On a scale of 1-10

[Jords]

How ***** was Gary tonight?


Solid 10 from me.

[Novo]

1

[Jordan.]

10 like everyweek.

[Adamw92]

I need an option for 11

[Brother Leon]

1.

[Mystic Mock]

9.5 For me because he did make a good and truthful comment about Misha tonight,but his a ****ing bastard trying to make out that Amelia shouted through the 2nd song when she didnt.

[Lee.]

1. He speaks sense

[reece(:]

10 hes arrogant and threatened by amelia

[joeysteele]

10 for me, he's been a total pain from the start of the 'live' shows, I cannot bear to even listen to him now.

[Strictly Jake]

yep ten! Get him off!!

[GypsyGoth]

How ***** was Gary tonight?


Solid 10 from me.

:worship:

[Princess]

I love him, I really really really do but he was being a douche tonight, he needs to get off that show.

[GypsyGoth]

I love him, I really really really do but he was being a douche tonight, he needs to get off that show.

I think he seems like such a nice guy, so when he's harsh on the show it sounds much worse, and I'm sure it's in his contract that he has to play the bad guy. Anyway I agree I don't think it'll do him any good coming back to judge next year.

[Jords]

I love him, I really really really do but he was being a douche tonight, he needs to get off that show.

Hes brilliant in Take That but I surprisingly cant stand him on TXF
(btw so glad Robbie is out again!!!)

Although I agree with Claudy that hes probably told to act it up a bit more.

[Jack_]

7.

And how funny was he on a scale from 1-10?

7.

The more ***** he is, the funnier it is, and the better TV it is. Legend.

[Locke.]

Sir Robbie needs to replace him next year

[Firewire]

He was being a douche. But I laughed when he said "your opinion means nothing", or something along those lines when he was talking to Louis.

[Jords]

7.

And how funny was he on a scale from 1-10?

7.

The more ***** he is, the funnier it is, and the better TV it is. Legend.

I found it pretty annoying.

[Princess]

Hes brilliant in Take That but I surprisingly cant stand him on TXF
(btw so glad Robbie is out again!!!)

Although I agree with Claudy that hes probably told to act it up a bit more.

Yay! Me too. Yeah he's lovely with Take That and everyone misses them, he just needs to get back to that. I don't think he is being told to be mean though, I think he's just saying what he thinks.

[Jack_]

I found it pretty annoying.

It's just funny, I find all the judges' banter funny. When he called Amelia's sing-off performance 'shouty' the other week, I totally disagreed, but initially laughed when he said it because it was pretty blunt...and I'm a massive Amelia fan.

His comments to Louis are also hilarious, and I'm a great Louis fan :joker:

[Princess]

I think he seems like such a nice guy, so when he's harsh on the show it sounds much worse, and I'm sure it's in his contract that he has to play the bad guy. Anyway I agree I don't think it'll do him any good coming back to judge next year.

He is! He's lovely! People seem to forget the charity events and the great dad and the Take That brilliance when he's being mean about people on X Factor. He is proper lovely, X Factor just brings out the worst of him.

[Tom4784]

He's trying to be Simon and failing, He needs to distance himself from the show otherwise he'll soon turn everyone against him.