Alexandra or Kelly?

[Kate!]

Having seen Alex stand in for Kelly last night, and doing a great job, I would prefer her to stay and Kelly not come back. Whats your opinion?

[Saph]

As much as I like Kelly, she comes across as the 'bitch judge' in a bad way, so I chose Alexandra

[joeysteele]

Kelly irritates me as a judge, I did enjoy Alex on the show last night to be honest.

[MeMyselfAndI]

They both irratate me a bit, I do like Alexandras Music, but not her personality LOL

[Visage]

I thought Alexandra was great last night, but I do really like Kelly.

[fruit_cake]

I can't stand Alex but at least she seems more real than the other judges

[Gillian-73]

Loved kelly at first but she does my head in now, alex was great last night! voted alex.

[Adamw92]

Alexandra! loved her as a judge last night :D

[Jordan.]

Kelly because I like the arguements when she stands up to the other judges. Alex was a good stand in though.

[Marsh.]

Kelly's been doing my head-in, she is not a good judge at all.

Yes, she can scream praise at one of "My girrrrrls, wooo" and whip the audience into screaming, yes she can argue with the other judges but she seems empty headed when giving her own feedback. She's worse than Cheryl when it comes to portraying expertise in the music industry, there's nothing interesting to be heard from her. Just an "I love it" or "That was the wrong song".

But Alexandra, as much as I never liked her and found her overconfident and slightly arrogant, I appreciated how she tried to give a positive and a negative along with some advice for improvement. Even if it was a little try-hard at times.

Don't think she'd work full time but she did a good job.

[Tom]

I liked Kelly during the auditions but she's unbearable now. Its judges like her that makes me wish they'd drop the mentor aspect

Alex brought a different dynamic to the panel. She was OK but last nights panel was all a bit flat

[Locke.]

I can't stand Kelly, so voted Alex, but she weren't great either