X Factor Live; Elimination #4 - 8pm ITV1 [Discussion Thread]

[Smithy]

After a week off ill, Kelly returns to the panel tonight, and the contestants perform some "Club Classics"

http://i2.cdnds.net/11/43/reality_tv_x_factor_tulisa_kelly_01.jpg

QOTD: What should tomorrow's QOTD be, coz i'm totally out of idea's :bigsmile:

[michael21]

f-me i never thought to make one of theses threads next week :dance:

[Locke.]

Hopefully Johnny is good tonight, can't have him in the bottom 3 tomorrow

http://images.mirror.co.uk/upl/m4/oct2011/4/2/x-factor-johnny-robinson-cuddles-the-dog-pic-splashnews-com-573876387.jpg

[Black Dagger]

Hopefully Johnny is good tonight, can't have him in the bottom 3 tomorrow

http://images.mirror.co.uk/upl/m4/oct2011/4/2/x-factor-johnny-robinson-cuddles-the-dog-pic-splashnews-com-573876387.jpg

Yeah I see Marcus as a definite with this awful song choice... tis all about Johnny.

Quite surprised you're a fan Locke... didn't think you'd be keen on him at all.

[michael21]

don't forget 2 acts leave this weekend

[Doogle]

f-me i never thought to make one of theses threads next week :dance:

Don't bother, we have Smithy doing it.

Anyway, looking forward to this, shame Kelly is back though.

[Sam:)]

After a week off ill, Kelly returns to the panel tonight, and the contestants perform some "Club Classics"

http://i2.cdnds.net/11/43/reality_tv_x_factor_tulisa_kelly_01.jpg

QOTD: What should tomorrow's QOTD be, coz i'm totally out of idea's :bigsmile:

Just ask who do you think will go tomorrow,it's lazy but relevant!

I was expecting the QOTD to be "should contestants be allowed to modify a song that fits in with the theme and change it to a song un-related to the theme "

[Smithy]

Don't bother, we have Smithy doing it.

Anyway, looking forward to this, shame Kelly is back though.

http://2.bp.blogspot.com/_tm33tTS2iZc/SO2XuJ0-_5I/AAAAAAAABIc/6mO83ax73dE/s400/ObamaSmug.jpg

[GypsyGoth]

qotd: maybe how does gravity work?

[Smithy]

qotd: maybe how does gravity work?

bitch what does that have to do with x factor

http://gifninja.com/animatedgifs/177934/slap-gif.gif

[Smithy]

S'ooon :amazed:

[GypsyGoth]

:laugh2:

[Doogle]

Kelly go away :bored:

[GypsyGoth]

:amazed:!!

[Ithinkiloveyoutoo]

so misha is hated for apparently bei ng a bully but you just watch how kitty survives even after the racism

an-noy-ing!

[Maia]

Ballad free zone, oooo

[Doogle]

Kitty won't survive ^

[Sam:)]

It would have been good if the judges got to send one home tonight!

[Doogle]

Kelly looks amazing, despite being an annoying bitch.

[King Gizzard]

Who's wedding is it Gary?

[Smithy]

Kelly :amazed:

[King Gizzard]

Go away Kelly

[King Gizzard]

Little dig at Alexandra :bored:

[Maia]

Johnny!

[GypsyGoth]

Johnny is pretty camp.

[Harry!]

OMG Queen M <3

[Tom]

Feels a lot more positive tonight, instantly liking Kelly again

[Smithy]

OMG Queen M <3

Queen *J

[Maia]

Johnny loves singing Harry's favourite songs

[Ithinkiloveyoutoo]

Little dig at Alexandra :bored:
that was wasn't it? lol uh oh was she not liked? :hugesmile:

[Doogle]

I really dislike this, he doesn't sound very good at all. :shocked:

And I hate this song.

Oh I like this song.

Ugh the poppies!

[GypsyGoth]

He forgot the lyrics and started singing a different song :conf2:

[Glenn.]

He sounded quite manly then :amazed:

[Sam:)]

Johny and camp go together!

He's as straight as a round-about

[Harry!]

Johnny loves singing Harry's favourite songs

Yes and now singing Spin Me haha.

[Maia]

He's singing in a lower voice!!!!

[Smithy]

:worship:

[Jarrod]

He Sounded better....

[Glenn.]

That was better than I thought.

And shut up Tulisa!

[Doogle]

He forgot the lyrics and started singing a different song :conf2:
:laugh3:

[Gillian-73]

He's been better!

[Smithy]

****. off. gary. you. ****

[Maia]

Cher, Kylie, Madonna, Pete Burns...This is all too much to be a coincidence now

[Glenn.]

Gary shut the **** up you mong :bored:

[Ithinkiloveyoutoo]

he sounded like he is on helium

[GypsyGoth]

Cher, Kylie, Madonna, Pete Burns...This is all too much to be a coincidence now

:laugh:

It'll be Aqua next week.

[Sam:)]

Cher, Kylie, Madonna, Pete Burns...This is all too much to be a coincidence now

...it is Louis picking the songs............

[Doogle]

Janet zzzzzzz

[Maia]

:laugh:

It'll be Aqua next week.

Or the Spice Girls :joker:

[Smithy]

kelly always has janet on before misha :bored:

[Maia]

...it is Louis picking the songs............

Wouldn't be so sure about that, I think Harry is involved somehow

[Maia]

Janet!!!! :lovedup:

[Smithy]

she looks really good too :amazed:

[Ithinkiloveyoutoo]

faaaaaaaaaaaiiillll

[King Gizzard]

What the hell

[GypsyGoth]

:worship:

[King Gizzard]

Phail

[Glenn.]

she looks really good too :amazed:

Agreed :thumbs:

[Harry!]

Cher, Kylie, Madonna, Pete Burns...This is all too much to be a coincidence now

:joker:

:laugh:

It'll be Aqua next week.

I can just imagine him doing a great Doctor Jones or Lollipop!

[Maia]

Oh no she slipped up a bit :(

[Adamw92]

Oh no, she forgot her words :(

[Sam:)]

Quite a poor preformance,she just forgot her words aswell for a second

[Doogle]

Oops, how awkward 4 her

[Glenn.]

Ooops :shocked:

[King Gizzard]

Really exposing her averageness

[Gillian-73]

Janet looks lovely!

[GypsyGoth]

Oh no she slipped up a bit :(

I hope the judges don't make a big deal of it.

[Maia]

I hope the judges don't make a big deal of it.

Me neither, but I think they will :(

[Sam:)]

Oh no, she forgot her words :(

like 80% of the time I go to post a comment you beat me too it

[Glenn.]

Bet Tulisa makes a big deal of it

[Harry!]

Kelly don't mislead me you made it seem she was going to sing Miss Jackson <3

[Wildcat!]

Forgot the words there.

[Saph]

Bitch forgot her words HA hope she goes :bored: isnt is a double this week?

[Gillian-73]

That wasn't to good for her tonight! pity

[Ithinkiloveyoutoo]

kelly wants to go home so she will make her acts fail

[Adamw92]

like 80% of the time I go to post a comment you beat me too it

Oh...I'm sorry :joker: I'm just psychic ;)

[Maia]

Johnny - 7/10
Janet - 8/10

[Smithy]

awwwww, she's about to burst into tears

[Sam:)]

Oh she's going to cry:)

[Black Dagger]

Johnny is definitely in the B3...

[Glenn.]

Don't cry Janet :sad:

[Maia]

She looks so lovely tonight :love: I hope she stays.

[Adamw92]

Johnny - 5/10
Janet - 6.5/10

[Ithinkiloveyoutoo]

aw janet bAby dont cry youre not going anywhere

[Sam:)]

In the VT at the start of tomorrows show they'll show her crying :( I think she'll go home tomorrow with frankie

[Doogle]

Johnny-7/10
Janet-6/10

[Glenn.]

Yeo Valley hunky farmer boyband :amazed:

[GypsyGoth]

Johnny 5
Janet 6

[Vicky.]

Oh dear Janet :bored:

[Gillian-73]

Johnny 5/10
Janet 6/10

[Callum]

Janet was really weak tonight and I'm a fan. Bad song choice, she didn't look comfortable and to top it off she forgot her words. I think she might be in trouble tomorrow.

[Harry!]

Wouldn't be so sure about that, I think Harry is involved somehow

:suspect:

[Sam:)]

Who picked the song Kelly or Janet?

[Black Dagger]

Janet was really weak tonight and I'm a fan. Bad song choice, she didn't look comfortable and to top it off she forgot her words. I think she might be in trouble tomorrow.

No chance... it's a popularity contest, she's most popular at this stage.

B3 will be Kitty, Johnny and Marcus.

[Gillian-73]

Johnny is definitely in the B3...

Yeah! i agree.

[Marc]

Janet was rubbish. Needs to go please.

[Doogle]

Johnny, Janet and Kitty will be bottom 3, with ****ing Frankie and Misha escaping again

[Black Dagger]

Yeah! i agree.

I don't want him to be, he's my 2nd favourite, but he was on first, doesn't have much support even if it was B2 and at the end of the night I see him as bookies favourite.

[Smithy]

oh janet is trending on twitter :joker:

[GypsyGoth]

Who picked the song Kelly or Janet?

Janet.

[Locke.]

Johnny - 2/10
Janet - 5/10

[Gillian-73]

Janet was really weak tonight and I'm a fan. Bad song choice, she didn't look comfortable and to top it off she forgot her words. I think she might be in trouble tomorrow.

i love her but i agree with what you said about tonight's performance but i don't think she'll be bottom 3 i think she'll have alot of support.

[Smithy]

ugh craig :bored:

[Maia]

Craig bores me

[GypsyGoth]

Craig the cookie monster.

[Gillian-73]

Looking forward to craig! my fave of last week.

[Glenn.]

This is quite good.

[Sam:)]

Craig is decent....

[Tom]

and Gary had the cheek to call Sami cruise ship

[Ninastar]

I was watching deadliest catch and missed the beginning, have I missed much? :love:

[Locke.]

Good performance that

[Harry!]

Craig just annoys me. I will say this every week till he goes.

[Doogle]

He's such a good singer, but wtf was up with that "dancing"

[Smithy]

I was watching deadliest catch and missed the beginning, have I missed much? :love:

johnny and janet

[Maia]

I was watching deadliest catch and missed the beginning, have I missed much? :love:

You missed Janet being amazingly adorable and Johnny singing Harry's record collection

[GypsyGoth]

I was watching deadliest catch and missed the beginning, have I missed much? :love:

Johnny sang a camp two songs mixed together. And Janet sang a jackson 5 number, she forgot a lyric, and it was noticeable, and when Dermot was interviewing her, you could tell all she wanted to do was get off stage and cry.

[Gillian-73]

I enjoyed that! i like him.

[Locke.]

**** off Kelly :bored:

[Marc]

Craig did well!!

[Tom]

How long before Smithy makes a gif out of the end of Kelly's comment?

[Wildcat!]

only good performANCe SO Far

[Smithy]

How long before Smithy makes a gif out of the end of Kelly's comment?

bitch i don't know how to make gifs

[Doogle]

Go away The Risk

[Maia]

Johnny - 7/10
Janet - 8/10
Craig - 4/10

[Ninastar]

thanks guys :D

and I liked him I thought he was good

[Maia]

The Risk aren't as good now they're 1/4 Nu Vibe

[Locke.]

Derry LOL

[Gillian-73]

Johnny 5/10
Janet 6/10
Craig 8/10

[Brother Leon]

Derry got in there lol

[Wildcat!]

nic\e

[Gillian-73]

Don't like the risk

[King Gizzard]

These are so bland

[Doogle]

Ew. :bored:

[Locke.]

They are back :worship:

[Black Dagger]

I'm bored of The Risk...

But they won't be in the B3 tomorrow.

[Ithinkiloveyoutoo]

go the risk

[Ninastar]

Much prefer them like this, I can see why people like them now :D

[Maia]

These guys are so Locke-ish

[Adamw92]

Johnny - 5/10
Janet - 6.5/10
Craig - 7/10
The Risk - 6/10

[Maia]

That was rather good, better than last week

[King Gizzard]

There needs to be a ban on standing up when performances aren't amazing

[GypsyGoth]

Johnny 5
Janet 6
Craig 5
The Risk 7

[Locke.]

Johnny - 2/10
Janet - 5/10
Craig - 7/10
The Risk - 7/10

[Maia]

Johnny - 7/10
Janet - 8/10
Craig - 5/10
The Risk - 7/10

[Tom]

Kelly should have shaved her armpits. Does she not know X Factor goes out in HD?

[Doogle]

BOOOORING. :bored:

[Brother Leon]

Might aswell just give them the crown tbh.

[Adamw92]

Shut up Gary, its not Charlie and his 3 back ups, they're meant to be a GROUP

[Brother Leon]

How dare he touch his hat? :o

[Maia]

Marcus after the break :worship:

[Locke.]

A good performance from Little Mix is needed now to make sure they are safe along with The Risk

[Black Dagger]

Johnny-10/10 (FUN FACTOR)
Janet- 4/10
Craig- 3/10 (Overrated)
The Risk- 6/10

FOR ****S SAKE... Marcus not last boy on again, that cock is... WHO PRODUCES THIS RUNNING ORDER? They need shooting.

[Locke.]

These guys are so Locke-ish

What do you mean :suspect:

[Maia]

What do you mean :suspect:

They remind me of you for some reason

[Gillian-73]

Johnny 5/10
Janet 6/10
Craig 8/10
The Risk 6.5/10

[Doogle]

Everyone on Twitter is going crazy over Kelly's armpit hair

[Locke.]

They remind me of you for some reason

That explains Derry pulling Nicole then

[Smithy]

That explains Derry pulling Nicole then

he didn't tho :L

[King Gizzard]

http://p.twimg.com/Adg59HACMAAWWyY.jpg

[Locke.]

he didn't tho :L

He did, off-camera

[Smithy]

:o

[King Gizzard]

Not bad. Sounds the best tonight so far

[Doogle]

He's so good :amazed:

[Maia]

Marcus!!!! :worship:

[Harry!]

The music video to this song freaks me out! But great song!

[Locke.]

This brings back memories of Olly

[King Gizzard]

Jackie Wilson <3

He's doing it justice

[Smithy]

sit down gary you ****

[GypsyGoth]

Johnny 5
Janet 6
Craig 5
The Risk 7
Marcus 7

[Locke.]

Johnny - 2/10
Janet - 5/10
Craig - 7/10
The Risk - 7/10
Marcus - 7.5/10

[King Gizzard]

9/10

[Marc]

Brilliant!!!

[Adamw92]

Johnny - 5/10
Janet - 6.5/10
Craig - 7/10
The Risk - 6/10
Marcus - 8.5/10

[Maia]

Johnny - 7/10
Janet - 8/10
Craig - 5/10
The Risk - 7/10
Marcus - 9/10

[Maia]

Everyone loves Marcus

[Gillian-73]

Great performance

[Smithy]

he said season instead of series, i hate him even more now

[Marc]

I love that song :D

[Locke.]

We need to see some real talent on that stage, where is Frankie

[Doogle]

I'd give him a 9.5, amazing.

[Adamw92]

Little Mix to close the show? :D

[Gillian-73]

Johnny 5/10
Janet 6/10
Craig 8/10
The Risk 6.5/10
Marcus 8.5/10

[Smithy]

only girl in the kitchen obviously

[Black Dagger]

Marcus is amazing... he can turn **** into an amazing performance.

Less worried for him then when I first heard he'd be singing it.

[Sam:)]

Very sexist option!

[Doogle]

So sexist.

[Maia]

A. Kitchen

I've won

[Black Dagger]

A. Kitchen

I've won

:joker::joker:

I love it.

[Jords]

Marcus was really good this week!!

[Maia]

Marcus is amazing... he can turn **** into an amazing performance.

Less worried for him then when I first heard he'd be singing it.

Marcus can turn anything into an amazing performance :worship:

[Black Dagger]

Marcus can turn anything into an amazing performance :worship:

FACT...

He's flawless, to be fair as long as him and Johnny are safe this week I don't care... (Johnny is B3 though for definite).

[Wildcat!]

someonem, tweet Kelly ABOUT HeR Hairy pits

[Harry!]

Oh my ONLY GIRL IN THE KITCHEN is trending WW!

[Smithy]

If frankie closes the show, ill cut a bitch

[King Gizzard]

Can she not just get rid of her eyebrows altogether

[Locke.]

Kitty's last saturday show :(

[Smithy]

born this way :lovedup:

[Brother Leon]

What a vile creature.

[Adamw92]

Kitty's last saturday show :(

Don't say that :(

[Harry!]

Like A Prayer <3 Queen M <3

[Marc]

Harry is dying somewhere

[Ithinkiloveyoutoo]

twitter

Watch there be no mention of Kitty's racist outburst... Yet Misha had to explain bullygate. Wevs.

abso****inglutely :bored:

kitty sucks. she can scream well thats it

[Ninastar]

i knew she was going to strip :bored:

[Adamw92]

I was hoping her clothes would light up there :(

[Harry!]

The intro was very Blond Ambition...

[Locke.]

Harry is dying somewhere

Kitty out-performing his favourite artist is pretty embarrassing

[GypsyGoth]

The choir really help this song. She might be safe.

[King Gizzard]

Them dancers must feel like right knobs

[Doogle]

Her voice is amazing, she has to get a record deal. AMAZING. :lovedup:

[Locke.]

Johnny - 2/10
Janet - 5/10
Craig - 7/10
The Risk - 7/10
Marcus - 7.5/10
Kitty - 6.5/10

[Marc]

Louis Walsh claps strangely

[Smithy]

Kitty > Madonna http://gagadaily.com/public/style_emoticons/default/redface.gif

[Adamw92]

Johnny - 5/10
Janet - 6.5/10
Craig - 7/10
The Risk - 6/10
Marcus - 8.5/10
Kitty - 7.5/10

[Ithinkiloveyoutoo]

tulisa wha the fook are you on. so your bf is black tulisa you're not going to call her out on racism? only the black girl had to get some mouth for alleged bullyism is it? :bored:

[Gillian-73]

I don't like kitty but she's got a good voice, this isn't her best performance though.

[King Gizzard]

Is that mole drawn on?

[Doogle]

twitter



abso****inglutely :bored:

kitty sucks. she can scream well thats it

Maybe if it happened before Misha bullygate.

They probably got told that.

[Smithy]

Is that mole drawn on?

yeah

[Adamw92]

Gary saying Kitty sounded out of tune and now he has to introduce Frankie to the stage... :bored:

[Doogle]

If the mole is drawn on maybe the armpit hair is too.

[Harry!]

Kitty out-performing his favourite artist is pretty embarrassing

"out-performing" , hardly. Come on the beginning of the song was like Madonna's Blond Ambition performance of it and that is better.

Kitty > Madonna http://gagadaily.com/public/style_emoticons/default/redface.gif

No.

[Locke.]

Here he is, the star of the show

[Smithy]

oh yay frankie, i can go for a dump now

[GypsyGoth]

Johnny 5
Janet 6
Craig 5
The Risk 7
Marcus 7
Kitty 6

[Gillian-73]

Johnny 5/10
Janet 6/10
Craig 8/10
The Risk 6.5/10
Marcus 8.5/10
Kitty 6.5/10

[Ithinkiloveyoutoo]

are the people saying kitty is outperforming madonna on crack?

Kitty is screaming out of tune. I would like to hear her sing a soft ballad.

[Kazanne]

Feel sorry for this lad

[Ithinkiloveyoutoo]

Maybe if it happened before Misha bullygate.

They probably got told that.

yeah yeah there's always an excuse.

go away frankie

[Doogle]

Awful already

[GypsyGoth]

Feel sorry for this lad

Because he has an sti?

[Gillian-73]

Oh not frankie!

[Sam:)]

I gotta feelin this will be ****e....

[King Gizzard]

It's like a drunken underage getting home from a night out stumbling around his bedroom

[Ninastar]

oh dear

[GypsyGoth]

Johnny 5
Janet 6
Craig 5
The Risk 7
Marcus 7
Frankie 2

[Maia]

:laugh2: Oh my god LOL!!!!!!!!!

[Marc]

Why is he still in the competition.

Sounds drunk

[King Gizzard]

He's just...talking?

[Adamw92]

Johnny - 5/10
Janet - 6.5/10
Craig - 7/10
The Risk - 6/10
Marcus - 8.5/10
Kitty - 7.5/10
Frankie - 1/10

[Doogle]

:laugh3:

[GypsyGoth]

This really is **** :D

[Tom]

This is up there on the bizarre scale with Jedward doing Britney Spears

I hate his indie voice he does too

[Ninastar]

do eeeht

[Maia]

I'm crying with laughter. Wowwww

[Harry!]

Just terrible.

[Locke.]

Wow, what a brilliant performance.

Frankie really pulled out all the stops this week

[Maia]

Dead.

[Brother Leon]

What a performance.


Take a bow son :worship:

[Ninastar]

go louis

[Gillian-73]

He can't sing, however they try to dress it up he just can't sing! bottom 3 without a doubt.