Who played a better Joker?

[Niamh.]

Jack Nicholson

Or

Heath Ledger

http://silentopinion.files.wordpress.com/2008/07/jokers1.jpg

[Roy Mars III]

Jack Nicholson


and anyone who disagrees is wrong

[Niamh.]

Heath by a mile :idc:

[Ammi]

Heath Ledger....seriously....bloody seriously
Oh...you might want to rethink your spelling in the title Niamh

[Roy Mars III]

Most of these children have never seen Nicholson play the Joker so the poll is invalid

[Roy Mars III]

Ledger preformance is subpar at best

Not even close to the best thing he'd done

[Niamh.]

Most of these children have never seen Nicholson play the Joker so the poll is invalid

well, so far the two people who voted Heath would remember when Jacks joker first came out so your argument is invalid :idc:

[Scarlett.]

Heath, simply because I didn't like the Tim Burton Batman films

[Roy Mars III]

Watch this right now. If this doesn't convice you that Nicholson's joker is the best ever than you have no taste

iXW4nji37-4

[Roy Mars III]

Burton's Batman films are the only good superhero movies ever. The rest are terrible, espically Nolan's crap

[Niamh.]

We've all seen the film Roy -yawn-

[Roy Mars III]

#Josyforadmin

[Patrick]

Is quite proud that this thread came from my Scarface thread :')

[Ammi]

I've seen both and tbh I did think Jack was great..can't lie
but that was before I watched Heath....it just can't be beaten.
..went to see it 4 times....just for Heath's performance

[Roy Mars III]

Black Dagger hasn't even seen the Burton Batman films. The poll has been corrupted.

[Niamh.]

Is quite proud that this thread came from my Scarface thread :')

:laugh:

[Josy]

I think Jack was by far the better joker tbh both of them played the part well but Heaths joker was too serious and too revealing, Jack was basically THE joker straight from the comics funny, witty, evil & psychotic.

[Niamh.]

Jacks joker was like a cartoon character, Heaths was dark and deadly.

[Scarlett.]

What about Mark Hamill's (Luke Skywalker) Joker?

Pu8DJnR9zNw

[Roy Mars III]

Jacks joker was like a cartoon character, Heaths was dark and deadly.

that is what the joker is suppose to be.

[Roy Mars III]

He is very good as well

[Bollo]

I voted Jack Nicholson, but only because I haven't seen the one with Heath Ledger

[Roy Mars III]

Don't , it's terrible

[Niamh.]

that is what the joker is suppose to be.

If I wanted to watch a cartoon.........I'd just go watch a cartoon.

[Niamh.]

I voted Jack Nicholson, but only because I haven't seen the one with Heath Ledger

Heath ledger is amazing as The Joker, you should watch. Until then, I'm afraid your vote is invalid :idc:

[Bollo]

Heath ledger is amazing as The Joker, you should watch. Until then, I'm afraid your vote is invalid :idc:

Yeah, you're right my vote shouldn't count really. I guess i was put off by him in Ten things i hate about you and when the new batman movies came out they always looked too actiony/ blockbusterish from the trailers as opposed to Tim Burtons kind of black humourness in films

But I'm really cynical when it comes to films, someone made me watch Date Night the other night and it nearly ended up in homocide

[Locke.]

Heath's. Nicholson is a much better actor in general though

[Ninastar]

Heath by far

[Roy Mars III]

If I wanted to watch a cartoon.........I'd just go watch a cartoon.

The jokers whole personality is cartoonish, without that he is not the joker

[Niamh.]

The jokers whole personality is cartoonish, without that he is not the joker

Heath displayed just how to do it :idc:

[Niamh.]

Yeah, you're right my vote shouldn't count really. I guess i was put off by him in Ten things i hate about you and when the new batman movies came out they always looked too actiony/ blockbusterish from the trailers as opposed to Tim Burtons kind of black humourness in films

But I'm really cynical when it comes to films, someone made me watch Date Night the other night and it nearly ended up in homocide

That film was crap alright, Heath was a good actor. He was really good in Candy

[SharkAttack]

Enjoyed both of them as TJ. Jack was more fun, so I gave him the edge.

[Ramsay]

Nicholson was amazing but Ledger brought it to a new level..not saying that cus he's dead cus alot of people do **** like that but i actually mean it Ledger was top class

[Ammi]

Heath still winning...

[Alf]

jacks one of my fave actors but ledger was the better joker

[LaLaLand]

Jack Nicholson because he played Joker how he is SUPPOSED TO BE. Heath's performance was outstanding don't get me wrong but he wasn't how Joker is "known" if you like.

As someone else said, Joker is supposed to be like a cartoon character almost.

[Marc]

Jack.

[Benjamin]

The only reason Heath is winning is because all the ladies fancy him. Ladies should not be allowed to vote. In anything. :bored:

[Shaun]

Heath. Easily. Jack's was a pantomime character. Heath's was a genuinely troubled and disturbing psychopath... it was more real.

[Liberty4eva]

I like the concept of Ledger's Joker better than the concept of Nicolson's Joker of this intelligent psychopath who wants to watch the world burn. But the reason I voted for Ledger is the nurse scene which I think is probably what got him the oscar. That scene is epic. Nicolson's Joker is often funny but sometimes comes across as very cartoony.

However, I like the movie Batman better than the Dark Knight because Batman never tries to convince you that this is the real world. It knows what it is and does it well. It's almost as if Dark Knight is ashamed of being a superhero movie and was trying to be something else and tries to convince you that this could happen in real life. And the CGI on Two-Face looked ridiculous.

[Ammi]

The only reason Heath is winning is because all the ladies fancy him. Ladies should not be allowed to vote. In anything. :bored:

http://t0.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcSLl3OqpwhhoPOqYWwm1k7pRzbAJ1KoQ 5ax90trUyAUNLYtGG_m

[King Gizzard]

Haven't seen either film..I have Dark Knight though...


*waits for shocked faces*

[SocietyIsRuined]

Ceaser Romero but as he isn't on the list then I would have to go with Heath only on the basis that he was more a psychopath than Nicholsons.

[Roy Mars III]

The only reason Heath is winning is because all the ladies fancy him. Ladies should not be allowed to vote. In anything. :bored:

true

[Roy Mars III]

to be honest though the problem with the Dark Knight, and nolan batman movies in general, isn't Ledger but Christian Bale. He was amazing in American Psycho, but is a terrible batman

Michael Keaton >

[Ammi]

http://t0.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcTbou5lzw1MkbcIdnfhnThbIjU5y2Iop f5t7wiJGtEDSubCPBxrRg

[Niamh.]

to be honest though the problem with the Dark Knight, and nolan batman movies in general, isn't Ledger but Christian Bale. He was amazing in American Psycho, but is a terrible batman

Michael Keaton >

This I do agree with. That stupid voice he puts on makes me want to scratch my eyes out ............or ears off maybe