Artist vs Artist game

[Me. I Am Salman]

Results
Round 1 - Rihanna v Beyonce - Rihanna wins Most popular song: Don't Stop The Music
Round 2 - Usher v Justin Timberlake - Justin wins Most popular song: Like I Love You/U Got It Bad


Two popular acts are put together and out of these decide from each artist's first 10 released singles (specific to the UK, ignoring soundtracks & features) which song you prefer

I will calculate the scores for each song at the end of the round and declare the winning songs, and the winning artist overall

I've decided to do Rihanna vs Beyonce first, people can help me decide which artists to do in the next rounds

Please try to judge each song fairly and not base your opinion on which artist you like more, if you get what I mean

And yes, I'm aware it looks like a rip-off of Shaun's thread :/ I'll put it off if it's needed..

Round 1 - Rihanna vs Beyonce

Pon de Replay vs Crazy In Love
If It's Lovin' That You Want vs Baby Boy
SOS vs Me Myself & I
Unfaithful vs Naughty Girl
We Ride vs Déjà Vu
Umbrella vs Irreplaceable
Shut Up and Drive vs Beautiful Liar
Don't Stop the Music vs Green Light
Hate That I Love You vs If I were a Boy
Take a Bow vs Single Ladies

Rihanna = 7 points
Beyonce = 3 points

[Vladimir]

Pon de Replay vs Crazy In Love
If It's Lovin' That You Want vs Baby Boy
SOS vs Me Myself & I
Unfaithful vs Naughty Girl
We Ride vs Déjà Vu
Umbrella vs Irreplaceable
Shut Up and Drive vs Beautiful Liar
Don't Stop the Music vs Green Light
Hate That I Love You vs If I were a Boy
Take a Bow vs Single Ladies

Rihanna - 6pts
Bey - 4pts

[ChristmasNeeve]

Round 1 - Rihanna vs Beyonce

Pon de Replay vs Crazy In Love
If It's Lovin' That You Want vs Baby Boy
SOS vs Me Myself & I
Unfaithful vs Naughty Girl
We Ride vs Déjà Vu
Umbrella vs Irreplaceable
Shut Up and Drive vs Beautiful Liar
Don't Stop the Music vs Green Light
Hate That I Love You vs If I were a Boy
Take a Bow vs Single Ladies

Beyonce 7
Rihanna 3

[Niall]

Round 1 - Rihanna vs Beyonce:
-Pon de Replay vs Crazy In Love
-If It's Lovin' That You Want vs Baby Boy
-SOS vs Me Myself & I
-Unfaithful vs Naughty Girl
-We Ride vs Déjà Vu
-Umbrella vs Irreplaceable
-Shut Up and Drive vs Beautiful Liar
-Don't Stop the Music vs Green Light
-Hate That I Love You vs If I were a Boy
-Take a Bow vs Single Ladies

[Gstar]

Pon de Replay vs Crazy In Love
If It's Lovin' That You Want vs Baby Boy
SOS vs Me Myself & I
Unfaithful vs Naughty Girl
We Ride vs Déjà Vu
Umbrella vs Irreplaceable
Shut Up and Drive vs Beautiful Liar
Don't Stop the Music vs Green Light
Hate That I Love You vs If I were a Boy
Take a Bow vs Single Ladies

Beyonce - 8
Rihanna - 2

/not being biased

[armand.kay]

Pon de Replay vs Crazy In Love
If It's Lovin' That You Want vs Baby Boy
SOS vs Me Myself & I
Unfaithful vs Naughty Girl
We Ride vs Déjà Vu
Umbrella vs Irreplaceable
Shut Up and Drive vs Beautiful Liar
Don't Stop the Music vs Green Light
Hate That I Love You vs If I were a Boy
Take a Bow vs Single Ladies

Beyonce = 5
Rihanna = 4
its weird coz I thought I preferred rihanna :laugh:

Can you do nick v mariah(or kim) :))

[Jords]

Pon de Replay vs Crazy In Love
If It's Lovin' That You Want vs Baby Boy
SOS vs Me Myself & I
Unfaithful vs Naughty Girl
We Ride vs Déjà Vu
Umbrella vs Irreplaceable
Shut Up and Drive vs Beautiful Liar
Don't Stop the Music vs Green Light
Hate That I Love You vs If I were a Boy
Take a Bow vs Single Ladies

[Amy Jade]

Pon de Replay vs Crazy In Love
If It's Lovin' That You Want vs Baby Boy
SOSvs Me Myself & I
Unfaithful vs Naughty Girl
We Ride vs Déjà Vu
Umbrella vs Irreplaceable
Shut Up and Drive vs Beautiful Liar
Don't Stop the Music vs Green Light
Hate That I Love You vs If I were a Boy
Take a Bow vs Single Ladies

Beyonce: 6
Rihanna: 4

I'm shocked, I thought I'd pick more Rihanna songs. I like her newer stuff more though.

[LemonJam]

Pon de Replay vs Crazy In Love
If It's Lovin' That You Want vs Baby Boy
SOS vs Me Myself & I
Unfaithful vs Naughty Girl
We Ride vs Déjà Vu
Umbrella vs Irreplaceable
Shut Up and Drive vs Beautiful Liar
Don't Stop the Music vs Green Light
Hate That I Love You vs If I were a Boy
Take a Bow vs Single Ladies

[Jordan.]

Pon de Replay vs Crazy In Love
If It's Lovin' That You Want vs Baby Boy
SOS vs Me Myself & I
Unfaithful vs Naughty Girl
We Ride vs Déjà Vu
Umbrella vs Irreplaceable
Shut Up and Drive vs Beautiful Liar
Don't Stop the Music vs Green Light
Hate That I Love You vs If I were a Boy
Take a Bow vs Single Ladies

Rihanna - 5
Beyonce - 5

[james130]

Round 1 - Rihanna vs Beyonce

Pon de Replay vs Crazy In Love
If It's Lovin' That You Want vs Baby Boy
SOS vs Me Myself & I
Unfaithful vs Naughty Girl
We Ride vs Déjà Vu
Umbrella vs Irreplaceable
Shut Up and Drive vs Beautiful Liar
Don't Stop the Music vs Green Light
Hate That I Love You vs If I were a Boy
Take a Bow vs Single Ladies

Rihanna = 5 points
Beyonce = 5 points

Even though on the whole I definitely prefer Rih Rih.

[james130]

-

[MeMyselfAndI]

Pon de Replay vs Crazy In Love
If It's Lovin' That You Want vs Baby Boy
SOS vs Me Myself & I
Unfaithful vs Naughty Girl
We Ride vs Déjà Vu
Umbrella vs Irreplaceable
Shut Up and Drive vs Beautiful Liar
Don't Stop the Music vs Green Light
Hate That I Love You vs If I were a Boy
Take a Bow vs Single Ladies

Rihanna - 7
Beyonce - 3

[Saph]

Pon de Replay vs Crazy In Love
If It's Lovin' That You Want vs Baby Boy
SOS vs Me Myself & I
Unfaithful vs Naughty Girl
We Ride vs Déjà Vu
Umbrella vs Irreplaceable
Shut Up and Drive vs Beautiful Liar
Don't Stop the Music vs Green Light
Hate That I Love You vs If I were a Boy
Take a Bow vs Single Ladies

Rihanna 5
Beyonce 5

but I like Rihs later work and not so much Beys later work.

[armand.kay]

Pon de Replay vs Crazy In Love
If It's Lovin' That You Want vs Baby Boy
SOS vs Me Myself & I
Unfaithful vs Naughty Girl
We Ride vs Déjà Vu
Umbrella vs Irreplaceable
Shut Up and Drive vs Beautiful Liar
Don't Stop the Music vs Green Light
Hate That I Love You vs If I were a Boy
Take a Bow vs Single Ladies

Rihanna 5
Beyonce 5

but I like Rihs later work and not so much Beys later work.
This Rihanna since loud :love:
Omg @ your sig :laugh:

[Shaun]

Pon de Replay vs Crazy In Love
If It's Lovin' That You Want vs Baby Boy
SOS vs Me Myself & I
Unfaithful vs Naughty Girl
We Ride vs Déjà Vu
Umbrella vs Irreplaceable
Shut Up and Drive vs Beautiful Liar
Don't Stop the Music vs Green Light
Hate That I Love You vs If I were a Boy
Take a Bow vs Single Ladies

[Me. I Am Salman]

bUMP

[Me. I Am Salman]

OK I've decided to end the round

Results:

Pon de Replay vs Crazy In Love
If It's Lovin' That You Want vs Baby Boy
SOS vs Me Myself & I
Unfaithful vs Naughty Girl
We Ride vs Déjà Vu
Umbrella vs Irreplaceable
Shut Up and Drive vs Beautiful Liar
Don't Stop the Music vs Green Light
Hate That I Love You vs If I were a Boy
Take a Bow vs Single Ladies

Rihanna = 5 winning songs
Beyonce = 4 winning songs

Therefore Rihanna is the winner of Round 1.

Most popular song = Don't Stop the Music with received 86% of votes
Least popular song = Both If It's Lovin' That You Want and Green Light, which could only gain 14% of the votes each

--------------------
something seems kinda flawed with the way I'm announcing the winner :suspect:

[Marc]

Pon de Replay vs Crazy In Love
If It's Lovin' That You Want vs Baby Boy
SOS vs Me Myself & I
Unfaithful vs Naughty Girl
We Ride vs Déjà Vu
Umbrella vs Irreplaceable
Shut Up and Drive vs Beautiful Liar
Don't Stop the Music vs Green Light
Hate That I Love You vs If I were a Boy
Take a Bow vs Single Ladies

Rihanna - 4
Beyonce - 6

[Marc]

oooh....

[Shaun]

there's also something quite wrong with your counting :suspect: Crazy in Love got 11 and Pon de Replay got 3...

unless the blue means they lost?

[Me. I Am Salman]

Round 2 - Justin Timberlake vs. Usher


Like I Love You vs Can U Get Wit It
Cry Me a River vs You Make Me Wanna...
Rock Your Body vs Nice & Slow
Señorita vs U Remind Me
I'm Lovin' It vs U Got It Bad
SexyBack vs Yeah
My Love vs Burn
What Goes Around... vs Confessions Pt II
LoveStoned vs My Boo
Until The End of Time vs Caught Up

Justin = 4 points
Usher = 6 points

[Me. I Am Salman]

there's also something quite wrong with your counting :suspect: Crazy in Love got 11 and Pon de Replay got 3...

unless the blue means they lost?

wait something's not right :suspect:

[Gstar]

Green light is one of my fav Beyonce songs, not impressed

[Gstar]

Are you gonna rename the thread lol

[Me. I Am Salman]

Fixed
I'm going to scrap points for that round (I don't think they mean anything anyway)

[Me. I Am Salman]

bump!

[Locke.]

Like I Love You vs Can U Get Wit It
Cry Me a River vs You Make Me Wanna...
Rock Your Body vs Nice & Slow
Señorita vs U Remind Me
I'm Lovin' It vs U Got It Bad
SexyBack vs Yeah
My Love vs Burn
What Goes Around... vs Confessions Pt II
LoveStoned vs My Boo
Until The End of Time vs Caught Up

[Shaun]

Like I Love You vs Can U Get Wit It
Cry Me a River vs You Make Me Wanna...
Rock Your Body vs Nice & Slow
Señorita vs U Remind Me
I'm Lovin' It vs U Got It Bad
SexyBack vs Yeah
My Love vs Burn
What Goes Around... vs Confessions Pt II
LoveStoned vs My Boo
Until The End of Time vs Caught Up

[Gstar]

omg @ Cry me a river vs You make me wanna. Hardest choice ever

[Jordan.]

Like I Love You vs Can U Get Wit It
Cry Me a River vs You Make Me Wanna...
Rock Your Body vs Nice & Slow
Señorita vs U Remind Me
I'm Lovin' It vs U Got It Bad
SexyBack vs Yeah
My Love vs Burn
What Goes Around... vs Confessions Pt II
LoveStoned vs My Boo
Until The End of Time vs Caught Up

JT - 6
Usher - 4

[The Human Santapede]

Like I Love You vs Can U Get Wit It
Cry Me a River vs You Make Me Wanna...
Rock Your Body vs Nice & Slow
Señorita vs U Remind Me
I'm Lovin' It vs U Got It Bad
SexyBack vs Yeah
My Love vs Burn
What Goes Around... vs Confessions Pt II
LoveStoned vs My Boo
Until The End of Time vs Caught Up

[LemonJam]

Like I Love You vs Can U Get Wit It
Cry Me a River vs You Make Me Wanna...
Rock Your Body vs Nice & Slow
Señorita vs U Remind Me
I'm Lovin' It vs U Got It Bad
SexyBack vs Yeah
My Love vs Burn
What Goes Around... vs Confessions Pt II
LoveStoned vs My Boo
Until The End of Time vs Caught Up

[Me. I Am Salman]

.

[Me. I Am Salman]

this thread is fast becoming a flop

[Jordan.]

Next round

[Me. I Am Salman]

I'm gonna give it 20 mins

[Me. I Am Salman]

Oh

[Me. I Am Salman]

Results

Like I Love You vs Can U Get Wit It
Cry Me a River vs You Make Me Wanna...
Rock Your Body vs Nice & Slow
Señorita vs U Remind Me
I'm Lovin' It vs U Got It Bad
SexyBack vs Yeah
My Love vs Burn
What Goes Around... vs Confessions Pt II
LoveStoned vs My Boo
Until The End of Time vs Caught Up

Justin Timberlake = 5 winning songs and 31 points
Usher = 4 winning songs and 29 points

Therefore Justin Timberlake is the winner of Round 2

Like I Love You and U Got It Bad were the most popular songs in that round with 100% of the vote

Can U Get Wit It and I'm Lovin' It were the least popular with 0% of the vote

Total votes this round: 6

[Me. I Am Salman]

I think what this game needs is variety

[Me. I Am Salman]

Round 3 - 50 Cent vs Britney Spears

In Da Club vs Baby One More Time
21 Questions vs Sometimes
P.I.M.P. vs Crazy
If I Can't vs Born to Make You Happy
Candy Shop vs Oops! I Did It Again
Just a Lil Bit vs Stronger
Hustler's Ambition vs Don't Be The Last To Let Me Know
Window Shopper vs I'm a Slave 4 U
Ayo Technology vs Overprotected
Get Up vs I'm Not a Girl, Not Yet a Woman

50 Cent = 9 points
Britney = 1 point

[Saph]

In Da Club vs Baby One More Time
21 Questions vs Sometimes
P.I.M.P. vs Crazy
If I Can't vs Born to Make You Happy
Candy Shop vs Oops! I Did It Again
Just a Lil Bit vs Stronger
Hustler's Ambition vs Don't Be The Last To Let Me Know
Window Shopper vs I'm a Slave 4 U
Ayo Technology vs Overprotected
Get Up vs I'm Not a Girl, Not Yet a Woman

britney 10
50 cent 0

[Brother Leon]

No "Till The World Ends"? :(

[Shaun]

In Da Club vs Baby One More Time
21 Questions vs Sometimes
P.I.M.P. vs Crazy
If I Can't vs Born to Make You Happy
Candy Shop vs Oops! I Did It Again
Just a Lil Bit vs Stronger
Hustler's Ambition vs Don't Be The Last To Let Me Know
Window Shopper vs I'm a Slave 4 U
Ayo Technology vs Overprotected
Get Up vs I'm Not a Girl, Not Yet a Woman

[Locke.]

In Da Club vs Baby One More Time
21 Questions vs Sometimes
P.I.M.P. vs Crazy
If I Can't vs Born to Make You Happy
Candy Shop vs Oops! I Did It Again
Just a Lil Bit vs Stronger
Hustler's Ambition vs Don't Be The Last To Let Me Know
Window Shopper vs I'm a Slave 4 U
Ayo Technology vs Overprotected
Get Up vs I'm Not a Girl, Not Yet a Woman

[MeMyselfAndI]

In Da Club vs Baby One More Time
21 Questions vs Sometimes
P.I.M.P. vs Crazy
If I Can't vs Born to Make You Happy
Candy Shop vs Oops! I Did It Again
Just a Lil Bit vs Stronger
Hustler's Ambition vs Don't Be The Last To Let Me Know
Window Shopper vs I'm a Slave 4 U
Ayo Technology vs Overprotected
Get Up vs I'm Not a Girl, Not Yet a Woman

[Brother Leon]

In Da Club vs Baby One More Time
21 Questions vs Sometimes
P.I.M.P. vs Crazy
If I Can't vs Born to Make You Happy
Candy Shop vs Oops! I Did It Again
Just a Lil Bit vs Stronger
Hustler's Ambition vs Don't Be The Last To Let Me Know
Window Shopper vs I'm a Slave 4 U
Ayo Technology vs Overprotected
Get Up vs I'm Not a Girl, Not Yet a Woman
--

50 - 10 points.

BRB, Listening to Get Rich Or Die Tryin' again.

[armand.kay]

Why did you choose them two :/

[Withano]

Never realised 50 Cent counted as a popular artist

In Da Club vs Baby One More Time
21 Questions vs Sometimes
P.I.M.P. vs Crazy
If I Can't vs Born to Make You Happy
Candy Shop vs Oops! I Did It Again
Just a Lil Bit vs Stronger
Hustler's Ambition vs Don't Be The Last To Let Me Know
Window Shopper vs I'm a Slave 4 U
Ayo Technology vs Overprotected
Get Up vs I'm Not a Girl, Not Yet a Woman

[Iceman]

In Da Club vs Baby One More Time
21 Questions vs Sometimes
P.I.M.P. vs Crazy
If I Can't vs Born to Make You Happy
Candy Shop vs Oops! I Did It Again
Just a Lil Bit vs Stronger
Hustler's Ambition vs Don't Be The Last To Let Me Know
Window Shopper vs I'm a Slave 4 U
Ayo Technology vs Overprotected
Get Up vs I'm Not a Girl, Not Yet a Woman

[Iceman]

Never realised 50 Cent counted as a popular artist


Yeah you dont have to go shave your head or show your vajayjay to be popular.

[Me. I Am Salman]

Never realised 50 Cent counted as a popular artist

In Da Club vs Baby One More Time
21 Questions vs Sometimes
P.I.M.P. vs Crazy
If I Can't vs Born to Make You Happy
Candy Shop vs Oops! I Did It Again
Just a Lil Bit vs Stronger
Hustler's Ambition vs Don't Be The Last To Let Me Know
Window Shopper vs I'm a Slave 4 U
Ayo Technology vs Overprotected
Get Up vs I'm Not a Girl, Not Yet a Woman

well you need to realise things more

[Me. I Am Salman]

Why did you choose them two :/

trying to attract people :)

[Firewire]

In Da Club vs Baby One More Time
21 Questions vs Sometimes
P.I.M.P. vs Crazy
If I Can't vs Born to Make You Happy
Candy Shop vs Oops! I Did It Again
Just a Lil Bit vs Stronger
Hustler's Ambition vs Don't Be The Last To Let Me Know
Window Shopper vs I'm a Slave 4 U
Ayo Technology vs Overprotected
Get Up vs I'm Not a Girl, Not Yet a Woman

[Me. I Am Salman]

bump!

[Me. I Am Salman]

bump

[Amy Jade]

All Britney, fiddy cent is ****rocious.

[Me. I Am Salman]

Round closes at 9pm!

[Me. I Am Salman]

5 mins to go!

[Amy Jade]

Do you want me to list them for my vote to count?

[Saph]

Britney Cent

[Me. I Am Salman]

Do you want me to list them for my vote to count?

it's ok :)

[Me. I Am Salman]

oh I forgot about this, someone calculate the results and do the next one please