1D wannabe "edgy" rock makeover

[alex_front2]

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/tvshowbiz/article-2524284/X-Factor-final-2013-One-Direction-grunge-make-X-Factor-final--divides-opinion.html

Bless them. Pretending to bleep out "sh*t".

Dangly earrings pretending to play guitar and pirate head bands.:joker: so so edgy. :joker:

Bless them.

[Mystic Mock]

It's their best song all because it's in a more Busted style which I liked.

But wtf was with the vocals lol? Seriously awful.

[Mystic Mock]

It's their best song all because it's in a more Busted style which I liked.

But wtf was with the vocals lol? Seriously awful.

[Saph]

well they've got to try and evolve somehow, they cant do teen pop forever

[Jarrod]

I loved it.

[Shaun]

sounded exactly the same as

0UIB9Y4OFPs

[Black Dagger]

sounded exactly the same as

0UIB9Y4OFPs

Yes, I thought so.

Mid-life crisis at 20 it seems, stick with the bubble-gum pop guys, some of it is decent.

[Jake.]

The Story of My Life > whatever that mess was last night

[mizzy25]

I loved it I love 1d I think they are great, they make great pop music and Im very happy they are so successful. Its funny how they've all grown up though lol

[Ramsay]

It's good for them to try something and evolve from the teen boy band poppy type thing. Like Saph said, they can't be like that forever

[Vicky.]

It's their best song all because it's in a more Busted style which I liked.

But wtf was with the vocals lol? Seriously awful.

I think that had something to do with them actually letting Louis sing..

[Kazanne]

I liked it,these guys will never be any good for some people what ever they do,personally ,I love their stuff,they make people happy and as far a I know they have never hurt any of us,we aren't going to like all their stuff,but that's the same with any artist,they are exploring different things,good for them.

[Vanessa]

I love them. :hugesmile:

[Marsh.]

It makes me laugh when that Louis steps forward with his stubble all ready to rock out then when he opens his mouth he sounds like a 12 year old girl doing karaoke. :laugh:

[Niamh.]

sounded exactly the same as

0UIB9Y4OFPs

I didn't watch them but the DJ on the radio station I was listening to this morning said the same thing

[Mystic Mock]

I think that had something to do with them actually letting Louis sing..

Don't forget that Niall as well.:joker:

[Kate!]

I like 1D, but it was godawful :(

Katy Perry was crap as well.

[Mystic Mock]

That's the worst that I've ever heard Katy Perry sing that was lol.

[joeysteele]

I liked it,these guys will never be any good for some people what ever they do,personally ,I love their stuff,they make people happy and as far a I know they have never hurt any of us,we aren't going to like all their stuff,but that's the same with any artist,they are exploring different things,good for them.

I'm happy to admit that I have come to be impressed by them. I have really liked their last few songs.

Good on them and they sure work hard at keeping the success coming too.

[Marsh.]

Katy Perry's problem is she's given songs for a completely different vocal range than the one she has. She can't reach the high notes of Firework without the aid of a computer.

Either that or she just simply can't sing full stop.

[Kazanne]

I'm happy to admit that I have come to be impressed by them. I have really liked their last few songs.

Good on them and they sure work hard at keeping the success coming too.

They have grown on me so much Joey,as my daughter keeps playing the CD(I can blame her):hugesmile:I love 'Little things' and the story of my life is my current favourite song,they just make me smile and that's a good thing:hugesmile:

[Me. I Am Salman]

stick with the bubble-gum pop guys, some of it is decent.

it's really not, they're so embarassing they bring bubble gum pop to a new level of cringe. god knows why people on here act as if their songs are hard to resist when they're not, I can only understand little girls liking them

may sound like I'm just jumping on a bandwagon but it honestly is true.

[Vanessa]

Did they look miserable, because Simon is about to trade them for a younger model? :joker:

[Mystic Mock]

Did they look miserable, because Simon is about to trade them for a younger model? :joker:

Bring on Luke.:devil::joker:

[Vanessa]

Bring on Luke.:devil::joker:

And wee Nicholas! :dog:

[Marsh.]

I'm happy to admit that I have come to be impressed by them. I have really liked their last few songs.

Good on them and they sure work hard at keeping the success coming too.

Surely you mean their team?

[Stu]

Here it comes. The wearing Tool T-Shirts in public phase.

[Harry!]

Next year the boys are set to play in stadiums across the world, teen pop style music alone wouldn't sound good in a stadium. Having a rocky edge would sound great live.

[alex_front2]

It never ceases to shock me how many fully functioning adults like 1D. Why do they get a hall pass whereas Westlife and Boyzone get slated (they are all sh*te!!).

Now Liam Gallagher from Oasis, Eminem, Rio Ferdinand, Elton John, and Ronnie Wood (he went to 1D film premier) have all praised 1D or admitted to being closet fans. WTF WTF WTF WTF!! The fact that Liam Gallagher said they were great live is still the most shocking thing he's said or done!!

[Kazanne]

It never ceases to shock me how many fully functioning adults like 1D. Why do they get a hall pass whereas Westlife and Boyzone get slated (they are all sh*te!!).

Now Liam Gallagher from Oasis, Eminem, Rio Ferdinand, Elton John, and Ronnie Wood (he went to 1D film premier) have all praised 1D or admitted to being closet fans. WTF WTF WTF WTF!! The fact that Liam Gallagher said they were great live is still the most shocking thing he's said or done!!

We all have differing tastes,why shouldn't people like them because you don't? They are obviously well liked,I like their music and I am fully functioning thankyou,people really annoy me when they slate others musical tastes,it's as though they think they own the music industry,nowt wrong with Westlife or Boyzone imo each to their own.I love that 1D are pissing so many off.

[alex_front2]

it's as though they think they own the music industry,nowt wrong with Westlife or Boyzone imo each to their own.I love that 1D are pissing so many off.


1D are p$$ing alot of people off, me included. They are like a great lump of poor that refuses to get flushed down a lav.

You said nowt wrong eith Westlife and Boyzone. :joker: I guess if i look in the middle of the road there are people who think there's nowt wrongwith Westlife, Daniel O Donnel, Josh Groban, Celine Deon, Cliffe Richard...

[Kazanne]

1D are p$$ing alot of people off, me included. They are like a great lump of poor that refuses to get flushed down a lav.

You said nowt wrong eith Westlife and Boyzone. :joker: I guess if i look in the middle of the road there are people who think there's nowt wrongwith Westlife, Daniel O Donnel, Josh Groban, Celine Deon, Cliffe Richard...

Well it may shock you to know all those you mentioned have fans lots of them whether we like them or not,who are we to say who and what people should like ,I think a lot of current stars are ****e but I'de never force that opinion down others throats,as I said each to their own.And if 1D are pissing you off that much,I never want to pull that chain:joker:

[Z]

God I hate Louis Tomlinson, self entitled talentless dick.