Only Louis is guaranteed a spot on next years panel

[Tom]

and thats only if he wants it and he said he doesn't know! Next Generation v2.0 for 2012?

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/tvshowbiz/article-2065941/X-Factor-2011-Louis-Walsh-judge-guaranteed-seat-panel-series.html

Really starting to think Cheryl will be back next year

[Doogle]

Ugh I forgot there's going to be another one next year. We need Simon. But not arselick Simon, good Simon.

[Locke.]

I think Louis and Tulisa will be back, and one of Simon or Cheryl will return, and one new member

[Kate!]

The only past Judge I want back is Dannii. Louis was better this year, and he has a great rapport with Tulisa, so Louis, Danni, Tulisa and ? Who knows.

[Beastie]

The only past Judge I want back is Dannii. Louis was better this year, and he has a great rapport with Tulisa, so Louis, Danni, Tulisa and ? Who knows.

And Simon!

[Jords]

They will not make it look like a massive fail and sack/allow leave all 3 of Gary, Kelly and Tulisa. I hope and think Tulisa will be back, I see her as the most successful judge and mentor especially with her managing of Little Mix.

Louis must return :worship:

[Callum]

Just cancel the whole show, it's past it's prime.

[Jords]

I remember I used to hate Louis LOL, but the past 2-3 years hes been the best along with Dannii and now Tulisa.

[Visage]

Anyone except Cheryl please.

[Tom]

I think Louis and Tulisa will be back, and one of Simon or Cheryl will return, and one new member

I think it'll be Louis, Tulisa, Cheryl and Gary next year and it would be a very strategic placement of Cheryl

Cheryl is good friends with both Tulisa and Gary so would bridge the clear divide on the panel. She also argues a lot with Louis nd if they brought her back as the lead judge (which was Simon's original plan for when he left the show) then she won't be sucking up to Gary like she did Simon. She'd have her own personality like she had before last year

[MusicXian]

Yeah Cherly back with Tulisa and Louis. I hope Gary will not be head judge.

[Black Dagger]

Louis and Tulisa to stay.

Simon and Dannii to return.

Cheryl/Kelly/Gary to stay as far away as possible, vacuous, rubbish mentors.

[abcd]

louis easily has the most LOL moments, i effing love how he puts his foot in it.
little risk was a classic
"at least i show up" to kelly being another

[mizzy25]

i think tulisa is a lot like cheryl so i wud like louis, tulisa, danni and maybe simon but please god get rid of kelly and gary hey maybe we cud have robbie instead of gary?

[joeysteele]

Would like Dannii back, but hope Louis does stay along with Tulisa. The other mentor/judge will hopefully be anyone other than Kelly or Cheryl.

[Fetch The Bolt Cutters]

why do people even like louis

[_Seth]

why do people even like louis

Because he has better grammar that you. :D

[Tom4784]

Tulisa should stay, I love Kelly but there's not really a place for her I think.

[Jack_]

Louis can't leave, it fell apart without him for one episode in series four, imagine an entire series without him? A complete disaster.

Pete Burns should be head judge...imagine that. I can only imagine his incredibly blunt critique :laugh3:

[Smithy]

cheryl won't come back, sharon might do now though, danni's gone and there's another yank on the pannel

[Callum]

cheryl won't come back, sharon might do now though, danni's gone and there's another yank on the pannel

Sharon loves America too much to come back on UK X Factor. She does The Talk every weekday over there and AGT once a year, wouldn't fit into her schedule.

[Jords]

Louis can't leave, it fell apart without him for one episode in series four, imagine an entire series without him? A complete disaster.

Pete Burns should be head judge...imagine that. I can only imagine his incredibly blunt critique :laugh3:

:joker:

[Jordan.]

Louis wouldn't leave and even if he did he'd just end up on BGT :bored: