Madonna or Kylie (Minogue)?

[Eddie.]

These two females are often regarded as the Queens Of Pop, they both are often compared to each other, and their areas of success are also different. Madonna being successful in the US and the world, while Kylie being successful anywhere but the US...(no offence, some of our American members might not even know her).
Who reigns for you?

For me, I love both of them, but I’m leaning towards Kylie due to her catalogue being more diverse, and her ability to become a pop icon, without ever getting widespread success in the USA, which I applaud. She also doesn’t get into controversies to boost her popularity, though nothing against Madge, I just love Kylie a bit more...

[LukeB]

Kylie :love:

[RileyH]

I like both but Kylie

[montblanc]

i've never really been interested in listening to madonna tbh

but i bop to kylie

[reece(:]

Madge has a better back catalogue

[Niamh.]

Madonna by far

[Barry.]

Like both but Madonna.

[_Tom_]

Madge edges it

[Alf]

In terms of music, hands down Madonna. As a person, it has to be Kylie.

[Crimson Dynamo]

Madonna

Kylie is not close musically

[Livia]

Too close to call, and for different reasons.

[Ross.]

Madonna didn’t release Get Outta My Way

[Marsh.]

The one who can sing. Both poor but Kylie just about nudges it.

[EspeonBB]

Madonna

I've never gotten into the Kylie's music

[montblanc]

Madonna didn’t release Get Outta My Way

tea!

[Mitchell]

Madonna’s only amazing song is 4 minutes so Kylie

[Shaun]

Kylie didn't release Borderline

[Nancy.]

These two females are often regarded as the Queens Of Pop, they both are often compared to each other, and their areas of success are also different. Madonna being successful in the US and the world, while Kylie being successful anywhere but the US...(no offence, some of our American members might not even know her).
Who reigns for you?

For me, I love both of them, but I’m leaning towards Kylie due to her catalogue being more diverse, and her ability to become a pop icon, without ever getting widespread success in the USA, which I applaud. She also doesn’t get into controversies to boost her popularity, though nothing against Madge, I just love Kylie a bit more...
Actually, Madonna is the one who is often regarded as the Queen of Pop, Kylie is the Princess of Pop.

Madonna's back catalogue is far more diverse than Kylie's. I mean, Ray of Light and Like A Virgin are worlds apart. Then there's I'm Breathless and Erotica. Many of her album's are like chalk and cheese, whereas a majority of Kylie's album's since 2000 all sound the same. I like both but Kylie's recent output has been awful. Hope there's some good tracks on the new album though.

[Cherie]

Madge

[Nancy.]

Madonna

Kylie is not close musically

:clap1:

[reece(:]

Actually, Madonna is the one who is often regarded as the Queen of Pop, Kylie is the Princess of Pop. I like both but Kylie's recent output has been awful. Hope there's some good tracks on the album though.

Ms Minogue is a local mainly to the gays, she flopped in the US

https://i.imgur.com/u6BEfSR.gif

[Nancy.]

Ms Minogue is a local mainly to the gays, she flopped in the US

https://i.imgur.com/u6BEfSR.gif

Oh yeah, sorry, I skipped over a lot of the OP's post and didn't read that part about the US. In that case Britney is the Princess of Pop.

[EspeonBB]

Ms Minogue is a local mainly to the gays, she flopped in the US

https://i.imgur.com/u6BEfSR.gif

Yeah Kylie is a cute girl but she doesn't come to close to having Madonna's legacy or impact

[Pete.]

I stan both but Madonna is better on all fronts except maybe personality

https://i.imgur.com/u6BEfSR.gif

[Strictly Jake]

Hard question

Love old school Madonna even the 90s, 00s Madonna was good but in recent years trash

Whereas most of Kylie songs are hits except recent few years where she had flopped

If it's based on whose music I like best then probably Kylie but I love the immaculate collection so...

[Eddie.]

I was certain when I made this thread that Nancy’s vote would go to Madge... :joker:

Kylie is mainly unknown in the states and her only sucesses there were “The Loco-Motion” and “Can’t Get You Out Of My Head”.

I would say Britney is the Princess Of Pop...

[Mystic Mock]

Again not mad on either of them, but I've liked more Madonna songs than I have Kylie's.

In fact the only Kylie song that I've liked is actually Nick Cave's song.:joker: