BB14 or BB15?

[Raph]

I know this has been done before but that was weeks ago, so which series did you prefer? BB14 by a country mile for me it's like comparing a diamond with a piece of trash.

Also could a mod add a poll for me please? I forgot :laugh:

[elliebrew]

15 by a very large margin

14 was an abortion of a series

I'm loving 15. Top 5 series for me

[Shaun]

I pretty much hate both :worry:

I'd say BB15 just because the housemates I hate actually provide some sort of talking point... rather than just sit idly by like Jack+Joe, Sophie or Dan

[Locke.]

14 was crap, 15 has been pretty good so far

[Me. I Am Salman]

15 > 14 but both weak

[reece(:]

I prefer 14 as at this point I had more to root for (Hazel, Charlie, Sophie ... & Dexter/Gina at times)

[Me. I Am Salman]

I know this has been done before but that was weeks ago, so which series did you prefer? BB14 by a country mile for me it's like comparing a diamond with a piece of trash.

Also could a mod add a poll for me please? I forgot :laugh:

go on thread tools

[rionablue]

BB15 by a million per cent. I hated Gina last year. She spoiled the series for me

[Jay.]

BB14 was a classic series for me, but I only liked Gina and Dexter out of every housemate..

BB15 I like everyone who's there at the moment, with the exception of Ash.

I think their both good for different reasons and I can see that BB15 is much more of a 'game show' vibe. I'm going to say BB14 purely because of Gina and Dexter.

[CaudleHalbard]

Preferred BB14, on the whole. There was a lot more interest and controversy on TiBB.

[Redway]

14.

[Macie Lightfoot]

I don't understand how the forum went from overrating BB14 as it aired to underrating it once it finished. It's a perfectly adequate series with some good and some bad.

[divergent]

these are the only 2 series that i've watched haha!

BB14 started off great and got worse towards the final, but i LOVED gina!

this series is getting better and better imo

but overall atm i'd say bb14 was better

[BigBrotherfan4ever]

BB14 by miles cause I liked more HM's that series, I don't find many of the HM's this year very likeable.

[mrflibble]

I'm currently about 2/3 the way through 14 and I have to say I prefer it. The twists make more sense and are fitting to the theme. I feel like there is less manipulation and I find the story lines, tasks and housemates more interesting on the whole. I only like a handful of housemates this year and the rest I hate and are boring and nasty and unfortunately get the most air time.

[Marc]

I forgot about those fat twins.

BB15 is little better

[Sophiee]

bb14 all the way, it kept me interested to watch even after my favourites were evicted whereas this one hasn't, I've forced myself to keep up with it.

[Deebo]

14

[Macie Lightfoot]

Both series have remarkably unlikable casts I must say. Gina and Charlie are the only ones from 14 in my top fifty (they're well in it tho don't worry) and the only ones I could see possibly making the top fifty this year are Ashleigh and Danielle. Good job C5 (I'm forever convinced BB13 was an accident or something)

[joeysteele]

BB14 for me.
In my opinion this series is the worst BB I have ever watched.

[Daniel.]

The first three weeks of BB15 > BB14 >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Post Toya BB15

[Lostie!]

BB15.

I stopped watching BB14 halfway through and only decided to go back and watch the rest this year. I find it so overrated.

[uniquedude]

14 by far it just had the most additive to watch people in it Gina Jemima Charlie hazel sallie (I love my females) this year is so cringe and unnatural to watch I do not feel I can lose my self and really get into it I only liked Bianca and toya. Last year. was housemate driven this year has been production driven

[Jamesy]

BB14. The first C5 Big Brother I watched from start to finish and kept engaged with throughout.

This series keeps ranging from "that was a good episode, it was fairly balanced, the editing is simpler, Marcus is toned down this episode, they are really learning" to "omfg the manipulation, the editing, the Steven show, Marcus' LOUD VOICE".

[Jase.]

BB14. Anything over this abomination of a series.

[RobynTheELF]

BB14 hands down. Too much meddling by the production team in 15.

[Strictly Jake]

BB14 isn't regarded as such a great series but I loved it. I think this largely is down to being the first series my new wife watched with me and she really got into it. I loved Gina Charlie hazel and dexter. I liked a lot of the housemates. The twists tasks ect weren't that original bit the housemates were good to watch. I have enjoyed this series though in the last few weeks, I absolutely adore Ashleigh and I'm really starting to like Chris and Christopher. The best thing about bb14 was Gina the best thing about bb15 is Ashleigh. But this series has been too manipulated so it has to be bb14 as the better series

[Marsh.]

BB14 by far. It had humour about it and wasn't relentlessly miserable.

Even Gina, who I couldn't stand in bitch mode could focus on other things at times and be funny. This year they're all just depressing twats.

[Samm]

15 >

[LukeB]

the one with less unfair twist

[Brother Leon]

15


The first weeks up to Jale's eviction were some of my fave for a while.

[LukeB]

15


The first weeks up to Jale's eviction were some of my fave for a while.

it's was better after she went :smug:

[Will.]

14 has been the most unique channel 5 series in my opinion, all the others have been filled with fame hungry, semi celebs. At least most of the BB 14 were different, some normal, and had normal jobs. Like Callum a football coach, Jack and Joe - supermarket workers (see them walking to work on the bus sometimes), Dan - police officer, Sophie - Dentist. The BB 14 cast were very likeable and a diverse bunch unlike this years. The twist in 14 were slightly better and the whole series was overall a more enjoyable watch as you could relate to the some of the housemates.

[Mick]

Enjoying this one but preferred 14.Liked Hazel and Dexter.

[Flamingjoe]

The first three weeks of BB15 > BB14 >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Post Toya BB15

I completely agree with this.

[Macie Lightfoot]

14 has been the most unique channel 5 series in my opinion, all the others have been filled with fame hungry, semi celebs. At least most of the BB 14 were different, some normal, and had normal jobs. Like Callum a football coach, Jack and Joe - supermarket workers (see them walking to work on the bus sometimes), Dan - police officer, Sophie - Dentist. The BB 14 cast were very likeable and a diverse bunch unlike this years. The twist in 14 were slightly better and the whole series was overall a more enjoyable watch as you could relate to the some of the housemates.

ummmm you are aware Dan's one's one of the most fame hungry HMs in BB history right

[AbbieJ]

Big Brother 14 because of Gina and Dexter :laugh:
Do you think it would be a better series if the housemates from BB14 were in the house this year and this years housemates were in the house last year??

[Jake.]

It's been a bit like BB14... For my anyway; The first 4-5 weeks being really gripping television, filled with plenty of drama, fun moments and talking points with things sinking a bit afterwards.. Whereas BB14 was consistant with it, I feel like BB15 has been less consistant, with one week being fantastic and the next being a tad dull... I'd definetly say that it has held up better after the first 5 weeks than BB14, though.

[Raph]

Glad to see BB14 leading with more than double bb15's percentage, way to go!

[user104658]

Easily BB 14, and it's bit even my favourite ch5 season, but I enjoyed it all the way through. This season I'm just watching the little clips posted here plus the eviction night... You get all you need to know from the weekly roundup at the beginning.

13 > 12 >>> 14 > 15, for me.