BB15 vs BB16

[Daniel.]

Which do you prefer now we've pretty much seen both?

Both received a bad reception by BB fans, but I will say BB16 is worse than BB15 by far. Also Ashleigh > anyone in BB16

[Daniel.]

Use this one it has a poll

http://cdn.thisisbigbrother.com/customavatars/avatar80210_151.gif

[Pete.]

BB15 because at least it was entertaining regardless of how painfully bad production was

[Liam-]

16.

[LukeB]

BB16,

BB15 was messy + the casting was just awful imo

[Daniel.]

16.

BB16,

BB15 was messy + the casting was just awful imo

This series casting has been way worse and production has been FAR worse

[Pete.]

I never thought that I would hate a series where Nikki, Aisleyne and Charley were housemates :(

[EspeonBB]

BB15 had Ashleigh so it's better than BB16 for me (both are awful tho)

[Daniel.]

I never thought that I would hate a series where Nikki, Aisleyne and Charley were housemates :(

They save it in some way, I still rank 12 worse than this because of them three making an appearance. If it wasn't for them three (and Jasmine) then it would be the worst ever.

[Pete.]

They save it in some way, I still rank 12 worse than this because of them three making an appearance. If it wasn't for them three (and Jasmine) then it would be the worst ever.
Yes

[Daniel.]

Tragic @ this poll being equal

[lewis111]

They both have the same negative points, so we could say this one was worse as BB15 was a trial for a twist series, it didnt work, so they should have left it, but they just am it bigger and badder

[Daniel.]

I'm really surprised BB15 isn't on 100% :unsure:

[Jason.]

Eh?

Aisleyne and Nikki, and all the other legends were one of the reasons why this series sucked. Don't get me wrong, I like Aisleyne.

But, those legends outstayed their welcome, and it just became a mess. The show was constantly about them for 2 weeks, with the original housemates being fillers in their own series, and not getting a second of airtime. It was unfair.

Those 2 weeks were pretty much an All Stars series. Not to mention how unorganised it was. You went from having 3 legends entering the bunker for a week, then extending their stay, then adding Aisleyne, and then the Hotel BB thing. It was just a mess.

I wouldn't have mind, if it had just been the 3 legends going into the bunker for ONE WEEK, as planned. Instead of making them stay longer, and adding a bunch of other ex-housemates too.

Although, seeing Charley again. :lovedup:

[Wojtek]

BB15

[Withano]

Neither. I suppose if you forced me, id go 16 cos there is a 4/6 chance that the winner will not be vile subhuman scum

[Calderyon]

It´s hard. Helen (and Pauline) ruined BB15, but producers themselves ruined BB16.

[Daniel.]

Pauline was one of the few good things about BB15

[GLENN BILL BB7]

BB16 is Better!

BB15 had Awful housemates (So does BB16 but not as much), Crap house, Vile winner.

[Jay.]

BB16, far better casting. Yeah, it got crap, but the people were much nicer. And I had quite a few favourites.

[Calderyon]

Pauline was one of the few good things about BB15

Nah... She was horrible. And she was the one that gave Helen the final pass to enable her to slide by and win.

[Daniel.]

BB16 is Better!

BB15 had Awful housemates (So does BB16 but not as much), Crap house, Vile winner.

BB16's housemates are worse, BB15 had Ashleigh, Danielle and Toya who are a million miles better than anyone in this series, also it was entertaining for the first month. BB16 wasn't/

BB16, far better casting. Yeah, it got crap, but the people were much nicer. And I had quite a few favourites.

BB16 had a terrible cast, no big outrageous characters like Toya, Danielle and Biannca and you loved BB15 at the time :unsure:

Nah... She was horrible. And she was the one that gave Helen the final pass to enable her to slide by and win.

She was hilarious

[Headie]

BB16 had a stronger female cast but they were all evicted early so didn't really get to shine.

I felt more invested with BB15 and people like Toya, Ashleigh, Danielle etc.

Both are awful but BB16 only had 2 good weeks whereas BB15 had 3 good weeks so BB15 just edges it.

[Jack_]

It's hard to say because I have actually quite enjoyed this series and I've been surprised that I've done so. The production values have been the worst of any show I have ever watched and are probably the worst in television history, but it's not been that bad.

I find BB15 really underrated and I really enjoyed it (plus the final two is the most deserving and perfect ever so it gives it more marks for me) so really it's comparing two series I actually liked. And BB16 had the legends whom for a time worked really well, so idk.

I'll say BB15 because of the abysmal production this year.

[Pete.]

Nah... She was horrible. And she was the one that gave Helen the final pass to enable her to slide by and win.
She was awful I agree

[Ramsay]

I got to maybe Day 3 of BB15, at least i got through all of this as awful as it has been

[joeysteele]

The horrendous messing about with this series, all the publicity mad has beens and winners going in an out from past series, the near discontinuation of anything resembling normal nominations will never have me voting this series better over any other.

For me, this is the worst ever and no last few weeks of how it should have been from the start, will alter that for me at all.

So BB15 for me.

[VanessaFeltz.]

Bb16 10 50.00%

wtf:facepalm::umm2::umm2:

[JeanP!]

BB15

Brilliant winner :)

[Lostie!]

It's a tough one, they were both promising series that descended into utter trash (imo). I'd say the final week of BB16 has been even more tedious than that of BB15, but then there's BB15's godawful winner. BB16 could have a terrible winner too, but likely not as odious as Helen.

[bots]

if there is a civilian BB next year, my prediction is we will be saying 16 is better than 17

[goldensunlight]

These two series are very close for me. I probably enjoyed the housemates more last year as they were more interesting as a whole (despite some awful evictions), but I've been quite invested in this series even though I didn't watch from the start. I went with BB15 though.

[Daniel.]

Bump now both are over and we've had time to reflect

I still say BB15 was better

[Daniel.]

tbh

[Daniel.]

BB15 winning :clap1:

It was still beyond awful though.

[Jason.]

Why do you like bumping these old poll threads? :laugh:

Both awful series IMO. By awful I mean BB lows. But I went for BB15, because BB16 had an even more abysmal production, and a crap eviction order. Plus BB15 still felt like BB, whereas BB16 didn't.

The only thing that BB16 beats BB15 in is the cast (well the female one anyway) and tasks.

[Daniel.]

Because I find them interesting, is there a problem here fat?

[Jason.]

Because I find them interesting, is there a problem here fat?

Is that an overstatement?

[Ashley.]

I chose BB15 but it's basically like choosing between two potatoes

[Dominic]

15 >

[Cal.]

BB15 by far.

[MB.]

Jaustin

[Cal.]

Why do you like bumping these old poll threads? :laugh:

Both awful series IMO. By awful I mean BB lows. But I went for BB15, because BB16 had an even more abysmal production, and a crap eviction order. Plus BB15 still felt like BB, whereas BB16 didn't.

The only thing that BB16 beats BB15 in is the cast (well the female one anyway) and tasks.

The BB15 female cast was amazing? Helen, Ashleigh, Danielle, Pauline, Toya, Biannca>>>>

[MB.]

The BB16 cast was absolute leagues ahead of the BB15 one

[MB.]

(especially the female cast)

[Daniel.]

Ashleigh and Danielle > the bb16 female cast combined sorry

[Jake.]

Danielle was great and one of the better 5 has come out with but to this day I refuse to agree that Toya was a good housemate. She was wank.

[Ross.]

BB16 >

Although Danielle > life itself

[Daniel.]

Ashleigh > Danielle

[Marsh.]

to this day I refuse to agree that Toya was a good housemate. She was wank.

:clap1:

[Jake.]

Ashleigh > Danielle

nah, Danielle's personality/act/what she brought to the table >>

[Marsh.]

First two weeks of BB16 >>>>>>>>>>>>>> Rest of BB16 >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> BB15

[LukeB]

First two weeks of BB16 >>>>>>>>>>>>>> Rest of BB16 >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> BB15

pretty much this

[Jason.]

First two weeks of BB16 >>>>>>>>>>>>>> Rest of BB16 >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> BB15

In other words

BB16 > BB15

[Jake.]

First two weeks of BB16 >>>>>>>>>>>>>> Rest of BB16 >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> BB15

pretty much

[Ross.]

First two weeks of BB16 >>>>>>>>>>>>>> Rest of BB16 >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> BB15

yes

[Ross.]

nah, Danielle's personality/act/what she brought to the table >>

also yes

[Marsh.]

In other words

BB16 > BB15

Yes but I need to differentiate between the potential we saw at the start to the mess it became when all the major twists hit. :laugh:

[Jason.]

First two weeks of BB16 >>> First 3 weeks of BB15 >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Rest of BB15 >>>> Rest of BB16

for me

[LukeB]

nah, Danielle's personality/act/what she brought to the table >>

I agree

[Daniel.]

First three weeks of BB15> Post Marc/money bomb BB16 > First two weeks of BB16 > Second half of BB15 >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> BB16 with Marc there.

[Marsh.]

First three weeks of BB15> Post Marc/money bomb BB16 > First two weeks of BB16 > Second half of BB15 >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> BB16 with Marc there.

A MESS

[Jason.]

BB16 post 4in4out was awful regardless if Marc was there or not. TBH, I think Timewarp week also added to the awfulness of BB16.

I like the idea of ex-housemates going in, but it became messy with what extending their stay an extra week, and throwing Aisleyne in randomly halfway through. It felt so unplanned and made up as they went along.

[Daniel.]

I really enjoyed money bomb post Marc.

[Jason.]

Moneybomb :joker:

[Marsh.]

Money bomb lost us Sam so shut up fat.

[Daniel.]

BB16 post 4in4out was awful regardless if Marc was there or not. TBH, I think Timewarp week also added to the awfulness of BB16.

I like the idea of ex-housemates going in, but it became messy with what extending their stay an extra week, and throwing Aisleyne in randomly halfway through. It felt so unplanned and made up as they went along.

Nah, Marc single handily ruined it for me. Suxh a ****ing crap hm who might actually be worse than conor

[Daniel.]

Money bomb lost us Sam so shut up fat.

She was an overrated bore

[Jason.]

Marc was awful. But lbr here, the production ruined BB16.

[Jake.]

I hated the cash week crap

[Marsh.]

She was an overrated bore

She was a shining beacon in a wasteland of a series.

[Jason.]

Same Jake.

By then I'd fully given up on the series.

[Jake.]

Same Jake.

By then I'd fully given up on the series.

Yeah, after Sam's eviction I didn't watch again until the final

[EspeonBB]

I hate both but BB15 >>>

BB16 has more good housemates but they all left by the halfway point whilst Ashleigh and Danielle lasted a long time in BB15

[MB.]

I hate both but BB15 >>>

BB16 has more good housemates but they all left by the halfway point whilst Ashleigh and Danielle lasted a long time in BB15

Harry and Chloe and to some extent Sam lasted until at least Day 60

[Jason.]

The BB16 cast was actually really good (well the female one was anyway) and was definitely an improvement on BB15's trashy Apprentice-esque cast. They were just wasted on an awful series. And the eviction results were beyond tragic.

[Marsh.]

:joker: Apprentice cast.

Apart from entering on launch night in suits and tight dresses they were the thickest bunch to ever enter.

[Jason.]

:joker: Apprentice cast.

Apart from entering on launch night in suits and tight dresses they were the thickest bunch to ever enter.

That's why I said trashy :smug:

But yeah, I agree with the BIB

[MB.]

That's why I said trashy :smug:

*edited it in

(but imagine Sarah Dales going on a Power Trip (and giving Steven a pass to the final) why did this not happen I want answers)

[Jason.]

*edited it in

(but imagine Sarah Dales going on a Power Trip (and giving Steven a pass to the final) why did this not happen I want answers)

I edited in the last sentence actually. :hmph:

I don't know what Sarah is like, but I'd like to think I would've liked her.

[EspeonBB]

*edited it in

(but imagine Sarah Dales going on a Power Trip (and giving Steven a pass to the final) why did this not happen I want answers)

This is the stuff dreams are made of

[Lostie!]

BB16 > BB15 but they're both pieces of absolute crap beyond the first few weeks.

[uniquedude]

I dragged myself through the last 6 weeks of bb15.
I dragged myself through the last 8 weeks of bb16
Therefore bb15 wins plus it had better housemates.

[Ant.]

Depends, both of the casts were good, in some sense. I loved Chloe, Nick, the twins, and Sam in BB16, but I also loved Ashleigh, Chris, Christopher, and Toya
I enjoyed a lot of BB16s tasks, and I enjoyed Timewarp week (I liked Nikki and Aisleyne, even if Aisleyne pretty much destroyed her reputation) but 4in4out ruined it for me

[Daniel.]

I'm not ready for another series like these two.

[Daniel.]

I'm not ready for another series like these two..

[Daniel.]

/

[Calderyon]

It´s a tough choice. Both were almost equally bad. You would have to assess which one was less bad than the other and it´s a hard job to do. Still undecided.

[_Tom_]

BB15 by a small margin.

I stopped watching BB16 in its final week (until the finale) as there was not a single HM I liked/could root for.