Organ Donation (Serious Debate)

[Lauren]

Whats everyone views on organ donation? Are you already on the register for donating organs once you have died? If you are, why? And if you aren't, why are you against it and how do you feel about it?

[Lauren]

Ok, since no-one is answering, I'll answer it myself, haha.

I will not ever put my organs up for donation once I have died. I suppose this is hypocritical because if ever my family members were in need of an organ transplant I would hope that there would be one there for them. However, I don't like the idea of my body not being a whole once I have died. It feels weird to know that I will continue to exist (Even if it's just a Kidney) in someone that I've never known in my life and they wouldn't have known me.

I donate blood, but it's completely different. With blood I can get it all back again, but I am still helping someone. However with organ donation I don't think the thought of it going to someone else. Even though I am going to get cremated aswell (and the organs will be destroyed regardless).

[Emilee]

LOL im answering, id love to organ donate, to know your saving someone life, must be the most awesome feeling in thw world, i am going to sign up to the organ donating list, when im older. :thumbs:

[MarkWaldorf]

Haha, loner Lauren. :laugh:

I'll probably give mine up when I'm dead. Why would I need them? They could help another life live. Although, there is the thought of it going to a random stranger.

[Lauren]

Gosh, I'm glad there's people like you two in the world instead of people like me for if ever a member of my family needs an organ transplant, haha.

I believe in life after death as well though, so I would feel uncomfortable dying without the whole of me, because then I might not be able to pass into the next life, which would be a bugger to say the least. :laugh:

[Bells]

For me personally, I don't like the idea of my insides being taken out and given to others, but I feel that makes me selfish. I perceive death as being old-fashioned - if you die in a natural way, you're buried and then go to your grave. But thinking about it in perspective, it won't make as much of a difference, because of course people that drown, people who are cremated, people who are buried, burnt, trapped, whichever way - all of them die and I'd assume all are the same after death as well. So I can understand why people say once you've died, you've died - and so surely it's a good thing if you donate organs and allow more lives to be saved, depending on the way you died, when you're going to be needing no uses for them anyway.

It's just for me personally, I'm not so sure. I think it has something to do with a cultural and family thing as well; the way your family and ancestors have been buried - you tend to follow the example and keep the tradition going.

[MarkWaldorf]

If there is "life after death" why would you need your organs? :laugh:

[Lauren]

Originally posted by Markus™
If there is "life after death" why would you need your organs? :laugh:

Well, it's like in many other cultures and traditions where many of them are buried with their favourite possessions to take into the next life.
For me I would not feel complete going into the next life without the whole of my body (Even though I believe my body is just a mode of transport into the next life). It's like I am no longer what I was in the real world, and so it's not me.

[Emilee]

Yer i really want to give an organ for some reason, ( i mean when im alive) I want to see how ive helped someone live. And i do want to give all my organs when im dead.

[Emilee]

Originally posted by Lauren
Originally posted by Markus™
If there is "life after death" why would you need your organs? :laugh:

Well, it's like in many other cultures and traditions where many of them are buried with their favourite possessions to take into the next life.
For me I would not feel complete going into the next life without the whole of my body (Even though I believe my body is just a mode of transport into the next life). It's like I am no longer what I was in the real world, and so it's not me.

Thats a good way to look at it, ok thats just freaked me out. haha.

[MarkWaldorf]

Originally posted by Lauren
Originally posted by Markus™
If there is "life after death" why would you need your organs? :laugh:

Well, it's like in many other cultures and traditions where many of them are buried with their favourite possessions to take into the next life.
For me I would not feel complete going into the next life without the whole of my body (Even though I believe my body is just a mode of transport into the next life). It's like I am no longer what I was in the real world, and so it's not me.

I guess that's true.
But isn't your soul you? Your spirit. That's the thing that takes you on to your next life. Your body's just a place for it stay (:hugesmile:)?

[Bells]

I guess that's true.
But isn't your soul you? Your spirit. That's the thing that takes you on to your next life. Your body's just a place for it stay (:hugesmile:)? [/quote]

Yes, that's how I perceive it as well. We all know it though - I mean, bacteria and parasites and stuff in the earth end up eating away at your body so in the end after many years you're left with no body and simply your skeleton! It's really the spirit that's 'you' but I can understand why some people would want to die the way they left the world, and allow nature to run its course on them rather than take organs out beforehand.

[Lauren]

Originally posted by Markus™
Originally posted by Lauren
Originally posted by Markus™
If there is "life after death" why would you need your organs? :laugh:

Well, it's like in many other cultures and traditions where many of them are buried with their favourite possessions to take into the next life.
For me I would not feel complete going into the next life without the whole of my body (Even though I believe my body is just a mode of transport into the next life). It's like I am no longer what I was in the real world, and so it's not me.

I guess that's true.
But isn't your soul you? Your spirit. That's the thing that takes you on to your next life. Your body's just a place for it stay (:hugesmile:)?

My spirit is me, yes.
But without the (full) body to go with me, It wouldn't be the way I lived in the real life - so it's not really me.
I know what I mean, I just can't put it into words easily, haha.

[MarkWaldorf]

Originally posted by ice_maiden02
I guess that's true.
But isn't your soul you? Your spirit. That's the thing that takes you on to your next life. Your body's just a place for it stay (:hugesmile:)?

Yes, that's how I perceive it as well. We all know it though - I mean, bacteria and parasites and stuff in the earth end up eating away at your body so in the end after many years you're left with no body and simply your skeleton! It's really the spirit that's 'you' but I can understand why some people would want to die the way they left the world, and allow nature to run its course on them rather than take organs out beforehand. [/quote]

Yeah, but personally I wouldn't like to lay underground rotting away. I would rather have my organs used to help others, rather then them rotting away whilst people are dying because they need them.

[MarkWaldorf]

Originally posted by Lauren
Originally posted by Markus™
Originally posted by Lauren
Originally posted by Markus™
If there is "life after death" why would you need your organs? :laugh:

Well, it's like in many other cultures and traditions where many of them are buried with their favourite possessions to take into the next life.
For me I would not feel complete going into the next life without the whole of my body (Even though I believe my body is just a mode of transport into the next life). It's like I am no longer what I was in the real world, and so it's not me.

I guess that's true.
But isn't your soul you? Your spirit. That's the thing that takes you on to your next life. Your body's just a place for it stay (:hugesmile:)?

My spirit is me, yes.
But without the (full) body to go with me, It wouldn't be the way I lived in the real life - so it's not really me.
I know what I mean, I just can't put it into words easily, haha.

Haha, I completely understand you. But when your dead, what use is your body to you? You won't need it. It'll just rot away.

[Lauren]

My body won't rot away :wink: Cremation.

So that all of me goes down the same route, at the same time.

[Dan_]

I've thought about this alot in the past and changed my mind a few times on whether or not I want my organs donated and come to the conclusion that I may aswell give my organs up for donation as even though the thought of being cut up when I'm dead is a little off putting for me but as it's giving someone else a chance of prolonging their life I think I'll put my feelings aside to help someone else rather than them just being in the ground and no use to anyone.

[MarkWaldorf]

Originally posted by Lauren
My body won't rot away :wink: Cremation.

So that all of me goes down the same route, at the same time.

Yeah, that's a good idea. I'm glad you wouldn't just rot underground. :laugh:

Will you consider cremation? I don't think I could think of being burnt. Even though I'll be dead.

[Lauren]

Originally posted by Markus™
Originally posted by Lauren
My body won't rot away :wink: Cremation.

So that all of me goes down the same route, at the same time.

Yeah, that's a good idea. I'm glad you wouldn't just rot underground. :laugh:

Will you consider cremation? I don't think I could think of being burnt. Even though I'll be dead.

Yeah, I am definitely being cremated, then my ashes buried. I know... really random.

[MarkWaldorf]

Originally posted by Lauren
Originally posted by Markus™
Originally posted by Lauren
My body won't rot away :wink: Cremation.

So that all of me goes down the same route, at the same time.

Yeah, that's a good idea. I'm glad you wouldn't just rot underground. :laugh:

Will you consider cremation? I don't think I could think of being burnt. Even though I'll be dead.

Yeah, I am definitely being cremated, then my ashes buried. I know... really random.

:laugh: Would you want your ashes spread? Or just kept in a jar/pot?

[Princess]

I would have said no but after watching a lot of hospital progammes I'd said yes. But omg the other day on Greys Anatomy you could donate skin and eyes which just creeped me out!

[Sunny_01]

I am a registered organ donor, I would also like to give blood but have had a transfusion which rules me out for a while.

I am not sure if they would want my bits following my transfusion but they are welcome to them when I die. I doubt I will miss them terribly :wink: Seriously though I think that it is such a great thing to do. I know I often go through life looking at what I have achieved and sometimes it is easy to think well I have done nothing, BUT I know that I will always be able to do something for someone else when I die so makes my life less pointless

[Ruth]

I'm on the organ donor list. Why wouldn't I be? My organs are no use to me once I'm dead, but they might be able to help someone else. If I ever needed an organ, I would be eternally grateful to whoever had donated it.

[Emilee]

Originally posted by Ruth
I'm on the organ donor list. Why wouldn't I be? My organs are no use to me once I'm dead, but they might be able to help someone else. If I ever needed an organ, I would be eternally grateful to whoever had donated it.

Thats exactly why i want to donate my organs :thumbs:

[Sunny_01]

I have also been looking at the web site to register as a bone marrow donor, there are so many people who could benefit from that. I have to see if I meet the acceptance criteria but none the less it is certainly worth a look at.

[Lauren]

Originally posted by Sunny_01
I have also been looking at the web site to register as a bone marrow donor, there are so many people who could benefit from that. I have to see if I meet the acceptance criteria but none the less it is certainly worth a look at.

I was thinking of also being a BM donor, as well as a blood donor - but I can't. :sad:

[Sunny_01]

Thats a shame Lauren - I am still looking at it and working my way through the information before I make a committment to something I might not feel able to do if and when the time came.

[Tanser_Man]

Originally posted by Lauren
Whats everyone views on organ donation? Are you already on the register for donating organs once you have died? If you are, why? And if you aren't, why are you against it and how do you feel about it?

Not for me, i'm all for a donor card tbh but while living and donating an organ, that's just suicide. Your given what your given for a reason and if you give that up, your creating problems for yourself.

I don't agree with giving donations to alcoholics or drug addicts, because (as George Best shown) they abuse there new organ all the same and it's a waste!

[Siouxsie]

Havent thought =about it much i must admit. Dont think my liver would be good to anyone though:sad:

[~Kizwiz~]

I would give any part of my body if i died. If it would help somebody's life then so be it. I dont understand when people say no. You could be helping a life..... surely thats all that matters? If its your religious beliefs then thats ok but to say no 'just because' is a waste. How would you feel if your child needed a transplant and there wasnt any organs available?

[Ruth]

I agree completely. I have 4 nephews and a niece, and if any of them needed any organs, it would be heartbreaking if the organs were not available.

My organs are no good to me when I'm dead - if they can save someone else's life, I hope people will use them.

[~Kizwiz~]

Originally posted by Ruth
I agree completely. I have 4 nephews and a niece, and if any of them needed any organs, it would be heartbreaking if the organs were not available.

My organs are no good to me when I'm dead - if they can save someone else's life, I hope people will use them.

If anyone wants to be put on the organ donor register then click Here (http://www.uktransplant.org.uk/ukt/how_to_become_a_donor/how_to_become_a_donor.jsp)

I just did and it takes no more than a minute and you could save lives :thumbs:

[GlitterEyes]

I think if they are healthy then they should be put to good use.

[Ruth]

I'm on the register.

[Vicky.]

Im on the register.

My organs are no good to me after I'm dead so why not put them to good use (though my lungs and liver I doubt would be much good to anyone...)

[Stacey.]

No, i wouldnt want that,:/