Mark the performances out of ten [Week 3 - Movie songs]

[James]

Mark each of the X Factor movie week performances out of ten.

Either during the show or after. Whichever suits you best.

Abi –

Hannah –

Kingsland Road –

Luke –

Miss Dynamix –

Nicholas –

Rough Copy –

Sam Bailey –

Sam Callahan –

Tamera –

Song choices.


Abi Alton – Moon River

Hannah Barrett – Skyfall

Kingsland Road – Oh, Pretty Woman

Luke Friend – Kiss From A Rose

Miss Dynamix – Dreams

Nicholas McDonald – In The Arms Of An Angel

Rough Copy – Everything I Do

Sam Bailey – My Heart Will Go On

Sam Callahan – All I Want Is You

Tamera Foster – Listen

[Benjamin]

Oh, hello. James made a thread. :hugesmile:

Abi – 6/10

Hannah – 9/10

Kingsland Road – 3/10

Luke – 7/10

Miss Dynamix – 6.5/10

Nicholas – 6/10

Rough Copy – 5/10

Sam Bailey – 10/10

Sam Callahan – 2/10

Tamera – 6/10

[Shaun]

will edit

Abi – 3/10

Hannah – 8/10

Kingsland Road – 4/10

Luke – 6/10

Miss Dynamix – 5/10

Nicholas – 6/10

Rough Copy – 7/10

Sam Bailey – 8/10

Sam Callahan – 3/10

Tamera – 7/10

[Vanessa]

Abi – 6/10

Hannah – 7/10

Kingsland Road – 6/10

Luke – 10/10 :dance:

Miss Dynamix – 5/10

Nicholas – 6/10

Rough Copy – 6/10

Sam Bailey – 9/10

Sam Callahan – 6/10

Tamera – 10/10

[Bigest Brother Fan ever]

Abi –

Hannah – 9/10

Kingsland Road –

Luke –

Miss Dynamix –

Nicholas –

Rough Copy – 8/10

Sam Bailey –

Sam Callahan – 3/10

Tamera –

WILL EDIT

[Samm]

Abi – 4/10

Hannah – 9/10

Kingsland Road – 2/10

Luke – 4/10

Miss Dynamix – 8/10

Nicholas – 5/10

Rough Copy – 5/10

Sam Bailey – 8/10

Sam Callahan – 8/10

Tamera – 9/10

[mizzy25]

Abi 3/10
Hannah 10/10
Tamera 8/10 i didnt know the song.

Luke 9/10
Nichlolas 8/10
Sam callaghan 6/10

Sam bailey 9/10 same old same old

Miss dynamix 2/10
Kingsland rd 7/10
Rough copy 7/10

[Jordan.]

Abi – 6.5/10

Hannah – 8/10

Kingsland Road – 6.5/10

Luke – 8/10

Miss Dynamix – 6/10

Nicholas – 5/10

Rough Copy – 5/10

Sam Bailey – 8.5/10

Sam Callahan – 6/10

Tamera – 9/10

[Benji_]

Abi – 7/10

Hannah – 8/10

Kingsland Road – 3/10

Luke – 8/10

Miss Dynamix – 6/10

Nicholas – 6/10

Rough Copy – 7/10

Sam Bailey – 9/10

Sam Callahan – 2/10

Tamera – 9/10

[joeysteele]

Abi – 3/10. Awful for me, with the way she did it, all she could fail in was vocals and she did that bigtime. Sounded like a child was singing it and a child may have sang it better too.

Hannah – 7/10 Far better than I thought she would be.

Kingsland Road – 6/10 Didn't mind this at all. They gave it new life.

Luke – 9/10 Loved this,he did this really good.

Miss Dynamix – 3/10. Dull and monotonous.

Nicholas – 6/10 I don't know, I just found this average.

Rough Copy – 4/10 Didn't go for this either it just didn't work for me.

Sam Bailey – 8/10 cannot fault her voice but it was also predictable.

Sam Callahan – 7/10 Maybe I am in a minority on this guy but I actually like his voice and really liked this performance too, I felt the criticism of him was rather unfair.

Tamera – 9/10 Certainly the joint performance of the night with Luke's for me but I agree with Gary she needs some of her own originality to come through.

[newsbb]

Abi – 4/10 apart from boring.. predictable, bland.

Hannah – 8/10 great performance.. but the arrangement ruined it, it felt rushed, and that song its sooo perfectly slow (if that makes sense)

Kingsland Road – 7/10 cheesy.

Luke – 8/10 he keeps on growing every week, i liked this performance... he still get lost sometimes.

Miss Dynamix – 6/10 flat.

Nicholas – 7/10 good vocal.. he need to gear up the song choices thou.

Rough Copy – 7/10 meh.

Sam Bailey – 9/10 stellar vocal.

Sam Callahan – 6/10 fail.

Tamera – 7/10 try-hard

[Kizzy]

kingsland road- 6/10 best band imo
abi- 2/10 really weak, can't believe she made live shows.
sam B - 9/10 great voice one of my top 3
Luke- 9/10 unique and likable, in my top 3
Rough copy- 1/10 a rough copy of boyz2men, but rubbish.
Nicholas- 7/10 shmultzy, the west end beckons.
Tamera- 8/10 British beyonce, fantastic voice in my top 3.
Hannah- 6/10 not my cup of tea but good.
miss dynamix- 1/10 pants....sorry.
Sam C- 3/10 who?...trying hard but no.

[Mystic Mock]

Rough Copy - Everything I Do - 3/10
Sam Callahan - All I Want Is You - 5/10
Hannah Barrett - Skyfall - 9/10
Nicholas McDonald - 6/10
Abi Alton - Moon River - 0/10
Miss Dynamix - Dreams - 2/10
Sam Bailey - My Heart Will Go On - 6/10
Kingsland Road - Oh, Pretty Woman - 4/10
Luke Friend - Kiss From A Rose - 9/10
Tamera Foster - Listen - 5/10

[Rawrbear]

Abi – 6/10 Always sounds nervous when she is singing.

Hannah – 9/10 Best of the night for me.

Kingsland Road – 4/10 The main singer guy is alright at best. And 3/4 of the other singers just annoy me.

Luke – 8/10 I've always like Luke. I think that performance was defiantly his best so far.

Miss Dynamix – 7/10 For some reason I could picture them singing this on Disney channel. Strange. Vocally one of them reminds me of Raven.

Nicholas – 6/10 he has a good voice. But I cant even remember the performance.

Rough Copy – 5/10 I find Rough Copy overrated. I do like them, but last night I found them to be very bland.

Sam Bailey – 7/10 Voice is great. But it was so obvious that she was going to sing that song. She needs to start changing it up a little.

Sam Callahan – 2/10 Dreadful. Needs to go home.

Tamera – 7/10 Tamera is one of my favourites. But she was trying to copy Beyoncé I feel. and I love Beyoncé and if you copy the Queen your going to be compared and Beyoncé is always going to slay.

[Marc]

Abi – 3/10 just.. meh I like the song but she killed it
Hannah – 4/10 I don't understand the praise for this performance, really not great
Kingsland Road – 7/10 I actually liked this; can't go wrong with the song
Luke – 8/10 actually really good
Miss Dynamix – 4/10 two weeks to practice that...
Nicholas – 8/10 good song good vocals
Rough Copy – 6/10 decent performance
Sam Bailey – 8/10 brill
Sam Callahan – 4/10 he's trying but he's just not good enough
Tamera – 5/10 nope.

[GypsyGoth]

Abi – 4

Hannah – 8

Kingsland Road – 5

Luke – 7

Miss Dynamix – 4

Nicholas – 5

Rough Copy – 6

Sam Bailey – 8

Sam Callahan – 4

Tamera – 7