Would BGT still be a success with the original line up?

[Denver]

Paul O'Grady was meant to be the host whil Simon, Cheryl Cole and David Hasslehoff were the judges but would it still have been a success?

[Pete.]

I think for a bit but it would have died down if they kept this lineup. And Ant & Dec are a huge part of the show

[_Tom_]

Are you asking would the original 2007 lineup (Piers, Simon, Amanda, Ant and Dec) still be successful or this rumoured one? :suspect:

Was Cheryl relevant in 2007?

[Pete.]

Are you asking would the original 2007 lineup (Piers, Simon, Amanda, Ant and Dec) still be successful or this rumoured one? :suspect:

Was Cheryl relevant in 2007?
As relevant as she was in 2008

[Smithy]

The judges are irrelevant to the success of BGT, it's just a tired format, rest it for a few years