The All Stars

[Cal.]

CBB16 Austin or CBB19 Austin?
CBB15 Calum or CBB19 Calum?
CBB10 Coleen or CBB19 Coleen?
CBB14 James J or CBB19 James J?
CBB13 Jasmine or CBB19 Jasmine?
CBB8 Jedward or CBB19 Jedward?
CBB9 Nicola or CBB19 Nicola?
CBB11 Speidi or CBB19 Speidi?

[Cal.]

CBB16 Austin or CBB19 Austin? - CBB16 Austin
CBB15 Calum or CBB19 Calum? - CBB15 Calum
CBB10 Coleen or CBB19 Coleen? - CBB19 Coleen
CBB14 James J or CBB19 James J? - CBB19 James J
CBB13 Jasmine or CBB19 Jasmine? - CBB19 Jasmine
CBB8 Jedward or CBB19 Jedward? - Can't judge
CBB9 Nicola or CBB19 Nicola? - CBB19 Nicola
CBB11 Speidi or CBB19 Speidi? - CBB11 Speidi

[Tom4784]

CBB16 Austin
Calum was woeful both times.
Same with Coleen.
CBB19 James J
CBB19 Jasmine
CBB19 Jedward
CBB19 Nicola (Shred Shred Shred remains iconic however)
CBB11 Speidi

[UserSince2005]

CBB16 Austin
CBB15 Calum
CBB10 Coleen
CBB14 James J
CBB19 Jasmine
CBB19 Jedward
CBB9 Nicola
CBB19 Speidi

[MB.]

CBB19 Austin, because he was rewarded the first time around and lolpwnt this time
CBB15 Calum
CBB19 Coleen, but only just
CBB19 James J
CBB13 Jasmine
CBB19 Jedward
CBB9 Nicola, but that doesn't mean she hasn't provided this series
CBB19 Speidi

[y.winter]

Austin - none, but CBB16 if you really insist
CBB15 Calum
CBB10 Coleen
CBB14 James J
CBB13 Jasmine
CBB19 Jedward
CBB19 Nicola
CBB19 Speidi - 11 was great too, but I like their toned-down version

[Denver]

Only Jedward and Austin bettered their original seasons

[LukeB]

CBB16 Austin or CBB19 Austin? CBB16 Austin
CBB15 Calum or CBB19 Calum? CBB15 Calum
CBB10 Coleen or CBB19 Coleen? no comment
CBB14 James J or CBB19 James J? CBB19 James J
CBB13 Jasmine or CBB19 Jasmine? CBB13 Jasmine
CBB8 Jedward or CBB19 Jedward? CBB19 Jedward
CBB9 Nicola or CBB19 Nicola? CBB19 Nicola
CBB11 Speidi or CBB19 Speidi? CBB11 Speidi

[reece(:]

CBB16 Austin or CBB19 Austin?
CBB15 Calum or CBB19 Calum?
CBB10 Coleen or CBB19 Coleen?
CBB14 James J or CBB19 James J?
CBB13 Jasmine or CBB19 Jasmine?
CBB8 Jedward or CBB19 Jedward?
CBB9 Nicola or CBB19 Nicola?
CBB11 Speidi or CBB19 Speidi?

[Wojtek]

CBB19 Austin (just because he was evicted so early)
CBB19 Calum
CBB19 James J
CBB13 Jasmine
CBB11 Speidi

I didn't watch CBB 8-10 so I can't judge Coleen, Nicola and Jedward

[DouglasS]

CBB16 Austin or CBB19 Austin?
CBB15 Calum or CBB19 Calum?
CBB10 Coleen or CBB19 Coleen?
CBB14 James J or CBB19 James J?
CBB13 Jasmine or CBB19 Jasmine?
CBB8 Jedward or CBB19 Jedward?
CBB9 Nicola or CBB19 Nicola?
CBB11 Speidi or CBB19 Speidi?


CBB16 Austin
Callum was same in both series
Coleen was also the same, very two faced yet feeble and boring
CBB19 James J
CBB13 Jasmine
Jedward were my faves in both CBB8 and CBB19, But I'll say CBB19 Jedward
CBB9 Nicola
CB11 Speidi

[Brooklyn]

CBB19 Austin
CBB15 Calum
CBB19 Coleen
CBB19 James J
CBB13 Jasmine
CBB19 Jedward
CBB19 Nicola
CBB19 Speidi

[Ashley.]

CBB16 Austin
CBB15 Calum
CBB10 Coleen
CBB14 James J
CBB19 Jasmine
CBB19 Jedward
CBB9 Nicola
CBB19 Speidi

I'd probably say this too.

[Ant.]

CBB16 Austin or CBB19 Austin?
CBB15 Calum or CBB19 Calum?
CBB10 Coleen or CBB19 Coleen?
CBB14 James J or CBB19 James J?
CBB13 Jasmine or CBB19 Jasmine?
CBB8 Jedward or CBB19 Jedward? (no thx)
CBB9 Nicola or CBB19 Nicola?
CBB11 Speidi or CBB19 Speidi? (although it was nice to see her take a step back in CBB19)

[Shaun]

CBB16 Austin or CBB19 Austin? Neither, ODed in three years time Austin
CBB15 Calum or CBB19 Calum?
CBB10 Coleen or CBB19 Coleen?
CBB14 James J or CBB19 James J?
CBB13 Jasmine or CBB19 Jasmine?
CBB8 Jedward or CBB19 Jedward?
CBB9 Nicola or CBB19 Nicola?
CBB11 Speidi or CBB19 Speidi?

[Epic.]

Austin: Equal
CBB15 Calum
CBB10 Coleen
CBB19 James J
Can't answer on Jasmine, haven't seen CBB13 yet
CBB19 Jedward
CBB9 Nicola
CBB19 Speidi

[Marsh.]

None. All boring koonts.

[Headie]

All were worse for me this time round except for Jedward and James J

[Daniel-X]

CBB16 Austin or CBB19 Austin? (HORRIFIC in both but had the decency to leave early this time)
CBB15 Calum or CBB19 Calum?
CBB10 Coleen or CBB19 Coleen?
CBB14 James J or CBB19 James J?
CBB13 Jasmine or CBB19 Jasmine?
CBB8 Jedward or CBB19 Jedward?
CBB9 Nicola or CBB19 Nicola?
CBB11 Speidi or CBB19 Speidi? (Horrific in both but slightly better in CBB11)

[EspeonBB]

CBB16 Austin or CBB19 Austin? Horrific in both
CBB15 Calum or CBB19 Calum?
CBB10 Coleen or CBB19 Coleen? I didn't see CBB10 so I can't judge
CBB14 James J or CBB19 James J?
CBB13 Jasmine or CBB19 Jasmine?
CBB8 Jedward or CBB19 Jedward? I didn't see CBB8 so I can't judge but I think I'd prefer them this time around
CBB9 Nicola or CBB19 Nicola?
CBB11 Speidi or CBB19 Speidi?

[RichardG]

CBB8 Jedward or CBB19 Jedward? - 19
CBB9 Nicola or CBB19 Nicola? - 9
CBB11 Speidi or CBB19 Speidi? - 11

i can't remember what any of the other housemates were like in their original seasons

"all stars"

[Stormy]

CBB19 Austin - because he got the boot early
CBB15 Calum - he wasn't as self-righteous then as he is now
CBB19 Coleen - she's less annoying 2nd time around, but not by much
CBB14 James J - because he wasn't anyone's minion the first time around
CBB13 Jasmine - she wasn't as rude/grating the first time
CBB8 Jedward - they were great with Tara Reid
CBB9 Nicola - "Shred, Shred, Shred"
CBB19 Speidi - hated them the first time 'round

[Liam-]

CBB16 Austin or CBB19 Austin? He was abhorrent both times.
CBB15 Calum or CBB19 Calum? I preferred his stint this time because he said less.
CBB10 Coleen or CBB19 Coleen? Loved her both times <3
CBB14 James J or CBB19 James J? Loved him both times, even more so this time <3
CBB13 Jasmine or CBB19 Jasmine? Good the first time, trash this time.
CBB8 Jedward or CBB19 Jedward? Liked them the first time around, they've been dire this time.
CBB9 Nicola or CBB19 Nicola? Great last time, amazing this time, goddess.
CBB11 Speidi or CBB19 Speidi? I preferred their more human take on the show this time around, seeing them have fun was nice, but they were still great last time.

[Jack_]

Austin - CBB19, I don't remember much of him last time (partly cause I stopped watching early as usual), but his arguments with James were hysterical this series

Calum - CBB19, surprised 15 is getting so many votes...he was a total bore. At least this time he began to meltdown

Coleen - CBB10, simply for Julie constantly owning her dull ass. She might've been mildly funnier this time, but still the same old bore who should never have been invited back

James - CBB19, liked him both times but the arguments were funnier this time and I liked seeing a nicer side to him too

Jasmine - CBB13, just for her role in one of the best showmance/love triangle storylines ever

Jedward - CBB19, did like them last time but they've not been so one dimensional this series and have been the catalyst for much of the drama/storylines

Nicola - CBB19, this one is really difficult cause her top of the stairs meltdown was hilarious, but I think she's played a bigger role this series so

Speidi - CBB11, most difficult of the lot because like JJ I liked seeing a nicer side to them too and the bottle drama/door opening are some of the highlights of the series, but their stint in the last series single handedly saved it and they went further, so

[Mitchell]

CBB16 Austin or CBB19 Austin?
CBB15 Calum or CBB19 Calum?
CBB10 Coleen or CBB19 Coleen?
CBB14 James J or CBB19 James J?
CBB13 Jasmine or CBB19 Jasmine?
CBB8 Jedward or CBB19 Jedward?
CBB9 Nicola or CBB19 Nicola?
CBB11 Speidi or CBB19 Speidi?
Bolded my answers

[Withano]

CBB16 Austin or CBB19 Austin? - CBB16 Austin
CBB15 Calum or CBB19 Calum? - CBB15 Calum
CBB10 Coleen or CBB19 Coleen? - CBB19 Coleen
CBB14 James J or CBB19 James J? - CBB19 James J
CBB13 Jasmine or CBB19 Jasmine? - CBB19 Jasmine
CBB8 Jedward or CBB19 Jedward? - Can't judge
CBB9 Nicola or CBB19 Nicola? - CBB19 Nicola
CBB11 Speidi or CBB19 Speidi? - CBB11 Speidi

I agree with all of that

[Jason.]

CBB16 Austin or CBB19 Austin
CBB15 Calum or CBB19 Calum
CBB10 Coleen or CBB19 Coleen
CBB14 James J or CBB19 James J
CBB13 Jasmine or CBB19 Jasmine
CBB8 Jedward or CBB19 Jedward
CBB9 Nicola or CBB19 Nicola
CBB11 Speidi or CBB19 Speidi

I only like Speidi more this time round because they got less airtime and didn't annoy me as much :laugh: Although I did kinda like Heidi.