Just wondering...

[Benjamin]

There is always mention from some members about just having one chat thread instead of two.

There are pros and cons for both sides of the argument, I'd just like to see what the majority of the forum feels is better. I'm not going to enforce anything, it's just to see the main concensus.

[King Gizzard]

It would be hell

Different people have different interests, you can't just expect everyone to post in one thread and get along

[InOne]

Get rid of them both and have people interacting properly again.

[MTVN]

It would be a disaster

[Locke.]

Get rid of both or get rid of none

[Munchkins]

It would be hell

Different people have different interests, you can't just expect everyone to post in one thread and get along

This Definitely
Keep Two

[Doogle]

We post in each other's threads sometimes and it works but overall no, it'd be terrible and would cause so many arguments. I don't even dislike any of them but with such different interests it would never work

[GypsyGoth]

I think having two is ideal, however I still feel some get left out, or feel too intimidated to join in with one of the existing chat threads.

There are groups that get on and kinda chat exclusively in one thread, and others that chat in both. So there is no real boundary between them, and to my knowledge everyone gets on with everyone else in the other thread.

I feel that having just the one chat thread would cause arguments and kinda feuds, it would seem like there is a lack of space on the forum.

[King Gizzard]

I think the whole intimidation thing is incredibly overplayed, sure someone can post and it just gets lost in the commotion and ignored but I don't think anyone in either thread doesn't want new people to post in the thread..afterall, if you don't like them, no one is forcing you to look in them/post in them

[thesheriff443]

even with two thread's member's only post between the same old faces.

[Roy Mars III]

no more chat threads

[Brother Leon]

Nar. Imagine the bell end lot talking about the football and then Scott comin in with "I would let that Rooney cum all over me"..it just won't work :laugh:
Remove all or none like Locke said.

[thesheriff443]

I think the whole intimidation thing is incredibly overplayed, sure someone can post and it just gets lost in the commotion and ignored but I don't think anyone in either thread doesn't want new people to post in the thread

see on this i dont agree!

[Fetch The Bolt Cutters]

i would not let rooney cum all over me tyvm

[Brother Leon]

i would not let rooney cum all over me tyvm

Just an example bro :joker:

Robin Van Persie then? :laugh:

[Josy]

Would cause far too much arguments if there was only 1.

[InOne]

I think you there should be a trial with no chat threads at all. See what happens

[King Gizzard]

Would be boring

[Fetch The Bolt Cutters]

Just an example bro :joker:

Robin Van Persie then? :laugh:

defiantly yes

[Doogle]

Why do people want no chat threads? Every thread would turn into a mini chat thread and go off-topic and there'd be no way of saying "take it to the chat threads" or anything

[Josy]

Get rid of them both and have people interacting properly again.

I think you there should be a trial with no chat threads at all. See what happens

See it's alright for people that don't post in them much to suggest this but it wouldn't be fair tbh, a lot of members like to just chat away about their lives, interests and general day to day things and they are able to do that in those threads, if there was no chat threads and members created a new thread for each thing they wanted to discuss the moaning would start about too much pointless threads being made.

Imagine Scott creating a thread for every old/new music artist he found or every gif he wanted an excuse to use? thats just one example off the top of my head.

[InOne]

Why do people want no chat threads? Every thread would turn into a mini chat thread and go off-topic and there'd be no way of saying "take it to the chat threads" or anything

I doubt it would, I'm sure people could restrain themselves to some extent. There's PM's and wall posts for chatting.

[InOne]

See it's alright for people that don't post in them much to suggest this but it wouldn't be fair tbh, a lot of members like to just chat away about their lives, interests and general day to day things and they are able to do that in those threads, if there was no chat threads and members created a new thread for each thing they wanted to discuss the moaning would start about too much pointless threads being made.

Imagine Scott creating a thread for every old/new music artist he found or every gif he wanted an excuse to use? thats just one example off the top of my head.

That's just a load of assumptions though. Don't knock it until you've tried it :pipe: There's threads for what most people talk about in there anyway. The examples being music threads and sports threads.

[Benjamin]

We couldn't implement no chat threads, a thread would just end up being adopted as one.

[Doogle]

I doubt it would, I'm sure people could restrain themselves to some extent. There's PM's and wall posts for chatting.

But that's only good for one-on-one, there isn't a better system for group talking and stuff. Plus the forum would feel boring without a place to just say what I'm doing or something LOL

[InOne]

You couldn't have one either because it wouldn't exactly be against the rules for someone to just start a new one.

[MTVN]

Yeah people just want to be able to generally chat about anything they feel like and not be restricted to a specific topic or subject, wall posts and PM's only cater to one-on-one conversations

[InOne]

But that's only good for one-on-one, there isn't a better system for group talking and stuff. Plus the forum would feel boring without a place to just say what I'm doing or something LOL


There's social groups too. I'm sure you could let people know about you daily life in them, or you could even write a blog :pipe:

[Josy]

I don't see any problems with the way the chat threads are atm

[Black Dagger]

i would not let rooney cum all over me tyvm

:joker:

[InOne]

Some people must do or we wouldn't be here right now discussing it

[Josy]

What is the problems with them in your opinion then? In what way are they having a bad affect on the forum?

[MeMyselfAndI]

One, because it would be hilar

[InOne]

What is the problems with them in your opinion then? In what way are they having a bad affect on the forum?

When did I say they were having a bad effect on the forum? I just think a trial period would be interesting. Especially after these dodgy thread wars that seem to be going on.

[Josy]

When did I say they were having a bad effect on the forum? I just think a trial period would be interesting. Especially after these dodgy thread wars that seem to be going on.

Sorry, my mistake I thought thats what you were meaning with your posts in here.

I don't think it would be fair to remove them for no reason when there is members that enjoy posting in them daily.

[InOne]

Sorry, my mistake I thought thats what you were meaning with your posts in here.

I don't think it would be fair to remove them for no reason when there is members that enjoy posting in them daily.

I'm not too bothered either way. Just thought I'd try get some discussion going LOL

[lily.]

I don't come here much.. so I don't really get into the chat threads.. I don't feel any more or any less comfortable/welcome in either of them though and nobody really knows me..

I voted for one, cos it's easier for newbies to find 'the chat thread' rather than wondering which one to chat in.

[Shaun]

don't care in the slightest, i talk in both

[Kizzy]

Well, you are a superhero you can do what the feck you like...

[lily.]

Aye, he thinks he is. ;)

I assume you're Scottish or Irish from your custom message..

[Maia]

We should all join together in unison and just be the best of friends

[michael21]

There is always mention from some members about just having one chat thread instead of two.

There are pros and cons for both sides of the argument, I'd just like to see what the majority of the forum feels is better. I'm not going to enforce anything, it's just to see the main concensus.

you no all thread made are chat thread apart form the one with no replies :idc:

[Redway]

Think I'd just scrap the pair of them so people can actually get around the forum and not just be seen in one particular thread.

[Doogle]

Everyone posts in other threads :suspect:

[Redway]

What Scrooge said basically.

[michael21]

Everyone posts in other threads :suspect:

that right

[Jesus.]

It would definitely cause arguments. For that reason, I'm in.

[Smithy]

It would definitely cause arguments. For that reason, I'm in.

http://24.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_m3mvolfHWM1qegxs3o1_250.gif

[Doogle]

wtf :joker::joker:

[Apple202]

It would definitely cause arguments. For that reason, I'm in.

lol this is why i voted for one :joker:

[Ammi]

It would definitely cause arguments. For that reason, I'm in.

..I thought Jesus was all for peace on earth....

..I'm starting to have serious doubts that you are really Jesus tbh.....:suspect:...you don't work for the enemy..do you..?...

[nicole_burks]

I post mainly in c&g in those threads, if you were to get rid of them what would I do?
:bawling:

But in that case, pretty much what everyone else said 2 is ideal.