the Big Benefits Row : Live Ch5HD 9PM Monday 3/2/14

[arista]

A Panel Debates it Live
on Ch5


http://www.channel5.com/shows/the-big-benefits-row-live/episodes/the-big-benefits-row-live

[21:00 3 Feb 2014
Sorry, this episode is not available to watch on Demand 5.]

[Kizzy]

Will be watching with interest.

[arista]

Will be watching with interest.


They may need Security on the live set
just in case

[Jack_]

Nobody should be watching this, it has Katie Hopkins, Kelvin Mackenzie and Edwina Currie as panelists. You couldn't get any more inflammatory if you tried.

This won't be a debate, but a sensationalist pile of crap.

[arista]

Nobody should be watching this, it has Katie Hopkins, Kelvin Mackenzie and Edwina Currie as panelists. You couldn't get any more inflammatory if you tried.

This won't be a debate, but a sensationalist pile of crap.


Rubbish there are more than them.

[joeysteele]

Nobody should be watching this, it has Katie Hopkins, Kelvin Mackenzie and Edwina Currie as panelists. You couldn't get any more inflammatory if you tried.

This won't be a debate, but a sensationalist pile of crap.

I agree from the sounds of that.

For crying out loud, has he,Mckenzie, found his extreme voice again following his self imposed hibernation after the revelations of all the wrong, and his part in it as to the Liverpool fans.

Why do ignorant people like him even get asked for their views.he really annoys me when he is on.
Then Edwina Currie for goodness sake too, this may be worth missing for me actually.

[arista]

[/B]

I agree from the sounds of that.

For crying out loud, has he,Mckenzie, found his extreme voice again following his self imposed hibernation after the revelations of all the wrong, and his part in it as to the Liverpool fans.

Why do ignorant people like him even get asked for their views.he really annoys me when he is on.
Then Edwina Currie for goodness sake too, this may be worth missing for me actually.


Joey Others will be there.

Jack is so Red

[joeysteele]

Joey Others will be there.

Jack is so Red

Jack's a great guy, I follow his lead a lot in these programmes.

They sound pretty bad panelists to me, I cannot understand why they are asked to things Like this, they have spouted their extreme 'uncompromising' views plenty on other outlets for ages.

[arista]

Jack's a great guy, I follow his lead a lot in these programmes.

They sound pretty bad panelists to me, I cannot understand why they are asked to things Like this, they have spouted their extreme 'uncompromising' views plenty on other outlets for ages.



He is having a joke
as The panel is still being worked out


So go Follow Joker Jack



[The Big Benefits Row: Live[ HD]
A panel discusses the UK's welfare system and why the subject has become
such a political hot potato, with questions and contributions by a studio audience.
Topics covered include whether the process
is being abused and if it should be made harder
for the long-term unemployed and recent immigrants
to claim benefits General Social/Political Issues/Economics/Discussion/Debate]

[Kizzy]

It's not a debate if you don't have both sides of the argument, that said who are those 3 representative of?
Their opinions are not those of the population not currently in receipt of a benefit as far as I can see. in the same vein I hope the selection of panelists chosen to speak for those on a benefit isn't as ignorant.

[arista]

It's not a debate if you don't have both sides of the argument, that said who are those 3 representative of?
Their opinions are not those of the population not currently in receipt of a benefit as far as I can see. in the same vein I hope the selection of panelists chosen to speak for those on a benefit isn't as ignorant.


Its is a Live debate
and of course both side will be there

Jack is a joker

[joeysteele]

It's not a debate if you don't have both sides of the argument, that said who are those 3 representative of?
Their opinions are not those of the population not currently in receipt of a benefit as far as I can see. in the same vein I hope the selection of panelists chosen to speak for those on a benefit isn't as ignorant.

If I do watch it, I would guess I will need to put my Dog in another room as Kelvin Mackenzie really gets me annoyed.:joker:

[InOne]

When are we getting the big tax evaders row?

[arista]

When are we getting the big tax evaders row?


I think Ch4 did that

[arista]

http://media.skynews.com/media/images/generated/2014/2/2/286386/default/v1/daily-star-1-329x437.jpg


Part of The Live Debate tonight

[Black Dagger]

Edwina and Katie vs White Dee.

This could be wonderfully car-crash.

[Redway]

Probably controversial but is it wrong that I actually like watching Benefits Street? :shrug:

[lostalex]

My Grandpa always said "if all the poor people died tomorrow we could use their bodies to fill the pot holes, but we'd have no one to do it".

[Jack_]

Well Owen Jones is on this now so I might watch a bit, but why must TV producers insist on pairing him with inflammatory, bigoted, ignorant trolls :bored:

There's plenty of right-wingers that can argue a point without being sensationalist, this is just going to be a freak show

[HD]

White Dee is a horror.

[Jesus.]

_meOwyOZxDE

[Tom4784]

It'll be terrible and I shan't bother watching, I don't have time for morons that think that struggling people on benefits are the problem while people on the other side of the scale get off scot free. It's stupid and sensationalist.

[smudgie]

Looking forward to it.
Hopefully both sides get equal shots at getting their points across.

[arista]

Well Owen Jones is on this now so I might watch a bit, but why must TV producers insist on pairing him with inflammatory, bigoted, ignorant trolls :bored:

There's plenty of right-wingers that can argue a point without being sensationalist, this is just going to be a freak show


Yes Both Sides Live Ch5HD - Bliss

You have not got the full list of the Panel

http://static.guim.co.uk/sys-images/Education/Pix/pictures/2012/9/11/1347382690825/Owen-Jones-author-008.jpg
Owen is Clever

[michael21]

Yes Both Sides Live Ch5HD - Bliss

You have not got the full list of the Panel

http://static.guim.co.uk/sys-images/Education/Pix/pictures/2012/9/11/1347382690825/Owen-Jones-author-008.jpg
Owen is Clever

where do you stand on this topic

[Jesus.]

More importantly, Michael, where do you stand on this topic?

[michael21]

More importantly, Michael, where do you stand on this topic?

well i did not start the thread

[arista]

On Ch5 and Ch5HD now

Will not be on any catch up , sadly.

[Brother Leon]

Hopefully White Dee destroys this Hopkins.

[HD]

Looks like White Dee has washed her hair. Amazing.

[arista]

Nobody should be watching this, it has Katie Hopkins, Kelvin Mackenzie and Edwina Currie as panelists. You couldn't get any more inflammatory if you tried.

This won't be a debate, but a sensationalist pile of crap.




Wrong you fake


Ken Livingston is there

[Kizzy]

Annabel Giles?..... Why? pffft.
Not representative of welfare claimants

[Jack_]

A BENEFITS COUNTER, ****ING REALLY?! What about the tax evasion counter?

[Jack_]

yes Matthew

[Jack_]

Wrong you fake


Ken Livingston is there

Well Kelvin's been dropped I know that, only reason why Owen has agreed to appear. He was booked though

[arista]

yes Matthew


Its a Great Panel.



Owen is in the Audience

[arista]

Well Kelvin's been dropped I know that, only reason why Owen has agreed to appear. He was booked though



Talking Bollocks


He was Never going to be on this Panel

[Kizzy]

We're going to meet this 'character'... knew it, 'white' dee paraded as the face of all walfare claimants. AAAAARRRGGHH!

[arista]

Its Well Balanced Panel.


Jack the Faker

[Vicky.]

Wonder if they will discuss thins like this
http://www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/sick-benefits-claimant-heart-attack-3098219

Or ignore it as usual...

[Headie]

What's the point having Katie Hopkins on if all they ever do is insult her, talk over her when she's giving her views and clap when someone opposes her?

This programme seems very one-sided and bias IMO.

[arista]

http://media.skynews.com/media/images/generated/2014/2/2/286386/default/v1/daily-star-1-329x437.jpg

She live Now

[Jack_]

Its Well Balanced Panel.


Jack the Faker

Kelvin was going to be on the panel and you only need to search Twitter to find that out, Owen confirmed that he was rejoining the show this morning as they'd confirmed he wouldn't be on the panel too. End of discussion

[Kizzy]

The fairy jobmother! lol

[HD]

The fairy jobmother! lol

She's an absolute moron

[Jack_]

Have to say I am surprised at the positive views so far and the negative reaction to Katie, rightly deserved...does she even believe what she's saying? It's total nonsense

Only problem with this show is the inflammatory title and the hyperbole surrounding it

[Jack_]

Wish they'd stop quoting this poll, the sample was of 1,000 people

[Jarrod]

Katie Hopkins. What is she actually on about?

[Jack_]

People on benefits are 'hard working people' you stupid trolling bitch

that was in caps

[GiRTh]

Katie getting destroyed. Didnt think this show was gonna be like this.

[Jack_]

how about you clean a ****ing toilet you privileged *****

[Kizzy]

She's an absolute moron

Do you know her?

[arista]

People on benefits are 'hard working people' you stupid trolling bitch

that was in caps


She is Fun


Owen is in the Audience

[Jack_]

Do I dare look at Twitter?

[Jarrod]

Would she get down and clean a toilet? No she bloody wouldn't. Stuck up cow.

[Jarrod]

Do I dare look at Twitter?

I can't actually get on Twitter right now.

[HD]

Do you know her?

Yes

[arista]

Would she get down and clean a toilet? No she bloody wouldn't. Stuck up cow.


Katie would clean bogs

[Jack_]

https://pbs.twimg.com/media/BflAyb1IIAARH4j.jpg:large

[arista]

New Panel now

[HD]

Edwina Currie :bored:

[Jack_]

You aren't ashamed of that? Well how about you get down to a food bank you dirty scummy bitch

[HD]

You aren't ashamed of that? Well how about you get down to a food bank you dirty scummy bitch

She's a twat

[Jack_]

'Next week on Channel 5:

THE BIG EXECUTION SHOW LIVE: Katie Hopkins and Edwina Currie'

35m viewers

[Brother Leon]

This short haired woman is irritating.

[Jack_]

PREACH IT SISTA BEAT THAT BITCH :dance:

[HD]

Sophie Anderton :laugh:

[arista]

No need to Shout

[Jack_]

I hope they rush her at the end and the show is taken off air

[Brother Leon]

Ok. This show just went to ****ing **** :joker:

Major cringe.

[HD]

"Every mother is a working mother" Umm, no.

[Jack_]

well at least it lived up to its name, 'row'

[arista]

New panel
after the break

[Jack_]

I can't @ some of the naive victims of media spin and sensationalism on Twitter talking about things they know nothing about, saddened and embarrassed for them

[arista]

Owen is there now

[Jack_]

yaaaay

[HD]

that accent :umm2:

[Marcus.]

tiwter has gone nuts at mo

[arista]

yaaaay



He is a Clever Chap

[Kizzy]

What was currie on about... when the audience called for a living wage she said 'we' can't afford it.... hang on who's we?...
The government don't pay wages, employers do. :conf:
I would think that government would want wages raised to lift people above the level where in work benefit is payable...

[GiRTh]

Excellent programme. Newsnight should be more like that.

[HD]

that hour has flew by :shocked:

[arista]

should have been a 90mins LIve

[Kizzy]

Well that was a bit rushed.... over 10 guests to debate such an incendiary issue in an hour?!...ridic.

[Brother Leon]

Was pretty **** tbh. As much as I don't like Hopkins, it was her and the other Woman against absolutely everyone. Meh.

[Jack_]

430458297234505728

preach it

[joeysteele]

This was much better than I expected and I liked the facts and figures given out too, they were very telling.

Edwina Currie and Katie Hopkins,to me anyway, made themselves look heartless and at times totally ridiculous as to their points.

Owen Jones is always superb and I loved his jibe at Labour for not doing enough as to tax avoidance,he always talks fairly.

Good programme,I hope those who watched it, digest the facts and figures given out on it and start to realise that we do have a media and very sadly a Govt too that are making scapegoats of and demonising people at the very lowest end of the scale in the UK.
Of almost 99% of who are in fact as the programme stated,not doing anything wrong and not fiddling the system likely at all !!

[Black Dagger]

I am not appreciating this hate for KT and Edwina tbh.

-I didn't even see it I was too busy watching football wish I didn't bother-

[Kizzy]

If you didn't watch it why are you commemting on the'hate' for Hopkins and Currie?
They had their say, not many agreed is all.

[InOne]

Well, don't think they really got anywhere with this debate at all. Nothing new was said and it was just a slagging match and free-for-all at times.

Good to see that horrible bitch Hopkins get a kick-in though. And hopefully people take note of the statistics.

I always knew White Dee would come off well as she's an intelligent woman, I bet a lot expected her to be like that Wife Swap woman who had notoriety about 10 years ago.

[michael21]

if White Dee can go on tv shows then she can work the fat fecker :fist:

[arista]

2nd Showing tonight 9PM
on the New Ch

Ch5+24