Survivor: Heroes v. Villians Pt II - Who would you pick?

[Marc]

Who would be in your tribes??

9 villians, 9 heroes?

Shoot.

[DrunkerThanMoses]

Can they be from any season or just post Heros v Villains 1?

[Marc]

From recent seasons..

Villians:

NaOnka (Nic) - maybe not, because she quit and therefore doesn't deserve it but.. imagine :love:
Abi-Maria (Phillippines)
Stephanie (Redemp)
Alicia (One World)
Colton (One World)
Philip (Redemp)
Pete (Phillippines)
Sash (Nic)
Jim (South Pacific)

Heroes:

Ashley (Redemp)
Lisa (Phillippines)
Christina (One World)
Kat (One World)
Kourtney (One World)
Ralph (Redemp)
Mick (Samoa)
Albert (South Pacific)
Bill (One World)

[DrunkerThanMoses]

I started it but ended up naming like 20 villians, most from Nicaragua, that really is a under rated season

[Marc]

Meh terrible winner. And the runner up wasn't too great either. Some great potential with the cast but meh..

I'm trying to re-watch Samoa, don't know why but I really liked it

[SoBig]

Heroes

Ozzy - Shame he wasn't on the original season.
Malcolm
Matt
Fabio
Troy
Denise
Lisa <-- Shoot me


Villains

Abi
Colton
Alicia
Kim
Sash
Brenda
Marty
Sophie
Cochran

[Marc]

Poor Kim, she wasn't a big villain! :laugh:

[LemonJam]

I struggled with the idea of from Nicaragua onwards only, but got there eventually

Heroes
Fabio (Nicaragua)
Chase (Nicaragua)
Holly (Nicaragua)
Stacey (South Pacific)
Edna (South Pacific)
Tarzan (One World)
Leif (One World)
Kat (One World)
Dawson (Phillippines)

Villains
Marty (Nicaragua)
Brenda (Nicaragua)
Albert (South Pacific)
Cochran (South Pacific)
Sophie (South Pacific)
Jonas (One World)
Christina (One World)
Pete (Phillippines)
Abi-Maria (Phillippines)

[SoBig]

Poor Kim, she wasn't a big villain! :laugh:
Well Parvati was a Villian and Stephanie, Cirie and Candice were Heroes.

[Marc]

Haha very true

[DrunkerThanMoses]

I struggled with the idea of from Nicaragua onwards only, but got there eventually

Heroes
Fabio (Nicaragua)
Chase (Nicaragua)
Holly (Nicaragua)
Stacey (South Pacific)
Edna (South Pacific)
Tarzan (One World)
Leif (One World)
Kat (One World)
Dawson (Phillippines)

Villains
Marty (Nicaragua)
Brenda (Nicaragua)
Albert (South Pacific)
Cochran (South Pacific)
Sophie (South Pacific)
Jonas (One World)
Christina (One World)
Pete (Phillippines)
Abi-Maria (Phillippines)

They were Villains?

[LemonJam]

They were Villains?

Not really. In fact in a battle where people play each other for money is there such a thing as a "Hero"? [/beingapretentiouscunt]

I kind of ran out of people from S21 onwards but I like those two and they can vaguely be considered villains (Jonas as Coltons right hand man and Christina for generally being useless and obnoxious) so I shoved them in there.

[reece(:]

From the bits and bobs i've seen of a few recent ones. (South Pacific, One World, Philippines).
Villains
Cochran
Pete
Abi-Maria
Artis
Colton
Sophie
Sabrina
One of the Hantz's
Alicia

Heroes
RC
Malcolm
Christine
Stacey
Edna
Tarzan
Whitney
Troyzan
Leif

[reece(:]

Watching some of Nicaragua, Marty and Brenda would have to be on the Villains tribe.

[rk3388]

Na Onka, Phillip and Lisi. rest of cast wouldnt matter.

[Macie Lightfoot]

Not Phillip, one of the worst castaways ever.

[rk3388]

Not Phillip, one of the worst castaways ever.

... In your opinion.

I also think Sierra deserves another chance to play!

[reece(:]

Not Phillip, one of the worst castaways ever.
you're stuck with him im afraid for Caramoan

[Macie Lightfoot]

... In your opinion.

I also think Sierra deserves another chance to play!

It's a fact that he was a main contributor to why Redemption Island sucked.

[rk3388]

It's a fact that he was a main contributor to why Redemption Island sucked.

Uhm, no , actually its not :conf:

[Macie Lightfoot]

He was fully aware of his position and ate it up, allowed the awful Rob to win, had a cringe-inducting fake personality that was an unbelievably horrid Coach rip off, and was a vacuum of airtime by creating tedious drama like baseless accusations of racism. It was seriously so horrid and whoever brought him back needs to be fired from the casting department.

[LemonJam]

If the second HvV would produce a Ponderosa as amazing as the first one I'd totally be up for it. I forgot this beauty existed until today :lovedup:

wk-DqvZNaxc

[DrunkerThanMoses]

http://images.tvrage.com/people/118/351892.jpg

and

http://t1.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcQ4VBhBASJ45JNn4t7_mqTFhUspl_dJc S42ErQHduwwuRrzpah7hSDu-JOLeg

Dont care for anyone else maybe

http://images4.fanpop.com/image/photos/19500000/Krista-Klumpp-survivor-19597360-595-893.jpg

[Macie Lightfoot]

alol well Brett's a nobody and Stephanie's a pathetic wannabe villain soooo no thanks.

[reece(:]

Totally agree with Stephanie Valencia, love her :love:

[rk3388]

I decided to just make a cast of 2 tribes of people i think deserve to play again ( From S21 onwards, altho it would b easy to makwe a H vs V cast if i could include all seasons )


Tribe 1:
1. Na Onka ( Nicaragua)
2. Christine ( Redemption Island)
3. Kat ( One World)
4. Laura ( Caramoan)
5. Cochran (South Pacific)
6. Marty (Nicaragua)
7.Tarzan ( One World)
8. Jim ( South Pacific)

Tribe 2:
1. Phillip ( Redemption Island)
2. Brandon ( South Pacific)
3. Colton ( One World)
4. Shamar ( Caramoan)
5.RC ( Phillipines)
6. Alina ( Nicaragua)
7. Lisa ( Phillipines)
8. Alicia ( One World)

* the challneges would be s*** but the entertainment would be great

[Jenn-CityIVLyfe]

Love this question!
Villains
1.Deena (Amazon)
2.Courtney (Panama)
3.John (Marquesas)
4.Burton (Pearl Islands)
5.Coby (Palau)
6.Judd (Guatemala)
7.Lisi (Fiji)
8.Natalie Bolton (Micronesia)
9.Crystal (Gabon)

Heroes
1.Rafe (Guatemala)
2.Sundra (Cook Islands)
3.Taj (Tocantins)
4.Holly (Nicaragua)
5.Kat (One World)
6.Colleen (Borneo)
7.Gregg (Palau)
8.Aras (Panama)
9.Marcus (Gabon)
Everyone else seems to be doing recent seasons but I just couldn't resist going all the way back.

[Jenn-CityIVLyfe]

Na Onka, Phillip and Lisi. rest of cast wouldnt matter.

Lisi <3
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J6CCNqnW3Js&playnext=1&list=PL74E8797098DAC25E&feature=results_video

(Sorry I can never get the Youtube tags to work)

[reece(:]

Heroes
Christine Shields-Markoski
Shirin Oskooi
Jaclyn Schultz
Alina Wilson
Christina Cha
Woo Hwang
Jeff Varner
Hayden Moss
Tarzan Smith
Eddie Fox

Villains
Kass McQuillen
NaOnka Mixon
Abi-Maria Gomes
Morgan McLeod
Stephanie Valencia
Marty Piombo
Jonathan Penner
Jon Misch
Pete Yurkowski
Shamar Thomas

[rk3388]

Heroes:
Sierra (Tocantins)
Jeremy (BvsW and Second Chances)
Yul (CI)
Taj (Tocantins)
Crystal (Gabon)
Rob C (Amazon & All Stars)
Ian (Palau)
Frosti (China)
RC (Phillipines)

VILLAINS
Shane (Panama)
Na Onka (Nicaragua)
Courtney (Panama)
Rocky (Fiji)
Phillip (RI)
Alicia (OW)
Abi (Phillipines)
Brad (BvsW)
Tony (Cagayan)

[rk3388]

^ Updated list --> But looking at what i said before, Lisi, Shemar, Marty and Kat would all be great too! aha

[rk3388]

I forgot Judd to add to the villains tribe --> why has this man not gotten a second chance ahahha

[JerseyWins]

Heroes:
Sierra (Tocantins)
Jeremy (BvsW and Second Chances)
Yul (CI)
Taj (Tocantins)
Crystal (Gabon)
Rob C (Amazon & All Stars)
Ian (Palau)
Frosti (China)
RC (Phillipines)

VILLAINS
Shane (Panama)
Na Onka (Nicaragua)
Courtney (Panama)
Rocky (Fiji)
Phillip (RI)
Alicia (OW)
Abi (Phillipines)
Brad (BvsW)
Tony (Cagayan)
That villains tribe would be reeeeally good entertainment. Most of the heroes tribe aren't that great though but I wouldn't hate it aside from a few of them.

[JerseyWins]

Also, I'm not sure why Corinne & Phillip were on Fans vs. Favorites but they belong on a Heroes vs. Villains season.

[reece(:]

Heroes
Woo Hwang
Jon Misch
Hayden Moss
Joe del Campo
Keith Nale
Natalie Anderson
Alecia Holden
Peih-Gee Law
Christine Shields-Markoski
Kelley Wentworth/Hali Ford

Villians
Tony Vlachos
Peter Baggenstos
Marty Piombo
Pete Yurkowski
Drew Christy
Na'Onka Mixon
Kass McQuillen
Abi-Maria Gomes
Debbie Wanner
Stephanie Valencia/Brenda Lowe

[JerseyWins]

I don't necessarily love that cast and there are a few duds but I think it could make for an entertaining season. :joker:

Take out Joe for another one of the golden boys and get Corinne in there for let's say Debbie and you're on to something. :clap1: