Who sang it better?

[Marc]

Alexandra Burke

K3hsoyW03po

Sam Bailey

mCylXy-IRGU

Andrea Faustini

68PGPC27NCw

[Liam-]

I love all 3 of them and Andrea was incredible.. but Alexandra tore it a new asshole.

[LukeB]

Alexandra

[Jessica.]

I listened to the three videos and decided purely on voice alone, that Sam sang it the best out of the selection. (I didn't watch her series or the current one)

[Raph]

Alexandra > Sam >>>>>>>>>>>> shrieking andre

[LukeB]

Alexandra > tamera > sam > andrea

[Jessica.]

Alexandra > Sam >>>>>>>>>>>> shrieking andre

I would rank them in that order too, he has great potential, but with that song he sounds like he is trying to communicate with a whale.

[Liam-]

'shrieking' elohel

[andybigbro]

Alexandra

[Jamesy]

Vocals - Sam > Alexandra > Andrea

Performance - Alexandra > Sam > Andrea

[GypsyGoth]

Alexandra :flutter:

[Crimson Dynamo]

Sadly i have to say Alexandra

the winning flopmeister

[joeysteele]

Alexandra for me.

[Black Dagger]

Andrea solo.

But when you added Beyonce into the mix, Alexandra and her had one of the greatest moments on the show ever.

[Adamw92]

Alexandra slays them both

[Vanessa]

I love Andrea version of the song. Last night he was phenomenal! :flutter:

[Amy Jade]

Sorry to Andrea fans but he screeched that song with no emotion. Sam was good but Alexandra beats both. She performed the song where the other two just sang it.

[Mystic Mock]

1. Alexandra (The only XF performance I really liked of hers)
2. Andrea
3. Sam
4. Tamera

[Mystic Mock]

1. Alexandra (The only XF performance I really liked of hers)
2. Andrea
3. Sam
4. Tamera