Deana v Gina v Ashleigh v Jayne v Isabelle

[Tony Montana]

The five Biggest C5 Female HMs and the Forum fan Favs, But who is the best?

Issy > Gina > Deana > Ashleigh > Jayne is how i rank them.

http://i.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2012/06/07/article-2155637-137BDA08000005DC-817_634x460.jpghttps://metrouk2.files.wordpress.com/2013/06/ay_112178597-e1371383216245.jpghttp://www.fansshare.com/media/content1/550x298_ashleigh-coyle-to-win-big-brother-2014--6360.jpghttps://tellymix-spykawebgroup.netdna-ssl.com/ts/800/450/tellymix-spykawebgroup.netdna-ssl.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/07/BB_JayneA4.jpghttps://tellymix-spykawebgroup.netdna-ssl.com/ts/800/450/tellymix-spykawebgroup.netdna-ssl.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/07/BB_Isabelle4.jpg

[LukeB]

Deana :love:

[RileyH]

Issy > Ashleigh > Deana > Jayne >>> Gina

[montblanc]

Deana

[LukeB]

Deana > Gina > Isabelle > Ashleigh > Jayne

[Jordan.]

Deana > Isabelle > Ashleigh > Gina > Jayne

[Amy Jade]

Iss > Deana > Jayne > Ashleigh > a million paper cuts on my eyeballs > Gina

[RileyH]

a million paper cuts on my eyeballs > Gina

:joker:

[Lostie!]

Jayne > Deana > Isabelle > Ashleigh > Gina

[Epic.]

Like all but Deana by a mile. The rest either went through brief phases of not being relevant (Jayne, Isabelle) or sometimes were hard to root for (Ashleigh, Gina).

[Daniel.]

Deana > Isabelle > Ashleigh > Gina > Jayne.

[Withano]

Jayne 10/10
Isabelle 9.5/10
Deana 8/10
Ashleigh (didnt watch her)
Gina literally 0/10, what a ****

[Matthew.]

Isabelle > Gina > Jayne > Ashleigh

haven’t seen BB13 so can’t comment on Deana but I’ve heard good things

[Eddie.]

Gina>Jayne>Isabelle>Deana>>Ashleigh

Deana is a tad bit overrated while sometimes Ashleigh could be vile, though I love them all...

[Marsh.]

Hazel >>>>>> Helen >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>

[Tony Montana]

Gina>Jayne>Isabelle>Deana>>Ashleigh

Deana is a tad bit overrated while sometimes Ashleigh could be vile, though I love them all...

I agree that she's a tad overrated. Seems that we are one of the few people on this forum.

[RileyH]

Lauren > Deana, mind

[Eddie.]

Lauren > Deana, mind

this.

[Eddie.]

Lauren and Lydia were far more better females than Deana...

[Tony Montana]

Lauren > Deana, mind

Lauren and Lydia were far more better females than Deana...

I Agree with this Tbh. Wait for the Die hard Deana Supporters to rip into us.

[Eddie.]

I Agree with this Tbh. Wait for the Die hard Deana Supporters to rip into us.

I agree with the last part :joker:

[TomC]

Jayne > Deana > Isabelle > Ashleigh > GIna

Deana is kinda overrated imo, and yet she's second best outta this lot for me lol. Gina's kinda annoying, and Isabelle and Asheligh aren't aging well on me?

[Wojtek]

Gina>Ashleigh>Jayne>Deana>Isabelle

[Daniel.]

Jayne was boring

[Lostie!]

Gina literally 0/10, what a ****

:joker: :clap1:

[Jake.]

Gina literally 0/10, what a ****

:joker:

Deana > Isabelle > Jayne > Ashleigh >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Gina

[Eddie.]

why at all this Gina hate... :bawling:

[RileyH]

why at all this Gina hate... :bawling:

She was awful :umm2:

[MB.]

Deana > Ashleigh > Isabelle > Jayne > Gina

[Jake.]

why at all this Gina hate... :bawling:

She’s rancid

[Shaun]

Jayne > Isabelle > Deana > Ashleigh > Gina for me.

Like all of them bar Gina... Ashleigh blew the easiest win of all time by being a miserable cow, though, and Deana blew another deserved win by getting too cocky. Isabelle was a good winner but Jayne was robbed, and the star of BB17.

[Tony Montana]

The Deana Love on here is Ridiculous at times. She was Good, but not that Good

[RileyH]

Ashleigh deserves better

[Epic.]

The Deana Love on here is Ridiculous at times. She was Good, but not that Good

I'm surprised you're saying that since you really liked BB13 and she was the biggest character of that series

[Macie Lightfoot]

Deana is the only C5 HM I would take a bullet for.

[Baby Jane]

Jayne > Isabelle > Deana > Gina > Ashleigh.

“I will annihilate you” and “role model to your son though?” should be recited by all at every meal time.

[montblanc]

issy’s more overrated than deana if we’re being real

[Epic.]

issy’s more overrated than deana if we’re being real

Isabelle's one of my all time favourites and even I can agree to this :laugh:

[Baby Jane]

I think a lot of the goodwill for both Isabelle and Deana comes from the fact that they both handled them self with such class and grace, and refused to be victimised by the men who targeted them for no reason other than for their own enjoyment. For me, seeing the two of them stand tall and stand up for themselves in that situation was empowering and inspiring, and it was that act which cements them as all time favourites of mine, despite the fact that a lot of the time they could be quieter and more reserved than other housemates.

[Epic.]

I think a lot of the goodwill for both Isabelle and Deana comes from the fact that they both handled them self with such class and grace, and refused to be victimised by the men who targeted them for no reason other than for their own enjoyment. For me, seeing the two of them stand tall and stand up for themselves in that situation was empowering and inspiring, and it was that act which cements them as all time favourites of mine, despite the fact that a lot of the time they could be quieter and more reserved than other housemates.

This sums it up completely! :clap1: The two housemates that fit female empowerment perfectly :love:

[Daniel.]

If anyone's overrated, it's Jayne.

Gina is also overrated by people who think shes' one of the best hms

[Alf]

When did we decide that these were the channel 5 forum favourites?

[montblanc]

When did we decide that these were the channel 5 forum favourites?

who are yours then :)

[reece(:]

I think a lot of the goodwill for both Isabelle and Deana comes from the fact that they both handled them self with such class and grace, and refused to be victimised by the men who targeted them for no reason other than for their own enjoyment. For me, seeing the two of them stand tall and stand up for themselves in that situation was empowering and inspiring, and it was that act which cements them as all time favourites of mine, despite the fact that a lot of the time they could be quieter and more reserved than other housemates.
Welcome to the forum hun

[RileyH]

When did we decide that these were the channel 5 forum favourites?

We wanted Hazel & the Woo Woo

[Epic.]

When did we decide that these were the channel 5 forum favourites?

By looking at the forum fave percentages :hee:

[Alf]

who are yours then :)To be honest with you, I ain't a fan of the channel 5 era.

I disliked Helen as a person, but she was a colossus housemate and looking back, she made the biggest impact.

[Daniel.]

Helen was a **** housemate with no interest apart from shouting and bullying people

[Epic.]

Making the biggest impact does not equate to being a great housemate

[Tony Montana]

I'm surprised you're saying that since you really liked BB13 and she was the biggest character of that series

You're Correct. i Love BB13 and i agree she was a Big Character. I just feel she gets the constant shower of praises due to what she went through rather than what she actually brought. Put her in any other series and i don't think she would have stood much.

[Tony Montana]

issy’s more overrated than deana if we’re being real

No she's not, Nowhere near. Deana is the Epitome when it comes to being overrated.

[RileyH]

oop

[montblanc]

No she's not, Nowhere near. Deana is the Epitome when it comes to being overrated.

so is isabelle

[Daniel.]

No

[montblanc]

:shrug:

[LukeB]

so is isabelle

You?
https://giphy.com/gifs/amy-jade-mermaid-6RKFVoMBWkduE?utm_source=media-link&utm_medium=landing&utm_campaign=Media%20Links&utm_term=

[RileyH]

so is isabelle

https://typeset-beta.imgix.net/uploads/image/2017/8/1/ac160c7a-e500-43d4-88f1-f6375c6936a3-200.gif

[Tony Montana]

so is isabelle

https://media.giphy.com/media/O5NyCibf93upy/giphy.gif

You can't be deadly serious? You honestly think Isabelle is the Epitome when it comes to being Overrated?

[Macie Lightfoot]

I feel like a rewatch of BB13 would just confirm that Deana is perfectly rated. Even if you ignore "what she went through" or whatever the ****, she had a unique and interesting relationship with just about every single person in the house (maybe not like... Chris or another early boot but that's about it), she was the most consistently righteous person in the house, and she was hilarious both intentionally and unintentionally.

[Shaun]

Isabelle snatched Deborah's crown and THAT'S the tea.

[montblanc]

https://media.giphy.com/media/O5NyCibf93upy/giphy.gif

You can't be deadly serious? You honestly think Isabelle is the Epitome when it comes to being Overrated?

i'm dead serious https://media.giphy.com/media/l0IyhspszrYBnC4V2/giphy.gif

[montblanc]

https://media.giphy.com/media/3oKIPiCg5CK1PuIGFa/giphy.gif

[Tony Montana]

i'm dead serious https://media.giphy.com/media/l0IyhspszrYBnC4V2/giphy.gif

Elaborate please

[Tony Montana]

To be honest with you, I ain't a fan of the channel 5 era.

I disliked Helen as a person, but she was a colossus housemate and looking back, she made the biggest impact.

WTF?! In what way was she a colossus HM? She was a 27 year old Adult and Mother who was a playground bully, who isolated, ridiculed, name called and Insulted her fellow HMs along with her pack of wolves and had a negative presence. If it wasn’t for that Pass, She would have gone week 2/3.

She’s easily bottom 10 HM and an absolute disgrace to the Human Race. Only Conor and Dennis Rival her for the title of Worst HM of all time.

[Alf]

WTF?! In what way was she a colossus HM? She was a 27 year old Adult and Mother who was a playground bully, who isolated, ridiculed, name called and Insulted her fellow HMs along with her pack of wolves and had a negative presence. If it wasn’t for that Pass, She would have gone week 2/3.

She’s easily bottom 10 HM and an absolute disgrace to the Human Race. Only Conor and Dennis Rival her for the title of Worst HM of all time.I'm the biggest and best Big Brother UK expert on this forum, and what I say, goes.

[Tony Montana]

Isabelle > Gina > Jayne > Ashleigh

haven’t seen BB13 so can’t comment on Deana but I’ve heard good things

Watch it ASAP. A fantastic series full of entertainment from start to finish, though extremely Nasty and very difficult to watch at times.

You won’t be disappointed

[RileyH]

Excuse me Helen is a legend

[Eddie.]

WTF?! In what way was she a colossus HM? She was a 27 year old Adult and Mother who was a playground bully, who isolated, ridiculed, name called and Insulted her fellow HMs along with her pack of wolves and had a negative presence. If it wasn’t for that Pass, She would have gone week 2/3.

She’s easily bottom 10 HM and an absolute disgrace to the Human Race. Only Conor and Dennis Rival her for the title of Worst HM of all time.

Helen is a vile bitch and Kim Woodburn needs to be in the same house as her so that she could drag Helen to the pits of hell...

[Tony Montana]

Excuse me Helen is a legend

Maybe to you, Riley but to most of us on the forum she was just a nasty bully

[Tony Montana]

Helen is a vile bitch and Kim Woodburn needs to be in the same house as her so that she could drag Helen to the pits of hell...

Kim would have owned her

[RileyH]

Helen is a vile bitch and Kim Woodburn needs to be in the same house as her so that she could drag Helen to the pits of hell...

You've got them the wrong way round x

[Tony Montana]

You've got them the wrong way round x

What exactly is it about Helen you like,Riley?

[RileyH]

What exactly is it about Helen you like,Riley?

elDIQOKkeeM

[Tony Montana]

elDIQOKkeeM

So you left out all her nasty Moments, Riley?

[RileyH]

Go get a wash and an 'errbrush you fat bitch was iconic

[Tony Montana]

Go get a wash and an 'errbrush you fat bitch was iconic

Yeah even i have to admit i enjoyed that Argument a lot.

Danielle was a Scream!

[RileyH]

Not fake virgin Danielle

[Tony Montana]

Not fake virgin Danielle

Fook Off, Get some Bloody Class ya Weirdo Man.

[RileyH]

Wow BB15 is really underrated :love:

[Tony Montana]

Wow BB15 is really underrated :love:

Those first three weeks were fantastic.

[Epic.]

I'm the biggest and best Big Brother UK expert on this forum, and what I say, goes.

Not when you're the same person who lied to me that Evelyn got evicted over Alex in BB17 before that pre-final eviction even aired

[Baby Jane]

Go get a wash and an 'errbrush you fat bitch was iconic

The best BB moment in years!

[Alf]

Not when you're the same person who lied to me that Evelyn got evicted over Alex in BB17 before that pre-final eviction even airedDid I?, I can't remember :joker:

I can be a daft apeth sometimes

[Babayaro.]

Gina!

[Niamh.]

Isabelle > Deanna > Ashleigh >Jayne > Gina

[Babayaro.]

When did we decide that these were the channel 5 forum favourites?

We wanted Aaron, Callum, Marlon, Pie Face and Jason??

[Tony Montana]

We wanted Aaron, Callum, Marlon, Pie Face and Jason??

Replace Pie Face and Marlon with Dexter and Benedict and that’s a solid Top 5 C5 males for me

[Tony Montana]

Anymore opinions?

[Jack_]

Isabelle is one of the most overrated housemates of recent years and is recipient of a lot of recency bias

Deana and Gina were both robbed

Jayne was hysterical but a bit inconsistent

And Ashleigh was one half of the best final two of all time

Gina > Ashleigh > Deana > Jayne > Isabelle

[Tony Montana]

bump

[lewys]

Issy being overrated is stupid, if she hadn't had gone in that series would've been awful, chanelle was undoubtedly funny but she played up to the cameras, tried extremely hard and obviously had planned lines / bits she wanted to do to be 'queen'. Issy was unapologetically herself and without meaning to do so took down a vile bully, was selfless and hilarious (i'll never get over her song to Chanelle when she callled her Chantelle HAHAHAHHA)

Isabelle > Gina > Jayne > Deana > Ashleigh

I liked Ashleigh but her only truly iconic moment IMO was her Kimberly take down at the party, she was good but not in the same league as the other 4 and is only considered at that level because every other HM that series was horrific so she seemed better than she was, imagine her in 17/18.

[Tony Montana]

Issy being overrated is stupid, if she hadn't had gone in that series would've been awful, chanelle was undoubtedly funny but she played up to the cameras, tried extremely hard and obviously had planned lines / bits she wanted to do to be 'queen'. Issy was unapologetically herself and without meaning to do so took down a vile bully, was selfless and hilarious (i'll never get over her song to Chanelle when she callled her Chantelle HAHAHAHHA)

Isabelle > Gina > Jayne > Deana > Ashleigh

I liked Ashleigh but her only truly iconic moment IMO was her Kimberly take down at the party, she was good but not in the same league as the other 4 and is only considered at that level because every other HM that series was horrific so she seemed better than she was, imagine her in 17/18.

I can see Ashleigh doing well in 18, But not 17. In 18 she would have joined the Outsiders whereas i think she would have been Overshadowed by the Bigger Characters in 17.

[lewys]

I can see Ashleigh doing well in 18, But not 17. In 18 she would have joined the Outsiders whereas i think she would have been Overshadowed by the Bigger Characters in 17.

What I meant was she would have been majorly overshadowed and not considered anywhere near the status she has. She would have been the Kieran version of the outsiders

[Tony Montana]

What I meant was she would have been majorly overshadowed and not considered anywhere near the status she has. She would have been the Kieran version of the outsiders

Oh Silly Me:laugh: