Winter vs Summer CBB

[Jake.]

I know the poll will completely go in Winters favour, but (on channel 5), which do you prefer/which has produced the better series?

[Pete.]

Winter!

[Cal.]

Winter - they usually have the better celebs, CBB feels better and the higher viewing figures just add to the enjoyment of it.

[waterhog]

I like any cbb. great to watch.

[LukeB]

Winter

Summer CBB needs axing, this years was good but they should only be 1 CBB a year

[Pete.]

13 > 15 > 9 > 11

vs

16 > 12 > 10 > 14 > 8

Winter outweighs mainly because stellar series 9 is 3rd :omgno:

[Shaun]

I've liked more of the summer ones so :shrug:

11 and 9 were trash, 13 was very irritating and had no one to root for, and 15 was good.

[Oaker]

Winter, but CBB16 is better than all of C5's winter CBB's.

[zakman440]

Winter. Whilst I've found this summer series amazing, I do still think that it's overkill that CBB is on twice a year and that it should be taken back to 1 winter CBB and 1 summer civilian BB.

[Jake.]

For me CBB8 is the only dud summer series, whereas 11 was ****e and 15 got far too repetitve after the first two weeks

16 > 9 > 12/10> 15/14/13 > 11 > 8

[LukeB]

Tbh CBB8/CBB14 are the only awful summer CBBs

[MB.]

14 > 13

Oh you did not just

[Jake.]

and yeh i could also agree with the notation that there should only be one a year but if the civilian series keep on the trend they're on atm then I'm all for summer cbb continuing

[Daniel.]

Both have good points, but I liked all of the winter ones except CBB11, CBB9 in particular was amazing :love:

I liked all summer CBB's too except CBB8 but post Frenchy CBB14 was trash

[Lostie!]

My ranking would probably go:

CBB16 > CBB9 > CBB15 > CBB14 > CBB13 > CBB10 > CBB12 > CBB11 > CBB8

so it seems pretty mixed for me, I'm really not sure. Winter CBB has 2/3 of my top 3 though.

[Jake.]

Oh you did not just

meant to have it next to 15/14 :laugh:

[Stevep]

Winter. Whilst I've found this summer series amazing, I do still think that it's overkill that CBB is on twice a year and that it should be taken back to 1 winter CBB and 1 summer civilian BB.

CBB brings in higher viewing figures, can't see them changing anything anytime soon, unless they shorten the civilian series and extend both CBBs(which i'd be in favour of).

[Oaker]

CBB14 is so overrated, it seriously sucked apart from the one episode of Frenchy vs Leslie

[Pete.]

CBB14 is so overrated, it seriously sucked apart from the one episode of Frenchy vs Leslie
Yeah it's awful :joker:

[Daniel-X]

Winter for me by far. I'd rank them.

15 > 13 > 9 > 16 > 10 > 14 > 8 > 12 > 11

[MB.]

CBB brings in higher viewing figures, can't see them changing anything anytime soon, unless they shorten the civilian series and extend both CBBs(which i'd be in favour of).

I wouldn't even mind if they axed civilian BB altogether and spent all their time on money on CBB, if they keep insisting on doing two per year

[EspeonBB]

Winter CBB feels like more of an 'event' and usually has better celebs which adds to the enjoyment of it all. Plus summer CBB comes only a couple of weeks after civilian BB and it feels like BB has been on for ages at that point and can get a little draining.

Also CBB9 & CBB13 are two of my fave CBB series (as well as CBB16)

[MB.]

I wouldn't even mind if they axed civilian BB altogether and spent all their time on money on CBB, if they keep insisting on doing two per year

(does that make me a bad Big Brother fan)

[Stevep]

I wouldn't even mind if they axed civilian BB altogether and spent all their time on money on CBB, if they keep insisting on doing two per year

I'd definitely be in favour of that, i don't bother with the civilian series anymore myself.

[Daniel.]

16 > 9 > 15 > 13 > 10 > 14 > 12 > 8 > 11

[Jake.]

(does that make me a bad Big Brother fan)

nope

[LukeB]

CBB14 is so overrated, it seriously sucked apart from the one episode of Frenchy vs Leslie

I agree,it fell flat after the amazing 1 week they had, but a good CBB has to be good throughout which CBB14 wasn't.

[EspeonBB]

For me:
16 >> 9 > 13 >>> 12 >>>> 14/15 >>>>>> 11

I haven't seen 8 or 10

[Firewire]

Both have good and bad points

9 and 13 are amazing but 16 has also been very good and I really enjoyed series 10

[Oaker]

I would say; 16 > 13 > 9 > 15 > 10 > 12 > 14 > 11 > 8