On a scale of Bear to Chantelle, how good of a winner would Shane J be?

[Withano]

Best cbb winner for a long time imo, maybe the best cbb c5 winner too.

[Jøsh]

A Sarah Harding - hated by some, loved by others.

[Shaun]

Chantelle at the top? Sis no.

[Withano]

Chantelle at the top? Sis no.

:umm2: are you new

[RileyH]

i'd be happy a rugirl won but he's far from my favourite

[Shaun]

:umm2: are you new

No I'm just aware of Shilpa, Katie Price, Gary Busey and Julian Clary! Thanks!

[lewis111]

i'd be happy a rugirl won but he's far from my favourite

Yea tbis
I'd also be worried someone like Bianca or Alaska was in a stronger series and didn't win or make the final even tho we know they're better

[Marches]

Awful end to a disappointing series

[Jamie89]

He'd be one of the best but that's not really saying a lot (and Shilpa > Chantelle)

[Epic.]

There's no denying he's been a big part of the series, but him, and by extension Ann, would still be an average result for me since they both have multiple drawbacks

[Paula D]

Worse than Bear by a mile

Sent from my SM-G925F using Tapatalk

[Withano]

No I'm just aware of Shilpa, Katie Price, Gary Busey and Julian Clary! Thanks!

Shilpa and Julian were great (probably my 2nd and 3rd)! I did prefer Chantelle though.

[poppsywoppsy]

My favourite was lovely Shilpa

Worst was "open it" Stephen what's his name.

[Vicky.]

Same as in the other poll, one of the best BUT the winners are usually dire so that doesn't mean that much :laugh:

[Jack_]

Of the series I've seen enough of to rank, he'd go here:

1) Denise
2) Gary
3) Jim
4) Shane J
5) Rylan
6) Alex
7) Julian
8) Chantelle
9) Paddy
10) Scotty
11) Charlotte
12) Katie
13) Shilpa
14) Ulrika
15) Coleen

[Oaker]

Average I guess? I think he'd be in my bottom 10 winners though.

[Gusto Brunt]

Just awful. He's done nothing to deserve a win. He's hopeless and very boring.

[Daniel.]

Denise is the best winner.

[Robodog]

Started well

Full of promise, seemed able to discuss with reason and humour

Then slumped for ages into boring showmance with the unlikeable Andrew

Then became a snidey gossip, tried to turn house against Ann but it backfired

Does these speeches full of PC cliches but is not actually saying anything new or constructive:
"People should be free to be themselves and we should all be nice to each other"
Well duh......

Conclusion?:

I don't think he is using himself to promote LGBT issues

I think he is using LGBT issues to promote himself

[Vicky.]

I don't think he is using himself to promote LGBT issues

I think he is using LGBT issues to promote himself

Thats an interesting way of putting it, and I think you might be right actually.

[bots]

Started well

Full of promise, seemed able to discuss with reason and humour

Then slumped for ages into boring showmance with the unlikeable Andrew

Then became a snidey gossip, tried to turn house against Ann but it backfired

Does these speeches full of PC cliches but is not actually saying anything new or constructive:
"People should be free to be themselves and we should all be nice to each other"
Well duh......

Conclusion?:

I don't think he is using himself to promote LGBT issues

I think he is using LGBT issues to promote himself

Spot on

[Parmy]

Gos.

[Robodog]

Spot on

Yeah interesting talking about him with gay friends, how he makes them cringe

Saying those who appoint themselves as 'a voice for the community' - are usually just attention seekers

And it doesn't help the cause to have someone so stereotypical considered as a 'representative'
(the outrageous dressing, the overt sexual behaviour like flashing on launch night, the preachy tone etc - all the cliches)

Kinda conforms to a stereotype: hence the cringe

[Northern Monkey]

Worse than Bear by a mile

Sent from my SM-G925F using Tapatalk

This

[Northern Monkey]

Started well

Full of promise, seemed able to discuss with reason and humour

Then slumped for ages into boring showmance with the unlikeable Andrew

Then became a snidey gossip, tried to turn house against Ann but it backfired

Does these speeches full of PC cliches but is not actually saying anything new or constructive:
"People should be free to be themselves and we should all be nice to each other"
Well duh......

Conclusion?:

I don't think he is using himself to promote LGBT issues

I think he is using LGBT issues to promote himself
This too

[montblanc]

out of the final five he's one of the three that i want to win but he'd be a pretty average winner overall

EDIT: i wasn't considering how dire the winners are so by comparison he'd actually be one of the best :skull:

[Epic.]

CBB winners >>>> BBUK winners

[Christmas Lights]

One of the worst as he's a one trick pony with a 1 dimensional personality :bored: who has a bitchy side .

[Peppermint]

One of the best, after Bear

[y.winter]

Totally average.

[jaxie]

In the year of the woman he'd be a terrible winner tbh. And just another example of women being sidelined.

[-Sue-]

A Shane J / courtney win would be wonderful :)