John disliking Stephanie

[LukeB]

I know people are entitled to their opinions on people etc.. but John disliking Stephanie seems really odd and strange, it came out of no where..I think he's only disliking her because it's a popular opinion and wants to please the public.. 'redemption' We already saw him lie about "the only one being Tiffany's friend" when he was trying to get her to leave.But he knows Tiffany is popular so yet again trying to please the public

[mr rochester]

Completely agree with him re; Selfish Steph...

[delta]

Surprised?

He's one of life haters, a poisonous tw@t.

[Kazanne]

I know people are entitled to their opinions on people etc.. but John disliking Stephanie seems really odd and strange, it came out of no where..I think he's only disliking her because it's a popular opinion and wants to please the public.. 'redemption' We already saw him lie about "the only one being Tiffany's friend" when he was trying to get her to leave.But he knows Tiffany is popular so yet again trying to please the public

He didn't say he disliked her now did he but keep making things up if it makes you feel better,he said He was fed up of hearing the Jeremy thing all the time and he didn't want to play strip poker:shrug: as for the Jeremy thing ,I like Steph but when people go on about the same old ****,it gets on your nerves.

[LukeB]

He didn't say he disliked her now did he but keep making things up if it makes you feel better,he said He was fed up of hearing the Jeremy thing all the time and he didn't want to play strip poker:shrug: as for the Jeremy thing ,I like Steph but when people go on about the same old ****,it gets on your nerves.

Did I say he said those words? he's only bitching about Stephanie because of the public.. sheep :sleep:

[billy123]

She is a horrid needy little brat though what is to like about her.

[Kazanne]

Did I say he said those words? he's only bitching about Stephanie because of the public.. sheep :sleep:

You put it in your title:shrug: I get you don't like him but pardon him for breathing, how is he bitching saying her going on about the same thing is annoying:shrug: nothing to do with the public.

[joeysteele]

I am surprised it has taken him this long to see what I have seen as to her near all the series.
A selfish, disrespectful and untrustworthy waste of space is how I see her, I am quite glad to see John has joined that road of thought as to her a little as to my view.

[Jason.]

First time I've agreed with him.

[Visage]

I don't think John really dislikes Steph, I think John is trying to go where the crowd are going. He had cheers the first week then was hit with boos and since then I've seen a pattern where he's going along with what he hears. I expect him to have a different approach after seeing Steph won tonight's public vote.

I don't think he's as horrid as people make out, he just wants to go with the flow.


Of course, I could be totally wrong, but that's how I see it.

[Niamh.]

He's not wrong though, she's annoying the **** out of everyone in there

[Visage]

He's not wrong though, she's annoying the **** out of everyone in there

And I'm loving it:cheer2:

[LukeB]

He's not wrong though, she's annoying the **** out of everyone in there

It would have been better if he really thought that and not saying it for the camera though :laugh:

[Niamh.]

It would have been better if he really thought that and not saying it for the camera though :laugh:


Well, I agree with everything he said about her so I have no problem believing him :p

[Kazanne]

It would have been better if he really thought that and not saying it for the camera though :laugh:

if they all did that there would be no show

[Jason.]

It would have been better if he really thought that and not saying it for the camera though :laugh:

How do you know he said it for the camera though. It's like any housemate who dares to dislike Stephanie in there is a "sheep" in your eyes. It was the same with Danniella. Maybe they just don't like living with her. Simple as. :shrug: Hence why she's had the most nominations and faced eviction like five times.

[LukeB]

How do you know he said it for the camera though. It's like any housemate who dares to dislike Stephanie in there is a "sheep" in your eyes. It was the same with Danniella. Maybe they just don't like living with her. Simple as. :shrug: Hence why she's had the most nominations and faced eviction like five times.

Because he is the biggest gameplayer there:shrug: first lying about being Tiffany's only friend because he knows she is popular and this random bitching about Stephanie. Not really, I'm not even a fan of Stephanie and I don't recall me saying that at all :think:

[Cherie]

if they all did that there would be no show

:laugh:

[Kazanne]

Because he is the biggest gameplayer there:shrug: first lying about being Tiffany's only friend because he knows she is popular and this random bitching about Stephanie. Not really, I'm not even a fan of Stephanie and I don't recall me saying that at all :think:

You need to let your hatred of John go it's not healthy,you are hallucinating:hehe:

[LukeB]

You need to let your hatred of John go it's not healthy,you are hallucinating:hehe:

I hate john the same way you hate gemma :think:

[Amy Jade]

His opinions of people do flip according to their reception during evictions, I agree. I also think he starts hating on people according to their popularity with other housemates.

• Kristina topped the first vote and he was all over her, they were inseparable.

• Tiffany was unpopular in the house and he lead the attempt to force her to leave the house.

• Started suddenly loving Tiffany after she got cheers and won a public vote and proclaimed himself her 'only friend' even though previously he had done the above...

• Heard Steph getting boos and decided to become more vocal about her.

I mean the proof is there really, he's trying to please the public.

[Kazanne]

I hate john the same way you hate gemma :think:

I don't hate Gemma,big difference,I don't hate anyone I don't know,i didn't LIKE her that's all and tbh that's a bit of an immature reaction.

[Amy Jade]

You need to let your hatred of John go it's not healthy,you are hallucinating:hehe:
Shame you're not as quick to dish out that advice to your good friends on the forum who make their daily very disrespectful threads about Tiffany :hee:

[Kazanne]

Shame you're not as quick to dish out that advice to your good friends on the forum who make their daily very disrespectful threads about Tiffany :hee:

And it's a shame you don't mind your own business . Who on earth would tell others what they can post?

[LukeB]

And it's a shame you don't mind your own business . Who on earth would tell others what they can post?

didn't you say I have to let my John hate go?:laugh:

[Kazanne]

didn't you say I have to let my John hate go?:laugh:

What has that to do with your friend telling me I need to tell others what they should post?

[rusticgal]

I don't like John...he is a massive crowd pleaser. She's been booed but she's been saved...so she's a threat in some ways but he can gain points by dragging her.
I think they all must be feeling the same way...because Steph is one needy selfish bitch who thinks life revolves around her...so he is right.

[Amy Jade]

And it's a shame you don't mind your own business

You posted on the forum in a thread that any member can post their views that makes it anyone's business.

Who on earth would tell others what they can post?
Do you not see the irony in what you told Luke and you telling me to mind my own business and then asking who tells others what they can post? :laugh::facepalm:

[Kazanne]

You posted on the forum in a thread that any member can post their views that makes it anyone's business.


Do you not see the irony in what you told Luke and you telling me to mind my own business and then asking who tells others what they can post? :laugh::facepalm:

Whatever you're on can I have some:laugh: You said I should give advice to my friends about what they post about Tiffany, why should I ? their opinions are theirs not mine,what gives you the right to tell me what I should say to friends? I was talking about a housemate to Luke,you got personal,you who call people out for dissing people and you do it yourself,the hypocrisy is real.I did not tell Luke what to post as he will confirm I said he should let go of his hate for John as it wasn't healthy!!!which was said tongue and cheek hence the smilie,but that bypassed you.

[bots]

well the maturity of this thread took a quick dive

Speaking personally, i find it very draining when housemates that are not deemed the forum clique favourite are just attacked at every corner. The trivialities raised as faults when every cast member is human, is just so very tiresome

[Amy Jade]

I didn't tell you what to tell your friends I simply questioned as to why you would tell Luke his opinion is hate filled but never do the same to people who clearly hate Tiffany and ridicule her for her appearance amongst other things

I also didn't get personal with you I just said I found your post ironic. Haha

[Kazanne]

well the maturity of this thread took a quick dive

Speaking personally, i find it very draining when housemates that are not deemed the forum clique favourite are just attacked at every corner. The trivialities raised as faults when every cast member is human, is just so very tiresome

:clap1::clap1::clap1:

[Amy Jade]

well the maturity of this thread took a quick dive

Speaking personally, i find it very draining when housemates that are not deemed the forum clique favourite are just attacked at every corner. The trivialities raised as faults when every cast member is human, is just so very tiresome

What forum clique? :laugh2:

[bots]

What forum clique? :laugh2:

there is a very obvious forum clique that go around hunting in packs. It just sucks all the enjoyment out of posting on this forum.

[Kazanne]

I didn't tell you what to tell your friends I simply questioned as to why you would tell Luke his opinion is hate filled but never do the same to people who clearly hate Tiffany and ridicule her for her appearance amongst other things

I also didn't get personal with you I just said I found your post ironic. Haha
.................................................. .................................................. .....
Shame you're not as quick to dish out that advice to your good friends on the forum who make their daily very disrespectful threads about Tiffany

This is your post,there was no need for it really as I said I was playing with Luke a bit,I would say that is a tad personal.people are allowed to dislike Tiffany,but if you don't think so,take it up with them,not me.

[Amy Jade]

.................................................. .................................................. .....
Shame you're not as quick to dish out that advice to your good friends on the forum who make their daily very disrespectful threads about Tiffany

This is your post,there was no need for it really as I said I was playing with Luke a bit,I would say that is a tad personal.people are allowed to dislike Tiffany,but if you don't think so,take it up with them,not me.
How is that personal? I didn't say a single word about you :shrug:

[Amy Jade]

there is a very obvious forum clique that go around hunting in packs. It just sucks all the enjoyment out of posting on this forum.
Sorry but I think that's a bit dramatic. 'Hunting in packs' like it's the Hunger Games around here

[LukeB]

Amy wasn't telling you what to do, she was questioning it. Because it does seem strange how my john dislike is a problem, tbh i don't need to do anything because my john dislike isn't that OTT like the tiffany threads, your friends make them and you don't say anything. Why should I stop making john threads? no one is being personal here.

[bots]

Sorry but I think that's a bit dramatic. 'Hunting in packs' like it's the Hunger Games around here

Its plain for anyone to see

[Amy Jade]

Its plain for anyone to see

Apparently not because I don't see it :think:

[Kazanne]

Amy wasn't telling you what to do, she was questioning it. Because it does seem strange how my john dislike is a problem, tbh i don't need to do anything because my john dislike isn't that OTT like the tiffany threads, your friends make them and you don't say anything. Why should I stop making john threads? no one is being personal here.

Luke you can make as many threads about John as you want,I don't tell my friends what to say or do ,so certainly wouldn't tell anyone else,I am not my friends keeper,you might do that with your friends :shrug:,I don't. I was talking to you about john,and it was kind of playful and now its way off topic,because some people are obsessed with Tiffany,I mean really ,people don't HAVE to like her as you don't like John,no one should really care that much.

[Kazanne]

Its plain for anyone to see

Well BOTS,I'm glad you spotted it too.

[Kazanne]

How is that personal? I didn't say a single word about you :shrug:

:facepalm:

[Northern Monkey]

John was right.She's annoying as feck and i'm no John fan.

[Amy Jade]

Luke you can make as many threads about John as you want,I don't tell my friends what to say or do ,so certainly wouldn't tell anyone else,I am not my friends keeper,you might do that with your friends :shrug:,I don't. I was talking to you about john,and it was kind of playful and now its way off topic,because some people are obsessed with Tiffany,I mean really ,people don't HAVE to like her as you don't like John,no one should really care that much.
Now who's the one getting personal?

You can't make it up honestly :laugh:

[jet]

I can't stand John. The way he flounces around in that awful dressing gown open to show his chest hair like a two - bit actor at half time. Does he own any clothes or does he just not wash them?
He thinks that everything that comes out of his mouth is the final word on any subject. Mr. Authority, Mr. Know It All and Mr. Perfect.
I don't see the appeal at all. He bores me rigid.

[Mac1978]

I can understand that Steph mightn't be the easiest to live with. So I'd say some of her housemates complaints are genuine.

But John's passive aggressive outburst at the table was a bit harsh for me. There just wasn't any need of it.

[Papillon]

I can understand that Steph mightn't be the easiest to live with. So I'd say some of her housemates complaints are genuine.

But John's passive aggressive outburst at the table was a bit harsh for me. There just wasn't any need of it.


what outburst at what table :conf:
If you are talking about the edited clip shown on BOTS last nite, it was in the living room AFTER Gemma's eviction, they were sitting on the sofas.

That so called outburst, wasn't what BOTS made out it was, very cleverly edited & completely out of context.
Steph was going on and on about hearing cheers and being saved first.
John just told her it's time for her to stop talking about Jezzer 24/7 & saying she is the most hated woman in the world.
They only have 3 days left before final, Steph should just enjoy it and put herself first. The pampering to her insecurities had to stop & I agree with John with this, Steph is a very needy Woman, not a young girl.

[waterhog]

I know people are entitled to their opinions on people etc.. but John disliking Stephanie seems really odd and strange, it came out of no where..I think he's only disliking her because it's a popular opinion and wants to please the public.. 'redemption' We already saw him lie about "the only one being Tiffany's friend" when he was trying to get her to leave.But he knows Tiffany is popular so yet again trying to please the public

john sees allot more of her then we do ie 1 hour a day. I trust his judgment.

[joeysteele]

what outburst at what table :conf:
If you are talking about the edited clip shown on BOTS last nite, it was in the living room AFTER Gemma's eviction, they were sitting on the sofas.

That so called outburst, wasn't what BOTS made out it was, very cleverly edited & completely out of context.
Steph was going on and on about hearing cheers and being saved first.
John just told her it's time for her to stop talking about Jezzer 24/7 & saying she is the most hated woman in the world.
They only have 3 days left before final, Steph should just enjoy it and put herself first. The pampering to her insecurities had to stop & I agree with John with this, Steph is a very needy Woman, not a young girl.

Well said, that is exactly how I saw it too and I didn't hear anyone disagreeing with what he said either, so clearly he was likely saying what everyone was thinking anyway.

[Kazanne]

what outburst at what table :conf:
If you are talking about the edited clip shown on BOTS last nite, it was in the living room AFTER Gemma's eviction, they were sitting on the sofas.

That so called outburst, wasn't what BOTS made out it was, very cleverly edited & completely out of context.
Steph was going on and on about hearing cheers and being saved first.
John just told her it's time for her to stop talking about Jezzer 24/7 & saying she is the most hated woman in the world.
They only have 3 days left before final, Steph should just enjoy it and put herself first. The pampering to her insecurities had to stop & I agree with John with this, Steph is a very needy Woman, not a young girl.

Exactly Papillion,selective hearing and sight is rife on here.The truth really hurts sometimes.

[Kazanne]

I will also say the title of this thread is so misleading,John has NEVER once said he dislikes Stephanie,just her constant talk about Jezza is annoying,that is fact,not some fabricated title to make him look the evil baddie.

[Pink Pegasus]

I think Stephanie is getting on everybody's nerves in there! :D

They all just want to enjoy their final few days in the house and Steph DOES keep going on and on and on about Jeremy and HER situation, so I could see how that could very quickly become irritating and draining when you just want to have some fun and enjoy the last few days.

They have each all at some point either listened to her, offered her advice in the early stages, comforted her at bad times, supported her when she said she had finally made a decision that she wants to be with Jeremy, offered her further advice after she had made that decision that she should just explain in her interview that she met someone and fell in love and that she never planned for it to happen etc etc etc, aside from some big rows they've mostly been as comforting and supportive as they could be, so what more does she want from them? They just want her to stop going on and on about it for goodness sake! :laugh:

It's not just John who is finding Steph annoying. Scotty couldn't even watch Steph's electric shock task on the screen without getting annoyed by her (I think because he and a few others felt she was deliberately getting shocked for attention?), Daniella and Tiffany have also expressed annoyance at Steph over the Jeremy thing and her untidiness as has Darren.

I think John is just reaching boiling point at this stage with all the annoyances built up.

That's not to say though that I don't think John is possibly a tactical player. I think Amy Jade and some others theory that John befriends who he believes may be popular - that theory may hold some merit. :hehe:

I don't think he's a completely fake or nasty person at all though, but I do think he's clever and I quite like him and would like to see him do well.

But let's just say even though I believe his annoyance and reaching boiling point with Steph is completely genuine and understandable, at the same time, after Steph topping the votes to save I would not be very surprised if John's anger and annoyance towards Stephanie softens considerably in the coming days.... :hehe: It would be foolish of him if he didn't...

[cassieparis]

Having reached the final week after a precarious start, John has decided to relax and let his full 3itch out. Stephanie irritates him with her repetitive need for comfort and assurance. He's just letting Stephanie know her behavior is insufferable.

[Ammi]

I think Stephanie is getting on everybody's nerves in there! :D

They all just want to enjoy their final few days in the house and Steph DOES keep going on and on and on about Jeremy and HER situation, so I could see how that could very quickly become irritating and draining when you just want to have some fun and enjoy the last few days.

They have each all at some point either listened to her, offered her advice in the early stages, comforted her at bad times, supported her when she said she had finally made a decision that she wants to be with Jeremy, offered her further advice after she had made that decision that she should just explain in her interview that she met someone and fell in love and that she never planned for it to happen etc etc etc, aside from some big rows they've mostly been as comforting and supportive as they could be, so what more does she want from them? They just want her to stop going on and on about it for goodness sake! :laugh:

It's not just John who is finding Steph annoying. Scotty couldn't even watch Steph's electric shock task on the screen without getting annoyed by her (I think because he and a few others felt she was deliberately getting shocked for attention?), Daniella and Tiffany have also expressed annoyance at Steph over the Jeremy thing and her untidiness as has Darren.

I think John is just reaching boiling point at this stage with all the annoyances built up.

That's not to say though that I don't think John is possibly a tactical player. I think Amy Jade and some others theory that John befriends who he believes may be popular - that theory may hold some merit. :hehe:

I don't think he's a completely fake or nasty person at all though, but I do think he's clever and I quite like him and would like to see him do well.

But let's just say even though I believe his annoyance and reaching boiling point with Steph is completely genuine and understandable, at the same time, after Steph topping the votes to save I would not be very surprised if John's anger and annoyance towards Stephanie softens considerably in the coming days.... :hehe: It would be foolish of him if he didn't...

..excellent post as always Peggy..:lovedup:...and I agree with you, I think Steph has got on all of the housemate's last nerve and as they said last night, just so wearing down and of course a few drinks brings out that 'weary feeling' as well, either in tensions/confrontations etc or just uggghh, I'm done with you, stuff..:laugh:...but of course they can't be done with her because there she is and there's no getting way from it all and on it goes...


...obviously he can only do as well as 2nd place because Tiffany's going to win..:tongue:...but like you, I would like to see him do well because although he's got it wrong at times and too readily 'followed' in what he's seen as something 'safe' ..I get the feeling that he is someone ..(and for whatever reason..)...who really does feel the need of some kind of 'acceptance', and has given us a lot in his quest for that, some good/some not so good but he's 'put himself out there' for sure...and yeah, I do think that we may see a little warming to Steph over the next few days and that weariness slipping away..:laugh:..but then, we would see that anyway and I think from all of them just because that end is in site and they're all naturally going to feel far less irritable in general with the relief of it all and the thoughts of seeing their families/friends again...I don't mind him, he gave up his career for his mum, has been a comforting voice to housemates at times and seems like an ok guy and I hope that BB has given him a positive experience with whatever he felt he wanted to get out of it....

[Kazanne]

..excellent post as always Peggy..:lovedup:...and I agree with you, I think Steph has got on all of the housemate's last nerve and as they said last night, just so wearing down and of course a few drinks brings out that 'weary feeling' as well, either in tensions/confrontations etc or just uggghh, I'm done with you stuff..:laugh:...but of course they can't be done with her because there she is and there's no getting way from it all and on it goes...


...obviously he can only do as well as 2nd place because Tiffany's going to win..:tongue:...but like you, I would like to see him do well because although he's got it wrong at times and too readily 'followed' in what he's seen as something 'safe' ..I get the feeling that he is someone ..(and for whatever reason..)...who really does feel the need of some kind of 'acceptance', and has given us a lot in his quest for that, some good/some not so good but he's 'put himself out there' for sure...and yeah, I do think that we may see a little warming to Steph over the next few days and that weariness slipping away..:laugh:..but then, we would see that anyway and I think from all of them just because that end in site and they're all naturally going to feel far less irritable in general with the relief of it all and the thoughts of seeing their families/friends again...I don't mind him, he gave up his career for his mum, has been a comforting voice to housemates at times and seems like an ok guy and I hope that BB has given him a positive experience with whatever he felt he wanted to get out of it....

He went in the CBB house to get the fee for his mothers continuing care,so wherever John comes in BB his job is done,for me he has been the best housemate this year and I have enjoyed watching him.

[bots]

He went in the CBB house to get the fee for his mothers continuing care,so wherever John comes in BB his job is done,for me he has been the best housemate this year and I have enjoyed watching him.

I agree with this. Given the amount of producer manipulation these days and the variation in fan base numbers before they enter, its not a fair or representative contest. They have done their time, get paid their fee. Thats all that can be concluded from it.

[Pink Pegasus]

I agree with the 3 last posts there from you Ammi, Kazanne and bitontheslide.

Yes he has been comforting to other housemates in there and I too believe that he is a overall a decent man.

The only reason I have the "possibly a bit tactical" thing in my head is because of that conversation with Tiff where he would "neither confirm nor deny" her allegations then asked her did she want to make some sort of deal - whatever became of that? :laugh: And he does seem to become a little bit extra pally with people who seem to be doing well with the public - but at the same time I guess that the timing could be coincidence whereby he has just resolved whatever issues he was having with particular housemates at the same time that the public had also grown to like them. This could make sense too because - as a housemates behaviour has changed and the public have grown to like them, it's likely that the change in behaviour could also have made John grow to like them too in the house and that is understandable and wouldn't necessary mean gameplaying.

In any case whether that is tactical or an understandable coincidence it wouldn't make me dislike him either way,as he hasn't in my opinion being aggressive or nasty to people in there.

I too enjoy watching him and also hope the fee helps him out a lot with his mothers care.

I would be happy enough with a John, Darren or Tiff win.

John because I find him intelligent, interesting, caring to others when they were seriously down (not just whinging) and overall decent.

Darren because I just find him so sweet and likeable, although I know he has provided very little entertainment wise, but I can't help but like him.

Tiff - because she has probably made me laugh the most. :laugh:

Whoever wins now, I'm just glad it is not Gemma as I really did not like her.

[Kazanne]

I agree with the 3 last posts there from you Ammi, Kazanne and bitontheslide.

Yes he has been comforting to other housemates in there and I too believe that he is a overall a decent man.

The only reason I have the "possibly a bit tactical" thing in my head is because of that conversation with Tiff where he would "neither confirm nor deny" her allegations then asked her did she want to make some sort of deal - whatever became of that? :laugh: And he does seem to become a little bit extra pally with people who seem to be doing well with the public - but at the same time I guess that the timing could be coincidence whereby he has just resolved whatever issues he was having with particular housemates at the same time that the public had also grown to like them. This could make sense too because - as a housemates behaviour has changed and the public have grown to like them, it's likely that the change in behaviour could also have made John grow to like them too in the house and that is understandable and wouldn't necessary mean gameplaying.

In any case whether that is tactical or an understandable coincidence it wouldn't make me dislike him either way,as he hasn't in my opinion being aggressive or nasty to people in there.

I too enjoy watching him and also hope the fee helps him out a lot with his mothers care.

I would be happy enough with a John, Darren or Tiff win.

John because I find him intelligent, interesting, caring to others when they were seriously down (not just whinging) and overall decent.

Darren because I just find him so sweet and likeable, although I know he has provided very little entertainment wise, but I can't help but like him.

Tiff - because she has probably made me laugh the most. :laugh:

Whoever wins now, I'm just glad it is not Gemma as I really did not like her.


Nice post Pink :thumbs:

[jet]

He went in the CBB house to get the fee for his mothers continuing care,so wherever John comes in BB his job is done,for me he has been the best housemate this year and I have enjoyed watching him.

That is good of him to do that, but I dislike HM's to say they want the money for a good cause. It gives them an advantage.
He must have made little from his career too not to have a good stash put away at his age.

[bots]

That is good of him to do that, but I dislike HM's to say they want the money for a good cause. It gives them an advantage.
He must have made little from his career too not to have a good stash put away at his age.

Its not like civilian BB where it could affect peoples choice to vote so the winner gets the cash prize, so I see no reason for any of them to withhold the information on the grounds of fair play

[LukeB]

I will also say the title of this thread is so misleading,John has NEVER once said he dislikes Stephanie,just her constant talk about Jezza is annoying,that is fact,not some fabricated title to make him look the evil baddie.

How is it misleading when the title doesn't say John said "I dislike Stephanie"

[rocket]

Because he is the biggest gameplayer there:shrug: first lying about being Tiffany's only friend because he knows she is popular and this random bitching about Stephanie. Not really, I'm not even a fan of Stephanie and I don't recall me saying that at all :think:

Totally agree..
Cannot stand the guy...
Hope he's out first ..

[jet]

Its not like civilian BB where it could affect peoples choice to vote so the winner gets the cash prize, so I see no reason for any of them to withhold the information on the grounds of fair play

The sympathy vote.

[Kazanne]

How is it misleading when the title doesn't say John said "I dislike Stephanie"

You titled it 'John disliking Stephanie' you are giving the impression he doesn't like her which is wrong, surely you can see that.he gave her some advice so I would say it should be the opposite!!