Survivor Ghost Island Cast Ranking Thread

[JerseyWins]

https://static.goldderby.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/12/survivor-ghost-island-logo-preview.jpg

Cast:

Domenick Abbate
Desiree Afuye
Kellyn Bechtold
Jenna Bowman
Jacob Derwin
Stephanie Gonzalez
Wendell Holland
Donathan Hurley
Laurel Johnson
Stephanie Johnson
Bradley Kleihege
James Lim
Chris Noble
Sebastian Noel
Angela Perkins
Morgan Ricke
Brendan Shapiro
Chelsea Townsend
Libby Vincek
Michael Yerger

[reece(:]

1. Stephanie
2. Jacob
3. Laurel
4. James
5. Domenick
6. Wendell
7. Morgan
8. Michael
9. Gonzalez
10. Jenna
11. Kellyn
12. Desiree (hew?)
13. Chelsea (hew?)
14. Angela (hew?)
15. Bradley (hew?)
16. Donathan
17. Libby
18. Sebastian
19. Chris
20. Brendan

[JerseyWins]

Tough to rank so far especially since I only saw limited pre-show interviews etc. but:

1. Jacob
2. Stephanie J
3. Domenick
4. Wendell
5. Morgan
6. Gonzalez (I didn't actually think I liked her this much :skull: but it's a lot to do with irrelevance from others or feeling meh towards them)
7. Libby
8. Michael
9. Donathan
10. James (started to like him towards the end of this premiere)
11. Laurel
12. Kellyn
13. Bradley
14. Chris
15. Desiree
16. Chelsea
17. Sebastian
18. Jenna
19. Angela (she had like no edit but seems too bitter from what I've seen of her in this and her pre-show interview)
20. Brendan

Don't feel very strongly for or against a ton of people. More than usual.

Libby to Laurel could easily be in orange.

Pretty terrible first two boots when I look at it this way. :(

[DrunkerThanMoses]

I cant rank Chelsea, Angela, Bradley or Libby as I have no idea who they are as they were that invisible this episode.

I like Donathon, Laurel, Domonick and Wendell so far

Not liking Brenden or Chris, and Steph kinda pissed me off joining forces with Brendick and voting Jacob out

The others are also to utr to comment on tbh

[DrunkerThanMoses]

I mean Andrea and Sierra had more of an edit then Libby, Bradley, Cheslea and Angela had

[JerseyWins]

I mean Andrea and Sierra had more of an edit then Libby, Bradley, Cheslea and Angela had
Libby had a bit of an edit. She was in some of the group talks heading into each of the TC's :hehe:

[reece(:]

Chelsea, Desiree and Angela the new Brianna, Brooke and Morgan?

[DrunkerThanMoses]

Libby had a bit of an edit. She was in some of the group talks heading into each of the TC's :hehe:

Well she did a poor job of making me notice her as I cant recall her at all

Chelsea, Desiree and Angela the new Brianna, Brooke and Morgan?

Desiree at least had 1 confessional and she seems okay, I would say Cheslea Bradley and Angela are the 3 invisibles this season

[DrunkerThanMoses]

Oh I forgot Morgan as well, I like her from what we saw

[reece(:]

I kept mixing up Jenna and Libby too

[DrunkerThanMoses]

Yeah Jenna and Libby are too similar, but we know Jenna is close with Steph, Libby on the other hand, I have no idea what she is doing, nor do I care

[LukeB]

Episode 1
1.Stephanie Johnson
2,Domenick Abbate
3.Jacob Derwin
4.Laurel Johnson
5.Gonzalez
6.Morgan Ricke
7.Michael Yerger
8.Desiree Afuye
9.Libby Vincek
10.Brendan Shapiro
11.Kellyn Bechtold
12.Angela Perkins
13.Donathan Hurley
14.Chris Noble
15.Chelsea Townsend
16.Jenna Bowman
17.James Lim
18.Wendell Holland
19.Sebastian Noel
20.Bradley Kleihege

[JerseyWins]

Tough to rank so far especially since I only saw limited pre-show interviews etc. but:

1. Jacob
2. Stephanie J
3. Domenick
4. Wendell
5. Morgan
6. Gonzalez (I didn't actually think I liked her this much :skull: but it's a lot to do with irrelevance from others or feeling meh towards them)
7. Libby
8. Michael
9. Donathan
10. James (started to like him towards the end of this premiere)
11. Laurel
12. Kellyn
13. Bradley
14. Chris
15. Desiree
16. Chelsea
17. Sebastian
18. Jenna
19. Angela (she had like no edit but seems too bitter from what I've seen of her in this and her pre-show interview)
20. Brendan

Don't feel very strongly for or against a ton of people. More than usual.

Libby to Laurel could easily be in orange.

Pretty terrible first two boots when I look at it this way. :(
1. Domenick
2. Stephanie J
3. Wendell
4. Libby
5. Michael
6. Morgan (robbed </3)
7. Sebastian
8. Laurel
9. Kellyn
10. Donathan
11. Chelsea (lmao @ literally no edit in basically 3 episodes - the line between who I kinda like / kinda dislike)
12. Jenna
13. Chris
14. Desiree
15. James
16. Angela
17. Bradley
18. Brendan

Starting to feel more strongly about characters & sides that I'm supporting now :clap1:

[Calderyon]

I don´t get the dislike for Brendan :shrug:

[LemonJam]

1. Donathan
2. James
3. Angela
4. Stephanie
5. Bradley
6. Kellyn
7. Jenna
8. Libby
9. Wendell
10. Laurel
11. Chris
12. Desiree
13. Sebastian
14. Chelsea
15.Brendan
16. Michael
17. Domenick

1. Jacob
2. Morgan
3. Gonzales

[JerseyWins]

1. Domenick
2. Stephanie J
3. Wendell
4. Libby
5. Michael
6. Morgan (robbed </3)
7. Sebastian
8. Laurel
9. Kellyn
10. Donathan
11. Chelsea (lmao @ literally no edit in basically 3 episodes - the line between who I kinda like / kinda dislike)
12. Jenna
13. Chris
14. Desiree
15. James
16. Angela
17. Bradley
18. Brendan
1. Domenick
2. Stephanie
3. Wendell
4. Michael
5. Libby
6. Laurel
7. Kellyn
8. Donathan
9. Jenna
10. Desiree (new line between who I kinda like / kinda don't like)
11. Sebastian (occasionally funny but kinda extra weird or annoying at times too :think:)
12. James
13. Chris
14. Chelsea (mehhh @ her first bit of edit)
15. Angela
16. Brendan
17. Bradley

I'm not a very big fan of most of this cast hmmm (although they're not really unlikable enough for me to classify them in red either - Bradley is the closest but I think he can maybe be comical enough to not be terrible).

There's a core few that I'm rooting hard for (basically all the greens) :clap1: :clap1:

[reece(:]

1. Stephanie
2. Michael
3. Angela
4. Chris
5. Laurel
6. Libby
7. Jenna
8. James
9. Domenick
10. Brendan
11. Donathan
12. Desiree
13. Chelsea
14. Wendell
15. Sebastian
16. Bradley
17. Kellyn

[VanessaFeltz.]

1) Stephanie Rae Johnson
2) Angela
3) Libby
4) Kellyn
5) Lauren
6) James
7) Jenna
8) Michael
9) Donathan
10) Chelsea
11) Desiree
12) Bradley
13) Brendon
14) Chris
15) Domenick
16) Wendell
17) Sebastian

[Wojtek]

1. Stephanie
2. Laurel
3. Desiree
(Gonzalez)
4. James
5. Michael
(Morgan)
6. Libby
7. Angela
8. Chris
(Brendan)
9. Kellyn
10. Sebastian
11. Chelsea
12. Jenna
13. Wendell
14. Domenick
15. Donathan
(Jacob)
16. Bradley

[MB.]

Bradley
Chris
Angela
Chelsea
James
Stephanie
Jenna
Libby
Sebastian
Desiree
Laurel
Donathan
Michael
Kellyn
Wendell
Domenick

Brendan
Morgan
Gonzalez
Jacob

(I don't have messianic love nor all-consuming hatred for anyone just yet, hence my conservative use of colour)

[TomC]

Now everyone has had at least a second of airtime, I feel equipped to rank em.

Episode 4:
1. Chris
2. Angela
3. Stephanie
4. Libby
5. Jenna
6. James
7. Kellyn
8. Chelsea
9. Sebastian
10. Donathan
11. Bradley
12. Desiree
13. Domenick
14. Michael
15. Laurel
16. Wendell
17. Brendan

We want more airtime for our UTR legends Angela, Libby, Jenna and Chelsea!

[JerseyWins]

1. Domenick
2. Stephanie
3. Wendell
4. Michael
5. Libby
6. Laurel
7. Kellyn
8. Donathan
9. Jenna
10. Desiree (new line between who I kinda like / kinda don't like)
11. Sebastian (occasionally funny but kinda extra weird or annoying at times too :think:)
12. James
13. Chris
14. Chelsea (mehhh @ her first bit of edit)
15. Angela
16. Brendan
17. Bradley

I'm not a very big fan of most of this cast hmmm (although they're not really unlikable enough for me to classify them in red either - Bradley is the closest but I think he can maybe be comical enough to not be terrible).

There's a core few that I'm rooting hard for (basically all the greens) :clap1: :clap1:
1. Domenick
2. Stephanie (most robbed so far </3)
3. Wendell
4. Michael
5. Libby
6. Laurel
7. Jenna
8. Desiree
9. Donathan
10. Sebastian
11. Kellyn
12. James
13. Chris
14. Chelsea
15. Angela
16. Bradley

For the most part this boot order isn't one to be admired so far

[reece(:]

1. Stephanie
2. Angela
3. Michael
4. Laurel
5. Libby
6. Chris
7. James
8. Jenna
9. Donathan
10. Kellyn
11. Domenick
12. Wendell
13. Chelsea
14. Sebastian
15. Desiree
16. Bradley

[TomC]

Episode 4:
1. Chris
2. Angela
3. Stephanie
4. Libby
5. Jenna
6. James
7. Kellyn
8. Chelsea
9. Sebastian
10. Donathan
11. Bradley
12. Desiree
13. Domenick
14. Michael
15. Laurel
16. Wendell
17. Brendan

Episode 5:
1. Chris (-)
2. Jenna (+3)
3. Stephanie (-)
4. Sebastian (+5)
5. Desiree (+6)
6. Angela (-4)
7. James (-1)
8. Libby (-4)
9. Chelsea (-1)
10. Donathan (-)
11. Kellyn (-3)
12. Domenick (+1)
13. Wendell (+3)
14. Bradley (-3)
15. Laurel (-)
16. Michael (-2)

I need someone to REALLY hate!

I do find this cast really likeable on the whole though. Still waiting for another Angela/Libby focussed episode!

[JerseyWins]

1. Domenick
2. Stephanie (most robbed so far </3)
3. Wendell
4. Michael
5. Libby
6. Laurel
7. Jenna
8. Desiree
9. Donathan
10. Sebastian
11. Kellyn
12. James
13. Chris
14. Chelsea
15. Angela
16. Bradley

For the most part this boot order isn't one to be admired so far
1. Domenick
2. Wendell
3. Michael
4. Libby
5. Laurel
6. Jenna
7. Donathan
8. Sebastian
9. Kellyn
10. Desiree
11. Chelsea
12. James
13. Chris
14. Angela
15. Bradley

[LemonJam]

1. Donathan
2. Sebastian
3. Chris
4. Angela
5. Bradley
6. Kellyn
7. Jenna
8. Wendell
9. Laurel
10. Desiree
11. Domenick
12. Libby
13. Chelsea
14. Michael

1. James
2. Jacob
3. Stephanie
4. Morgan
5. Brendan
6. Gonzales

[JerseyWins]

1. Domenick
2. Wendell
3. Michael
4. Libby
5. Laurel
6. Jenna
7. Donathan
8. Sebastian
9. Kellyn
10. Desiree
11. Chelsea
12. James
13. Chris
14. Angela
15. Bradley
1. Domenick
2. Wendell
3. Michael
4. Libby
5. Laurel
6. Jenna
7. Donathan
8. Kellyn
9. Sebastian
10. Desiree
11. Chelsea
12. Chris
13. Angela
14. Bradley

[JerseyWins]

1. Domenick
2. Wendell
3. Michael
4. Libby
5. Laurel
6. Jenna
7. Donathan
8. Kellyn
9. Sebastian
10. Desiree
11. Chelsea
12. Chris
13. Angela
14. Bradley
1. Domenick
2. Wendell
---by far top 2---
3. Michael
4. Libby
5. Donathan
6. Jenna
7. Laurel
8. Kellyn
9. Sebastian
10. Chris
11. Desiree
12. Chelsea
13. Angela

[reece(:]

1. Libby
2. Jenna
3. Chris
4. Michael
5. Laurel
6. Angela
7. Domenick
8. Chelsea
9. Sebastian
10. Donathan
11. Wendell
12. Desiree
13. Kellyn

[Wojtek]

1. Libby
2. Laurel
3. Desiree
4. Angela
5. Michael
6. Sebastian
7. Jenna
8. Chelsea
9. Kellyn
10. Donathan
11. Wendell
12. Domenick

---

1. Stephanie
2. James
3. Gonzalez
4. Morgan
5. Chris
6. Bradley
7. Brendan
8. Jacob

[JerseyWins]

1. Domenick
2. Wendell
---by far top 2---
3. Michael
4. Libby
5. Donathan
6. Jenna
7. Laurel
8. Kellyn
9. Sebastian
10. Chris
11. Desiree
12. Chelsea
13. Angela
1. Domenick
2. Wendell
---by far top 2---
3. Michael
4. Libby
5. Donathan
6. Kellyn
7. Sebastian
8. Jenna
9. Laurel
10. Desiree
11. Chelsea
12. Angela

I guess I'd say I like a lot of this cast but I really don't care too much about that many of them tbh. Still, I'm highly rooting for my top 2 though so that's a good thing and the season has been good/interesting. :clap1:

[DouglasS]

I've been rooting for just Michael from the start, glad hes still in. Idc about any of the others.... Stephanie was cute and James seemed nice though. Chris and Bradley were brilliant also

1. Michael
---------------------
2. Donathan
3. Libby
4. Domenick
---------------
5. Kellyn
6. Jenna [who]
7. Wendell
8. Laurel
9. Sebestian [who]
10.Desiree
11. Chelsea [who]
------------------
12. Angela


Eliminated

1. Chris
2. Bradley
3. Stephanie
-----------------------------
4. James
5. Libby
-----------------------------
6. Brendan
7. Morgan
8. Jacob
9. Gonzales

[MB.]

1. Chris
2. Bradley
3. Angela
4. Desiree
5-20. that Elaine Stritch "whooo cares" gif

[JerseyWins]

1. Domenick
2. Wendell
---by far top 2---
3. Michael
4. Libby
5. Donathan
6. Kellyn
7. Sebastian
8. Jenna
9. Laurel
10. Desiree
11. Chelsea
12. Angela
Half way point (# of them left) so I'll rank the eliminated ones too:

1. Domenick
2. Wendell
------------------------
3. Michael
4. Donathan
5. Kellyn
6. Laurel
7. Jenna
8. Sebastian (he's a bit funny sometimes but I don't care much about him)
9. Chelsea (one of the most invisible ever, nothing to like but barely even anything to judge)
10. Angela

Eliminated:
1. Stephanie
2. Jacob
3. Morgan
4. Libby
5. Gonzales
6. James
7. Chris
8. Desiree
9. Brendan
10. Bradley

[LemonJam]

1. Kellyn
2. Sebastian
3. Angela
4. Donathan
5. Jenna
6. Wendell
7. Laurel
8. Chelsea
9. Michael
10. Domenick

1. Chris
2. James
3. Bradley
4. Jacob
5. Stephanie
6. Desiree
7. Libby
8. Morgan
9. Brendan
10. Gonzales

[Paige22]

1. Michael
2. Jenna
3. Chelsea
4. Angela
5. Sebastian
6. Kellyn
7. Laurel
8. Domenick
9. Wendell
10. Donathan

1. Stephanie
2. Libby
3. Chris
4. Brendan
5. Morgan
6. Desiree
7. Gonzales
8. James
9. Jacob
10. Bradley

[Macie Lightfoot]

k I haven't done a cast ranking this whole time so...

1. Angela - she only shows up every third episode but she's raw and real and vulnerable and complex and one of the only unique characters left? She's delightful but we never see her.
2. Chelsea - alol yes I'm serious. I'm just intrigued more than anything, because she is ALWAYS present in the strategizing scenes and she's openly vocalized and spearheaded like two or three voting plans correctly, but yet she only has like 3 confessionals this entire season. Her edit is complete bull**** because she's actually a pretty competent player from the little we've seen.
3. Jenna - the state of this season when she's my #3. This is still entirely from her struggles with resting bitch face, even though that was a full month ago now.
4. Sebastian - most obvious stoner in Survivor history :love:
5. Kellyn - she's.... fine? I can't imagine feeling any sort of way about her.
6. Donathan - he's nice enough, and I was expecting an insufferable Tai-like edit so I'll take the small victory here.
7. Laurel - I thought I liked her a lot more than I actually do but I'm not really digging the whole "it's too soon to make a big move" blue-balling. Sierra Dawn Thomas did it better hun......x
8. Domenick - not terrible, but I don't have anything to say about him at all and yet he's a constant 4 or 5 visibility. I don't think he's particularly interesting or telegenic or noteworthy and I am struggling to find any adjectives to describe his personality.
9. Wendell - you can just C/P the Domenick write-up here. Even in spite of some personal content, I feel like I do not know who he is at all and I could not describe his personality if you put a gun to my head.
10. Michael - I don't think he's actually my least favorite and he's really not THAT bad, but oh my gooooooooooooddddddd is his edit redundant or what. WE GET IT, you're on the bottom and you've been since like episode 4! Sing me a different tune. It's like a Spencer Bledsoe edit, just without the smarmy facial expressions and smug remarks as he looks down his nose at others.

[JerseyWins]

Half way point (# of them left) so I'll rank the eliminated ones too:

1. Domenick
2. Wendell
------------------------
3. Michael
4. Donathan
5. Kellyn
6. Laurel
7. Jenna
8. Sebastian (he's a bit funny sometimes but I don't care much about him)
9. Chelsea (one of the most invisible ever, nothing to like but barely even anything to judge)
10. Angela

Eliminated:
1. Stephanie
2. Jacob
3. Morgan
4. Libby
5. Gonzales
6. James
7. Chris
8. Desiree
9. Brendan
10. Bradley
1. Domenick
2. Wendell
------------------------
3. Michael
4. Kellyn (lmfao :love:)
5. Donathan
6. Laurel
7. Jenna
8. Sebastian
9. Chelsea
10. Angela

[LemonJam]

1. Sebastian
2. Angela
3. Donathan
4. Laurel
5. Wendell
6. Domenick

1. Kellyn
2. Chris
3. James
4. Bradley
5. Jacob
6. Jenna
7. Stephanie
8. Desiree
9. Chelsea
10. Libby
11. Morgan
12. Brendan
13. Gonzales
14. Michael

[JerseyWins]

Final Ranking:

1. Domenick
2. Wendell
3. Stephanie
4. Jacob
5. Michael
6. Morgan
7. Kellyn
8. Libby
9. Donathan
10. Laurel
11. Gonzales
12. Jenna
13. Sebastian
14. James
15. Chris
16. Chelsea
17. Desiree
18. Brendan
19. Angela
20. Bradley

I mean it was a great cast, no other way to say it for me... it's not that often I actually love half the cast (and the top 2-3 were amazing). Still quite a few I felt pretty indifferent towards BUT there wasn't really anyone that was too annoying either.

All in all the season wasn't overly entertaining and it was kinda predictable towards the end but I enjoyed it a lot anyway (my favorite characters getting big edits and the end result was nice)

[Macie Lightfoot]

1. Bradley (don't worry hun, I hate sand and dirt too :love:)
2. Chris (I looooooooove @TheN0bleOne BUT the Dom/Chris thing was a bit much and it ****ed up the second half of the season)
3. Chelsea ("I'm sitting." :love: I'm still so intrigued bc she was clearly a very competent player but the show wouldn't allow us to see it)
4. Angela (a particularly unique casting choice that really should have received more focus)
5. Jenna (her struggles with resting bitch face and almost duping Donathan into using his HII on her is somehow enough to put her in the top five for me!)
6. Donathan (I was NOT ready for the country bumpkin schtick but Woke Donathan was appreciated in the endgame even though it was futile)
7. Sebastian (obvious stoners :love: a bigger edit could have easily bumped him up to green)
8. Desiree (she clearly had spunk and chutzpah but she also didn't have an edit at all so)
9. Morgan (she was a presence... that was liked?)
10. Jacob (benefits huuuugely from the fact that his arc was contained to one night of television)
11. James (he was nice and his play to get Morgan out was v impressive but he was also kinda bland)
12. Kellyn (I could not imagine anyone caring about her in any sort of way. She was just a narrator. Beige wallpaper if you will)
13. Libby (cutting Morgan's throat was eye-opening but then... she did nothing. I know we all LOVE her because reasons but she wasn't all that)
14. Wendell (I appreciate him as a winner more now after a few days. His aggression and temper and cockiness during ICs was Not A Good Look but I think he's genuinely a nice guy)
15. Stephanie (most overrated castaway since like... Jenn Brown at least? vaguely annoying and inconsequential)
16. Brendan (I think people, maybe not here but at least on Reddit, were VERY upset when he was gone... and I don't know why. He didn't do anything)
17. Gonzalez (she annoyed me during her one episode and I don't remember why!)
18. Domenick (he's not that bad in the grand scheme of Survivor buuuuut his edit was way too ****ing much and he was kind of an arrogant jerk at times, but not even enough of one for it to be concretely shown in the episodes? I still feel like I know nothing about him)
19. Laurel ("my only hope is for Wendell and Domenick to split the votes and I can pick up whatever's left" yeah how that'd work out for you hun? .......x)
20. Michael (oh my god I actually liked him at first but his edit was suuuuuuuuuuuuuuch a colossal waste of time and Probst verbally rimming him all season long was just torturous. I do not watch Survivor to gush over a rational and confident 18-year-old male model. He pretty much has the same personality as like... Kim Spradlin so why didn't we gush over her? :3)

[MB.]

I think you'll find the idea that Bradley dislikes sand is a common misconception; he is fact a big fan of sand and was visibly disappointed in the lack of sand, and the presence of dirt in sand's absence, at Malolo beach, which, to reiterate, had very little sand