Have any later Survivor contestant's appearances tarnished their initial appearance?

[reece(:]

For me:

Kathy ruined herself in All-Stars and it makes me look on her less fondly
Tasha was TRASH in Cambodia and it makes me see more through the lines on her Cagayan appearance and I don't stan her as much there
Dawn was so much worse in Caramoan but I didn't really stan her in SP anyway
Monica was worse in BvsW but I still love her One World incarnation
Skupin (no reason needed)
Jenna L.
Gervase!!! (He was diabolical in BvsW)

Some who weren't as good but I blame the editors:

Kelly Wigs, Brenda, Monica (Cambodia)
Kimmi was worse in Cambodia but partly due to editing and partly due to her being totally different to Australia

[MB.]

Tasha, most of the All Stars cast, people who completely fizzled out like Rob C and Yau-Man, most of the favourites in Caramoan as if they had any positive impression to tarnish in the first place, maybe Shirin?

[MB.]

Oh and Jonny Fairplay, which... yeah, let's forget his whole Micronesia stint ever happened shall we

[reece(:]

Oh and Jonny Fairplay, which... yeah, let's forget his whole Micronesia stint ever happened shall we
Welp that was a wasted spot

[Calderyon]

Colby Donaldson: Massive individual competitor that was a shadow of himself on All Stars and an even bigger disappointment Heroes vs Villains.

Rupert Boneham: A likable guy on Seasons 6 and 7 becomes an useless and unlikable individual on Heroes vs Villains

[JerseyWins]

Well I haven't always seen someone's first Survivor appearance before their second one but:

Ozzy in Micronesia (but he redeemed himself in South Pacific)
James in Micronesia/HvV (one of the best examples for this IMO because he just progressively got less entertaining / less likable but was GREAT in China)
Phillip in Caramoan
Ciera in Cambodia (kinda but still liked)
Peih-Gee in Cambodia
Shirin in Cambodia
Joe in Cambodia (he went from somewhat likable but pretty boring to a lot less likable and even more boring)
Stephen in Cambodia (kinda but still liked)

Most are from Cambodia :joker: But it is one of the few seasons with a full returning cast.

I tried to leave out people that regressed mainly only due to being an early boot... otherwise I'd include people I really liked that didn't leave that much of an impression in their return seasons like: Vytas, Yau-Man, Sugar, Fairplay, etc.

[rk3388]

My post got deleted for somereason but I posted Phillip and James as well
-Andre kind of annoyed me her second run too but that was also cause she doesn't seem likeable outside of her first season either

[_Tom_]

Stephenie in Guatemala
Rupert each time he returned