Best Singing Reailty TV Show Winner

[Arneldo]

Who is the best winner of a singing Reailty show?

Here is a list of all the winner i could remember (Sorry if i left anyone out). I've also added a clip of each winners debut singles, except David Snedden's because i couldnt find it on Youtube.

Will Young (Pop Idol 1)
Evergreen (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kHvJRpiN5Cg)
Michelle MacManus (Pop Idol 2)
All This Time (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TF4p-r71WtA&mode=related&search= )
Six (Poptars Ireland)
A Whole lotta' Luvin (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q_aTXdLvHKM)
Hear'Say (Popstars 1)
Pure & Simple (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lyy78Ok07Oc)
Girls Aloud (Popstars: The Rivals)
Sound Of the Underground (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EfU3CtbVmpM)
David Sneddon (Fame Acadamy 1)
Could Not Find Video.
Alex Parks (Fame Acadamy 2)
Maybe Thats What It Takes (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GmzSOJwCIzY )
Steve Brookstein (The X Factor 1)
Against All Odds (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yhQcQ8M8yyg)
Shayne Ward (The X Factor 2)
That's My Goal (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dTmCpw_45MU)
Leona Lewis (The X Factor 3)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D0lasOYPv-w (A Moment Like This)

[Chrizzle]

Leona!

Then Girls Aloud

[MarkWaldorf]

Girls Aloud.

[Sophii3x]

Im saying Girls Aloud

Even though I'm not a fan I think they have been the biggest sucess
out of all of them :thumbs:

[BB-Rocks]

Originally posted by Sophii3x
Im saying Girls Aloud

Even though I'm not a fan I think they have been the biggest sucess
out of all of them :thumbs:

Ditto!

Their the only winners thats really stayed around and they now have a greatest hit album

[Sophii3x]

Originally posted by BB-Rocks
Originally posted by Sophii3x
Im saying Girls Aloud

Even though I'm not a fan I think they have been the biggest sucess
out of all of them :thumbs:

Ditto!

Their the only winners thats really stayed around and they now have a greatest hit album

Yup:hugesmile:

[Arneldo]

Will by a Mile.

[BigSister]

I agree with aaron then Leona

[lilmissnaughty]

good to see no one has voted for Gorgrinzola [Steve] Brookstein :thumbs:

I went for Leona

[Arneldo]

If i had to rank them, it would be:

1. Will
2. Leona
3. Shayne
4. Girls Aloud
5. Michelle MacManus
6. Steve Brookstein
7. Alex Parks
8. David Sneddon
9. Six
10. Hear'Say

[Bells]

The majority of them were really popular at the time, weren't they?
And those who have continued in the limelight are of course Will Young, Girls Aloud etc., so they're all successful.

Voted for Leona though.

[lily.]

GA for me. They have stuck around and managed to keep it up to date.

[Lance]

Will, most definately.

GA second.:thumbs:

[Noopie]

Leona Lewis (voice-wise)

[Legend]

I voted Will Young as he's personally my favourite but GA too as there seems to be no stopping them which is great.

[Princess]

Hear'say but only cos I was obsessed with them for about a year well however long they were together! Haha I remember Six! I have their single! Wasn't Nadine supposed to be in Six but was too young?

[Arneldo]

Originally posted by Princess
Hear'say but only cos I was obsessed with them for about a year well however long they were together! Haha I remember Six! I have their single! Wasn't Nadine supposed to be in Six but was too young?

Yeah she was only 16. She was in the band and the day before She was to go move into the house She was found out and sent home and they had to get in a replacement.

[sol]

Leona and Girls Aloud.

[Dan_]

1. Will
2. Shayne
3. Leona
4. David Sneddon
5. Girls Aloud
6. Steve Brookstein
7. Alex Parks
8. Hearsay
9. Mick McManus
10. Six

[Mike]

I think Girls Aloud personally, although i like some of their music i'm not a massive fan but got to give them credit because they havent really ever been unpopular and even now their still gaining more and more fans.

[SiMoN!]

will young has the best voice i think

[andybigbro]

Girls Aloud Or Will Young as they have been most sucessfull

[Ruth*Star]

Leona Lewis Followed by Girls Aloud

[Nicola]

I like most of them, but my top 2 are Shayne Ward and Will Young.

[duaxeallowed]

GIRLS ALOUD!!!