Big Musical debate: Is P!NK better than lady gaga?

[Crimson Dynamo]

I would say yes

What say you? Similar type female singers with good long careers (well Pink is still going more) and have had similar success here in the UK and in the USA

its the big musical debate so make sure and take part :thumbs:


https://i2-prod.mirror.co.uk/incoming/article1316793.ece/ALTERNATES/s615/49786530.jpghttp://www.king5.com/img/resize/content.kgw.com/photo/2017/10/05/pink_1507215853450_11314403_ver1.0.jpg?preset=534-401

[Niamh.]

I definitely prefer P!nks music

[Crimson Dynamo]

The new album is a triumph

[Nancy.]

:joker: I'm glad I didn't make this thread.

Not only is P!nk a much better artist but her artistry is organic and she doesn't come across as desperate or try hard. She isn't desperate for number one's or accolades. She let's the music speak for itself. She's incredible.

[Denver]

P!nk is better than pretty much anyone bar Adele

[Crimson Dynamo]

:joker: I'm glad I didn't make this thread.

Not only is P!nk a much better artist but her artistry is organic and she doesn't come across as desperate or try hard. She isn't desperate for number one's or accolades. She's incredible.

Yes she has always let the music speak for her

[Vicky.]

Much prefer pink

[Alf]

Gaga is a better artist.

She has far better showmanship than Pink. I don't particularly care for eithers music, but Gaga wins that one too.

[Shaun]

Gaga is more rounded. Whilst I probably like more P!nk songs, her album cycles are now essentially the same formula and have been for the past 10 years. Angsty "**** men!" lead single followed by 3 ballads.

[Denver]

What About Us is a bop Gaga wishes she could have

[Kazanne]

I prefer P!nk,she seems mre down to earth and I like her music.

[Black Dagger]

P!nk hasn't released anything good in about 10 years x

[Denver]

P!nk hasn't released anything good in about 10 years x

Thats clearly a lie

[LukeB]

What About Us is a bop Gaga wishes she could have

The Saturdays what about us >

[Crimson Dynamo]

P!nk hasn't released anything good in about 10 years x

She only released one of the songs of the year

unlike LG who must have been busy this year with family stuff or something?

[Black Dagger]

Thats clearly a lie

HkE83Zu8z58

[LukeB]

She only released one of the songs of the year

unlike LG who must have been busy this year with family stuff or something?

Shes busy with her sold out tour

[Nancy.]

Gaga is more rounded. Whilst I probably like more P!nk songs, her album cycles are now essentially the same formula and have been for the past 10 years. Angsty "**** men!" lead single followed by 3 ballads.

With the exception of Joanne, the same can be said for Lady Gaga's first four album's. (Including The Fame Monster). Same old repetetive ibiza sounding pop ditties with zero substance whatsoever.

[Crimson Dynamo]

Shes busy with her sold out tour

So is Bucks Fizz

[Black Dagger]

She only released one of the songs of the year

unlike LG who must have been busy this year with family stuff or something?

What About Us is forgettable as ****.

I like a lot of P!nk stuff, she has a solid place in my Spotify playlist, but she no longer hooks me in.

[Crimson Dynamo]

What About Us is forgettable as ****.

I like a lot of P!nk stuff, she has a solid place in my Spotify playlist, but she no longer hooks me in.

we heaven knows what you must then make of Lady Gaga now as she has really tailed off into like Las Vegas Celine Dion territory?

[Nancy.]

From a "sold out" show, apparently.

https://www.instagram.com/p/BXtigkZBcOm/?hl=en&taken-by=putyourpawsdown

https://www.instagram.com/p/BXg9rD4h6H4/?hl=en&taken-by=putyourpawsdown

:joker:

[LukeB]

These are two different (both good) artist so this makes thread makes no sense.

[Denver]

P!nk spent 5 years away and still came back to chart success unlike Gaga

[Shaun]

With the exception of Joanne, the same can be said for Lady Gaga's first four album's. (Including The Fame Monster). Same old repetetive ibiza sounding pop ditties with zero substance whatsoever.

For some reason I don't think I'll ever hear anything other than incessant hate from you on this subject, so forgive me if I don't reply

[Nancy.]

For some reason I don't think I'll ever hear anything other than incessant hate from you on this subject, so forgive me if I don't reply

But you did reply.

It's not incessant hate. I was merely responding to what you said about P!nk's album's all sounding the same.

If it's appreciation you want, then stick to the Gaga thread.

[caprimint]

Nope, Pink has some good songs but overall I way prefer Lady Gaga, like it's not even close

[joeysteele]

I like both but would lean to Lady GaGa

[Jordan.]

Gag doesn't have Just Like A Pill in her discography so yes

[Nicky91]

NO LT :fan:

[Oliver_W]

They both have catchy songs, and they both can sing pretty well, but they're different enough so the one you think is "better" would accord to your tastes in general. Neither are groundbreaking artists who will be remembered for decades, but neither are discardable trash.

[Locke.]

Think Pink is the only artist that has been around for about 20 years who I've never liked 1 song from, Gaga on the other hand has worked with the most talented and versatile man in the industry so is the clear winner in this scenario.

[RileyH]

Pink is wayyy better

[Alf]

I grew up with Madonna in her prime, so you can see why I think the modern pop girls ain't up to much.

Gaga is probably the modern day equivalent to Madonna, but no way as good or prolific.

[Smithy]

Gaga by far (obviously) you could shuffle all of P!nks albums up and they’d all still pretty much be the same, like Shaun said she’s just been doing the same album run for the past few years.

Not to mention her being a complete slut shamer, making fun of eating disorders and male domestic abuse victims

[Jake.]

Yeah I agree with Shaun re Gaga being more rounded. Some of P!nk’s stuff is fantastic but it’s been a bit samey for the past however many years.

If you’re discussing talent, I think Gag’s just edges it.

[bots]

i think Gaga is the consummate artiste but I find her pretty sterile, pink is more natural. Musically, neither are to my taste.

[Denver]

14 people do not have taste

[Jamie89]

Love both. I sort of want to say Pink because I've liked her for longer and I'd place Misunderstood (or however she spells it) above any of Gaga's albums, but tbh I have got a bit bored of her over the last few years. Gaga on the other hand is the best she's ever been right now imo, and like others have said is generally more rounded, and more of an artist I guess. I'd probably opt for Gaga thinking about it.

[reece(:]

P!nk has more classics, but prefer Gags music now.

P!nk's R&B era though >>>>

[reece(:]

P!nk loves ha acrobatics too

[Jamie89]

P!nk loves ha acrobatics too

Oh yeah I was going to say if I was choosing one of them to see live it'd probably be Pink, apparently she puts on an amazing show with her stunts etc

[Shaun]

I do think P!nk is massively overlooked by all of the pop girl stans, though. She's far better than the likes of Britney, Rihanna, Taylor and Katy, just by discography alone. She's a great performer but I'd agree with Smithy, she seems like a bit of a dickhead.

From the past 20 years I'd say it goes:

1) Beyonce
2) Gaga
3) P!nk
4) Rihanna
5) Christina

[Fetch The Bolt Cutters]

as long as everyone appreciates that kesha is better than both of them i don’t think it matters

[Saph]

thats tough because Pink is boring nowadays and a one trick pony however her back catalogue pre 2008 is amazing

Gaga between 2009-2011 was the best but shes not released an actual decent single since Marry The Night and thats just the tea

[Saph]

so all in all as of 2017 they both suck

http://i.imgur.com/7FdWCdZ.gif

(but I have faith in gags to comeback)

[Amy Jade]

I prefer P!nk.

I still like Gaga though.

[Smithy]

Did someone make a multi (Miss Lovelace) just to vote in the poll :skull:

[reece(:]

https://i2-prod.mirror.co.uk/incoming/article1316793.ece/ALTERNATES/s615/49786530.jpg

[Denver]

https://i2-prod.mirror.co.uk/incoming/article1316793.ece/ALTERNATES/s615/49786530.jpg

Looks like a right smackhead

[Smithy]

Looks like a right smackhead

I know loads of smackheads that wear McQueen wedding dresses too hen

[EspeonBB]

I think I actually prefer Gaga :o

She usually has at least one or two bops an era. I don't think I've enjoyed a P!nk song since 2008

[Jase.]

Not to mention her being a complete slut shamer, making fun of eating disorders and male domestic abuse victims

Angel Gaga would NEVER

[thesheriff443]

Pink is a star,gaga is a super star.
The gaga brand got as big as Madonna in her hey day, which is not easy to do.
Will gaga last as long as Madonna and be able to reinvent herself, no.

But it just boils down to individual taste and songs you like.

[GoldHeart]

https://i2-prod.mirror.co.uk/incoming/article1316793.ece/ALTERNATES/s615/49786530.jpg

That picture :facepalm: . Would of been more fair if both the photo's were of them looking pretty with makeup instead of gaga looking like she has a massive hangover . just woken up . and pink with makeup and a smile .

I like both Pink & Gaga :) . I wouldn't say pink is better .

[TomC]

thats tough because Pink is boring nowadays and a one trick pony however her back catalogue pre 2008 is amazing

Gaga between 2009-2011 was the best but shes not released an actual decent single since Marry The Night and thats just the tea

Applause, DWUW, TIHTY, PI and Million Reasons beg to differ x.

Looks like a right smackhead

Fffff off.

[GoldHeart]

Proper picture of Gaga looking her best :) .

https://s33.postimg.org/m6tk1zt8f/lady-gaga-fashion-awards-getty-1.jpg

[reece(:]

Ga's best look

https://lovelace-media.imgix.net/uploads/324/e252ca40-0c31-0132-709c-0add9426c766.jpg?w=740&h=740&fit=crop&crop=faces&auto=format&q=70

[JerseyWins]

Don't like either. Gotta go with Pink though since a few of her songs are decently good and I've only heard maybe 10 or less of her songs before.. while I've heard a ton of Lady Gaga's music (mainstream radio & my sister loved/loves her) and I practically like none of her songs.

[joeysteele]

This is a really tight poll.

[Livia]

Gaga all the way.

[Nancy.]

P!nk's new video...

EBt_88nxG4c

LOVE IT!

[Crimson Dynamo]

P!nk's new video...

EBt_88nxG4c

LOVE IT!

:clap1:

brilliant song from a woman in her prime

[Saph]

why does she have hair like a 16 year old boy wearing nike

[Nancy.]

why does she have hair like a 16 year old boy wearing nike

Whereas this is so much better, I suppose?

https://www.thesun.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2016/04/1582825.main_image.jpg?strip=all

[Tom4784]

Gaga, P!nk's become far too same-y over the years.

[Smithy]

Whereas this is so much better, I suppose?

https://www.thesun.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2016/04/1582825.main_image.jpg?strip=all

She actually shaved her head like that because her friends mum died from cancer, but drag her I guess

[arista]

NO LT :fan:


You are Wrong Nicky91

[Saph]

Whereas this is so much better, I suppose?

https://www.thesun.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2016/04/1582825.main_image.jpg?strip=all

this was a mess

[Nancy.]

She actually shaved her head like that because her friends mum died from cancer, but drag her I guess

I'm sure she could've shaved it in a more attractive manner - but then again, she wouldn't have gained as much exposure if she'd done that, would she? I mean, she's known for her wacky clothes and hairstyles, so why should she want an attractive ordinary cut?

[reece(:]

A look

http://www1.pictures.zimbio.com/bg/2001+Billboard+Music+Awards+press+room+A2xbFo44mt0 x.jpg

[Nancy.]

O M G

yH-IdakytEs

[Tom4784]

She's spent half her career on a trapeze, it's hardly impressive anymore.

[Jordan.]

A look

http://www1.pictures.zimbio.com/bg/2001+Billboard+Music+Awards+press+room+A2xbFo44mt0 x.jpg

A fashion icon doing the dreadlock look 12 years before gag

[Denver]

She's spent half her career on a trapeze, it's hardly impressive anymore.

Sommething Gaga could never

[Tom4784]

You're right, Gaga wouldn't do the same performance gimmick for years.

[Nancy.]

Sommething Gaga could never

:joker::joker: Exactly.

Let's all remind ourself of Gaga's talents on the trapeze..

https://media.giphy.com/media/26gsp4Tpugv4gs2aI/source.gif

[Tom4784]

Well P!nk's done the same thing for years, she's had the time to perfect it.

[Denver]

You're right, Gaga wouldn't do the same performance gimmick for years.

But she has done though

[Jordan.]

P!nk being smart and knowing what her audience wants :clap1: if gag had done the same she might still have half of her relevance.

[Nancy.]

You're right, Gaga wouldn't do the same performance gimmick for years.

:joker: Hammering away at her piano while wearing weird costumes was a massive gimmick. It's what she's best known for.

[Tom4784]

:joker: Hammering away at her piano while wearing weird costumes was a massive gimmick. It's what she's best known for.

Playing a piano is a gimmick?

[Nancy.]

Playing a piano is a gimmick?

You left out the rest. I said: "Hammering away at her piano while wearing weird costumes"

[Nancy.]

I don't believe Gaga could master the trapeze either. She has already said during an interview that she doesn't rehearse over and over to perfect her performances.

_S8NzgYT890

"There's a spontaneity in my work, I allow myself to fail, I allow myself to break" :joker: Oh f-off.

This is the same women who has two left feet and breaks her hip while trying to perform simple dance moves on stage. She wants to be praised by critics and fans but she's doesn't want to put any REAL effort in. She's a lazy bitch.

The excuses she comes up with to justify her half baked ****ty performances are hilarious.

[Tom4784]

You left out the rest. I said: "Hammering away at her piano while wearing weird costumes"

She's a popstar, they all wear weird costumes? Does P!nk wear what she wore in that video of her 10520349Th Trapeze performance around the house and to the shops?

Honestly, you're making very little sense at this point.

[Nancy.]

She's a popstar, they all wear weird costumes? Does P!nk wear what she wore in that video of her 10520349Th Trapeze performance around the house and to the shops?

Honestly, you're making very little sense at this point.

No they don't. There's hundreds or artists who don't wear weird costumes. I can;t even believe i'm having the discussion, tbh. I better go otherwise you'll have me banned for arguing with you - which is what assume you're ITCHING to do.

[Tom4784]

No they don't. There's hundreds or artists who don't wear weird costumes. I can;t even believe i'm having the discussion, tbh. I better go otherwise you'll have me banned for arguing with you - which is what assume you're ITCHING to do.

????

I don't understand why you are so angry over this?

Costumes are par for the course for popstars? They don't usually get up on stage and perform in a snuggie do they?

[GoldHeart]

Another classy picture of Gaga :)

http://s33.postimg.org/hrym6k5b3/020816-lady-gaga-superbowl.jpg

[Jase.]

Another classy picture of Gaga :)

http://s33.postimg.org/hrym6k5b3/020816-lady-gaga-superbowl.jpg

Stunning beauty!

[GoldHeart]

Stunning beauty!

Exactly :clap1:
Why is there such a huge argument in this thread :rolleyes: , I like both Pink & Gaga they're both amazing artists :dazzler: .

[Wizard.]

Pink. The poll says so.

[Crimson Dynamo]

So there you have it. The debate is closed and P!NK has won

:clap1: well done to her and her amazing album this year


https://pbs.twimg.com/profile_images/920350543620526083/0F0GaT0G_400x400.jpg

thankyou for participating in this big musical debate

[Nancy.]

So there you have it. The debate is closed and P!NK has won

:clap1: well done to her and her amazing album this year


https://pbs.twimg.com/profile_images/920350543620526083/0F0GaT0G_400x400.jpg

thankyou for participating in this big musical debate

Well done, P!nk. :cheer2:

[Niamh.]

Closed I think it's run it's course now