Music Debates: Re-Up ~ The 2nd Wave (Tulisa VS Alesha)

[Z]

I wish we would have actual debates instead of .GIF wars - I'm not having a go, but I was hoping this thread would be discussing artistic merits and pros and cons of different artists rather than posting YouTube videos and internet pop music forum slang with matching .GIFs...

[Jake.]

Agreeing with Greg, you should all be disgusted with yourselves

[Saph]

I'll try and be more debate(y) in the next round :p

[Gstar]

We are debating though, the gifs are just something extra

[Saph]

why is cheryl cole a tag btw

[reece(:]

Agreeing with Greg, you should all be disgusted with yourselves
You have some nerve asserting your authority after dragging Marina to dust, the alcohol is doing bad things to you http://i1190.photobucket.com/albums/z448/reeecerawwr/ed2305b7.png

[Z]

We are debating though, the gifs are just something extra

I know, I just wish there was more actual debating if you get what I mean, like people arguing one side and other people arguing the other. So far there's just been a lot of "who's better?" questions in the title; but what if the questions was like "which album by (one artist) is better: (one album by them) or (another album by them)" and we discuss that, or something like that, I dunno.

[King Gizzard]

Nicki because of this masterpiece

Ys7-6_t7OEQ

great song

[Jake.]

You have some nerve asserting your authority after dragging Marina to dust, the alcohol is doing bad things to you http://i1190.photobucket.com/albums/z448/reeecerawwr/ed2305b7.png

Marina is tripe, we've already discussed this and the case was closed

[Gstar]

@Zee That's just our humour, if you look past that we're actually doing what the thread says.

[Jake.]

Nicki because of this masterpiece

Ys7-6_t7OEQ

great song

One song featuring Bieber I actually like lol

[Z]

Or like "is Nicole Scherzinger better as part of the Pussycat Dolls or as a solo artist?" idk something where we're not comparing two different people because that just ends up being a "who do you like better" competition

[King Gizzard]

Bieber knocks out some bangers to be fair to him

[Jake.]

He's pretty dire

[Z]

Or like "is Nicole Scherzinger better as part of the Pussycat Dolls or as a solo artist?" idk something where we're not comparing two different people because that just ends up being a "who do you like better" competition

Obviously the example I gave here is still a who do you like better competition :joker: but hopefully you get what I mean...

[King Gizzard]

Baby should go down as one of the songs of the century

[King Gizzard]

Probably not even trolling. Maybe half trolling. Great song tho

[reece(:]

Baby should go down as one of the songs of the century
I'm afraid you need to stop with these asinine remarks

[Z]

Bieber knocks out some bangers to be fair to him

He is so beige IMO, his music is really dull, it's like background lounge music like Norah Jones or something, I don't think he's had one song that really stands out as a huge hit but I don't know if that's because he's not releasing music aimed at people like me or if it's because he just isn't all that people make him out to be.

[Drew.]

Bieber >>>> Gaga, Rihanna + Taylor..

doesn't even need confirming, but Nath pls confirm

[Jake.]

Baby should go down as one of the songs of the century

Time for you to pop off to bed

[King Gizzard]

Happily confirmed

[Drew.]

Argument settled

[Jake.]

Perhaps Bieber would come off better if he didn't have such an unlike-able personality

[Jake.]

But no as Greg said none of his music stands out to me, just generic, teenage pop which isn't going to stand the test of time by any means and is just here to fill a slot in the market

[Jake.]

And to be fair to him he's done a good job of it, he just ****s himself over by being the biggest knob possible

[Saph]

Boyfriend was a good song but everything else, no

[Brother Leon]

Nicki because of this masterpiece

Ys7-6_t7OEQ

great song

Confirmed. Amazing track.


Bieber >>>> Gaga, Rihanna + Taylor..

doesn't even need confirming, but Nath pls confirm

& Confirmed.

Arguably the best Pop artist the last couple years. Too many bangers.

[reece(:]

The only relevant "bangers" are the ones Miley has produced.

[Saph]

where have all these beiber stans come from

[reece(:]

where have all these beiber stans come from
The darkest depths of the planet (where all the pre teen girls are found)

[Drew.]

Biggest variety of music out of any current artist, his teenage pop days are all in the past

V1DzCIofoS8

gotEw1JrByY

BiOmXeKyrxo

b_4rdHIMDfk

[armand.kay]

What's going on?
http://oi56.tinypic.com/2dhd0e8.jpg

[reece(:]

What's going on?
http://oi56.tinypic.com/2dhd0e8.jpg
The thread has been hijacked by Bieber stans

[Z]

But no as Greg said none of his music stands out to me, just generic, teenage pop which isn't going to stand the test of time by any means and is just here to fill a slot in the market

I don't see him having any longevity, I think when his fans grow up he'll no longer have a music career. He's not mentally capable of making the transition - he's been cracking under the pressure for the last couple of years as shown by his increasingly erratic behaviour and I think he'll end up like Corey Haim...

[Drew.]

this thread has given me a great idea

[Saph]

uh oh

[Drew.]

Saph knows whats coming

[reece(:]

This is not good.

[Jake.]

I don't see him having any longevity, I think when his fans grow up he'll no longer have a music career. He's not mentally capable of making the transition - he's been cracking under the pressure for the last couple of years as shown by his increasingly erratic behaviour and I think he'll end up like Corey Haim...

Yeah, 100%, when his fans move on then he'll have nobody to appeal to and by that stage God only knows what state he will be in

[Gstar]

Bieber hits +1 -1

[armand.kay]

Yeah, 100%, when his fans move on then he'll have nobody to appeal to and by that stage God only knows what state he will be in
They've already started moving on, 1D are basically taking his spot.

[armand.kay]

Bieber hits +1 -1

http://i1190.photobucket.com/albums/z448/reeecerawwr/ed2305b7.png

[Ithinkiloveyoutoo]

h7M0LP3Nb2Q

lil kim always! quality is weird and slow though

[Gstar]

^^ :worship:

[reece(:]

http://theconnorchronicles.files.wordpress.com/2011/06/bieber.jpg

[Z]

Baby is a nice enough song but other than that his music is such a non-event to me. Can honestly say I only know a handful of his songs by title and the only songs other than Baby I can remember how they go are Beauty And A Beat and Boyfriend.

[Joelle.]

Bieber stans please leave, that basic bitches name being mentioned has threatened to tarnish the thread of the decade.

http://cdn.thisisbigbrother.com/customavatars/avatar64372_88.gif

[Jake.]

Baby is a nice enough song but other than that his music is such a non-event to me. Can honestly say I only know a handful of his songs by title and the only songs other than Baby I can remember how they go are Beauty And A Beat and Boyfriend.

This.

[reece(:]

I think Nicki wins ...

[Gstar]

no

[reece(:]

no
Outnumbered
https://fbcdn-sphotos-a-a.akamaihd.net/hphotos-ak-prn2/1461766_677253592299040_163449456_n.jpg

[Gstar]

ithinkiloveyoutoo voted lil kim and Salman PM'd me to vote lil kim, the game is still on http://31.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_m3rr63iOem1rve3vjo8_250.png

[reece(:]

Enough faking Salman PMs, ima need those receipts
https://fbcdn-sphotos-a-a.akamaihd.net/hphotos-ak-prn2/1461766_677253592299040_163449456_n.jpg

[Gstar]

All will become clear when he returns

https://fbcdn-sphotos-a-a.akamaihd.net/hphotos-ak-prn2/1461766_677253592299040_163449456_n.jpg

[reece(:]

Sis this debate can not go on another 4-5 days
https://fbcdn-sphotos-a-a.akamaihd.net/hphotos-ak-prn2/1461766_677253592299040_163449456_n.jpg

[Gstar]

I know sis, and Kim will still conquer

https://fbcdn-sphotos-a-a.akamaihd.net/hphotos-ak-prn2/1461766_677253592299040_163449456_n.jpg

[Saph]

when is the next one :idc:

[Me. I Am Salman]

Nicki minaj >>>
She redeemed herself with the Re-Up

[Samm]

Nikki.

[james130]

http://doblelol.com/thumbs/animation-gifs-nicki-minaj-girl-sexy-funny-face-gif_4822523454293618.jpg

Nicki wins.

[james130]

Next :idc:

[james130]

Can we have another one please?

[Joelle.]

Not the greatest thread of all time dormant for 2 months :nono:

[Saph]

its Reeces fault

https://fbcdn-sphotos-a-a.akamaihd.net/hphotos-ak-prn2/1461766_677253592299040_163449456_n.jpg

[james130]

its Reeces fault

https://fbcdn-sphotos-a-a.akamaihd.net/hphotos-ak-prn2/1461766_677253592299040_163449456_n.jpg

Where is that little ****? :devil:

[Me. I Am Salman]

Nikki.

Are you really spelling it like that
it's clearly spelt Nicki in the title anyway :joker:

[Gstar]

:laugh: :laugh:

[Z]

Madonna vs ageing

I just don't think she's going to win this one

[reece(:]

Madonna vs ageing

I just don't think she's going to win this one
http://i.minus.com/i0s3gG7XGDHoF.png

[Joelle.]

Where is that little ****? :devil:

No way to address our supreme deity

http://25.media.tumblr.com/da1da86cfa9f4d90bef1656d0e58d07c/tumblr_mz588uiYVw1qcbk34o4_250.gif

[reece(:]

New:

Jennifer Hudson
http://img2.timeinc.net/instyle/images/2007/galleries/070507_hudson_400X400.jpg

vs
Kelly Rowland
http://www.biography.com/imported/images/Biography/Images/Profiles/R/Kelly-Rowland-20979907-1-402.jpg

[Samm]

Omg it's back best thread of 2013 <333333333

[reece(:]

Hope y'all ready

[Saph]

Kelly >>>>>>>>>

Work, Stole, Motivation, Ice, Kisses Down Low :worship:

[Samm]

Kelly

[Shaun]

kinda one-sided :laugh:

[Z]

Kelly Rowland, obviously.

[Kate!]

Kelly for music, but I don't like her. :fist:

[reece(:]

I Can't Describe and Think Like A Man are flawless R&B jams, don't pay them dust

[Jake.]

Madonna vs ageing

I just don't think she's going to win this one

I think otherwise http://i.imgur.com/6yUCjDus.jpg

[Jordan.]

An underrated classic

wGx9DHcm9Jg

[reece(:]

^ I still bop to that... and her other 2 faves of mine

oBUVRumce6U

s1XozsBN5Z4

And for those lazy asses still paying dust to Jenny's bops:

fY2PXJHsXno

CSE_S8WXQrI

[james130]

Ms Kelly, obviously,

http://media.giphy.com/media/Jqaap1pTRydji/giphy.gif

[reece(:]

Ms Kelly, obviously,

http://media.giphy.com/media/Jqaap1pTRydji/giphy.gif
http://img2.timeinc.net/instyle/images/2007/galleries/070507_hudson_400X400.jpg

[james130]

I like this:

lYg01llluMM

and Spotlight. That is all.

[Headie]

Jennifer has the better voice but Kelly produces better music.

[reece(:]

Night of Your Life is one of my faves :love:

[Joelle.]

Nice to see Kelly clocking the lessors here.

This needs resurrected tho
http://31.media.tumblr.com/11357f7a1a07062a86780a21f50269a1/tumblr_mwmfa9hnNU1ql5yr7o1_250.gif

[reece(:]

hews ready 4 anothaa debate?

[Samm]

yep

[Joelle.]

Here for it

[reece(:]

SIA
http://images.contactmusic.com/images/press/sia-1000-forms-of-fear-2014-promo-636.jpg
HLA0ofsu0Qg

vs
Foxes
http://metrouk2.files.wordpress.com/2013/10/ad_117290751-e1380808434644.jpg
Pecj5GGjQi8

vs
Paloma Faith
http://assets3.heart.co.uk/2014/10/paloma-faith-without-make-up-running-1394706421-view-0.jpeg
imi9Smkt_cI

[Me. I Am Salman]

ew ew and ew

[reece(:]

ew ew and ew
http://assets3.heart.co.uk/2014/10/paloma-faith-without-make-up-running-1394706421-view-0.jpeg

[Jordan.]

As solo artists Foxes >

Sias writting is obvs best

[reece(:]

for me:

Foxes > Sia >>>> Paloma

Glorious is one of my fave albums this year :flutter:

Sia's solo songs have mostly been flops (loved Clap Your Hands tho), I like Chandelier too but haven't listened to the rest of the album.

[Samm]

Sia the best writer, Paloma :love:, I also like foxes a bit so idc :worry:

[MeMyselfAndI]

Sia & Paloma >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Fox hew

[Joelle.]

Tough one, love them all

Foxes is a lazy bitch tho for releasing an album full of old demos when I was thirsty for new stuff.
Paloma's new album is also disappointing, but Only Love Can Hurt Like This is iconic.
Love Chandelier, Clap Your Hands, Youve Changed and Eye of the Needle from Sia tho, as well as her writing credits.

still Foxes tho

Let Go For Tonight and Glorious > Mariah's career

[Joelle.]

On a side note, here for the future bloodbath that is Ariana v Mariah

[reece(:]

I only like Can't Rely On You (MK Remix) from Paloma

[Joelle.]

Picking Up The Pieces is an iconic anthem tho

[Gstar]

I love Paloma but Sia wrote "Pretty Hurts" so i'm torn in between the two

.. coz I really wanna be with you

[reece(:]

On a side note, here for the future bloodbath that is Ariana v Mariah
Maybe when Ariana has a bigger back catalogue, it's no contest atm

[Joelle.]

Glorious, Shaking Heads, Holding Onto Heaven, White Coats, The Unknown and Count The Saints are all tunes

http://i.minus.com/ibwSUR1VcRyfX9.gif

[Joelle.]

Maybe when Ariana has a bigger back catalogue, it's no contest atm

If were all still here in 20 years

[reece(:]

Glorious, Shaking Heads, Holding Onto Heaven, White Coats, The Unknown and Count The Saints are all tunes

http://i.minus.com/ibwSUR1VcRyfX9.gif
And ofc Let Go For Tonight

[Me. I Am Salman]

this is a bit random but does anyone know whatever happened to gabriella cimi
i loved sweet about me/on a mission

[reece(:]

this is a bit random but does anyone know whatever happened to gabriella cimi
i loved sweet about me/on a mission
She brought out another album

[Joelle.]

http://www.plattenladentipps.de/wp-content/uploads/2014/04/Gabriella-Cilmi__cov__The-Sting_300x300.jpg

Released this. Still havent listened tho :worry:

Ten was a flawfree album too

[Joelle.]

ycmQpXWwT0c

Bop. She needs her own debate at some point (probably with a fellow flop)

[Jords]

Foxes

[reece(:]

ycmQpXWwT0c

Bop. She needs her own debate at some point (probably with a fellow flop)
Yeah, flops will be grouped togetha

[Me. I Am Salman]

apparently she's only 18 in that video wtf

[Smithy]

All those bitched slay me how dare you make them compete

Paloma >> Sia/Foxes

I think :worry:

[LaLaLand]

Paloma.

[Iceman]

Sia....just for the em collabs

[Saph]

hew r those 3? http://i.imgur.com/jiCG31T.png

[King Gizzard]

Everyone > Paloma

[james130]

Paloma by a long mile.

Stone Cold Sober, New York, Only Love..., Picking Up The Pieces, Never Tear Us Apart...
I could go on.
And a load of great album tracks too.

[Jake.]

Sia >>> Paloma >>>>>> Foxes

[Pete.]

the 3 irrelevants http://i.imgur.com/bvJsLsY.png

I guess Sia would be my fave with Paloma close behind. But Foxes http://i.imgur.com/SJyZxK3.gif

[Joelle.]

the 3 irrelevants http://i.imgur.com/bvJsLsY.png

What kinda shade for Sia, the saviour of Brinty Joan http://i.imgur.com/SJyZxK3.gif

[Pete.]

What kinda shade for Sia, the saviour of Brinty Joan http://i.imgur.com/SJyZxK3.gif
was she tho http://i.imgur.com/jiCG31T.png

[reece(:]

Here for the resurrection of this

[Pete.]

Revive it!

[Firewire]

Geri vs David Bowie vs Alanis

[Pete.]

:suspect:

[reece(:]

Body Talk promo?

[reece(:]

To rihturn with a new format!

[Ross.]

the 3 irrelevants http://i.imgur.com/bvJsLsY.png

I guess Sia would be my fave with Paloma close behind. But Foxes http://i.imgur.com/SJyZxK3.gif

just shut your mouth 2014 Pete http://i.imgur.com/SJyZxK3.gif

[Pete.]

To rihturn with a new format!
It's Rihup :clap1:

[Pete.]

just shut your mouth 2014 Pete http://i.imgur.com/SJyZxK3.gif
Did I lie though

[reece(:]

After two years a winner has been declared

http://images.contactmusic.com/images/press/sia-1000-forms-of-fear-2014-promo-636.jpg

[EspeonBB]

Is this undergoing a revival?

[Ross.]

Is this undergoing a revival?

Selena round incoming?

[Pete.]

Anti teas

[reece(:]

Where's the hype?

[Pete.]

Where's the hype?
2 years worth

[EspeonBB]

When's the resurrection happening
https://45.media.tumblr.com/1a58522c39aa67cf8284003bc35b3e46/tumblr_npm48jhiRF1uxe9njo8_r1_400.gif

[reece(:]

When more than 2 people are interested

https://45.media.tumblr.com/1a58522c39aa67cf8284003bc35b3e46/tumblr_npm48jhiRF1uxe9njo8_r1_400.gif

[Ross.]

A third person is now interested

https://45.media.tumblr.com/1a58522c39aa67cf8284003bc35b3e46/tumblr_npm48jhiRF1uxe9njo8_r1_400.gif

[reece(:]

A third person is now interested

https://45.media.tumblr.com/1a58522c39aa67cf8284003bc35b3e46/tumblr_npm48jhiRF1uxe9njo8_r1_400.gif
Almost at the number of people who bought Geri - Half of Me

https://45.media.tumblr.com/1a58522c39aa67cf8284003bc35b3e46/tumblr_npm48jhiRF1uxe9njo8_r1_400.gif

[Pete.]

http://britney-galaxy.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/12/seee.gif (http://www.google.co.uk/url?sa=i&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=images&cd=&cad=rja&uact=8&ved=0ahUKEwj3prGK9OvLAhWHOhQKHWXKCfwQjRwIBw&url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.breatheheavy.com%2Fexhale%2Fi ndex.php%3F%2Ftopic%2F698494-will-b9-have-any-features%2F&psig=AFQjCNEu_EV-uDOKAY5CakOQFvP-7z5W2g&ust=1459547396951426)

[Ross.]

justice for the comeback?

[Pete.]

First debate - which had had the most drawn out comeback: this, Anti or Artpop?

[EspeonBB]

http://i.imgur.com/Nsx5hQ0.gif

[reece(:]

First debate - which had had the most drawn out comeback: this, Anti or Artpop?
Stacie Orrico

http://i.imgur.com/Nsx5hQ0.gif

[Pete.]

Will the relaunch be accompanied with an HBO special?

http://i.imgur.com/Nsx5hQ0.gif

[Pete.]

Prays for this

[Jordan.]

praying for this and singles rate http://cdn.thisisbigbrother.com/customavatars/avatar82167_67.gif

[Pete.]

The Singles Rate will be back http://cdn.thisisbigbrother.com/customavatars/avatar82167_67.gif

[reece(:]

The Singles Rate will be back http://cdn.thisisbigbrother.com/customavatars/avatar82167_67.gif

oop

[reece(:]

We need a #Revival considering the Maids are no more!

[Pete.]

:clap1:

[reece(:]

Returning after Pete's HM Rank!

[Jordan.]

The Singles Rate will be back http://cdn.thisisbigbrother.com/customavatars/avatar82167_67.gif

https://media.giphy.com/media/n4e4IRXBiTl2E/giphy.gif

[Ross.]

https://media.giphy.com/media/n4e4IRXBiTl2E/giphy.gif

:joker:

[reece(:]

The debates return will not just be one artist vs the other this time round either.

An example could be:

"Debate the artist with the best musical features"
"Is Shakira over now"

[Pete.]

"Predict Perfect Illusion's opening week performance"

https://media.giphy.com/media/n4e4IRXBiTl2E/giphy.gif

[Pete.]

Returning after Pete's HM Rank!
http://abload.de/img/brittany2prjhb.gif

[Ross.]

Returning TONIGHT!

https://media.giphy.com/media/n4e4IRXBiTl2E/giphy.gif

[reece(:]

The Re-Up Pt. I

http://www.famousbirthdays.com/rec/contostavlos-tulisa-rect.jpghttps://s-media-cache-ak0.pinimg.com/236x/66/d2/b5/66d2b50ccd2c81a1ad81f168be53da18.jpg
TULISA VS ALESHA!

Some of their well known songs:

xGnSuTWXC9A

kVPjldfJ9rM

we_ISy2E15o

2kL9sS95zRc

[Pete.]

Impact: Both 1 era artists but Alesha had the biggest era & peak back in the day. Alesha also managed to have more success as a solo act compared to Tulisa who was also from a group.

Singles: Prefer Alesha's singles from The Alesha Show (especially Lets Get Excited which is underrated). Young by Tulisa is her best and I liked that song that Daniel spams on plug.

Albums: The Alesha Show is a tad better than The Female Boss (or whatever that mess with British Swag on was called). Tulisa's album artwork > Alesha's though

TV Judge: Tulisa wins this one!

Overall: Alesha :clap1:

[reece(:]

Their latest offerings

ESxBzc-rWLA

ji2qFKjzdDI

[Shaun]

the boy does nothing >>>>>>>> careers

[armand.kay]

Sorry Tulisa just leaves more of an impact.

[reece(:]

Re-Axed?

[Shaun]

you can't seriously expect Tulisa and Alesha to revive a dead career

[LukeB]

Alesha is miles better than Tulisa

Alesha has more bops, is a better judge and more talented.

Tulisa is a wannabe who calls herself the female boss... she isn't the boss of anything lmao her career is dead.

[Headie]

Alesha is miles better than Tulisa

Alesha has more bops, is a better judge and more talented.

Tulisa is a wannabe who calls herself the female boss... she isn't the boss of anything lmao her career is dead.

http://38.media.tumblr.com/fea44067bd56de4fd4baafd165f048e5/tumblr_n9izgzC9JE1rtta3uo1_250.gif

[Tom4784]

Alesha wins by default, Tulisa is TRASH.

[Ross.]

Alesha always