Worst Judge?

[King Gizzard]

Poll coming up

[King Gizzard]

Gary by quite a distance for me, then Tulisa, Kelly, Louis (and I hated louis the last couple of years)

[Locke.]

Kelly.

At least the other 3 turn up :idc:

[mizzy25]

kelly i cannot stand her accent i mean they cudnt understand wor cheryl i cannot understand kelly

[Iceman]

Gary, he's become a novelty in himself, with his Holier Than Thou attitude, I cant stand him.

[Fetch The Bolt Cutters]

kelly i thought i would love her because shes all sassy but no

[Tom]

Gary. Louis is funny and was spot on tonight, Tulisa is clueless but shes doing a good job with her acts. I don't know about Kelly. Some weeks I like her, others I hate her. Shes bigger than the show and she knows it, but I don't think she realises they could get rid of her and the ratings wouldn't budge

It wasn't so bad at the start but during the live shows its really missing Simon, Cheryl and Dannii

[Callum]

Gary

[joeysteele]

Gary for me now, I can almost see why Take That had problems with him and Robbie when they split. I really cannot be bothered with Gary now at all. He has a truly bad attitude problem.

[Smithy]

Gary has edged over louis tonight, can't stand him

[Maia]

Louis. Quite amazing considering this time last year he was my favourite judge, but this year he's just been absolutely terrible.

[Kerry]

Kelly. Silly OTT cow

[Visage]

My choice is Gary, which surprises me a little because I thought he came across really well during the auditions, I actually believed he was going to be the best judge by far.

He seems to be getting worse each week.

[Iceman]

My choice is Gary, which surprises me a little because I thought he came across really well during the auditions, I actually believed he was going to be the best judge by far.

He seems to be getting worse each week.

Exactly how I feel, I thought he would have toned down the smug attitude he has but he seems to be playing on it.....for reasons I dont get

[Kerry]

My fave is Gary though sadly, right now, he seems the best of a bad lot. The only reason I say that though is because I can see the puppet strings being pulled of each and every judge by Simon Cowell. I did however think Gary would be better than that

[Barbie]

Can't stand any of them really, voted Tullisa because she gets on my nerves the most. Gary is a close second, followed by Louis

[fruit_cake]

I'm not sure, they're all pretty bad imo

[Black Dagger]

Gary, for being useless and getting rid of James Michael over Frankie, I can't condone that at all.

Kelly is just as bad, stupid cow.

[Z]

It's a scary sign that Louis, the renowned piss taker of the panel, is now the one who is talking sense and saying what the majority of the public thinks (e.g. saying Frankie can't sing) - I like Tulisa, she's inoffensive and does well with her acts but her comments are really pointless, so she's filling Cheryl's position quite well, even if she's not quite as pretty to look at. Kelly Rowland and Gary Barlow are totally full of themselves. Gary's downright boring and has been picking terrible songs for ALL of his acts; while Kelly has actually ruined all of her acts when she originally had the best category from the outset. This is no bad thing, because it's giving Tulisa's groups a level playing field, which isn't something that really happens on the X Factor. I think Kelly's probably the worst because of her weird attitude.