If you was a Jury on Big Brother USA or Suvivor

[DrunkerThanMoses]

How do you think you would vote?

Would you vote for someone you liked and was loyal to you, but they played a crap game, basically floated to the end, or would you vote for the gameplayer; the underdog who stabbed you in the back to make the final 2/3, but undoubtedly played a great game.

[Marc]

Depends, if I was voted out by everybody then I'd drop all ties to my 'loyal' counterparts and I'll vote the best game player.

I'd like to think that no matter what I'd always vote the best gameplayer, but I reckon if I was close to somebody in there and they reached the final I'd vote them. I'd hope that they played at least some good strategy.

My thoughts going into the game would be not to make any close friends though, just alliances. Then I should hopefully not have that problem and then I could just vote for the best game player in the final.

I fear that I've rambled a bit too much :blush2: basically, gameplayer or somebody who I would have accidently gotten to close to.

[LemonJam]

I couldn't vote for somebody I thought was an absolute tit, regardless of their gameplay. It depends on the persons character really.

[Marc]

James we all know you'd vote the fodder who doesn't do anything :bored:

[LemonJam]

**** Marc no I wouldn't :hmph:

[Marc]

Who's you favourite in Survivor atm James? :idc:

[LemonJam]

that doesn't mean I'd vote for her :suspect:

[LemonJam]

unless she did some sortof cluster**** move and bought Alicia and Troyzan to the end then I would :P

[DrunkerThanMoses]

I think it would depend on personality, I know it sounds bitter but I would never vote for someone who played a good game but was a complete bastard or bitch to me or other people.

[Marc]

Haha I want people to make big moves. When Parvati lost in HvV I could have died

[swinearefine]

I would vote for who I wanted to win, which could be for a number of reasons. There is no black and white definition for a "good gameplayer" and a "bad gameplayer" and the game does not end once you have made it to the finals. The game encompasses making it to the end whilst securing the votes of the people you have a hand in voting out. It's not really fair to label people who make big moves and are duplicitous and awful as "gameplayers" while floaters are dubbed "crap."

If you can manage to float to the end and secure the right amount of votes to win, it would seem to me that you've played the best game, as the goal of the game is to win, not to be the flashiest and nastiest. More often than not it is floaters and under-the-radar players who win, which should indicate that it's a good strategy. I think people who just steamroll through the game and inevitably lose (perfect example: Russell in S19/20) are the worst players because they are too stupid to acknowledge 50% of the game - getting the jury to vote for you.

Whoever wins is the deserving winner, end of, and I really don't know why there is so much debate about it.

Note: I think most people erroneously equate floating with being under-the-radar now. A floater is someone who constantly switches sides, following the power. Under-the-radar means that you do not draw attention to yourself through making big moves, winning competitions, etc.

[LemonJam]

^ couldn't sum it up better myself :worship:

[BBfanUSA]

If I was on a jury I would just ask Pepperoni or Sausage and just see how well they answer the other questions.

Sure everyone in the room would go WTF?!?!?!?! but I would be random enough that i would get a few laughs.

[rk3388]

i would vote for the person who didnt deserve it because i would probably be feeling very bitter towards the big gameplayers. Just being honest

[swinearefine]

Haha I want people to make big moves. When Parvati lost in HvV I could have died

That was the happiest moment of my life :hmph:

[Mystic Mock]

I would vote for my friend in the game.

[reece(:]

a mixture of personality, gameplay and who needs it more

[Bluerang1]

I'd vote for who I think deserves the prize the most. Not about game, who I know the best.

[Jords]

Id vote for my mate and failing having any mates in the final Id vote for the best gameplayer rather than the nicer player.

[AndrewLee***]

If they were in my alliance I would vote for them. But besides that I would vote by game play. I HATE when people don't vote for someone because of personal reasons. Its so annoying -__-