Is Amanda Knox guilty? bbc3, 21:00

[Vanessa]

I find her very cold and calculating.

[lostalex]

i find you very.. oh wait, i'm not allowed to make personal judgements about members of this site...

but you can feel free to keep making judgments about a girl you've never met....

[Vanessa]

This is a forum. We're allwed to have opinions on things. :rolleyes:

[Vanessa]

This court case has dragged on so much it's unreal. Italian justice sistem is ridiculous. :bored:

[lostalex]

This is a forum. We're allwed to have opinions on things. :rolleyes:

yea, isn't it interesting that on this forum we are allowed to express our opinions about people that we've never talked to, but we can get banned for expressing opinions about people we have talked to on this forum...

it's funny, isn't it?

anyways, i've seen all the evidence in the case, and there's not a single shred of evidence that implies that Amanda and Rafaelle had anything to do with the murder.

There is tons of evidence that Rudy Guede raped and murdered Meredith, his DNA and finger prints are all over the room, and his DNA (his cum) is INSIDE her, he raped her, no doubt about it, he raped and killed Meredith. He's in jail, justice has been done.

[Vanessa]

yea, isn't it interesting that on this forum we are allowed to express our opinions about people that we've never talked to, but we can get banned for expressing opinions about people we have talked to on this forum...

it's funny, isn't it?

anyways, i've seen all the evidence in the case, and there's not a single shred of evidence that implies that Amanda had anything to do with the murder. there is tons of evidence that Rudy Guede raped and murdered Meredith, his DNA and finger prints are all over the room, and his DNA (his cum) is INSIDE her, he raped her, no doubt about it, he raped and killed Meredith. He's in jail, justice has been done.

No, i think she did it.

[lostalex]

No, i think she did it.

I don't think you've put much thinking into what you think. Where's the evidence?

[Vanessa]

I agree Meredith and Amanda had a fight. Everything points to that.

[Vanessa]

I don't think you've put much thinking into what you think. Where's the evidence?

She has been found guilty, so they must have strong evidence that she did it.

[lostalex]

I agree Meredith and Amanda had a fight. Everything points to that.

wow, college roommates had a fight? shocking. if having a fight with your college roommate over who's not picking up after themselves, who's not doing the dishes, who's leaving dirty laundry around., leads to murder than there would be murders everyday. every university in the world would be a pool of blood if every time college roommate had an argument it led to murder.

[Vanessa]

wow, college roommates had a fight? shocking. if having a fight with your college roommate leads to murder than there would be murders everyday. every university in the world would be a pool of blood if every time college roommate had an argument it led to murder.

Some arguments do lead to murder.

[lostalex]

Some arguments do lead to murder.

but the vast majority don't. right?

[Vanessa]

but the vast majority don't. right?

No, not all of them..

[Kazanne]

I find her very cold and calculating.

I cant warm to her either Vanessa,sometimes those gut feelings are spot on.

[Samm]

I have an agrument with someone every week and I never think about killing them, and she has also be found not guilty btw

[Vanessa]

I cant warm to her either Vanessa,sometimes those gut feelings are spot on.

This programme is very interesting. They're exploring both sides of the case. Trying to find out what really happened.

[lostalex]

Not all of them, i think just a few.

and what percentage of them, would take in an african drifter to do the job? and african drifter with a history of knife violence, just happened to be in the neighborhood, just when amanda needed him? if Amanda was so incensed, so angry, in a country she only just arrived in, and didm;'t speak the language, if she was so angry, why would she find some random african drifter to do the job, if she was zoo angry at meredith just because meredith told her to clean up, wouldn't she just kill her herself? why would she need Rudy Guede to do it. You are saying it was a crime of passion of anger because Amanda was soooo angry just because Meredith asked her to clean up a bit more, ...

do you understand how RIDICULOUS your scenario sounds?

[Vanessa]

I have an agrument with someone every week and I never think about killing them, and she has also be found not guilty btw

I know, italian justice sistem is crazy. Now there will be appeals as well. This case will just drag on and on.

[Vanessa]

and what percentage of them, would take in an africa drifter to do the job? if Amanda was so incensed, so angry, in a country she only just arrived in, and didm;'t speak the language, if she was so angry, why would she find some random african drifter to do the job, if she was zoo angry at meredith just because meredith told her to clean up, wouldn't she just kill her herself? why would she need Ridy guide to do it. you are saying it was a crime of passion of anger because Amanda was soooo angry just because Meredith asked her to clean up a bit more, ...

do you understand how RIDICULOUS your scenario sounds?

I think it's a possibility.

[michael21]

I find her very cold and calculating.

i find her hot but dont tell her as she might try and kill me :bawling::bawling::bawling:

[lostalex]

i think it's ridiculous, and i thnk it's pathetic that Amanda and Rafaelle are being victimized along with Meredith. It seems the Kertcher family will only be happy if they get to kill 2 other innocent lives along with their daughter. They seem hell bent on destroying Amanda and Rafaelle, and that makes them just as bad as Rudy Guede.

Meredith's family are the villains in this story now. Shame on them, they are a disgrace to their daughter.

[the truth]

I think it's a possibility.

how can we concentrate on this trivial tale when youre distracting us with this uber cool yoga kitten....:joker:

[Vanessa]

how can we concentrate on this trivial tale when youre distracting us with this uber cool yoga kitten....:joker:

:laugh:

[Vanessa]

Sollecito did a runner before the vedict was announced. I think he knew it was going to be bad news.

[lostalex]

Sollecito did a runner before the vedict was announced. I think he knew it was going to be bad news.

i don't blame him, if i knew i didn't have any chance at justice i'd run too. This young man has had his life destroyed and now he faces 20 years in prison for something he didn't do. Wouldn't you run? I would. I have zero faith in the Italian justice system and i guess he doesn't either.

[Vanessa]

i don't blame him, if i knew i didn't have any chance at justice i'd run too. This young man has had his life destroyed and now he faces 20 years in prison for something he didn't do. Wouldn't you run?

Italian law made such a mess of this case. This is just going to drag on. There will be more appeals.

[Ninastar]

I watched this last night and found it very interesting. I don't think Amanda had anything to do with it at all now. I think it was 100% that Guede man.

[Vanessa]

I watched this last night and found it very interesting. I don't think Amanda had anything to do with it at all now. I think it was 100% that Guede man.

It was very interesting, wasn't it? I find Amanda behaviour a bit suspicious. Why did she accuse an innocent man? He has been cleared and awarded compensation.

[Ninastar]

^ It could have easily happened. Two young girls living together in a forigen country and then your best friend is murdered. You want to know who did it (as you would) and you'd think about anyone who did anything strange/creepy at the time.

maybe he was always staring at the girls? perhaps he said things that were a little strange?

there's loads of different reasons. You'd be so exhausted that you wouldn't know what to think.

[Vanessa]

^ It could have easily happened. Two young girls living together in a forigen country and then your best friend is murdered. You want to know who did it (as you would) and you'd think about anyone who did anything strange/creepy at the time.

maybe he was always staring at the girls? perhaps he said things that were a little strange?

there's loads of different reasons. You'd be so exhausted that you wouldn't know what to think.

My gut feeling tells me she did it. But i don't think she was alone.

[Munchkins]

But Rudy's DNA is INSIDE HER? and all over her
i'm pretty sure the only evidence of Amanda does not come from the bedroom, theres no blood linking her in the actual bedroom
so shes meant to have managed to murder Meredith quite bloodily, but then got out of the bedroom with no traces of blood from her being found?
Theres blood linking her in the bathroom but that could have been saliva
It's like a witch hunt the way peoople go on with Amanda

I do think its awful how the media has always focused on Amanda though, its poor Meredith who should be, she was the one who died

I think Amanda may have been there and witnessed it and not done anything, but killed her no

[Vanessa]

But Rudy's DNA is INSIDE HER? and all over her
i'm pretty sure the only evidence of Amanda does not come from the bedroom, theres no blood linking her in the actual bedroom
so shes meant to have managed to murder Meredith quite bloodily, but then got out of the bedroom with no traces of blood from her being found?
Theres blood linking her in the bathroom but that could have been saliva
It's like a witch hunt the way peoople go on with Amanda

I do think its awful how the media has always focused on Amanda though, its poor Meredith who should be, she was the one who died

I think Amanda may have been there and witnessed it and not done anything, but killed her no

I think all three of them are guilty.

[Brother Leon]

They had it right the first time tbh, the three of them were guilty. Such a joke of a case though.

Just lol at the possibility of Rudy doing it all on his own. Picking up that huge rock,throwing it high into a window when there were easier ways to go in and he had already been in the apartment before aswell as knowing the boys downstairs,no genuine trace of a break in,being able to pin down and stab her the way she's was stabbed? Can't see it and that's just stuff off the top of my head that doesn't make sense. The whole scene screamed fake break in. Broke window,unrealistic rock used, clothes on the floor and room generally a mess, but all the expensive items are untouched. Also the obvious washing up cleaning attempt.

One thing that got my attention though was when Rudy claimed a white guy tried stab him and then yelled to a woman that a black guy is in the house. I immediately thought that was why Amanda blamed the pub owner. Although of course that is all BS unless we want to imply Rudy is innocent and it was just Amanda and the bf :laugh:

[Vanessa]

They had it right the first time tbh, the three of them were guilty. Such a joke of a case though.

Just lol at the possibility of Rudy doing it all on his own. Picking up that huge rock,throwing it high into a window when there were easier ways to go in and he had already been in the apartment before aswell as knowing the boys downstairs,no genuine trace of a break in,being able to pin down and stab her the way she's was stabbed? Can't see it and that's just stuff off the top of my head that doesn't make sense. The whole scene screamed fake break in. Broke window,unrealistic rock used, clothes on the floor and room generally a mess, but all the expensive items are untouched. Also the obvious washing up cleaning attempt.

One thing that got my attention though was when Rudy claimed a white guy tried stab him and then yelled to a woman that a black guy is in the house. I immediately thought that was why Amanda blamed the pub owner. Although of course that is all BS unless we want to imply Rudy is innocent and it was just Amanda and the bf :laugh:

I agree with you. I think all three are guilty. I don't think Rudy is innocent at all. He may not have killed her, but he was part of the assault.

[Tom4784]

I don't think we'll ever know the truth for certain, the Italian justice system ballsed this one up from the start.

[Vanessa]

I don't think we'll ever know the truth for certain, the Italian justice system ballsed this one up from the start.

They did. Now there will be more appeals. :facepalm:

[Niamh.]

They did. Now there will be more appeals. :facepalm:

I doubt it will matter, I'd bet my life the Americans won't send her back anyway

[Vanessa]

I doubt it will matter, I'd bet my life the Americans won't send her back anyway

They will have to if she's found guilty in appeal as well.

[Niamh.]

They will have to if she's found guilty in appeal as well.

I bet they won't even if she is found guilty again

[Vanessa]

I bet they won't even if she is found guilty again

Of course she could be found not guilty. That is possible.

[Brother Leon]

I bet they won't even if she is found guilty again

[2]

America does whatever the **** it wants to do :laugh:

[Niamh.]

[2]

America does whatever the **** it wants to do :laugh:

They'll probably say something like oh double jeopardy blah blah blah (eventhough it's not their court system)

[Vanessa]

They'll probably say something like oh double jeopardy blah blah blah (eventhough it's not their court system)

I was wondering if double jeopardy applied on this case. :suspect:

[Niamh.]

I was wondering if double jeopardy applied on this case. :suspect:

Well Double Jeopardy is only an American thing though isn't it?

[Vanessa]

Well Double Jeopardy is only an American thing though isn't it?

I know, but this case has had so many trials it's become a joke.

[Jesus.]

iPkjljS1Cxk