your ideal 2012 judge lineup

[Fetch The Bolt Cutters]

amy winehouse
beyonce
lady gaga
god

but that just aint gonna happen so realistically

lily allen
sharon osbourne
chris moyles
paul o grady (they had ellen on AI so shut up)

[Kate!]

amy winehouse
beyonce
lady gaga
god

but that just aint gonna happen so realistically

lily allen
sharon osbourne
chris moyles
paul o grady (they had ellen on AI so shut up)

:laugh2:

Lily Allen would be great, think she would make a cracking mentor.

I would like to see

Tulisa again
Katy Perry
Shane Filan from Westlife
Jason Donovan

- awaits ridicule - :joker:

[Lee.]

Simon Cowell
Gary Barlow
Nicole Sherzinger
Gaga

[MusicXian]

I doubt Katy Perry could do it, probably another year of touring for her. Simon will stay in the US I am quite sure. I dislike Gary Barlow more and more on this show, but realistically I see him staying, but I doubt Kelly will be here next year. I think it will/could be...

Gary Barlow (but would be good if he could be replaced, not sure who with)
Lily Allen or Nicole Sherzinger
Tulisa
Louis Walsh

Would be nice if Simon Cowell could come back and be a guest judge on a few shows aswell, especially maybe the first live show, week 5 or 6 and perhaps the final to listen to what he thinks how the contestants are doing.

People like Katy Perry, Gaga, Rihanna and so on have no chance, they are too succesful as stars already and will probably be touring again.

[Smithy]

I think Paul O Grady is in talks to do BGT

[Black Dagger]

Katy Perry (Replacing Kelly Rowland)
Tulisa
Louis Walsh
Chris Martin (Replacing Gary Barlow)

More chance of pigs flying I reckon.

[Strictly Jake]

I would like Simon Cowell. Michael Buble/Justin Timberlake/Matthew Morrison. Cheryl Cole/Sharon Osbourne/Lily allen. Nicole Scherzinger/Alicia Keys/Gwen Stefani. One english guy. One american guy. One english girl. One american girl. I think would work well

[Tom]

Simon Cowell, Cheryl Cole, Sharon Osbourne, Louis Walsh

I'd be happy if Sharon replaced Kelly next year though, but I think Nicole will

[Saph]

Simon
Sharon
Louis

How it was meant to be :)

[_Seth]

Simon, Sharon, Louis and Dannii.

[Doogle]

Simon
Sharon
Louis

PLEASE

Also I swear Lily hates this show. Then again if the money was good enough I'm sure she'd do it regardless.

[Vicky.]

Simon Sharon and Louis.

[Adamw92]

Simon, Tulisa, Dannii and Louis

[Callum]

Simon, Sharon and Louis.

[Visage]

No one has mentioned Lauren Harries so far...


...Still I guess it's early days.

[Ryan.]

Simon, Sharon, Louis and Tulisa

[Crimson Dynamo]

Tulisa

Moyles

Cowell

Craven

[dannyboy]

Simon Cowell, Sharon Osbourne, Courteney Love and Liam Gallagher. They wouldn't stand a chance!! :D

If the likely/current/previous judges, I'd say Cowell, Osbourne, Tulisa and Louis. Louis gets on my nerves but I can't imagine it without him!

[US Nacho]

Anybody but Louie
Anybody but Louie
Anybody but Louie
Anybody but Louie

That would be ideal for me. :)