Kelly vs Nicole

[reece(:]

Both have been labelled "annoying" and "gimmicky".. who do you prefer?

[Jake.]

Kelly

[Black Dagger]

Nicole.

I think Kelly will excel on the US version for sure though, she'll do a Nicole, be a bit meh here but be better in the US whereas Nicole was awful in the US.

[Amy Jade]

Nicole.

I wish Dannii was in the poll though, she's been by far the best female judge on any X Factor platform I have seen.

[Princess]

I liked Kelly but I really like Nicole, love her and Gary together.

[Jordan.]

Nicole, although she's been quite disappointing so far this series

http://i.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2011/08/21/article-0-0D823D8700000578-703_634x405.jpg

[GypsyGoth]

Nicole has made me laugh a couple of times so far, I loved when she was bossing that new guy Matt around on xtra fact. And I agree about her chemistry with Gary, it's been nice to watch.

[Mystic Mock]

Nicole, I actually hated Kelly more than Gary at the time so that says a lot.

[Jack.]

Nicole

[Kate!]

Nicole

[james130]

I loved Kelly. :(

[Toy Soldier]

I find Nicole slightly annoying but ... Kelly was awful. She made it almost unwatchable for me. She was almost on the same level as Jessie J in "The Voice". Almost. Jessie J made me actually stop watching The Voice.