Mariah vs Whitney vs Celine

[Me. I Am Salman]

which one do you prefer overall?
Mariah ****s on them both discography and voice wise. Then Whitney, then lastly Celine (:yuk:)

[Jessica.]

I like them all, but Whitney just about wins it for me.

[Saph]

Mariah >>>> Whitney >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> 1-hit wonder Celine

[Jordan.]

Jessie J

[Amy Jade]

Whitney
Celine
Mariah

[Me. I Am Salman]

Jessie J

ew stop

[Saph]

whitney does have some good songs

YFVnVuTcz9I
kxZD0VQvfqU
6J538b-OLRU

[Jessica.]

Jessie J

:joker::joker:

[james130]

Whitney ****s on the other two in terms of material.
I think i've liked maybe 3 Mariah songs:
It's Like That, Get Your Number & Obsessed.
Don't get me started on Celine (amazing voice but...), but these... :love:

7EjfbyCpAxA
m3-hY-hlhBg

ESPECIALLY THIS :|

0H-jLOoz-YY

and obviously I Wanna Dance With Somebody

[Ithinkiloveyoutoo]

I really hate that celine is disrespected when she has/had one of the most wonderful voices of the 90s. Forget My heart will go on, listen to her discography that woman has excellent vocals. On top of this she can still sing, Mariah is just crap nowadays, even over pre-recorded music.

Having said that I couldn't choose, I love all three.

[Z]

Whitney > Celine > Mariah

[Amy Jade]

I agree with ithinkiloveyoutoo about Mariah. In her prime she was amazing but she struggles live now, Celine can still pull off the same stuff she did in her hight of fame.

Can't really compare Whitney for obvious reasons but her voice was something really special it's a shame she went down the path she did.

[Shaun]

Whitney by far in terms of discography. Then Mariah, and I barely register Celine Dion as a musician - she's just a moose that occasionally ventures out of the forest for some water.

[Mystic Mock]

Mariah Carey had it all, sadly her voice has gone nowadays but she was really good about 10 years ago.

Whitney Houston was a great talent with some good songs, it's just that I liked Mariah's style more.

And Celine Dion has a good voice but she loses to the other two in practically every department for me.

[Z]

Celine Dion is crazy, has anyone seen that video of her on Larry King crying her eyes out? Talking utter nonsense

[Z]

QXD4BGvPngM

[Loukas]

Whitney > Mariah > Celine

[Natalie.]

Whitney > Mariah > Celine

[Pete.]

Mariah

[Saph]

Celine
Chuck, Locke.

https://31.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_m6cz9iT5Os1r0ir1xo2_250.png

[Samm]

Mariah > Whitney > Who?

[Marc]

I like Mariah but I have a soft spot for Celine

[smeagol]

mariah - sexy still got it still doing it and doing it well

whitney - well she died much the same way as jackson and like jackson had'nt done anything good in a decade,

celine - awful horse woman stuck up her own ass, how and why she is making so much money still is bewildering. awful in every way. she cant sing a song normally without going ott. thats a bad singer. stick a saddle on her back ride her round ascot she will sound better

[Me. I Am Salman]

I am loving the Celine hate

[Tom4784]

Whitney is by far the best out of these three.

[Ammi]

Whitney is by far the best out of these three.

..and yes..:love:...

[Benjamin]

Celine. :love:

I used to absolutely hate her when i was a kid, but now I love her voice.

[Joelle.]

Whitney by miles. Her discography is flawless - How Will I Know, I Wanna Dance.., So Emotional, Queen of the Night, etc. and those two dont even compare. Doesn't help Mariah's case that shes an utter **** as well. Celine has a better voice than Mariah imo too.

[Nia-96]

Whitney
Mariah
Celine

[Harry!]

Whitney > Celine > Mariah

[Niamh.]

In her prime Whitney was by far the best of the 3

[reece(:]

Mariah by far, although her standards are slipping

[Z]

I can't get into Mariah's music, other than All I Want For Christmas Is You, I feel like she's an extremely American-centric artist whereas Celine and Whitney have music that has a more European friendly feel to it?

[Kate!]

Whitney by far in terms of discography. Then Mariah, and I barely register Celine Dion as a musician - she's just a moose that occasionally ventures out of the forest for some water.

This.

Whitney is head and shoulders above Mariah in talent and consistency, Celine hmm well she can sing but I have no interest in her, she's bland.

[Z]

To be honest I don't really appreciate any of them as artists; Whitney has more songs I know by name and I can appreciate that they are all amazingly talented singers but the whole sassy diva persona that comes with that I find totally unappealing and contrived.

[Lee.]

I can't stand Mariah's voice.. Whitney has had some great songs, but Celine's voice is :love:

[Z]

I think Mariah's a bit cringe worthy nowadays, her voice is meant for belting big songs, not breathy R'n'B-lite features on other artists' songs to try and keep her "young". Think it's about time she accepted a residency somewhere and stopped trying to act half her age.

[Lee.]

I think Mariah's a bit cringe worthy nowadays, her voice is meant for belting big songs, not breathy R'n'B-lite features on other artists' songs to try and keep her "young". Think it's about time she accepted a residency somewhere and stopped trying to act half her age.

Even as a belter, I find her voice unbearable. I think she has something like an 8 octave range.. But is there any need to demonstrate that range in one short line of a song? No I do not think so :bored:

[Z]

Even as a belter, I find her voice unbearable. I think she has something like an 8 octave range.. But is there any need to demonstrate that range in one short line of a song? No I do not think so :bored:

Ugh I know, being able to go as high as a dog whistle doesn't mean you should do it at every opportunity

[Lee.]

Ugh I know, being able to go as high as a dog whistle doesn't mean you should do it at every opportunity

I'll bet your shower singing is better x 100

[Z]

I'll bet your shower singing is better x 100

I bet fewer people have told me to shut up and go away when I'm singing than Mariah's had

[Saph]

LfRNRymrv9k

>>>

[Z]

Yeah but she's no Zee in the shower is she