Ammi
28-10-2012, 03:55 PM
A council is considering plans to scrap the titles Mr and Mrs from forms because they offend the transgender community
All titles could be scrapped from paperwork after an investigation by Brighton and Hove city council into the lives of the transgender community in the city.
The proposal is backed by Phelim MacCafferty, the council’s deputy leader, but has been branded “political correctness gone too far” by a Conservative councillor.
A scrutiny panel will put forward a number of recommendations, including the scrapping of titles, to the council for approval in December.
Mr MacCafferty said: “Trans people aren’t necessarily male or female and sometimes they don’t want to be defined by their gender.
“Putting Mr and Mrs on a form is completely useless. This is an issue that concerns most institutions from banks to mobile phone companies. Why is Mr on my debit card, for instance? We should at least examine the issue.” Mr MacCafferty said the change would be “done sensitively” and with the backing of the public.
Steph Scott, a lesbian, gay and transgender activist, said: “Being called Mr or Mrs forces me to choose between genders. It’s assuming people live in a binary world where you’re either one thing or another and it pigeonholes people
“I think it’s a good idea to expand across the city because it’s about getting people to be aware that gender isn’t just male or female.”
Dawn Barrett, Tory councillor for Hangleton and Knoll, said: “It’s completely ludicrous and shows a complete lack of respect. How are they going to address letters properly? This is just political correctness gone too far.”
The Trans Equality Scrutiny Panel was set up to examine issues affecting transgendered people’s safety, welfare and job opportunities and visited support groups throughout the city in July.
The panel’s website, which can be found via the council home page, outlines the main issues for the transgender community when filling out forms.
The panel explains that sometimes “genderqueer” people feel there are “contradictions” in filling out forms. For example, gender has an “other” category but titles eg “Mr and Mrs” does not.
It adds that there are “no options for non-binary/genderqueer people”.
The advice given to combat this suggests “no honorifics” and to “ask gender only if needed”.
The themes were described as a preliminary “snapshot” and are used as “rapid feedback” for those who took part
Other articles:
http://www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/brighton-plans-to-scrap-mr-and-mrs-1399751
http://www.theargus.co.uk/news/10007505.Is_it_the_end_for_Mr___Mrs_/
......Personally, I think it’s about time….very few titles mean anything..if something is irrelevant, why have it..?...I don’t need a title to tell me I am male or female or that I have committed to a partner..and I wouldn’t need a title to tell me I hadn’t....
...do you think it's a good idea..?
All titles could be scrapped from paperwork after an investigation by Brighton and Hove city council into the lives of the transgender community in the city.
The proposal is backed by Phelim MacCafferty, the council’s deputy leader, but has been branded “political correctness gone too far” by a Conservative councillor.
A scrutiny panel will put forward a number of recommendations, including the scrapping of titles, to the council for approval in December.
Mr MacCafferty said: “Trans people aren’t necessarily male or female and sometimes they don’t want to be defined by their gender.
“Putting Mr and Mrs on a form is completely useless. This is an issue that concerns most institutions from banks to mobile phone companies. Why is Mr on my debit card, for instance? We should at least examine the issue.” Mr MacCafferty said the change would be “done sensitively” and with the backing of the public.
Steph Scott, a lesbian, gay and transgender activist, said: “Being called Mr or Mrs forces me to choose between genders. It’s assuming people live in a binary world where you’re either one thing or another and it pigeonholes people
“I think it’s a good idea to expand across the city because it’s about getting people to be aware that gender isn’t just male or female.”
Dawn Barrett, Tory councillor for Hangleton and Knoll, said: “It’s completely ludicrous and shows a complete lack of respect. How are they going to address letters properly? This is just political correctness gone too far.”
The Trans Equality Scrutiny Panel was set up to examine issues affecting transgendered people’s safety, welfare and job opportunities and visited support groups throughout the city in July.
The panel’s website, which can be found via the council home page, outlines the main issues for the transgender community when filling out forms.
The panel explains that sometimes “genderqueer” people feel there are “contradictions” in filling out forms. For example, gender has an “other” category but titles eg “Mr and Mrs” does not.
It adds that there are “no options for non-binary/genderqueer people”.
The advice given to combat this suggests “no honorifics” and to “ask gender only if needed”.
The themes were described as a preliminary “snapshot” and are used as “rapid feedback” for those who took part
Other articles:
http://www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/brighton-plans-to-scrap-mr-and-mrs-1399751
http://www.theargus.co.uk/news/10007505.Is_it_the_end_for_Mr___Mrs_/
......Personally, I think it’s about time….very few titles mean anything..if something is irrelevant, why have it..?...I don’t need a title to tell me I am male or female or that I have committed to a partner..and I wouldn’t need a title to tell me I hadn’t....
...do you think it's a good idea..?