Which Judge Deserves To Win?

[Jordan.]

Gary - Biased, everyone is **** but his own acts
Kelly - Her last remaining act is the one she originally sent home
Tulisa - Given one of the toughest categories and created the most successful girl group in TXF

[mizzy25]

tulisa

[joeysteele]

Tulisa, she has been the only one of those 3 who has given constructive comments and has been surprisingly good as a mentor and judge.

Gary has turned more and more obnoxious feom the start of the live shows and is really quite an unpleasant person it seems,choosing to insult rather than be constructive.
Kelly hasn't said a single comment that is really worth remembering,always too over the top.

However,it will be difficult I think for Littlemix to actually win this for Tulisa.

[Callum]

Tulisa, she's the only one who seems to really care for her acts and not just them as a group, but as people too. She makes time for them always and it's paid off because they're now first girl group in the final.

[Smithy]

Louis

[Niamh.]

Gary - Biased, everyone is **** but his own acts
Kelly - Her last remaining act is the one she originally sent home
Tulisa - Given one of the toughest categories and created the most successful girl group in TXF

Agree with all your comments there. Tulisa deserves it most imo.

[Adamw92]

Tulisa

[Princess]

I just click Gary automatically in these things. He does work very hard you know.

[Smithy]

All the other judges do too, and they do it without acting like utter bellends :idc:

[Kate!]

Hard to answer as Marcus is my fave to win, but went for Tulisa purely as a mentor and Judge :D

Tulisa deserves loads of credit, she's done a great job with Little Mix, so if they do win, I would be pleased for her.

[Locke.]

Louis and the invisibles

[Brother Leon]

Tulisa.

She actually bonds with all het acts. Would love to have a mentor like that.

[Mystic Mock]

Lets see,Obnoxious Gary,Agressive chav Tulisa or annoying Kelly,hmmmmmmmmmmm............. I will say Annoying Kelly to win.

[Doogle]

Tulisa, surprisingly.

[MeMyselfAndI]

Tulisa As a judge, although Tbh i want Amelia to win. I would be really happy with Little Mix winning too. So for me i have a 2/3 chance of a good winner:)

[Marc]

You make valid points Jordan.. Tulisa has done the near impossible and Gary has picked Frankie and been an absolute arse every weekend. Kelly has only one left and she originally sent her home! Not a good decision :idc:

[Marc]

Louis and the invisibles

I can't wait for Casper to win

[Marc]

I just click Gary automatically in these things. He does work very hard you know.

All the other judges do too, and they do it without acting like utter bellends :idc:

:laugh: It's true. Tulisa was a bit of a minge to Misha that one week but lets face it she probably is a bully :idc: Kelly has been nice to everybody pretty much every week but she's been bias back stage toward Misha and reglecting Janet. Louis.. well what the hell is there to be said about him :shrug:

[Shasown]

Funny I thought it was about the acts, not the judges.

If any judge deserved to win it was Louis for taking all the flak off the other judges, being constructive to all competitors at some point and for having to mentor crap acts the last couple of years.

[Jords]

It is about the acts... this thread is essentially a 'whos been the best judge/mentor this year?' just worded at this angle.

Tulisa hands down!!!

[robb]

Gary - Biased, everyone is **** but his own acts
Kelly - Her last remaining act is the one she originally sent home
Tulisa - Given one of the toughest categories and created the most successful girl group in TXF

I agree with most of this.....the exception is Tulisa, who I feel got lucky with Little mix/rythmix/pick and mix lol. That is what she did with the risk, and they flopped. Somehow Little Mix have gained strength, helped no doubt by the number of unpopular/useless/underachieving acts there has been this year. That said they CAN sing. Maybe it is their year, although Amelia is now closing up in the bookies odds....

[King Gizzard]

Any judge that doesn't answer to the name Tulisa

[robb]

Funny I thought it was about the acts, not the judges.

If any judge deserved to win it was Louis for taking all the flak off the other judges, being constructive to all competitors at some point and for having to mentor crap acts the last couple of years.

I have always felt a bit sorry for Louis being lumbered year after year with the worst category (apart from when shane ward won). But having seen his performance/comments this year (you all deserve to be in the final, blah blah) I now feel it is time for him to go. TBH I started off thinking the other 3 were a breath of fresh air, but have rapidly gone off them too :nono::nono:

[Glenn.]

I think Tulisa deserves it the most, but I don't want Little Mix to win.

Tulisa has been a pretty good judge. THE best judge this year.

I think she's worked with the groups really well, and to have a girl group in the final is an outstanding feat.


Amelia FTW though :hmph:

[BigBrotherfan4ever]

Tulisa because she seems the most dedicatied to her acts/act.

But I want Amelia to win.

[Tom]

Tulisa, shes the only one that has formed genuine relationships with her acts and thats been clear since the first results show where it was pretty obvious she hadn't made her mind up until the last minute

Kelly has been too busy moulding Misha B into a mini version of herself and Gary has been too occupied reliving his teenage years through Frankie

Louis is long overdue a fair crack at the whip with a decent category.

[joeysteele]

Tulisa, shes the only one that has formed genuine relationships with her acts and thats been clear since the first results show where it was pretty obvious she hadn't made her mind up until the last minute

Kelly has been too busy moulding Misha B into a mini version of herself and Gary has been too occupied reliving his teenage years through Frankie

Louis is long overdue a fair crack at the whip with a decent category.

A really strong post, summing things up totally. I agree with it all.