The most important decision you will ever have to make

[Ross.]

Who is your favourite X Factor judge of all time?

The poll is coming and here’s a video to help with your decision x

OeHSZT3RGMM

[Marsh.]

Mrs O.

[Lostie!]

Why are you so obsessed with dickheads?

[Cal.]

Imagine it not being Simon!

[Shaun]

Dannii, followed by Louis and then Simon.

[Ross.]

Why are you so obsessed with dickheads?

Nick isn’t in the OP?

[Ross.]

Imagine it not being Simon!

Sharon's return saved the show whilst Simon’s made it go further towards death

https://i.imgur.com/a8EJZGp.gif

[Marsh.]

Imagine it not being Simon!

https://i.imgur.com/mIHvfoT.gif

[Wizard.]

https://media.giphy.com/media/2ZxRgdZYySUTu/giphy.gif

[Ross.]

Nick
TwentyOneThrones

https://media.giphy.com/media/n4e4IRXBiTl2E/giphy.gif

[Oaker]

Simon, Cheryl & Sharon are the best 3

[caprimint]

Louis for me. :love:

The panel just isn't the same without him and he's really missed when he's not there. Sharon, Simon and Cheryl are all up there too following behind.

[Jack_]

It's Louis. A couple of years ago I'd have said Sharon but I think he's given more to the show overall across its run, from the predictable cliches to the feuds with Simon and Cheryl, to his bond with Sharon, and of course, to the inevitability that he would drag the judges vote out only to troll everyone by sending it to Deadlock/some fodder home only for the viewers to fume that they were 'robbed' :love: :love: :love:

Also, he's the only thing that's integral to the show along with Dermot. The year they both weren't on the show was a DISASTER. There were perfectly good series when Sharon (and Simon) weren't on the panel.

The official all-time ranking is:

Louis
Sharon
Simon
Gary (really underrated)
Nicole
Mel
Alexandra
Kelly
Tulisa
Dannii
Cheryl
Rita
Nick


Nick isn’t in the OP?

https://media.giphy.com/media/n4e4IRXBiTl2E/giphy.gif

:joker::joker::joker::joker::joker::joker::joker:: joker:

[Jack_]

honestly I was close to putting Nick just slightly above Rita for the Anton "I AM NOT FAKE" Stephans moment but then that was all Anton's doing so I couldn't bring myself to do it

[Natalie.]

Louis

[Eddie.]

Cheryl.

[RileyH]

Tulisa and it isn't even close.

[RileyH]

Gary, Nicole, Mel, Sharon and Rita are good as well tho

[caprimint]

Ranking:
1) Louis
2) Sharon
3) Simon
4) Cheryl
5) Nicole
6) Nick
7) Rita
8) Tulisa
9) Kelly
10) Gary
11) Dannii
12) Mel B

[Babayaro.]

Louis. No contest.



1. Louis
2. Simon
3. Sharon
4. Dannii
5. Gary
6. Tulisa
7. Nicole
8. Kelly
9. Cheryl
10. Mel B
11. Rita
12. Nick

[Niamh.]

Louis and then Dannii, damn was this a multi Poll?

[Ross.]

Louis. No contest.



1. Louis
2. Simon
3. Sharon
4. Dannii
5. Gary
6. Tulisa
7. Nicole
8. Kelly
9. Cheryl
10. Mel B
11. Rita
12. Nick

Not Tulisa above Nicole, Chez and Mel

https://i.imgur.com/a8EJZGp.gif

[supertv247]

I think Sharon just for pure hilarity. My rankings (at this moment in time, because Simon used to be much better but now he's so fake it drives me mad)..

1. Sharon
2. Tulisa
3. Dannii
4. Nicole
5. Kelly
6. Mel B
7. Rita
8. Cheryl
9. Louis
10. Simon
11. Gary
12. Nick

[Drew.]

Nicole or Si

[LukeB]

1.Simon
2.Cheryl
3.Danni
4.Kelly
5.Louis
6.Sharon
7.Rita
8.Gary
9.Mel B
10.Nicole
11.Tulisa
12.Nick

[Crimson Dynamo]

Simon of course

but i love Louis

[Nicky91]

Gary Barlow, but i'm a take that fan :hee:

[Firewire]

Lou :love:

[Amy Jade]

Dannii

[Ross.]

Lou :love:

Lou...isa Johnson sadly hasn’t been a judge yet but yes she’d be my fave too

[BBUK-Fan]

Sharon is the best but Gary was great

[Jamie89]

Of the ones I've seen...

Dannii
Nicole
Louis
Tulisa
Kelly
Sharon
Simon
Cheryl
Gary

[Strictly Jake]

To be fair I have enjoyed all of them apart from nick

Rita was underrated I think given time she'd be great

[Denver]

Like you need to ask me

[Adamw92]

Dannii obviously

[Ant.]

Lou...isa Johnson sadly hasn’t been a judge yet but yes she’d be my fave too

:joker:

[Ant.]

Lou...isa Johnson sadly hasn’t been a judge yet but yes she’d be my fave too

:joker:

[Black Dagger]

Best 3 are/were ~ Louis/Simon/Sharon (the original <3) and Dannii

Worst 3 are Tulisa/Nick/Gary