BBUK Finalists - how would the jury vote?

[Jack_]

Here's an interesting one, if BBUK followed US rules and the winner was determined by a jury made up of the last 7 or 9 housemates to be evicted, whom would they vote for in the final two of each series?

Since there's no way of ever knowing whether each final two would have made it to the end if the series played out under a different format, work on the assumption that the entire series played out as it did, but the jury is now casting their vote for the winner :spin2: you can either use 7 or 9 jurors idc, but walkers/ejectees are excluded

Here's a few of mine:

Big Brother 7: Pete VS Glyn

Aisleyne - Pete
Richard - Pete
Nikki - Pete
Jennie - Glyn
Imogen - Glyn
Susie - Pete
Mikey - Pete

Pete wins 5-2

Big Brother 12: Aaron VS Jay

Alex - Jay
Louise - Jay
Tom - Aaron
Faye - Aaron
Harry - Aaron
Jem - Jay
Anton - Jay

Jay wins 4-3

Big Brother 17 - Jason VS Hughie

Jackson - Hughie
Andy - Jason
Evelyn - Hughie
Jayne - Jason
Sam - Hughie
Alex - Hughie
Laura - Hughie
Ryan - Hughie
Lateysha - Hughie

Hughie wins 7-2

[BBUK-Fan]

This is why they should never have the US format for uk because the clique people like Hughie end up winning and ruining it

[Epic.]

If anything the BB17 one proves how plot convenient Jason winning actually was. I mean a) he evicted Lateysha and became public enemy #1, b) he survived the next eviction because it was vote to save c) he survived the next eviction barely against Laura because she did **** in a vote to save and took the time to call the crowd out on being horrible people, and d) he had the finale vote with a task two days before the final that saved him. Loads stan him cause he implemented this whole BBUS mindset that we toootally haven't seen before but really his win was almost completely reliant on BBUK's format

[Epic.]

Also Jack_ wtf Jayne would never vote Jason to win over Hughie, she hated when Jason won over him :laugh:

[Jack_]

This is why they should never have the US format for uk because the clique people like Hughie end up winning and ruining it

I specifically wrote the following

Since there's no way of ever knowing whether each final two would have made it to the end if the series played out under a different format

to discourage nonsense arguments like that, and you still go and do it smh :bored:

For the record Hughie should've won anyway but this is supposed to be a prediction thread not another to discuss the merits and detractions of the US format

[RileyH]

For the record Hughie should've won anyway but this is supposed to be a prediction thread not another to discuss the merits and detractions of the US format

https://typeset-beta.imgix.net/uploads/image/2017/8/1/ac160c7a-e500-43d4-88f1-f6375c6936a3-200.gif

[Cal.]

Isabelle vs Raph
Deborah - Raph
Tom - Raph
Andrew - Isabelle
Kieran - Raph
Hannah - Raph
Charlotte - Raph
Ellie - Raph
Chanelle - Raph
Sam - Isabelle

Raph wins 7-2.

[Jack_]

Also Jack_ wtf Jayne would never vote Jason to win over Hughie, she hated when Jason won over him :laugh:

See I thought about this and the fact she always joined Charlie in slagging him off, but then I swear they had a good friendship inside the house for a while? He was the only one ~on her level~

[Jack_]

Isabelle vs Raph
Deborah - Raph
Tom - Raph
Andrew - Isabelle
Kieran - Raph
Hannah - Raph
Charlotte - Raph
Ellie - Raph
Chanelle - Raph
Sam - Isabelle

Raph wins 7-2.

*Emma reveals the votes*

"Ellie has voted for Raph to win the game"

http://i3.cdnds.net/16/05/300x225/ellie-ibiza-weekender-jan.jpg?1562060824

"Chanelle has voted for...Raph"

"Sam has voted for...Isabelle"

https://i0.wp.com/realitybox.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2016/03/ellie.png?resize=584%2C425

https://tellymix.co.uk/ts/800/450/www.tellymix.co.uk/files/2017/07/ellie-sob.jpg

https://tellymix.co.uk/ts/800/450/www.tellymix.co.uk/files/2017/07/BB_Sam-1.jpg

[RileyH]

:laugh2::joker:

[Cal.]

:laugh2:

[Shaun]

Helen vs. Ashleigh
Christopher - Ashleigh
Ash - Helen
Chris - Ashleigh
Pav - Ashleigh
Winston - Helen
Mark - Helen
Zoe - ???
Steven - Helen
Danielle - Ashleigh

Vote rests on Zoe Birkett!! :omgno: (I genuinely can't recall who she liked though)

(I'm guessing walkers can't join the jury, hence no Kim)

[BBUK-Fan]

For the record Hughie should've won anyway

Ha, nope. A loud attention seeking argumentative fake should have won? What a joke

[Epic.]

See I thought about this and the fact she always joined Charlie in slagging him off, but then I swear they had a good friendship inside the house for a while? He was the only one ~on her level~

No, that'd be Andy @Jayne. She still socially got along with Jason but she did not trust him :laugh: Plus, when you say she slagged him off she REALLY slagged him off ("DON'T be a FOOL Charlie! :) ). Hughie on the other hand she consistently was always getting along with and only had brief moments of getting fed up with his more youthful side. The fact she shaded Jason's win in her FIRST post-series Bots appearance proves Hughie would destroy Jason almost unanimously.

[Epic.]

Ha, nope. A loud attention seeking argumentative fake should have won? What a joke

Did you just miss what the point of the thread was? It's NOTHING to do with opinions!

(although i'll say once and once only that Jason is very overrated here and Hughie is very underrated with me and Jack_ being his only vocal stanners</3)

[Jason.]

Nadia vs. Jason

Dan: Nadia
Shell: Nadia
Stuart: Jason (although he could vote the same as Michelle)
Michelle: Nadia
Victor: Jason
Ahmed: Jason
Becki: Nadia

Nadia wins 4-3.

Did a seven-person jury for BB5 as there were only thirteen housemates.

[Babayaro.]

Hughie was crap.

[BBUK-Fan]

Did you just miss what the point of the thread was? It's NOTHING to do with opinions!

(although i'll say once and once only that Jason is very overrated here and Hughie is very underrated with me and Jack_ being his only vocal stanners</3)

I don't care what the point of it is. Hughie is overrated ****

[LukeB]

BB17 finale 2 is the worse final 2 ever

[Jack_]

I'm using a jury of 7 for the pre-BB15 series (which is what they did in the US) and 9 for post-BB15, so

Big Brother 14 - Sam VS Dexter

Gina - Dexter (this is actually a hard one cause I know her and Sam got close in the last fortnight)
Jack & Joe - Sam
Charlie - Dexter
Sophie - Dexter
Hazel - Sam
Callum - Sam
Dan - Sam

Dan's the swing vote but I reckon Sam wins 4-3

No, that'd be Andy @Jayne. She still socially got along with Jason but she did not trust him :laugh: Plus, when you say she slagged him off she REALLY slagged him off ("DON'T be a FOOL Charlie! :) ). Hughie on the other hand she consistently was always getting along with and only had brief moments of getting fed up with his more youthful side. The fact she shaded Jason's win in her FIRST post-series Bots appearance proves Hughie would destroy Jason almost unanimously.

You have me convinced :laugh:

I don't care what the point of it is. Hughie is overrated ****

Celebrity Big Brother 20 (2017)
Shaun Williamson

Celebrity Big Brother 19 - January 2017
James Cosmo

Celebrity Big Brother 17 - January 2016
Darren Day

Celebrity Big Brother 10 2012
Coleen Nolan

Celebrity Big Brother 2012
Gareth Thomas

I'm a Celebrity 2014...
Carl Fogarty

I'm a Celebrity... 2013
Kian Egan

fam I don't even know where to begin here, now play the game or gET OUT OF MY DAMN THREAD

http://i3.cdnds.net/16/05/300x225/ellie-ibiza-weekender-jan.jpg?1562060824g

[RileyH]

http://i3.cdnds.net/16/05/300x225/ellie-ibiza-weekender-jan.jpg?1562060824g

[Jason.]

Not a seven-person jury for BB7-11 when they all had thirty housemates.

[Epic.]

Celebrity Big Brother 15 (the jury starts after Alicia's eviction since that was the point really submerged into its forced Hopkins/Hilton territory :skull: )

Calum - Hopkins
Keith - Pricey
Michelle - Hopkins
Perez - Pricey
Kavana - Hopkins
Cami-Li - Hopkins
Nadia - Pricey
Patsy - Pricey
Alicia - The tiebreaker vote and votes Pricey!!! :laugh:

Hopkins loses to her even in the BBUS format! :love:

[Jack_]

Not a seven-person jury for BB7-11 when they all had thirty housemates.

:joker: a mess @ Kinga entering the game late and automatically making the jury

Mattress would be jel http://cdn.thisisbigbrother.com/customavatars/avatar9362_57.gif

[Babayaro.]

Celebrity Big Brother 20 (2017)
Shaun Williamson

Celebrity Big Brother 19 - January 2017
James Cosmo

Celebrity Big Brother 17 - January 2016
Darren Day

Celebrity Big Brother 10 2012
Coleen Nolan

Celebrity Big Brother 2012
Gareth Thomas

I'm a Celebrity 2014...
Carl Fogarty

I'm a Celebrity... 2013
Kian Egan

fam I don't even know where to begin here, now play the game or gET OUT OF MY DAMN THREAD

http://i3.cdnds.net/16/05/300x225/ellie-ibiza-weekender-jan.jpg?1562060824g

What have his favourites got to do with anything?

[Jack_]

What have his favourites got to do with anything?

You tell me, he brought his least/favourites into the discussion in post #2

What has one's personal preference for winners got to do with a thread entitled 'how would the jury vote'?

[Epic.]

Anthony vs Eugene

Makosi - Anthony
Kinga - Eugene
Craig - Anthony
Derek - Eugene
Orlaith - Anthony
Kemal - Anthony
Science - Eugene

Anthony wins 4-3 (i think? kemal's vote was the hardest to work out)

[Time to Sleigh]

Don't think Rachel would have won bb9

[SoberLikeGizmo]

Anthony vs Eugene

Makosi - Anthony
Kinga - Eugene
Craig - Anthony
Derek - Eugene
Orlaith - Anthony
Kemal - Anthony
Science - Eugene

Anthony wins 4-3 (i think? kemal's vote was the hardest to work out)

Walker gets to vote?

[RileyH]

Anthony v Eugene is a lose-lose situation tbh

[Epic.]

Walker gets to vote?

Don't they? I recall an ejectee being allowed to vote once in BBUS

[LukeB]

Don't they? I recall an ejectee being allowed to vote once in BBUS

Which ejectee was this :suspect:

The last ejectee was BB14 and it was weeks before jury.

[Jason.]

America votes in place of a walker or ejectee.

So Orlaith's vote would be a public vote and Anthony would get it as well...he got more votes than Eugene in the real thing.

[SoberLikeGizmo]

Don't they? I recall an ejectee being allowed to vote once in BBUS

Nah the last time Chima was removed and her vote jury vote was replaced by America. Terrible Chima would have made sure Natalie would win as well.

[Babayaro.]

You tell me, he brought his least/favourites into the discussion in post #2

What has one's personal preference for winners got to do with a thread entitled 'how would the jury vote'?

But basically replying to someone saying something negative about a person you like, by listing their 'favourites' in an attempt to make their opinion invalid, is a bit odd.

[SoberLikeGizmo]

Imagine Survivor final 3 votes.... Makosi would be dragged by the jury so hard

:( Just like our missed cass final 3 in cagayan, where the Jury would have destroyed her :(

[Jack_]

But basically replying to someone saying something negative about a person you like, by listing their 'favourites' in an attempt to make their opinion invalid, is a bit odd.

How can I invalidate someone's opinion though? That would only work if he cared about what I thought of his favourites, and I very much doubt he does and tbh nor should he. That wasn't actually what I was doing however. I asked him once to not hijack this thread for the purposes of discussing the merits of US format, so instead he then took to discussing the merits of particular winners, and when asked not to again by another poster he just said 'I don't care'. So if he doesn't care about bringing irrelevant issues into the thread, I don't care about being flippant (which is what it was) using something as irrelevant (irony intended) as his favourites

I'm not the first person to quote someone's favourites and I won't be the last

[Daniel.]

Anthony vs Eugene

Makosi - Anthony
Kinga - Eugene
Craig - Anthony
Derek - Eugene
Orlaith - Anthony
Kemal - Anthony
Science - Eugene

Anthony wins 4-3 (i think? kemal's vote was the hardest to work out)

No way Kemal votes Anthony

[Daniel.]

But basically replying to someone saying something negative about a person you like, by listing their 'favourites' in an attempt to make their opinion invalid, is a bit odd.

Because his favourites are garbage

http://cdn.thisisbigbrother.com/customavatars/avatar9362_57.gif

[Epic.]

No way Kemal votes Anthony

So EUGENE wins?? :skull::skull::skull:

[Daniel.]

So EUGENE wins?? :skull::skull::skull:

Kemal liked Eugene said he wants him to win in BBBM final darling

[Jack_]

Someone's gonna have to help me out with this one cause I can barely remember the social relationships of half of these would-be jurors, so am guessing for the most part

Big Brother 8 - Brian VS Samanda

Liam - Brian
Ziggy - Brian
Carole - Samanda
Jonty - Samanda
Kara-Louise - Samanda
Tracey - Brian
Gerry - Brian

This is an interesting one tho :think: add Amy and David into the fold and I don't have a ****ing clue

[karl100589]

Going to add some of my own thoughts to this. I'll start with BB5 since it's the first series I remember well:

BB5: Nadia vs Jason (Nadia wins 5-2)
Dan: Nadia
Shell: Nadia
Stuart: Nadia (Stuart is a swing vote since he was part linked with the Jungle Cats, but I think Michelle would sway him in the jury house)
Michelle: Nadia
Victor: Jason
Ahmed: Jason
Bekki: Nadia

BB6: Anthony vs Eugene (Eugene wins 4-3)
Makosi: Anthony
Kinga: Eugene
Craig: Anthony
Derek: Eugene
Kemal: Eugene (A big swing vote, but I imagine Kemal voting for Eugene more out of his dislike for Anthony)
Science: Eugene
Britain (implemented since Orlaith walked): Anthony

BB7: Pete vs Glyn (Pete wins 4-3)
Aisleyne: Glyn
Richard: Pete
Nikki: Pete
Jennie: Pete
Imogen: Glyn
Susie: Pete
Mikey: Glyn

BB8: Belo vs Samanda (Samanda win 5-2)
Liam: Samanda
Ziggy: Belo
Carole: Belo
Jonty: Samanda
Kara-Louise: Samanda
Tracy: Samanda
Gerry: Samanda

BB9: Rachel vs Mikey (Rachel wins 5-2)
Sara: Mikey
Rex: Rachel (Rex's relationship with Rachel was quite love/hate. I don't think he disliked her enough to give Mikey the win over her)
Darnell: Rachel
Kat: Rachel
Mo: Rachel
Lisa: Mikey
Nicole: Rachel (her vote goes wherever Rex's does)

BB10: Sophie vs Siavash (Sophie wins 5-2)
David: Sophie
Charlie: Sophie
Rodrigo: Sophie
Lisa: Sophie
Marcus: Sophie
Bea: Siavash
Freddie: Siavash

BB11: Josie vs Dave (Josie wins 7-0)
Mario: Josie
JJ: Josie
Andrew: Josie
Steve: Josie
Sam Pepper: Josie
Corin: Josie
John James: Josie

BB12: Aaron vs Jay (Jay wins 4-3
Alex: Jay
Louise: Jay
Tom: Jay (The big swing vote)
Faye: Aaron
Harry: Aaron
Anton: Jay
Britain (Taking Jem's vote): Aaron

BB13: Luke vs Adam (Adam wins 6-1)
Deena: Luke
Sara: Adam
Luke S: Adam
Ashleigh: Adam
Scott: Adam
Conor: Adam
Becky: Adam

BB14: Sam vs Dexter (Dexter wins 4-3)
Gina: Dexter
Jack and Joe: Sam
Charlie: Dexter
Sophie: Dexter (Big swing vote)
Hazel: Sam (She'd vote against Dexter to spite Gina)
Callum: Sam
Dan: Dexter

BB15: Ashleigh vs ******* (******** wins 4-3)
Christopher: Ashleigh
Ash: ********
Chris: Ashleigh
Pav: ********
Winston: *******
Mark: *******
Zoe: Ashleigh


BB16: Chloe vs Joel (Chloe wins 4-3)
Danny: Chloe
Jack: Chloe
Nick: Joel
Christian: Joel
Sam: Chloe
Harry Amelia: Chloe
Marc: Joel

I have no idea about this one, very forgettable series

BB17: Jason Vs Hughie (Hughie wins 6-1)
Jackson: Hughie
Andy: Jason
Evelyn: Hughie
Jayne: Hughie
Sam: Hughie
Alex: Hughie
Laura: Hughie

BB18: Isabelle vs Raph (Raph wins 5-2)
Deborah: Raph
Tom: Raph
Kieran: Isabelle
Hannah: Raph
Charlotte: Isabelle
Ellie: Raph
Chanelle: Raph

Andrew is not included due to being a half-housemate

I'll try and do CBB tomorrow.

[Epic.]

BB16: Chloe vs Joel (Joel wins 6-1)
Danny: Joel
Jack: Joel
Nick: Chloe
Christian: Joel
Sam: Joel
Harry Amelia: Joel
Marc: Joel

I have no idea about this one, very forgettable series

BB17: Jason Vs Hughie (Hughie wins 5-2)
Jackson: Hughie
Andy: Jason
Evelyn: Hughie
Jayne: Jason
Sam: Hughie
Alex: Hughie
Laura: Hughie

BB18: Isabelle vs Raph (Raph wins 7-0)
Deborah: Raph
Tom: Raph
Kieran: Raph
Hannah: Raph
Charlotte: Raph
Ellie: Raph
Chanelle: Raph

These 3 are so wrong :skull:

Danny: Joel
Jack: Joel

There's no way these two vote Joel. They lost all trust with him in the last few weeks and were part of Chloe's clique.

Nick: Chloe

He was besties with Joel and nommed Chloe twice :skull:

Sam: Joel

Chloe was her only friend after Marc left :skull:

Harry Amelia: Joel

She didn't like Joel that much :skull:

Jayne: Jason

Can people stop saying this? Jayne loved Hughie and trusted Jason as far as she could throw him.

Kieran: Raph

This is harder to work out but he clashed with Raph more in the last few weeks.

Charlotte: Raph

She thought Raph wouldn't be friends with most of the people after he left/wanted Isabelle to win.

[Jason.]

Aisleyne would've voted for Pete.

[karl100589]

These 3 are so wrong :skull:



There's no way these two vote Joel. They lost all trust with him in the last few weeks and were part of Chloe's clique.



He was besties with Joel and nommed Chloe twice :skull:



Chloe was her only friend after Marc left :skull:



She didn't like Joel that much :skull:



Can people stop saying this? Jayne loved Hughie and trusted Jason as far as she could throw him.



This is harder to work out but he clashed with Raph more in the last few weeks.



She thought Raph wouldn't be friends with most of the people after he left/wanted Isabelle to win.

All I remembered from BB16 was the house turning on Chloe after the prize money task.

[Epic.]

All I remembered from BB16 was the house turning on Chloe after the prize money task.

She was genuinely sorry though. Joel kept spouting about how he wouldn't take the money only to buy some pizza and everyone flipped their **** at him for it, including Sam Kay

[karl100589]

She was genuinely sorry though. Joel kept spouting about how he wouldn't take the money only to buy some pizza and everyone flipped their **** at him for it, including Sam Kay

I changed it now, happy?

[Epic.]

I changed it now, happy?

I meant Charlotte votes Isabelle. Not Chanelle she'd defo vote Raph

[karl100589]

Gonna do some more of these:

CBB4: Chantelle vs Barrymore (Chantelle wins 6-1)
Maggot: Chantelle
Preston: Chantelle
Pete: Chantelle
Traci: Chantelle
Dennis: Chantelle
George: Barrymore
Rula: Chantelle

CBB5: Shilpa vs Jermaine (Jermaine wins 4-3)
Dirk: Shilpa
Ian: Shilpa
Danielle: Jermaine
Jack: Jermaine
Cleo: Shilpa
Jo: Jermaine
Jade: Jermaine

This one would NOT go down well.

CBB6: Ulrika vs Terry (Terry wins 4-3)
Coolio: Terry
Verne: Ulrika
Ben: Terry
Tommy: Terry
Latoya: Terry
Michelle: Ulrika
Britain (Muyta loses her vote): Ulrika

Latoya and Verne are the big swing votes here

CBB7: Alex vs Dane (Alex wins 6-1)
Vinnie: Dane
Jonas: Alex
Stephanie: Alex
Nicola T: Alex
Ivana: Alex
Sisqo: Alex
Stephen: Alex

CBB8: Paddy vs Kerry (Kerry wins 4-3)
Jedward: Kerry
Amy: Kerry
Lucien: Kerry
Darren: Paddy
Bobby: Paddy
Tara: Paddy
Pamela: Kerry

CBB9: Denise vs Frankie (Frankie wins 6-1)
Gareth: Frankie
Madsen: Frankie
K and K: Frankie
Romeo: Frankie
Nicola: Frankie
Natalie: Denise
Kirk: Frankie

[Epic.]

George hated Michael towards the end and would vote Chantelle, Pete wanted Michael to win, Jade is a flip vote and could possibly vote Shilpa since she felt guilt about the whole thing, and Lucien was a fake audience-pandering prick so would probably vote Paddy over the girl he was showmancing.

[Jack_]

George hated Michael towards the end and would vote Chantelle, Pete wanted Michael to win, Jade is a flip vote and could possibly vote Shilpa since she felt guilt about the whole thing, and Lucien was a fake audience-pandering prick so would probably vote Paddy over the girl he was showmancing.

These two rest on whether the jury was sequestered or not though surely, I didn't specify that either way in the OP though so you could make a case for both

[Epic.]

I think even if Lucien didn't know what the outside thought, he'd probably still vote Paddy

[Jason.]

CBB5: Shilpa vs Jermaine (Jermaine wins 4-3)
Dirk: Shilpa
Ian: Shilpa
Danielle: Jermaine
Jack: Jermaine
Cleo: Shilpa
Jo: Jermaine
Jade: Jermaine

This one would NOT go down well.


Racist jury the new bitter jury?

[Epic.]

CBB10 (Coleen vs Julian) (Coleen wins 4-1)

Martin - Coleen
The Situation - Coleen
Ashley - Coleen
Harvey - Coleen
Julie - Julian

CBB19 (Coleen vs Jedward) (Coleen wins 7-3)

Kim - Jedward
James C - Coleen
Nicola - Coleen
Bianca - Coleen
Calum - Coleen
Jamie - Coleen
Speidi - Jedward
Jessica - Jedward
Stacy - Coleen

:skull::skull:

[Jack_]

^ not that it would make a difference but you can't have an even numbered jury :p

[Epic.]

^added Stacy and took away Danica, Samantha, and Lorenzo