Should Groups SK and OTY "axe" Louis

[alex_front2]

Louis has lost 2 acts and talked about axing 2 from SK and kept messing OTY song choices, should get together to axe Louis.

[Crimson Dynamo]

Do you mean not do a 30 second to camera piece on the friday with louis

Becuase thats what being mentored by him means

[joeysteele]

No, they probably wouldn't get much better mentoring from the others.

I really don't think any judge would know what to really do with them or how to handle them,and the themes make it even harder to bring out all the positives as to them.

Louis is wise to let them do their own thing and just be there to advise if needed.

[GoldHeart]

groups are annoying!! and louis is a rubbish mentor he never knows what to do with his acts!
OTY were something different and use to be ok but instead of getting better each week they keep getting weaker :rolleyes: maybe its to do with the wrong song choices but their vocals aren't that good

SK were crap and irritating from day 1 too many of them and not strong enough but tonight they were slightly better but i still dont like them :nono:

[alex_front2]

No, they probably wouldn't get much better mentoring from the others.

I really don't think any judge would know what to really do with them or how to handle them,and the themes make it even harder to bring out all the positives as to them.

Louis is wise to let them do their own thing and just be there to advise if needed.

But Louis doesn't let them do their own thing. On Xtra Factor they admitted they prefer older songs, Boom Clap is from this year (Charlie MCX)

[andybigbro]

Nah, Louis knows what he is doing.

He gets a lot of criticism but he has managed very successful groups.

[Jamesy]

Louis knows what he's doing.

The whole disagreements we see are just small sections taken out of a long week, to add drama and make the show interesting.

[joeysteele]

But Louis doesn't let them do their own thing. On Xtra Factor they admitted they prefer older songs, Boom Clap is from this year (Charlie MCX)

Agreed,I take your point.
For me however I think it worked and they were having difficulty too with the choices anyway.
He is right to steer them to not only do old songs.

As I said earlier, I doubt any of the judges would know what to do with them but the advice was to do a modern song and it will be seen later as to if that was the right thing to do this week.

I think it was the best thing to do for this week at least.

[Cherie]

Nah, Louis knows what he is doing.

He gets a lot of criticism but he has managed very successful groups.

Louis gets paid well to be the fall guy, he knows more about managing an act than Mel B or Cheryl

[joeysteele]

But Louis doesn't let them do their own thing. On Xtra Factor they admitted they prefer older songs, Boom Clap is from this year (Charlie MCX)

I bow to you alex_font, you were right.
They do need to put their own and more to the point confident stamp as to their performances.