If Cheryl Returns, Would You Watch?

[Saph]

I know I wouldnt :bored: This series has been the best since S4 for me without Cheryl.

http://profile.ak.fbcdn.net/hprofile-ak-snc4/50493_311760011265_2682466_n.jpg

[Maia]

Definitely not. It's much better without her.

[Locke.]

Yes, the nations sweetheart would make up for having to put up with Kelly for a year

http://www.picpiggy.com/bank/cheryl_cole_hot_picture-1266945963.jpg

[Jordan.]

Yeah but it'd be a boring judging panel. We'd only have Louis and Gary arguing.

[Shaun]

I don't watch anyway but I'm glad she's not a part of it. Just not sure Kelly/Tulisa are suitable either.

[joeysteele]

I couldn't stand her before and if she was to return again I would likely still watch it but totally ignore all she said on the show.

It would be a big backward step for X Factor and indeed herself if she was to return to it.
I didn't care for her but I would rather Sharon Osborne back than Ms Cole,I consider Ms Cole to be massively overrrated in all things.

[MTVN]

Yes, would make me more inclined to watch if anything

[King Gizzard]

If she replaced tulisa, yes

[Locke.]

Gary, Cheryl, Tulisa, Louis

What a great panel

[Black Dagger]

Reluctant... she's made some ****e decisions in her time though.

Lloyd/Rikki over Ethan/Duane to name just two.

And well sending home Gamu over Katie Waissel

[Visage]

No.

Her absence this year is why I tuned in.

[Jack_]

Yes. I find people that stop watching things (mainly their favourite shows) because of one person they don't like extremely odd. And pathetic.

I'd rather Sharon than Cheryl though, but that's just because she was more entertaining.

[Kerry]

Yes but tbh I watch through habit now

[Mystic Mock]

Gary, Cheryl, Tulisa, Louis

What a great panel

When Louis talks the most sense out of that panel then you know something is wrong.

And no I would not watch if Chavryl Cole returned.

[Glenn.]

I would rather Danni replace Kelly tbh.

As much as I didn't like Tulisa at the start of this year, she's more than earnt her place on the panel.

She took a girlband to the final and then won with them.

I would love it if Danni came back.

She was amazing:lovedup:

Edit• I would stop watching if Cheryl came back. Last year it got to the stage where I was Sky+ing the show to fast forward her meaningless tripe :bored:

[Callum]

Yeah, never really had a problem with Cheryl so I wouldn't stop watching if she came back. I doubt she will though and even if she does I doubt the ratings will improve solely because of her presence. XF needs a big shake up, it's not just the judges which is a problem, it's the level of talent and people are fed up of seeing joke acts making the live shows/judges houses stages when talented singers are sent home. The show has gotten stale.

[MeMyselfAndI]

Simon needs to return

[fruit_cake]

I'd only watch if Cheryl and Tulisa were on the same panel, If she replaced Tulisa I'd not bother watching anymore.

[mizzy25]

simon cheryl tulisa and loius wud b cool get rid of kelly and gary please i wud also like danni back so danni or cheryl wud b good for me

[Saph]

Yes. I find people that stop watching things (mainly their favourite shows) because of one person they don't like extremely odd. And pathetic.



dont like is an understatement, I absolutely hate the woman.

[Visage]

Yes. I find people that stop watching things (mainly their favourite shows) because of one person they don't like extremely odd. And pathetic.

I'd rather Sharon than Cheryl though, but that's just because she was more entertaining.

I find it odd that some people watch a show and moan about one of the main characters in the show. I wonder why they bother watching it if they don't like what or who is on the show.

That said I don't find it pathetic, I wouldn't insult any one's decision to watch (or not watch) a show.

[Jords]

Of course, Kelly and Gary pissed me off this series but I carried on watching why would Cheryl-haterz just switch off? Bit sad... she really isnt that bad... just overrated.

[Mystic Mock]

Of course, Kelly and Gary pissed me off this series but I carried on watching why would Cheryl-haterz just switch off? Bit sad... she really isnt that bad... just overrated.

You cant get her acts out though,I mean it took until the 5th attempt to get Katie out last year ffs.

[Novo]

dont like is an understatement, I absolutely hate the woman.

no surprise Cheryl is pretty normal and you love all the freaks and Weirdos like that girl in your Sig.. :idc:

[Saph]

Cheryl is pretty normal

...:conf:

[reece(:]

Simon Tulisa Cheryl/Sharon and Louis would be the best panel ever

[robb]

Simon Tulisa Cheryl/Sharon and Louis would be the best panel ever

why??? tulisa and cheryl love each other...boring. Simon and Louis....fake arguing, they are best buddies....boring....And the return of Sharon????? beyond boring!!!
GET RID OF JUDAS WALSH AND 'up herself' KELLY.Simon to come back, Tulisa too because she did decent work with pick And mix. AND TWO NEW JUDGES PLEASE!!!

[Tom]

Get Cheryl & Nicole on the same panel, sit back and watch the fireworks :hugesmile:

I really don't see peoples problem with Cheryl