was adam right to hold tobacco from ash?

[the truth]

I thought he played it superbly

tha foul mouthed sub human ashleigh, was fully supportive of carolines unoriginal unhilarious sabotaging of the shopping....yet when there was only a tiny bit of tobacco , she soon demanded it....she should have said yes it was her who helped caroline ruin the weekly shopping and therefore she should forfeit her bit of tobacco....

adam made this point clearly and fairly and still gave her a share

she of course grabbed it ....what a brainless bore she is

another moral victory for adam:wavey:

[MistyMeg]

I think he was right!! She doesn't even smoke that much anyway!:pipe:

[Jake.]

As much as I dislike her, no. Its not his place, all smokers are entitled to their fair share, he isn't in charge imo.

[the truth]

As much as I dislike her, no. Its not his place, all smokers are entitled to their fair share, he isn't in charge imo.

she encouraged caroline to destroy the £550 shop? was that her place to do that? she was too cowardly to stop it? as were the other insiders.

[AshesonMars]

As much as I dislike her, no. Its not his place, all smokers are entitled to their fair share, he isn't in charge imo.

She knew Caroline was planning on sabotaging the shopping list and thought it was hilarious. Adam gave Ashleigh her share of the tobacco in the end any way. So what's the problem? She's not even a proper smoker.

[sarah78]

He was right to keep it, she doesn't really smoke, and she knew about Caroline not putting tobacco on the shopping list, i would of kept it too, she kept it from the smokers what caroline was doing with the shopping so they were right to keep the tobacco, i don't know why Luke S were telling her she has a right to have some tobacco when he hates Ash smoking he just likes a fight.

[In the Drunk Tank]

She didn't know Caroline wasn't getting any fags though, she even told her to make sure she got some, not really Adam's place to take control of the cigarette supply

[Jake.]

She didn't know Caroline wasn't getting any fags though, she even told her to make sure she got some, not really Adam's place to take control of the cigarette supply

:worship: and even with persuasion, the list would have still been sabotaged. Caroline had her mind set.

[Fetch The Bolt Cutters]

no :bored:

he is a ****

[Kazanne]

Adam did the right thing it should have taught her a lesson,and he gave some to her after a while,which is more than i would have done,she is opne of those people who Have to get thier mitts on anything other people have,plus on LF Luke S was telling her NOT to give 'someone' fags not sure who it was,but shows they are so thick they learn nothing.

[Jake.]

And I dont get this whole 'she doesnt even smoke that much' nonsense. The tabacco is for everyone, from casual to hard smokers.

[WozMan]

Does anyone know roughly how many a day each of them smoke?

[Gizmo]

Adam went down in my estimation after this. But Ashleigh's counter-argument was weak and she didn't express herself very well (as usual). She was trying to say it was never her intention to have no cigs and it was Caroline who made the decision when she was in the DR. But she isn't very articulate and just got in a strop like a child. Glad he saw sense and decided to give her her share. Luke S was worse imo for getting involved. It had nothing to do with him and he's not even a smoker.

[Tinsel Toes]

As much as I dislike her, no. Its not his place, all smokers are entitled to their fair share, he isn't in charge imo.

Well why didn't the stupid dumb cow go to the diary room herself and ask for some ! she took no cigs in and then continually scrounged cigs Lauren had paid for - she also had the neck to have a go at Lauren for complaining about it. *******igh don't even inhale - what a waste of cigs and tobacco , esp when it is so expensive. I would have told her to sod right off - Skank

[WozMan]

Realistically by any proper standards her 'fair share' consists of a portion commensurate with how many a day she smokes, which is WAAAY less than a fifth.

She really is a complete leech.

[Black Dagger]

Absolutely, she knew what Caroline was up to, she faces the consequences, and she's a sket, if only she walked :idc:

[InOne]

He wussed out and gave her some anyway.

[Knitting Nana]

She didn't know Caroline wasn't getting any fags though, she even told her to make sure she got some, not really Adam's place to take control of the cigarette supply

Yeah, exactly she thought SHE was getting some. She made it clear that she thought she was going to be the only one getting some. When it backfired on her she had no right demanding some from the others.

[WozMan]

Did BB not insruct him to do so? I thought someone else said that?

[Cherry Christmas]

He wussed out and gave her some anyway.

No, he made his point, and got her to think about how her and her friends actions affected others, then he divided it up. Win, win for Adam, he got his point across and then showed he was better than them.:hugesmile:

[InOne]

No, he made his point, and got her to think about how her and her friends actions affected others, then he divided it up. Win, win for Adam, he got his point across and then showed he was better than them.:hugesmile:

He still wussed and gave her some. No matter how you wrap it up dear.

[WozMan]

I think the crowd should all make sucking sounds when she leaves the house:devil::devil:

[Rustic bauble]

She didn't know Caroline wasn't getting any fags though, she even told her to make sure she got some, not really Adam's place to take control of the cigarette supply

She asked Caroline but Caroline later explained that if she got tobacco she would have to get it for all the smokers...then if she did that then she would have had to have got protein powder etc.... so she had to leave it all together.

Lets not forget when Ashleigh etc drank the wine in the cudboard...Adam did good to wind her up. He did eventually give her some.

[Gillian-73]

She didn't know Caroline wasn't getting any fags though, she even told her to make sure she got some, not really Adam's place to take control of the cigarette supply

If that is true, she's still a horrid little get, when realising Caroline hadn't got them she didn't have a go at her but soon found her voice to kick off with Adam.

[fitz2k2]

He wussed out and gave her some anyway.

Adam=pussy

[Gillian-73]

He still wussed and gave her some. No matter how you wrap it up dear.
Maybe because he's a decent person.

[InOne]

Maybe because he's a decent person.

Yeah but he should've stuck to his guns, especially after Luke A's comment. Maybe she did really get Luke S on them...

[WozMan]

Yeah but he should've stuck to his guns, especially after Luke A's comment. Maybe she did really get Luke S on them...

Adam's done hard time. What has Luke S ever endured? Also think BB told him to share it.

[Cherry Christmas]

He still wussed and gave her some. No matter how you wrap it up dear.

Makes me laugh your attempt at being patronising..or are you really 90?....:joker::devil:

He's a good man with a sense of fairness, we saw this right at the beginning when he was the only HM to tell ALL those who didnt know that they could speak about noms.

[Lister of Smeg]

Adam was completely in the right to do what he did Ash deserved nothing for her part in Caroline wasting the shoping budget on chocolate if Ash really wanted some cigs she would have gone into the diary room and asked for some for herself but shes to lazy she has to have everyone else fight her battles or do everything for her seriously she cant even cook a basic meal yet screems demands on what she wants for dinner spoiled brat is all she is .

[smeagol]

he shouldn't of gave her any bacci is precious in there. luke s was telling her last night not to give them filters or something. they are evil and dont give a crap so why should adam and co be nice.. do unto those who do unto you lol.
ash just wants the precious they cants haves it sneaky trickys fat hobbitises always after the precious cigs

[InOne]

He still wussed and gave her some. No matter how you wrap it up dear.

Makes me laugh your attempt at being patronising..or are you really 90?....:joker::devil:

He's a good man with a sense of fairness, we saw this right at the beginning when he was the only HM to tell ALL those who didnt know that they could speak about noms.

Fixed the quote sweetie. :wavey:

It looked very silly Luke A getting all sarky with Ash and then end up giving her in the end. She didn't learn anything, he just came off as pathetic.

[Gillian-73]

Yeah but he should've stuck to his guns, especially after Luke A's comment. Maybe she did really get Luke S on them...

Lol i doubt Luke S could have done anything to convince him, Adam made his point, he did good imo.

[InOne]

Lol i doubt Luke S could have done anything to convince him, Adam made his point, he did good imo.

Probably mentioned how it's gonna look to the public ;)

[Munchkins]

NO, he really had no right regardless of he dislikes her or not

[Gillian-73]

Probably mentioned how it's gonna look to the public ;)

I must admit that did make me laugh :laugh3: i still disagree and believe he did it for the right reasons, though!

[Roy Mars III]

yes, she deserved none of it

[Yayita]

he should have held steady, but he crumbled and gave her some

[EzzaB]

YOU FACKIN' WAIT ADAM!!!
Ashleigh is pathetic

[WozMan]

YOU FACKIN' WAIT ADAM!!!
Ashleigh is pathetic

A pathetic little leech:devil:

[Cherry Christmas]

Fixed the quote sweetie. :wavey:

It looked very silly Luke A getting all sarky with Ash and then end up giving her in the end. She didn't learn anything, he just came off as pathetic.

Okay Im thinking blue rinse, support stockings, and a shopping bag on wheels. I will be nicer to you in future as I do really respect my elders.:blush:

[Manal]

I liked him when he did that

[InOne]

Okay Im thinking blue rinse, support stockings, and a shopping bag on wheels. I will be nicer to you in future as I do really respect my elders.:blush:

You're mostly likely older than me, you seem grumpy a lot of the time :suspect:

I've noticed in our little duels you tend to stray off-topic when I'm destroying you ;)

[erinp5]

Adam made the point that Ash was aware and supported Caroline sabotaging the shopping ,if Ash was mad at anyone regarding the cigs it should have been Caroline . That lots are blinded by their hate for the outsiders.
What really annoyed me was last night LukeS said "If they want a cig let them come and *****ing ask me "
Why was he as a non smoker controlling the cigs?

[Razor]

Well why didn't the stupid dumb cow go to the diary room herself and ask for some ! she took no cigs in and then continually scrounged cigs Lauren had paid for - she also had the neck to have a go at Lauren for complaining about it. *******igh don't even inhale - what a waste of cigs and tobacco , esp when it is so expensive. I would have told her to sod right off - Skank

+1

I would of told to sod off.

Luke A's comment about getting Luke S was superb. I was really hoping for a double eviction this week and for *******igh to go along with Caroline.

[armand.kay]

Definitely not Big Brother gave it to them for all the housemates to share. Adam had no right to take it upon himself to decide who gets some and who does not. I have actually noticed how pathetic this man is.

[Cherry Christmas]

You're mostly likely older than me, you seem grumpy a lot of the time :suspect:

I've noticed in our little duels you tend to stray off-topic when I'm destroying you ;)

Thats nearly as deluded as when you predicted a Lauren win.:devil:

[Rustic bauble]

Adam made the point that Ash was aware and supported Caroline sabotaging the shopping ,if Ash was mad at anyone regarding the cigs it should have been Caroline . That lots are blinded by their hate for the outsiders.
What really annoyed me was last night LukeS said "If they want a cig let them come and *****ing ask me "
Why was he as a non smoker controlling the cigs?

Luke S is a control freak....he probably did not like Adam controlling the situation yesterday.
I wonder what made Adam give her some....Did you see Luke S and Ashleigh just staring at him when he shared it out?... That was uncomfortable. It was good that Adam wound her up....maybe it made her think...but I doubt it. By giving her some it showed he was not going to sink to their level...and to be fair it wasnt his to control. We will see more tonight.... If Luke S takes control of the tobacco it would be foolish considering he nearly went last night.

[InOne]

You're mostly likely older than me, you seem grumpy a lot of the time :suspect:

I've noticed in our little duels you tend to stray off-topic when I'm destroying you ;)

Thats nearly as deluded as when you predicted a Lauren win.:devil:

If it wasn't for BB's blatant manipulation of noms she'd still be there. If she wasn't stiched up then she would've been a winner for sure.


Anything else?

[Rustic bauble]

Definitely not Big Brother gave it to them for all the housemates to share. Adam had no right to take it upon himself to decide who gets some and who does not. I have actually noticed how pathetic this man is.

He gave some to the thick bitch in the end.... The alcohol is for them all to share but it didnt stop Ashleigh and co drinking a bottle in the cudboard did it?

What goes around....comes around. Its a shame Adam did the decent thing cos she didnt deserve it.

[chuff me dizzy]

100% behind him ,but I was disappointed when he backed down

[the truth]

She didn't know Caroline wasn't getting any fags though, she even told her to make sure she got some, not really Adam's place to take control of the cigarette supply

if she had a brain she would have worked out in the unoriginal hilarious prank, that when all the money gets spent on chocolate, you dont get fags...even skanleigh knows cigarettes arent made of chocolate? doesnt she?:joker:

[the truth]

No, he made his point, and got her to think about how her and her friends actions affected others, then he divided it up. Win, win for Adam, he got his point across and then showed he was better than them.:hugesmile:

100% agree...well put :dance:

[Cherry Christmas]

If it wasn't for BB's blatant manipulation of noms she'd still be there. If she wasn't stiched up then she would've been a winner for sure.


Anything else?

Is this still you destroying me? :tongue:

[InOne]

If it wasn't for BB's blatant manipulation of noms she'd still be there. If she wasn't stiched up then she would've been a winner for sure.


Anything else?

Is this still you destroying me? :tongue:

Yes. Learn to love it :)

[Cherry Christmas]

Yes. Learn to love it :)

Just checking so I could get a handle on your idea of "destroying".....:laugh2:

[InOne]

Just checking so I could get a handle on your idea of "destroying".....:laugh2:

You've not handled it since we had our first duel. God loves a trier though :pipe:

[rayheartbliss]

adam and luke A didnt get what they wanted, *******igh got her satisfaction from caroline's shopping stunt therefore she lost her rights to the cigarettes, hell...caroline said how much chocolate she was gonna order , so she knew caroline wasnt getting cigarettes, i mean that was her purpose, so *******igh was just being a b*tch

i actually wanted adam to shove that tobacco down her mouth, so she could shut up

[Rustic bauble]

I have to say....that was one of the best moments this series.

[armand.kay]

He gave some to the thick bitch in the end.... The alcohol is for them all to share but it didnt stop Ashleigh and co drinking a bottle in the cudboard did it?

What goes around....comes around. Its a shame Adam did the decent thing cos she didnt deserve it.
Two wrongs do not make a right.

Whether she deserved it or not she had right to some of! It was not right of Adam and Luke to decide who gets tobacco and who does not.

[Cherry Christmas]

You've not handled it since we had our first duel. God loves a trier though :pipe:

When did we have our first duel? cant say its left the same impression on me as it did you as I cant recall, but if you consider quoting an odd post of yours here and there and having a differing opinion to you dueling then so be it.:pat:

[InOne]

When did we have our first duel? cant say its left the same impression on me as it did you as I cant recall, but if you consider quoting an odd post of yours here and there and having a differing opinion to you dueling then so be it.:pat:

I can't remember our first duel, all I know is you pop up now and again arguing with my point and get completely destroyed :joker:


Bless :pat:

[joeysteele]

No,he was completely wrong, he was gieven them for the house not just for him and Luke A.
Ashleigh had shared cigarttes with housemates in the early weeks, odd how Conor can make offensive remarks and be pilloried for it all series but Adam can be given Cigarettes and tobacco for the house, yet chose to discriminate against a female housemate yet is hailed a hero for it.

I am no fan of Ashleigh but they were 'not' his to withhold, also we didn't see all the carry on and I would dare guess although not shown that he was very likely told by BB to give her a share of them.

[Cherry Christmas]

I can't remember our first duel, all I know is you pop up now and again arguing with my point and get completely destroyed :joker:


Bless :pat:

:joker: what a wag, at least you believe your own hype thats important obviously.

[Babschap]

I think that all those who supported Caroline and laughed with her in the shopping task should be made to eat the sweets this week. The others should have supplements to their diet. What a 1st class twat Caroline is, and her friends in the house too.

[Cherry Christmas]

I think that all those who supported Caroline and laughed with her in the shopping task should be made to eat the sweets this week. The others should have supplements to their diet. What a 1st class twat Caroline is, and her friends in the house too.

What a top idea, that would be fantastic TV.

[Censored]

Adam's done hard time. What has Luke S ever endured?

*******igh fumbling with his giant knacker :yuk:

[Razor]

I think that all those who supported Caroline and laughed with her in the shopping task should be made to eat the sweets this week. The others should have supplements to their diet. What a 1st class twat Caroline is, and her friends in the house too.

Superb idea.

[Gillian-73]

I think that all those who supported Caroline and laughed with her in the shopping task should be made to eat the sweets this week. The others should have supplements to their diet. What a 1st class twat Caroline is, and her friends in the house too.

Lol i would love that

[Indy]

Luke S is a control freak....he probably did not like Adam controlling the situation yesterday.
I wonder what made Adam give her some....Did you see Luke S and Ashleigh just staring at him when he shared it out?... That was uncomfortable. It was good that Adam wound her up....maybe it made her think...but I doubt it. By giving her some it showed he was not going to sink to their level...and to be fair it wasnt his to control. We will see more tonight.... If Luke S takes control of the tobacco it would be foolish considering he nearly went last night.

If we look at what we know from Twitter and the HL's:
Ashleigh is not a smoker, she only steals other people's
Ashleigh knew about the shopping, and claimed later she told Caroline to get "the tobacco", but we never SEE her tell Caroline that
Ashleigh admits in the kitchen she thought Caroline would still get HER tobacco, just not everyone else
DR gives Adam less than half of what just one person would smoke in a week
Adam tells her no
Ashleigh stomps off to the DR screaming
Adam silently gives Ashleigh a small share of the tobacco
The DR only hands out tobacco for "free" when the shrink and lawyer advises them to do it to prevent violence or extreme aggression

In other words - BB most likely made Adam share it.

[crocs]

I don't like Ashleigh but Adam was not right. He was right to explain to Ashleigh how Caroline's actions and Ashleigh condoning those actions affected others but he strayed from his killing them with kindness tactics. But I suppose he was trying to teach her a lesson but that was wasted.

[Petershaw1984]

Luke s telling her to go get some as she is entitled to some made me laugh. He **** hinself when adam was destroying the choclate. Luke s is in fact a pussy and ashleigh had a pussys fingers inside her p......................

[Johnnyuk123]

He still wussed and gave her some. No matter how you wrap it up dear.

Yes but he wiped her baccy on his bum hole before handing it over.

[WozMan]

How tremendiously ironic is it that she thought SHE was going to get ciggies from Caroline and NOT Adam or Luke. She just thought that was HILARIOUS. Shoe on the other foot and she goes APE **** BALLISTIC!!!!!

As for demanding a FIFTH of the ciggies when she is a casual smoker who only smokes a few a day as opposed to Adam and Luke A who are on like 40ish a day, that's just pure bollox.

[Kazanne]

NO, he really had no right regardless of he dislikes her or not

Yes he did,after all wasn't it Ashleigh and Becky that necked the wine in the store cupboard without telling the others they had an extra bottle ! whats good for the goose is good for the gander.

[Indy]

Yes he did,after all wasn't it Ashleigh and Becky that necked the wine in the store cupboard without telling the others they had an extra bottle ! whats good for the goose is good for the gander.

Just like it's Ashleigh who steals Adam's energy drinks when they have alcohol, because the idea that he doesn't drink and the drinks are a trade off is too complicated for her 3 brain cells.

[Cherry Christmas]

Yes he did,after all wasn't it Ashleigh and Becky that necked the wine in the store cupboard without telling the others they had an extra bottle ! whats good for the goose is good for the gander.

Good point, Adam went to the DR to request ciggies so techinically they are his.

[InOne]

:joker: what a wag, at least you believe your own hype thats important obviously.

'wag' never heard that one before :suspect: As in I'm a footballers wife :conf:

[InOne]

Yes but he wiped her baccy on his bum hole before handing it over.

wat

[Cherry Christmas]

'wag' never heard that one before :suspect: As in I'm a footballers wife :conf:

Someone who overuses the word "destroyed" should have no trouble figuring out which of the following applies to them, heres a clue, it has nothing to do with being a footballers wife...:devil:


with reference to an animal's tail) Move or cause to move rapidly to and fro: "his tail began to wag"; "the dog went out, wagging its tail".


Noun: 1.A single rapid movement from side to side: "a chirpy wag of the head".
2.A person who makes facetious jokes.



Synonyms: verb. shake - waggle - wave - swing
noun. jester - joker

[InOne]

Someone who overuses the word "destroyed" should have no trouble figuring out which of the following applies to them, heres a clue, it has nothing to do with being a footballers wife...:devil:


with reference to an animal's tail) Move or cause to move rapidly to and fro: "his tail began to wag"; "the dog went out, wagging its tail".


Noun: 1.A single rapid movement from side to side: "a chirpy wag of the head".
2.A person who makes facetious jokes.



Synonyms: verb. shake - waggle - wave - swing
noun. jester - joker


You have an odd use of words. Scrap me destorying you, you're doing a pretty good job of it all by yourself. Getting yourself and muddled up, copy and paste job. I think it's time you went to bed.

[Cherry Christmas]

You have an odd use of words. Scrap me destorying you, you're doing a pretty good job of it all by yourself. Getting yourself and muddled up, copy and paste job. I think it's time you went to bed.



Didnt you say I was older then you earlier in the thread....heres your cocoa...:joker:

[InOne]

Didnt you say I was older then you earlier in the thread....heres your cocoa...:joker:

How old are you then? If you're a granny it's probably time for bed as well :pipe:

[Cherry Christmas]

You know it occured to me after your admission that you associated the word "wag" with a footballers wife that your vocabulary is slightly limited, in truth I don't come on here to "destroy" anyone, I post my opinion end of...so following on in that spirit I thought I should give you some alternative options to "destroy" as my parting gift on this thread, , you could try "annihilate"..."obliterate".... "decimate".....all can be used instead of "destroy" and if you substitute these, then you can continue your raison d'etre with a slightly improved vocabulary...

ps ...please dont ask me to explain raison d'etre, try wikipaedia if you are stuck....:xyxwave:

[InOne]

Awwww is someone grumpy?

[Cherry Christmas]

Awwww is someone grumpy?

In truth, Im bored with it...the fun died, and I realised you weren't a worthy adversary when you thought "wag" was a term only applied to a footballers wife...so with regret Im going to have to leave while you still have some dignity..come back and play when you have improved your liguistic ability..:devil::thumbs:

[InOne]

In truth, Im bored with it...the fun died, and I realised you weren't a worthy adversary when you thought "wag" was a term only applied to a footballers wife...so with regret Im going to have to leave while you still have some dignity..come back and play when you have improved your liguistic ability..:devil::thumbs:

It's not my fault you can't form a decent argument. You took it off-topic ages ago. It always seems to happen, you can't answer my points so you start with the snipes and smilies. The 'wag' thing is clutching at straws, it's only one term I've never heard of fgs. Maybe you could try getting back to the original topic and stop making an idiot of yourself. And if we should cross paths again STICK to the topic. Don't wuss out like Adam did ;)

[Rustic bauble]

Two wrongs do not make a right.

Whether she deserved it or not she had right to some of! It was not right of Adam and Luke to decide who gets tobacco and who does not.

Adam shared the tobacco in the end.... the others didnt even have the courage to owning up to the wine...

[Rustic bauble]

No,he was completely wrong, he was gieven them for the house not just for him and Luke A.
Ashleigh had shared cigarttes with housemates in the early weeks, odd how Conor can make offensive remarks and be pilloried for it all series but Adam can be given Cigarettes and tobacco for the house, yet chose to discriminate against a female housemate yet is hailed a hero for it.

I am no fan of Ashleigh but they were 'not' his to withhold, also we didn't see all the carry on and I would dare guess although not shown that he was very likely told by BB to give her a share of them.

....and it wasnt her shopping...but she denied her fellow housemates their right to proper food by agreeing to Carolines 'joke'!!.... Adam put it right...but the shopping list could not be rectified...

[Cherry Christmas]

It's not my fault you can't form a decent argument. You took it off-topic ages ago. It always seems to happen, you can't answer my points so you start with the snipes and smilies. The 'wag' thing is clutching at straws, it's only one term I've never heard of fgs. Maybe you could try getting back to the original topic and stop making an idiot of yourself. And if we should cross paths again STICK to the topic. Don't wuss out like Adam did ;)

My argument was perfectly sound, just because you didnt think so doesn't make it invalid..:hugesmile: night night x.

[InOne]

My argument was perfectly sound, just because you didnt think so doesn't make it invalid..:hugesmile: night night x.

It was barely an argument, so weak you had to ditch it and start all this nonsense. You say you're bored yet still reply :rolleyes: Have you made yourself some little rule where you have to get the last word in or something?

[the truth]

You have an odd use of words. Scrap me destorying you, you're doing a pretty good job of it all by yourself. Getting yourself and muddled up, copy and paste job. I think it's time you went to bed.

this poster seems to be doing a number on you, Id suggest you stop going around telling people you will destroy them and try focusing on the topic at hand:wavey:

[InOne]

this poster seems to be doing a number on you, Id suggest you stop going around telling people you will destroy them and try focusing on the topic at hand:wavey:

I'd suggest not bringing old arguments up looking for a reaction :)