David Nalbandian investigated by police after line judge injury

[Omah]

http://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/0/tennis/18479244

Police are investigating a complaint of alleged assault against David Nalbandian, who was disqualified from the Aegon Championships final after a line judge was injured.

The Argentine, 30, was leading Marin Cilic 7-6 (7-3) 3-4 at Queen's when he kicked a panel in front of Andrew McDougall's seat.

McDougall's leg was cut and umpire Fergus Murphy awarded the match to Cilic despite boos from the crowd.

Nalbandian apologised for the incident.

A spokesman for Scotland Yard said: "We are aware of an incident at the Aegon Championships on June 17.

"A complaint has been made and the Metropolitan Police Service is now investigating. The allegation is of assault."

The incident happened after Nalbandian missed a lunging forehand in the second set.

He kicked an advertising hoarding, which flew off its hinges and struck McDougall in the shin, causing a large gash.

McDougall received immediate treatment from St John's Ambulance and saw the tournament medical team.

Nalbandian told the 6,000-capacity crowd: "I am very sorry, sometimes you get frustrated on court."

He was deemed guilty of unsportsmanlike conduct and his £36,500 prize money was withdrawn and he could be hit with a further fine.

Bang 'im up, bang the Argie up ..... :hmph:

[lostalex]

damn argies... first the faulklands, now this.. what cheek!

[MTVN]

Pathetic, it was obviously just an accident

[Brother Leon]

**** happens in the heat of the moment of sports. This is stupid.

[Omah]

Pathetic, it was obviously just an accident

**** happens in the heat of the moment of sports. This is stupid.

Rules are rules - the assault on the adverting board was intentional not accidental, the line judge was clearly visible, inches behind it, and the injury was both bloody and painful - it could have been worse if, say, the judge had gone into shock and died - I hope the Argie gets a massive fine and a stretch at HMP ..... :pipe:

[MTVN]

He just got a bit pissed off and directed a kick at an advertising board, it accidentally gave the judge a bit of a cut but as if there was any real possibility of serious injury, never mind death from it. He was disqualified from the final of a tournament he was looking likely to win and missed out on nearly £40k in prize money, that's punishment enough

[Locke.]

Hasn't done anything wrong.

[Omah]

He just got a bit pissed off and directed a kick at an advertising board, it accidentally gave the judge a bit of a cut but as if there was any real possibility of serious injury, never mind death from it. He was disqualified from the final of a tournament he was looking likely to win and missed out on nearly £40k in prize money, that's punishment enough

I disagree.

If he's a professional, he should act like one, not like a petulant schoolboy.

To paraphrase Candide:

"Dans ce pays-ci, il est bon d'emprisonner de temps en temps un joueur de tennis pour encourager les autres."

:pipe:

[lostalex]

He just got a bit pissed off and directed a kick at an advertising board, it accidentally gave the judge a bit of a cut but as if there was any real possibility of serious injury, never mind death from it. He was disqualified from the final of a tournament he was looking likely to win and missed out on nearly £40k in prize money, that's punishment enough

the advertising board was like 2 inches from the judge, how could he not know that it would hit the guy?

[MTVN]

Well it's more of a box, he probably thought it was a lot more sturdy

[Omah]

Well it's more of a box, he probably thought it was a lot more sturdy

He should have thought harder, longer before lining up his "free kick" ..... :hmph:

[arista]

Hasn't done anything wrong.

The Old boy sitting down
had Blood on his leg.


Thats why he was removed


http://i.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2012/06/17/article-2160615-13A75953000005DC-879_634x410.jpg
Injury 1

http://i.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2012/06/17/article-2160615-13A748AA000005DC-759_306x423.jpg
Assault by the Argie

[arista]

http://i.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2012/06/17/article-2160615-13A748A5000005DC-260_306x423.jpg

http://i.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2012/06/17/article-2160615-13A74CA7000005DC-804_634x636.jpg
Assault being checked

[Mystic Mock]

I can't believe they give excuses out to the scum of the earth, yet treat cases like this seriously, wtf is wrong with the law? it was a god damn accident unlike some of the other cases I could point out where they got away scott free.

[King Gizzard]

Absolutely pathetic the reaction to this, Sue Barker used the word brutal to describe it yesterday

Get

a

grip

[Omah]

it was a god damn accident.

:nono:

I believe that you are grossly mistaken. The video clearly shows deliberation and intent from the Argie - he was reckless as to the outcome of his assault on the board.

:idc:

[Omah]

Get

a

grip

Obviously, that's what the Argie should have done ..... :shrug:

[arista]

:nono:

I believe that you are grossly mistaken. The video clearly shows deliberation and intent from the Argie - he was reckless as to the outcome of his assault on the board.

:idc:


Yes Argie Reckless


Bang On Right

[MTVN]

I think disqualifying him was even a bit harsh, and unfair on all the people who'd paid to watch it, should have just given him a massive fine

[Redway]

I just love the way the women who find amusement in murdering their children are left to roam free whilst such trivial matters as this are taken so seriously. Absolute disgrace.

[Livia]

This is tennis we're talking about. The line judge was sitting inches away but the professional sportsman couldn't control himself and lashed out like a petulant child. The assault thing is a bit far fetched because there was no intent, but it was right he was disqualified, or at what point of unprofessional behaviour do you draw the line?

[Mystic Mock]

I just love the way the women who find amusement in murdering their children are left to roam free whilst such trivial matters as this are taken so seriously. Absolute disgrace.

This, and don't forget the 3 Muslim girls that beat the white girl up calling her a white slag, and the woman in Southend yesterday having 4 people beat her up yet I bet they won't even be taken as seriously as this.

Im not saying he shouldn't be disqualified, but seriously why has it got to be investigated? there's been fights in loads of Football matches yet they've never been investigated.

[Marc]

I think it's just.

[Marc]

Absolutely pathetic the reaction to this, Sue Barker used the word brutal to describe it yesterday

Get

a

grip

Don't you DARE start on Sue.

[Redway]

This, and don't forget the 3 Muslim girls that beat the white girl up calling her a white slag, and the woman in Southend yesterday having 4 people beat her up yet I bet they won't even be taken as seriously as this.

Im not saying he shouldn't be disqualified, but seriously why has it got to be investigated? there's been fights in loads of Football matches yet they've never been investigated. Exactly. As I say, dickheads exist in every shape, size or form and if they called her a 'white slag' there's no justification whatsoever on the race issue. Just a month or two back we had that Essex woman hurling vile abuse at people she deemed to be 'foreigners' (which was utter nonsense). She gets banged up for five months yet the Muslim racists have nothing happen, bar a caution. Talk about equality.

This is tennis we're talking about. The line judge was sitting inches away but the professional sportsman couldn't control himself and lashed out like a petulant child. The assault thing is a bit far fetched because there was no intent, but it was right he was disqualified, or at what point of unprofessional behaviour do you draw the line?
He certainly did act like a petulant child, as you put it, and he most certainly deserved to be disqualified but the whole 'assualt' thing is bollocks.

[Marc]

He deserved the DQ

[Mystic Mock]

Exactly. As I say, dickheads exist in every shape, size or form and if they called her a 'white slag' there's no justification whatsoever on the race issue. Just a month or two back we had that Essex woman hurling vile abuse at people she deemed to be 'foreigners' (which was utter nonsense). She gets banged up for five months yet the Muslim racists have nothing happen, bar a caution. Talk about equality.


He certainly did act like a petulant child, as you put it, and he most certainly deserved to be disqualified but the whole 'assualt' thing is bollocks.

Exactly, the judge excused them because they was drunk at the time and he said that Muslims are not used to handling there drink, but the last time I checked Alcohol doesn't make you gang up on a girl, calling her a white slag and pull chunks of her hair out which still hasn't grown back, and she's still scared to go outside because of what those bitches done to her.

The law seems to pick and choose which cases to take seriously and which ones not to take seriously.

[Redway]

I think disqualifying him was even a bit harsh, and unfair on all the people who'd paid to watch it, should have just given him a massive fine

I'm going to have to disagree with you here, although I would usually agree very much with what you're saying.

The only objection I have to any of this is to the ridiculous 'assault' case being brought up, when it was simply a case of him acting like a 10-year-old and throwing his dollies out of the pram.

However harsh any of that may be, you cannot justify a professional acting unprofessional on professional grounds. Are you saying that people should be allowed to make fools out of themselves without fear of valid repercussions and consequences? Is that what you're saying?

I know the whole thing seems pretty ridiculous put together but when you actually take out all the bits and think about it you see that not all of it was wrong to do (i.e. the law's consequences on the guy, not his behaviour).

[arista]

http://i.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2012/06/17/article-2160615-13A75953000005DC-879_634x410.jpg

Its a Attack on the Old Boy
The argie is guilty

[Mystic Mock]

But he didn't intend on attacking him.

[arista]

But he didn't intend on attacking him.


Thats is not important
He Did It
and paid the price.

[Mystic Mock]

Thats is not important
He Did It
and paid the price.

Yeah just like the law to go down hard on the lesser crimes.

[Omah]

But he didn't intend on attacking him.

Exactly, he was reckless as to the endangerment of others.

[Mystic Mock]

Exactly, he was reckless as to the endangerment of others.

It's still not as bad as the planned attacks that I mentioned above and nothing was and will not be done about them.

[MTVN]

This is tennis we're talking about. The line judge was sitting inches away but the professional sportsman couldn't control himself and lashed out like a petulant child. The assault thing is a bit far fetched because there was no intent, but it was right he was disqualified, or at what point of unprofessional behaviour do you draw the line?

Intentional/serious assault

[Mystic Mock]

Intentional/serious assault

This, even Joey Barton wasn't getting into as much trouble when he beat the crap out of Dabo, yet this is something that's being investigated seriously.

I give up with the world sometimes.

[Marc]

Intentional/serious assault

Well it's a very well behaved english's gentlemens tournament. The actions of Nalbandian can be viewed as very extreme to those blazer wearing supports :pipe:

[lostalex]

I stopped following tennis since andy roddick isn;'t a contender anymore. He was the only reason i followed tennis.

[MTVN]

Well it's a very well behaved english's gentlemens tournament. The actions of Nalbandian can be viewed as very extreme to those blazer wearing supports :pipe:

Haha yeah it's like cricket, really caught up in sportsmanship

[lostalex]

I think prolly the british just did this to try to embarass the argies before the olympics and because it is the anniversary of the fauklands war.

I've never seen any other tennies tourny where they strategically place such an old man right next to an advertizing board before, it does seem like a bit of a set up....


lol

[Redway]

I think prolly the british just did this to try to embarass the argies before the olympics and because it is the anniversary of the fauklands war.

I've never seen any other tennies tourny where they strategically place such an old man right next to an advertizing board before, it does seem like a bit of a set up....


lol

:laugh: