Top 50 Dumbest Moves In BB History

[karl100589]

A quick project to keep me going, I have begun a list counting down what I consider to be the 50 worst moves in the history of the American version of Big Brother. Due to size this has been broken down into five different videos with the first counting from 50 to 41. I hope you enjoy the videos and whilst I don't expect everyone to agree with my choices I am very willing to explain them:

/WbeAsoRYD1Q

And keep on the lookout for the future parts which I will publish in due course.

[LemonJam]

Glad to see something like this on here. :love:

I would question Drew nominating Holly as a bad move. Had he nominated two of the other girls or Will the girls wouldn't have trusted him nearly as much in the future and he probably wouldn't have had a chance at winning. Holly was a very good choice IMO because by doing so he separated himself from an alliance that everyone wanted out of the house before jury and was able to slip his way into a better position.

The others are great inclusions though. Possibly would've had Nathans veto higher in the list. Will be following this fo sho.

[Ramsay]

Marcellus surely

[Marc]

Marcellas

[LemonJam]

https://image-cdn.zap2it.com/images/lawon-big-brother-13.jpg

[LukeB]

I want to watch this but i want to wait for these moments.

[T*]

Ooh, I'll enjoy watching this, Thanks :love:

[JerseyWins]

Good list so far, looking forward to the top 40. :thumbs:

[DrunkerThanMoses]

Intresting

Think the top 3 will be Lawon and Powers, Marcellus and Danielle using veto on Dan and him voting Shane out.

[Macie Lightfoot]

I'm hoping that Cody evicting Victoria served as some inspiration for this to happen because good lord that was the cherry on top of Cody's lackluster game

[AarynGriesfan]

Yeah Cody earned his place in the top 3 no doubt.

[Slevin]

in no particular order i think top 4 is Marcellus, Lawon, Cody and Danielle moves

[Pete.]

Who's more stupid Marcellas or Lawon?

[JerseyWins]

Lawon <3 tho :joker:

[karl100589]

Starting work on #40 to #31, here are some clues for what to expect. I would love to see what your guesses are:

1 from 4
1 from 6
2 from Allstars
2 from 9
3 from 14
1 from 16

[Pete.]

Starting work on #40 to #31, here are some clues for what to expect. I would love to see what your guesses are:

1 from 4
1 from 6
2 from Allstars
2 from 9
3 from 14
1 from 16


Dan choosing Kara over his two girls
Dan choosing Danielle over Jodi </3

Dan did make up for it tho

[karl100589]

Dan choosing Kara over his two girls
Dan choosing Danielle over Jodi </3

Dan did make up for it tho

It's neither of those two.

[LemonJam]

my guesses

4 - Dana flips/Jee takes the food reward even though he's HoH and everyone else is on PB&J (<33)
6 - I wanna say Howie targets James but I think that'd be higher.
7 - Erika nominates Danielle over Chilltown at f6/Alison and Danielle tell Jase to get himself nominated 1st week? (i have no idea tbh)
9 - Adam and Natalie vote James back into the house/Jacob calls Parker a snake when he's 1 part of the power couple.
14 - Dan tells Frank he was going to be evicted in the fake eviction/Janelle refuses the coaches alliance/Boogie neglects Jenn and Ian? [It can't be Danielle/Shane f4 it'd be too low]
16 - Joey admits to the all girl alliance?

[Donovan.]

The one from 16 can't be Cody's surely, that has to be higher. Maybe Frankie pressing the button? Or Caleb turning on Frankie and then getting sent home right after?

[karl100589]

my guesses

4 - Dana flips/Jee takes the food reward even though he's HoH and everyone else is on PB&J (<33)
6 - I wanna say Howie targets James but I think that'd be higher.
7 - Erika nominates Danielle over Chilltown at f6/Alison and Danielle tell Jase to get himself nominated 1st week? (i have no idea tbh)
9 - Adam and Natalie vote James back into the house/Jacob calls Parker a snake when he's 1 part of the power couple.
14 - Dan tells Frank he was going to be evicted in the fake eviction/Janelle refuses the coaches alliance/Boogie neglects Jenn and Ian? [It can't be Danielle/Shane f4 it'd be too low]
16 - Joey admits to the all girl alliance?


Three of them are correct

I'll also admit that one of these moves is something some people will expect to be higher.

[karl100589]

Continuing my countdown of the worst moves in Big Brother history from number 40 through to 31, although I do note caution if you are a Janelle fan as this is a very Janelle heavy update.

/W7Xi-Xobui0

[karl100589]

And some spoilers for 30-21:

1 from 4
1 from 5
2 from 6
1 from Allstars
1 from 9
1 from 10
2 from 11
1 from 14

[Raph]

Definitely Cody not taking Victoria to final 3

[LukeB]

not watching the video till i finished all seasons, but the one that i seen the other day is Marcellas not using the veto on himself.

[SoBig]

Loved that Janelle made the list multiple times. Horrible player.

[karl100589]

Loved that Janelle made the list multiple times. Horrible player.

I love her competitive spirit, but aside from that she is very poor, easily manipulated and too driven on emotion for a game like this, in retrospect I should have put her non-nomination of Maggie higher as that symbolises for me a lot of Janelles issues as a player.

[JerseyWins]

Some more really good moments there. :joker:

[Pete.]

Janelle is easily the best female player in BB history

[Calderyon]

Competition wise, yes she is the best. Game wise, she is unfortunately too emotional/vengeful and trusting.

[LukeB]

Janelle is easily the best female player in BB history

I see no lies :love:

[Udanax]

Janelle is easily the best female player in BB history

:joker:

[LukeB]

Janelle is a big brother legend for a reason :lovedup:

[Udanax]

ok...? that doesn't mean she played a good game.

[Calderyon]

She is the best female house guest though, just not the best female player, that honor goes to either Jun, Danielle R. or Maggie.

[Udanax]

:joker: @ Danielle D

[SoBig]

Janelle is easily the best female player in BB history
:joker:

Danielle Reyes is easily the best female BB player.
She is the best female house guest though, just not the best female player, that honor goes to either Jun, Danielle D. or Maggie.
Daniele Donato? :shocked:

Another great competitor, but a horrible social and strategic player. Janelle is definitely a better player than her.

[JerseyWins]

Did Danielle Reyes do some crazy stuff in Season 3? Cause she definitely wasn't bad in the all stars season but nothing to get so much praise that I always see her getting. I'm guessing the praise is mostly from 3.

Daniele Donato was an ok / sort of good game player and awesome competitor. Janelle was probably an even better competitor but truly not that good of a player.

[Marc]

Yeah she called the shots in S3 IIRC.

[SoBig]

Did Danielle Reyes do some crazy stuff in Season 3? Cause she definitely wasn't bad in the all stars season but nothing to get so much praise that I always see her getting. I'm guessing the praise is mostly from 3.

Daniele Donato was an ok / sort of good game player and awesome competitor. Janelle was probably an even better competitor but truly not that good of a player.
Neither are good game players. Daniele's social and strategic game in BB8 was horrendous and in BB13 she was in the perfect position to win once Dick left and she still managed to screwed it up by overplaying. And she got played by Jeff of all people.

Danielle Reyes played a great game in BB3.

[karl100589]

It's been a while but part three of the video is up, counting from number 30 to 21:

?v=w_p1Wop2yAw&feature=youtu.be

[Calderyon]

Daniele Donato? :shocked:

Another great competitor, but a horrible social and strategic player. Janelle is definitely a better player than her.

Oops... i meant Danielle R. :hehe:

Daniele D. was all right in BB 8, but although a little more maturer in BB 13, still not very good strategic player.

Too emotional and personal IMO. A little like Janelle, but Janelle is way more likable.

[karl100589]

A few clues for the #20 to #11 update:

1 from series 3
2 from series 5
2 from series 6
1 from series 8
1 from series 11
2 from series 13
1 from series 15

[karl100589]

Don't want Luke to keep bumping this down.

[LukeB]

Don't want Luke to keep bumping this down.

huh?

[karl100589]

huh?

The most recently posted tpic gets shown on the main forum page. When your do your BB rewatch it bumps mine down so nobody notices my topic.

It's all a bit of fun Luke, don't take it to heart, it's childish on my part TBH.

[LukeB]

oh haha

[Raph]

haven't been watching these as I don't want to be spoiled, but is the Cody not taking Victoria thing still in the running? I couldn't believe he through away 475K so easily!

[karl100589]

haven't been watching these as I don't want to be spoiled, but is the Cody not taking Victoria thing still in the running? I couldn't believe he through away 475K so easily!


It's still there

[LukeB]

i really want to watch the video!

[karl100589]

Post 40 is the most recent update.

[Raph]

Thanks, Karl!

[JerseyWins]

Overall good choices and order

Can't wait for top 10 :hello:

[karl100589]

We go for 20 to 11 with our next update:

?v=2N99t-r9X9U&feature=youtu.be

And some clues for the top 10:

1 from BB2
1 from BB3
2 from BB8
1 from BB9
1 from BB11
1 from BB12
1 from BB13
1 from BB14
1 from BB16

[karl100589]

Anyone?

[LukeB]

I think evicting Aaryn over Andy was a bad idea. because Andy set up Elissa's eviction! she could of done well if it wasn't for him

[Raph]

waiting for top 10 tbh

[JerseyWins]

^ That

Top 10 is gonna be hype :dance:

[karl100589]

What does everyone think is going to be in the top 10?

[Calderyon]

BB2 is probably Nicole evicting Monica instead of Will in the final 3 or housemates evicting Bunky instead of Will.
1 from BB3 - If the Marcellas not using the VETO has not come up, then that. Otherwise, maybe Danielle not controlling herself in the diary room the whole season. Gerry evicting Lisa instead of Eric on week 4. Gerry using the VETO on Marcellas week 1 and making him one of the biggest targets in the game.
BB8 - Eric not using the Veto to get Evel Dick backdoored on final 8, i think.
1 from BB9 - Ryan choosing to face Adam in the final 2 instead of Sharon, maybe.
1 from BB11 - Russell conspiring against Jeff in the final 6 or Jeff falling for the "lie that turned out to be true" and then nominating and evicting Russell instead of Natalie.
1 from BB12 - Rachel getting Kristen out instead of Hayden or Lane answering truthfully in Enzo´s question in the final. Matt using the DPOV to evict Kathy instead of someone from the Brigade and then afterwards throwing the HOH feeling too safe.
1 from BB13 - Keith throwing the first VETO or Lawon´s special powers eviction (not sure if it has come up yet)
1 from BB14 - Ian not using the second VETO (from the price machine) or HM not evicting Frank instead of Kara on Week 1. Or Dan as the HOH getting Jenn out instead of Danielle in thr final 4.
1 from BB16 - Cody choosing to take Derrick in the final 2 instead of Victoria.

[SoBig]

McCrae getting rid of Elissa was beyond stupid. He knew Elissa was with him and that Andy was lying.

I don't think Jenn using the veto on Dan to get rid of Britney was a bad move. Dan would have stayed with Frank/Jenn if Ian didn't win HOH the following week. They were by themselves and needed allies. Britney and Shane weren't ever going to align with them.

[JerseyWins]

^ Agreed with the first part, McCrae should've probably been higher on this list. Kinda agree with the second part too. That whole thing was more so genius by Dan than dumb by Jenn/Frank.

[karl100589]

For the record I agree to an extent with Frank and Jenn keeping Dan, it's one of the reasons I put it mid pack, but the reason I put it on the list was that for almost nearly a month Franks sole goal in the game was to get Dan out, and now that he finally had it he decided to keep him around instead. I agree that Frank had nothing to lose so I understand why he took the chance aligning with Dan, but in my opinion Dan would have looked to reunite the quack pack and take Frank out as soon as he possibly could, he was lucky it happened the week after.

[karl100589]

BB2 is probably Nicole evicting Monica instead of Will in the final 3 or housemates evicting Bunky instead of Will.
1 from BB3 - If the Marcellas not using the VETO has not come up, then that. Otherwise, maybe Danielle not controlling herself in the diary room the whole season. Gerry evicting Lisa instead of Eric on week 4. Gerry using the VETO on Marcellas week 1 and making him one of the biggest targets in the game.
BB8 - Eric not using the Veto to get Evel Dick backdoored on final 8, i think.
1 from BB9 - Ryan choosing to face Adam in the final 2 instead of Sharon, maybe.
1 from BB11 - Russell conspiring against Jeff in the final 6 or Jeff falling for the "lie that turned out to be true" and then nominating and evicting Russell instead of Natalie.
1 from BB12 - Rachel getting Kristen out instead of Hayden or Lane answering truthfully in Enzo´s question in the final. Matt using the DPOV to evict Kathy instead of someone from the Brigade and then afterwards throwing the HOH feeling too safe.
1 from BB13 - Keith throwing the first VETO or Lawon´s special powers eviction (not sure if it has come up yet)
1 from BB14 - Ian not using the second VETO (from the price machine) or HM not evicting Frank instead of Kara on Week 1. Or Dan as the HOH getting Jenn out instead of Danielle in thr final 4.
1 from BB16 - Cody choosing to take Derrick in the final 2 instead of Victoria.


6 out of 10 are correct

[Calderyon]

^ Could you tell me which of them are incorrect via PM?

[karl100589]

And the long-awaited top ten has finally arrived:
7nhN8fP1_cE

[JerseyWins]

Lawon deserving for #1 definitely. :joker:

And even though I like her, I think Danielle's move should've been closer to #1 on the list, maybe top 5.

Really good top 10. :clap1:

[SoBig]

I wouldn't put Dustin's move in the top 10. Dick was 100% going to be evicted until America told Eric to save him. Dustin had no way of knowing that Eric was America's player.

[LemonJam]

Great list Karl :clap1: