What would you say is the worst decision in X Factor history?

[Mystic Mock]

This series is included and the decision can be by the public or the judges that you disagreed with them on.

What I found was the worst decision in X Factor was when Aiden Grimshaw got voted out by the judges against Katie Waissel last year as Simon knew the results and he still voted out the better and way more popular act out.

Anyway whats your worst decision in X Factor history?

[Niamh.]

It all depends on who you like imo. The person I was most upset to see go prematurely was Laura White though

[Vicky.]

Aiden and Katie
Lucie and Jedward

:bored:

[Jordan.]

Amelia sent home

[nanaimo]

agree with jordan, thats the worst ever

[Locke.]

Amelia.

[Doogle]

Lucie & Jedward (but only because of Simon's vote)
Laura & Ruth :mad:
Maria & The Conway Sisters

[Mystic Mock]

I have got to say that the public voting for Leon to beat Rhydian in XF4 was disgraceful aswell as Leon was just a crybaby.

[Maia]

Lucie voted out over Jedward :bored: That was the moment my hatred for The X Factor began.

[Maia]

I have got to say that the public voting for Leon to beat Rhydian in XF4 was disgraceful aswell as Leon was just a crybaby.

Hated Rhydian, was so glad when Leon beat him, even though I didn't particularly like Leon either :tongue:

[Novo]

Katie getting saved or Aiden was amazing :joker: can remember everyone going mad

[Mystic Mock]

Katie getting saved or Aiden was amazing :joker: can remember everyone going mad

I remember when she stayed over Treyc it was quite bad on here and Digital Spy broke apart.:joker:

Treyc losing to Katie was a bad one aswell imo.

[Doogle]

XF4 was such a mess actually other than the amazing auditions and the bitchiness of the judging panel. My 2 favourites were Beverly and Nikki. The final 3 was so appalling and all the good ones went too early for my liking. And then there was all that controversy over Emily whatsherface too :joker:

[MeMyselfAndI]

Katie staying over Aiden & TreyC :bored:
Laura White losing to Ruth D:
Lucie going over Jedward :(

[King Gizzard]

Whoever stayed over Laura White

[Tom]

Louis sending home Maria over The Conway Sisters ... the original and best controversial exit. Only Jedward and Lucy came close to that

[Princess]

Louis sending home Maria over The Conway Sisters ... the original and best controversial exit. Only Jedward and Lucy came close to that

Was going to say this.

[Black Dagger]

The public voting Ray into the final over Ben...

Amelia and James being sent home.

Frankie making the live shows.

[Strictly Jake]

putting katie through instead of gamu. . .

[Adamw92]

X Factor 2005
Maria being sent home over The Conway Sisters :bawling:

X Factor 2006
Ray being voted into the final

X Factor 2007
Leon winning

X Factor 2008
Eoghan being voted into the final over Diana :bawling: :mad:

X Factor 2009
Lucie going home over Jedward :mad: :mad: :mad:
Olly making the final two over Stacey

X Factor 2010
Treyc being sent home over Katie :mad:
Matt winning over Rebecca

X Factor 2011
Kelly saving Sophie over Amelia :bored: :mad: :mad: :mad:

[bbfan1991]

Maria going over The Conway Sisters.

Lloyd lasting a week longer than Jedward. Lloyd beating Jamie on deadlock.

[Crimson Dynamo]

same diff

[Z]

Danyl being saved over Miss Frank - he was cocky, arrogant and I found it ridiculous that Simon was trying to push him forward as his chosen favourite for that year - Miss Frank were a far better act than Danyl, IMO. I stopped watching that series after they went out.

[Iceman]

Leona winning. She hasn't got an ounce of originality in her or personality.

[Ryan244]

Same difference getting to the final - just goes to show how crap XF4 was
Austin being voted off week 4 in XF5 - seriously probably the best male vocalist to have appeared on the show
XF8 - Frankie getting through the auditions, Amelia getting kicked out week 1, The whole judges pick their favourite acts week 1, Just basically a fail of a series !