 9/10
Frankie 4/10

[Adamw92]

The Risk - 5.5/10
Johnny - 6.5/10
Sophie - 6/10
Marcus - 8.5/10
Misha - 6.5/10
Janet - 9/10
Frankie - 4/10

[Tom]

Louis is on fire "you're like a young Robbie with a silly haircut"

Why is going on a night out so rebellious? :rolleyes:

[Callum]

Kitty is the best

[Maia]

The Risk - 3/10
Johnny - 7/10
Sophie - 7/10
Marcus - 8/10
Misha - 7.5/10
Janet - 9/10
Frankie - 4/10

[Locke.]

It is so annoying how they put him across as someones who is with different women all the time when he clearly isn't :bored:

The best footage they had of him was giving the slut from geordie shore a friendly kiss on the lips, which just proves the point even further, even Novo could pull that off

[Jords]

Frankie was ok tonight but hes just a right ****, and hes acting way too up.

[Gillian-73]

The Risk 3/10
Johnny 7/10
Sophie 7.5/10
Marcus 6.5/10
Misha B 6.5/10
Janet 8/10
Frankie 4.5/10

[nanaimo]

GO!

[Harry!]

Frankie the definition of Halloween.

[Gillian-73]

I really don't like kitty but there's no doubt she can sing!

[Tom]

Frankie goes on a night out and he's a rebel

Kitty goes on a night out and shes meeting new people

Sweet Dreams :amazed: love this song

[GypsyGoth]

The Risk 4/10
Johnny 6/10
Sophie 7/10
Marcus 7/10
Misha B 8/10
Janet 9/10
Frankie 4/10
Kitty 6/10

[Adamw92]

The Risk - 5.5/10
Johnny - 6.5/10
Sophie - 6/10
Marcus - 8.5/10
Misha - 6.5/10
Janet - 9/10
Frankie - 4/10
Kitty - 7/10

[Gillian-73]

Love the song! like i said before i don't like her but i did actually quite like that!

[Locke.]

Janet - 7/10
Kitty - 6.5/10
Marcus - 6.5/10
The Risk - 6/10
Johnny - 6/10
Misha - 5/10
Sophie - 3/10
Frankie - 3/10

[Vicky.]

Louis is such an ignorant twat. Shouting over Alex :bored:

[Kazanne]

Feel sorry for Frankie,he's a young lad,what lad that age would not be a bit cocky,and they all go out partying,I think he's ok

[Gillian-73]

The Risk 3/10
Johnny 7/10
Sophie 7.5/10
Marcus 6.5/10
Misha B 6.5/10
Janet 8/10
Frankie 4.5/10
Kitty 7/10

[Callum]

Worst competition ever

[Callum]

Alexandra Burke's "dot com" comment was funny :laugh:

[Harry!]

Love Krazy Kitty!

[Locke.]

Craig should be great with his song but it is just the same type of song for him once again

[Callum]

Kitty was the best as usual

[Black Dagger]

OK.com

Shut up Alex :/

What a terrible evening, only Marcus, Johnny, Janet and Sophie have stood out.

[Black Dagger]

Unbelievably **** name...

[Maia]

Rhythm - I mean...Little Mix :amazed:

[GypsyGoth]

I don't get the name change, I suppose it's marginally better.

[Tom]

Her from Little Rhythmix clearly saw my thread. Oops, sorry about that you fat ugly beast with weird features

[Ninastar]

nooo poor chubs! I think she's adorable and beautiful

[Locke.]

Poor girl has seen Tom's thread about her

[Gillian-73]

What sort of name is little mix for a band! rubbish.

[GypsyGoth]

nooo poor chubs! I think she's adorable and beautiful

I agree, I hope she doesn't get an eating disorder now.

[Tom]

This is Amelia's song :nono:

[Maia]

O_O What

[Ninastar]

omg amazing :D

[Maia]

A couple of them look freakishly robotic

[Black Dagger]

They are surprisingly good...

Still can't take the name seriously.

[Braden]

:( I hope she never saw my post comparing her to a Sloth, I did say she could be a cute Sloth.

[Novo]

These are so underrated

[GypsyGoth]

Brilliant performance :love:

[Maia]

This is good, but why are they trying to be so robotic :joker:

[Tom]

That was terrible

[Adamw92]

Loved that!

[Ninastar]

These are so underrated

:worship:

[GypsyGoth]

The Risk 4/10
Johnny 6/10
Sophie 7/10
Marcus 7/10
Misha B 8/10
Janet 9/10
Frankie 4/10
Kitty 6/10
Little Mix 8/10

[Callum]

I much prefer Katy's version

[Locke.]

Think these might be my favourites

[Smithy]

they were really good :love:

[Maia]

The Risk - 3/10
Johnny - 7/10
Sophie - 7/10
Marcus - 8/10
Misha - 7.5/10
Janet - 9/10
Frankie - 4/10
Little Mix - 9/10

[Adamw92]

The Risk - 5.5/10
Johnny - 6.5/10
Sophie - 6/10
Marcus - 8.5/10
Misha - 6.5/10
Janet - 9/10
Frankie - 4/10
Kitty - 7/10
Little Mix - 8.5/10

[Locke.]

Little Mix - 8/10
Janet - 7/10
Kitty - 6.5/10
Marcus - 6.5/10
The Risk - 6/10
Johnny - 6/10
Misha - 5/10
Sophie - 3/10
Frankie - 3/10

[Black Dagger]

The Risk 3/10
Johnny 7/10
Sophie 7/10
Marcus 8/10
Misha 7/10
Janet 9/10
Frankie 1/10 (He turned up, so he get's a point)
Little Mix 9/10

[Gillian-73]

These don't do it for me! girl and boy bands tend not too though because they're just not my thing.

[GypsyGoth]

Craig looks like someone who might owe you money.

[Locke.]

Haven't seen one of these vote craig posters

[eezamana]

Is it just me, or does anyone think, "YaY!!!!" its 'Benny Hill' when Craig comes on?

I'm sure they're related.:hugesmile:

[Maia]

Wonder how he's gonna make Set Fire To The Rain Halloweenish

[Gillian-73]

The Risk 3/10
Johnny 7/10
Sophie 7.5/10
Marcus 6.5/10
Misha B 6.5/10
Janet 8/10
Frankie 4.5/10
Kitty 7/10
Little Mix 5.5/10

[Tom]

So male Adele is doing an Adele song?

He still sings like a fat black woman from South London

[Locke.]

Not fair on Marcus that they are pushing Craig for the liverpool vote

[Maia]

Craig looks like someone who might owe you money.

:laugh2:

[Tom]

Wonder how he's gonna make Set Fire To The Rain Halloweenish

By setting fire to Lorraine?

[Smithy]

That weirdass wobbling he does is sf annoying

[Maia]

Is it me or is he trying to look like the lead guy from Coldplay

[Gillian-73]

Craig looks like someone who might owe you money.

Lmfao

[Adamw92]

By setting fire to Lorraine?

:laugh3:

[Harry!]

He still annoys me!

[Maia]

By setting fire to Lorraine?

:joker::joker:

[Tom]

Not a Craig fan but he did best performance of the night

[GypsyGoth]

The Risk 4/10
Johnny 6/10
Sophie 7/10
Marcus 7/10
Misha B 8/10
Janet 9/10
Frankie 4/10
Kitty 6/10
Little Mix 8/10
Craig 7/10

[Maia]

I somehow don't think Locke will be voting for him

[Adamw92]

The Risk - 5.5/10
Johnny - 6.5/10
Sophie - 6/10
Marcus - 8.5/10
Misha - 6.5/10
Janet - 9/10
Frankie - 4/10
Kitty - 7/10
Little Mix - 8.5/10
Craig - 7/10

[Gillian-73]

His coat/jacket is lovely! be even nicer in my size :D

[Maia]

The Risk - 3/10
Johnny - 7/10
Sophie - 7/10
Marcus - 8/10
Misha - 7.5/10
Janet - 9/10
Frankie - 4/10
Little Mix - 9/10
Craig - 5/10

[Black Dagger]

I liked that...

Don't want him to win though and he isn't in my top 5.

[Gillian-73]

The Risk 3/10
Johnny 7/10
Sophie 7.5/10
Marcus 6.5/10
Misha B 6.5/10
Janet 8/10
Frankie 4.5/10
Kitty 7/10
Little Mix 5.5/10
Craig 8.5/10
Craig my performance of the night!

[Locke.]

Little Mix - 8/10
Craig - 7.5/10
Janet - 7/10
Kitty - 6.5/10
Marcus - 6.5/10
The Risk - 6/10
Johnny - 6/10
Misha - 5/10
Sophie - 3/10
Frankie - 3/10

Little Mix, Craig and Janet = Good. Everyone else was either average or crap.

[Smithy]

Cher Lloyd

http://t0.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcRxrUXErCDoqCBnevAdbBo8_LOzy86TO BYQ670OJIITPw68lSk27JcwRZ8Q

[Maia]

Little Mix, Craig and Janet = Good. Everyone else was either average or crap.

Looks like the whole of Liverpool will be voting for Craig then

[Callum]

Kitty was the best by a mile

[Locke.]

Looks like the whole of Liverpool will be voting for Craig then

The whole of Liverpool will be voting for Little Mix and The Risk :idc:

[Callum]

That show was so boring, I don't what it is with XF this year but it's felt so dull.

[Marsh.]

I'm surprised Kitty is as liked as she is, I find her unbearable. Her voice is completely flat with no range whatsoever.

It's only when she reaches the high note that she finally has a good voice but unfortunately a whole song of that high note just comes across as shouting.

Just like Frankie, she is overcompensating the fact she doesn't have much of a voice with the shouting.

[Tom]

Jenny is back on Xtra Factor :amazed:

[Tom4784]

The Risk 2/10 - Very Karaoke.
Johnny 6/10 - His best performance.
Sophie 8/10 - One of my favourite performances of the night.
Marcus 7/10 - It was a good performance.
Misha B 8/10 - Another strong performance.
Janet 7/10 - I liked it, she needs to mix it up a little though.
Frankie 5/10 - His best performance.
Kitty KITTY/10 - Just give her the prize already.
Little Mix 8/10 - A very strong performance.
Craig 5/10 - Terrible diction, he bores me to tears.

[eezamana]

Kitty was the best by a mile

Yip, I'm with you on that one mate............Kitty, the best by a country mile.:)

[Visage]

The risk are in my top three but tonight's performance really let me down.