Mark out of ten / review XF Live Week 9 performances [Christmas + another song]

[James]

Give your marks out of ten and / or thoughts for each performance.

5 After Midnight - Stay Another Day -
5 After Midnight - Signed, Sealed, Delivered (I'm Yours) -
Emily - War is Over -
Emily - Mad World -
Matt - Silent Night -
Matt - Say You Love Me -
Saara - All I Want For Christmas is You -
Saara - Chandelier -

[LukeB]

5 After Midnight - Stay Another Day - 4/10
5 After Midnight - Signed, Sealed, Delivered (I'm Yours) - 5/10
Emily - War is Over - 4/10
Emily - Mad World - 6/10
Matt - Silent Night - 2/10
Matt - Say You Love Me - 4/10
Saara - All I Want For Christmas is You - 10/10
Saara - Chandelier - 10/10

[cliffxen]

5 After Midnight - Stay Another Day - 3.5/10
5 After Midnight - Signed, Sealed, Delivered (I'm Yours) - 7/10
Emily - War is Over - 3/10
Emily - Mad World - 7.5/10
Matt - Silent Night - 4/10
Matt - Say You Love Me - 6.5/10
Saara - All I Want For Christmas is You - 9.5/10
Saara - Chandelier - 9.5/10

[Adamw92]

5 After Midnight - Stay Another Day - 6/10
5 After Midnight - Signed, Sealed, Delivered (I'm Yours) - 6/10
Emily - War is Over - 3.5/10
Emily - Mad World - 6.5/10
Matt - Silent Night - 5/10
Matt - Say You Love Me - 5.5/10
Saara - All I Want For Christmas is You - 10/10
Saara - Chandelier - 10/10

[Nicky91]

5 After Midnight - Stay Another Day - 7/10
5 After Midnight - Signed, Sealed, Delivered (I'm Yours) - 9.5/10
Emily - War is Over - 8/10
Emily - Mad World - 10/10
Matt - Silent Night - 5/10
Matt - Say You Love Me - 3/10
Saara - All I Want For Christmas is You - 10/10
Saara - Chandelier - 10/10

[Babayaro.]

5 After Midnight - Stay Another Day - 8/10
5 After Midnight - Signed, Sealed, Delivered (I'm Yours) - 10/10

Emily - War is Over - 5/10
Emily - Mad World - 6/10

Matt - Silent Night - 5/10
Matt - Say You Love Me - 4/10

Saara - All I Want For Christmas is You - 10/10
Saara - Chandelier - 10/10


Yeah, Saara deserves to win after that.

[Nicky91]

5 After Midnight - Stay Another Day - 8/10
5 After Midnight - Signed, Sealed, Delivered (I'm Yours) - 10/10

Emily - War is Over - 5/10
Emily - Mad World - 6/10

Matt - Silent Night - 5/10
Matt - Say You Love Me - 4/10

Saara - All I Want For Christmas is You - 10/10
Saara - Chandelier - 10/10


Yeah, Saara deserves to win after that.


Emily is so underrated, that performance of mad world was so lovely, i had goosebumps :love:, sorry but it ain't a 6, pure a 10/10 :fist:

[Liam-]

5 After Midnight - Stay Another Day - 7/10
5 After Midnight - Signed, Sealed, Delivered (I'm Yours) - 9/10
Emily - War is Over - 4/10
Emily - Mad World - 4/10
Matt - Silent Night - 4/10
Matt - Say You Love Me - 5/10
Saara - All I Want For Christmas is You - 9/10
Saara - Chandelier - 10/10

Saara stealing the show once again.

[Nicky91]

5 After Midnight - Stay Another Day - 7/10
5 After Midnight - Signed, Sealed, Delivered (I'm Yours) - 9/10
Emily - War is Over - 4/10
Emily - Mad World - 4/10
Matt - Silent Night - 4/10
Matt - Say You Love Me - 5/10
Saara - All I Want For Christmas is You - 9/10
Saara - Chandelier - 10/10

Saara stealing the show once again.

no way that this was a 4/10, you're low scores to Emily is putting me off Saara a lot now :(


keep it honest and fair, please Liam :hee:

[Black Dagger]

It was boring as ****. People can have different opinions to you.

[Cal.]

5 After Midnight - Stay Another Day - 6/10
5 After Midnight - Signed, Sealed, Delivered (I'm Yours) - 7/10
Emily - War is Over - 5/10
Emily - Mad World - 4/10
Matt - Silent Night - 6/10
Matt - Say You Love Me - 8/10
Saara - All I Want For Christmas is You - 9/10
Saara - Chandelier - 10/10

[Lostie!]

no way that this was a 4/10, you're low scores to Emily is putting me off Saara a lot now :(


keep it honest and fair, please Liam :hee:

Why should someone scoring Emily low put you off Saara? It has nothing to do with her.

I didn't like Mad World either, nothing dishonest or unfair about that. I've never liked that version of the song anyway though so it was never gonna be a performance I'd love.

[Nicky91]

Why should someone scoring Emily low put you off Saara? It has nothing to do with her.

I didn't like Mad World either, nothing dishonest or unfair about that. I've never liked that version of the song anyway though so it was never gonna be a performance I'd love.

why not, i dislike the tears for fears version way too happy for a sad song, Emily did it justice, and i had goosebumps so i hope she will have a lovely singing career after x factor anyway :)

[Jordan.]

Emily - 0
Saara -10

[Ashley.]

why not, i dislike the tears for fears version way too happy for a sad song

:facepalm: