Least Deserving Winners in BBUK

[KingBergkamp]

Its a very tricky subject
Many will say the public voted for them to win so they deserved it.
But in terms of Entertainment, Storylines, involvement in making their BB who do you feel were least deserving winners?
Its a matter of opinion of course

My Top 3

1. Sophie
Apart from her little thing with Kris which lasted a few days, what the hell did this Nice but dull woman do apart from get drunk, fart and gain weight. She wasn't involved in any big storylines and clearly won out simply cause their wasn't anyone decent left or her main rivals blew their chances (Freddie and Siavash). There have been Dull winners (Anthony BB6 and Rachel bb9) but they had at least a running storyline in their series (Craig stalking and Rex vs Rachel).

2. Josie
The worse case of tampering seen in BBUK ever for a Housemate. Producers made sure to show nothing of her bitching, sitting in bed all day but just her so called romance with JJ :sleep:. People fell for it sadly and she went on to win the last BBUK on Channel 4. The way producers would edit her rivals if any of them got in the way of her romance or upset them was shocking and the last eviction was a basic set up for her to get rid of her rivals before the final. Even on UBB, Davina even slaughtered her past favourite Nadia for knocking Josie. Left a sour taste in the mouth.

3. Cameron
BB4 I think is an underrated BB and is actually quite good but the major blot for me was Cameron winning. He was so undeserving of it as he was one of the main reasons the fun was zapped out of the house at times. How the public picke him over Jon and Fed is still one of the most upsettin evictions I saw. He did nothing but sit there and bemoan anyone having fun.

[Me. I Am Salman]

Pete and Aaron.

[swinearefine]

Most of the winners are on the terrible side, but the one that really grinds my gears is Brian Belo. He played up to this obviously fabricated dimwit persona the entire time, yet no one seemed to care because he was a boring douchey male and that's what the general public seem to value in a HM. He claimed he didn't know who Shakespeare was, and they even had his English teacher go on BBLB and say that much of the class was Shakespeare, and still he won?

[Brekkie]

Rachel Rice. You can close the thread now.

[Shaun]

Brian Belo and Sophie

[Jordan.]

Rachel Rice. You can close the thread now.

http://a.mod-site.net/s/appl.gif

[Macie Lightfoot]

Were any winners actually that deserving though? I guess if I had to pick the worst though it'd be Cameron and Aaron

[Black Dagger]

Rachel is vastly superior to Brian Belo/Josie/Cameron!

[GiRTh]

Belo. Compared to him the others are all great winners.

[KingBergkamp]

Rachel is vastly superior to Brian Belo/Josie/Cameron!

I agree Rachel winning was two fingers up to the way BB producers and Davina portrayed her and treated her. Very much a good person winning over the bad guys.

Belo's winning didn't bother me as he beat out those awful twins.

Cameron was just boring and zapped any fun out of BB4 , that's his crime for me. He won simply of his trip to Africa BB and the loyal Scottish vote at the time.

Josie win ruined BB11 cause producers just tampered with everything for her to win.

[KingBergkamp]

Were any winners actually that deserving though? I guess if I had to pick the worst though it'd be Cameron and Aaron

I don't agree

Brian BB2 deserved his win

Craig BB1 win was worth it cause he gave his money to a great cause. Plus he did stop Nasty Nick in his tracks :joker:. He was a great Housemate imo.

Nadia BB5 the journey she had and she had great moments. Although she could be quite nasty at times.

Pete BB7 many of his detractors say he was the chosen one. But I still think he deserved it just about.

Rachel BB9 as I stated above

Aaron BB12 he played the game and won it fair and square.

[Macie Lightfoot]

Craig was smug and self-righteous, Pete played up his Tourettes, and Aaron was appalling.

[Alf]

Nadia - only won because she was a transexual, what did she do apart from smoke or moan about not having any cigs? We saw her true colours in ultimate bb.

Pete - won the minute he went in, just because he had tourettes

[Alf]

Nadia BB5 the journey she had and she had great moments. Although she could be quite nasty at times..
What journey? she only came from Portugal, it's not the end of the World.

oh your talking about her being a transexual? why should that give her an advantage over the rest?

[Marsh.]

Apart from her little thing with Kris which lasted a few days, what the hell did this Nice but dull woman do apart from get drunk, fart and gain weight.

:laugh2:

[Marc]

Rachel Rice. You can close the thread now.

:worship:

[bbfan1991]

Rachel Rice and Sophie Reade, they were sooooooo dull especially no personality Rachel.

[Vanessa]

Rachel was boring as hell. Sophie only won because of Rodrigo, who was robbed. :nono:

[Headie]

Can't believed no one has mentioned Anthony Hutton yet.

BB6 had an amazing cast, and out of all the characters in that show he was the least deserving to win. I always assumed he got off lightly with the whole jacuzzi situation because he was a young attractive lad and yet poor Makosi got all the hate for it, when it takes two to tango. I remember Anthony came on UBB as part of a task and said "oh I remember now, I fingered ya, you must of thought it was my penis!". The fact that he blatantly denied doing anything on the show annoys me, especially as he couldn't even remember the night whilst he was in the house. Owning up to it after the show only makes it even worse.

[bbfan1991]

Can't believed no one has mentioned Anthony Hutton yet.

BB6 had an amazing cast, and out of all the characters in that show he was the least deserving to win. I always assumed he got off lightly with the whole jacuzzi situation because he was a young attractive lad and yet poor Makosi got all the hate for it, when it takes two to tango. I remember Anthony came on UBB as part of a task and said "oh I remember now, I fingered ya, you must of thought it was my penis!". The fact that he blatantly denied doing anything on the show annoys me, especially as he couldn't even remember the night whilst he was in the house. Owning up to it after the show only makes it even worse.

Oh yes. He is so forgettable! Makosi caused her own downfall and did not win, but to me she will always be the true winner of that series because of the entertainment and controversy she provided and the divided opinions she caused people to have about her:).

Science was an awesome housemate too, my favourite from that series.

[Raph]

It makes me so sad to see so many people saying Rachel :( She's such a nice girl and is the best female housemate ever, let alone best winner ever. #TeamRachel!

[Raph]

Brian D winning Ultimate Big Brother, it should've been Nikki :bored: He basically did nothing the whole season except for have the occasional bitch/sassy comment. I was so dissapointed when he won.

Oh and Rylan in CBB, so underserving -.-

Sophie was a little undeserving, but only because the title should've gone to Hira.

[Vanessa]

Brian D winning Ultimate Big Brother, it should've been Nikki :bored: He basically did nothing the whole season except for have the occasional bitch/sassy comment. I was so dissapointed when he won.

Oh and Rylan in CBB, so underserving -.-

Sophie was a little undeserving, but only because the title should've gone to Hira.

Hira? I think i prefer watching paint dry. Sorry, Ralph. :o:o:o:o

[bbfan1991]

It makes me so sad to see so many people saying Rachel :( She's such a nice girl and is the best female housemate ever, let alone best winner ever. #TeamRachel!

I actually disliked Rachel as a housemate and even though she was a nice person something about her irritated me.

I can't remember anything memorable about her? Best female housemates for me even though they did not win their series were Makosi and Nikki for sheer impact;).

[Ramsay]

Raph, stop smoking crack

[Jordan.]

lmfao at Hira should have won

[Black Dagger]

lol Hira.

[Macie Lightfoot]

Brian D winning Ultimate Big Brother, it should've been Nikki :bored: He basically did nothing the whole season except for have the occasional bitch/sassy comment. I was so dissapointed when he won.

Oh and Rylan in CBB, so underserving -.-

Sophie was a little undeserving, but only because the title should've gone to Hira.

From a narrative standpoint Rylan was the only acceptable winner and that's indisputable.

A Hira win would've been lovely though <3

[Vanessa]

Hira winning? http://boards.soapcentral.com/images/smilies/yahoo/sick.gif

[Jack_]

From a narrative standpoint Rylan deserved to win? LOL Speidi created the bloody narrative

[Macie Lightfoot]

That's not even true but I spent all of January going there and I really don't feel like doing it again, but what I am going to say is that whether you enjoy Speidi or not, they aren't supposed to be a mirror to the hypocrisy and flaws of the others, leaving us questioning who the true villain is. They are unambiguously the supervillains and Rylan is unambiguously our protagonist. Good triumphs over evil. Et cetera, et cetera.

[Omah]

Series 1-11

1 Stout (4), 2 Bennett (7), 3 Gibson (11), 4 Rice (9), 5 Belo (8)

[Ramsay]

Dont think Speidi even cared about winning..they just wanted to put on a show really and they did :love:

[Iceman]

Rachel by a million ****ing country miles.

[Jack_]

That's not even true but I spent all of January going there and I really don't feel like doing it again, but what I am going to say is that whether you enjoy Speidi or not, they aren't supposed to be a mirror to the hypocrisy and flaws of the others, leaving us questioning who the true villain is. They are unambiguously the supervillains and Rylan is unambiguously our protagonist. Good triumphs over evil. Et cetera, et cetera.

Neither do I, because I'm sure a lot of us are going to be going over the same thing again this summer when you end up deliberately supporting the housemate that contributes the least to the show.

I never bought that argument myself either, so I'm not sure why you're bringing it up with me. They were the villains but they played the villains, there's a difference. Basically, I can't be bothered doing this now cause in a couple of weeks I'll have to do it properly, but without housemates that cause drama and get the fans talking, we wouldn't have a show...so I'm not quite sure why you always want those kind of housemates to leave. Yeah, you can like 'nice' people, I know your side of the argument...but if you were a true fan of the show you would surely see the need to keep housemates in that are giving viewers stuff to discuss? Big Brother thrives on discussion and fails if there isn't any, it's simple really.

[Macie Lightfoot]

I don't deliberate support people who do nothing, I support the people who I like, but apparently you can't see the difference in that and instead keep trying to lecture me about how I'm watching the show wrong (as if there's such a thing.)

But as I've said before, Speidi... well, they didn't actually do anything. They isolated themselves and moaned about how much they hate everyone. Nothing was actually done and it was tiring. I guess somewhere in there me not rooting for them makes me not a true fan of the show (again, lol) but they were boring, end of.

[Gstar]

Hira :worship:

Brian was one of the worst for me, he played up to his persona so much and the favouritism in the last few weeks of BB8 was disgusting.

His little crew with Liam and Ziggy trying to run the house omg *puts gun down* *breathe*

[Roy Mars III]

Nadia

[rk3388]

Uhm, All Of them in my opinion but ill explain why for only a few:

1. Aaron- Hate people who act to win. I remember him asking alex what ndubbz was and then later on compared aden to dappy :idc: also felt a lot of his dancing was set up to make "good tele" moments

2. Pete- I agree with when he said he wouldnt believe in heaven if he didnt win, a very calculated comment to manpilate people into voting for him

3. Rachel- zzzzz

4. Sophie- zzzzzzz

5. Brian- Fake Stupid act and got tired of hearing "CIDER!!" every 2 secs

6. Anthony- So many strong housemates that series who shoulda won over him! ( Makosi, Science, Derek, etc)

7. Josie- Liked her at first, but hate fake relationships and got tired of her whispering under the bed

The other winners are irrelevant or just not worth mentioning

[KingBergkamp]

Uhm, All Of them in my opinion but ill explain why for only a few:

1. Aaron- Hate people who act to win. I remember him asking alex what ndubbz was and then later on compared aden to dappy :idc: also felt a lot of his dancing was set up to make "good tele" moments

2. Pete- I agree with when he said he wouldnt believe in heaven if he didnt win, a very calculated comment to manpilate people into voting for him

3. Rachel- zzzzz

4. Sophie- zzzzzzz

5. Brian- Fake Stupid act and got tired of hearing "CIDER!!" every 2 secs

6. Anthony- So many strong housemates that series who shoulda won over him! ( Makosi, Science, Derek, etc)

7. Josie- Liked her at first, but hate fake relationships and got tired of her whispering under the bed

The other winners are irrelevant or just not worth mentioning

Brian BB2 deserved his win. Kate BB3 deserved her's.

I agree with Sophie, awful winner to the last decent BB. What did she do to win?

Josie winning for me was wrong cause the way the BB producers set it all up for her. The most blatant fix up win for a BB HM ever.

Pete BB7 I taught he deserved it, I think the hate towards Pete these days is cause he was favourite to win from day 1 onwards.

[reece(:]

Stout, Brian Belo, Anthony all awful winners.

[Marcus.]

Sophie

[LemonJam]

It's really hard to defend Sophie as a good winner because it was the little moments that made her so hilarious. I disliked Rachel as a winner at the time but the more I reflect she's actually a really good winner. (Would've preferred Sara in that final to win though of course)

It's probably Brian Dowling for me.

[Me. I Am Salman]

Aaron

[Me. I Am Salman]

Oh I already posted a few days ago http://atrl.net/forums/images/smilies/images/smilies/ahh.gif

[Samm]

Anthony BB6

Rachel BB9

[JeanP!]

1 Brian Belo
2 Luke A
3 Josie

Hated those victories

[Patrick]

Josie and Rachel.

The rest I can bare, the only deserving winners in all honesty were Kate and Aaron.

[Patrick]

Oh I already posted a few days ago http://atrl.net/forums/images/smilies/images/smilies/ahh.gif

:joker::joker:

[Macie Lightfoot]

Josie and Rachel.

The rest I can bare, the only deserving winners in all honesty were Kate and Aaron.

I know there are two threads going on about this and I think I said it in the other thread, but if we're going off the basis that a deserving winner is someone who the majority of the public votes for, Aaron is easily the least deserving (and only undeserving?) winner on the basis that when everyone else won, people actually watched the show and voted and you couldn't win via online forum fringe group that takes extreme advantage (borderline cheating with multiple accounts even?) of the ridiculously cheapened online voting process. Thankfully they scrapped that in BB13, it truly was for the better although it could've propelled Deana to a win which may have actually made up for the travesty of Aaron winning.

And on a completely unrelated but probably equally controversial note, it irritates me to no end that Kate did **** all for nine weeks and was rewarded for it simply for having a vagina (a female winner? are we ready for that as a nation?????), yet Tim did just as much and was hated for being a miserable bore (even though he was hilariously righteous).

[Munchkins]

Luke A :( dull dull dull
Brian BB8 just terrible